Background
School curriculum
| Health education topics are promoted through the formal school curriculum. |
Ethos and/or environment
| Health and well-being of students are promoted through the ‘hidden’ or ‘informal’ curriculum, which encompasses the values and attitudes promoted within the school and the physical environment and setting of the school. |
Families and/or communities
| Schools seek to engage with families, outside agencies and the wider community in recognition of the importance of these other spheres of influence on children’s health. |
Methods
Inclusion criteria
Primary health outcomes
| Overweight/obesity; physical activity and sedentary behaviours; nutrition; tobacco use; alcohol use; substance use; sexual health; mental health; violence; bullying; infectious disease (e.g. diarrhoea, respiratory infections); safety and accident prevention; body image/eating disorders; sun safety; and oral health. |
Primary educational outcomes
| Academic achievement, including student standardised test scores or school-level academic achievement. |
Secondary outcomes included
| School attendance outcomes; other school-related outcomes (such as school climate or attachment to school). |
Search strategy
Data extraction
Statistical analysis
Results
Authors | Name | Review outcomes | Country | Target group | Duration for study design | Theory |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nutrition Interventions
| ||||||
Anderson 2005 [19] | - | Nutrition | UK | 6-7 and 10–11 year- olds | 8 months | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Bere 2006 [20] | Fruits and Vegetables Make the Mark | Nutrition | Norway | Grade 6 | 6 months | Social cognitive theory |
Evans 2013 [21] | Project Tomato | Nutrition | UK | Year 2 | 10 months | Framework for health maintenance behaviour |
Foster 2008 [22] | School Nutrition Policy Initiative | Obesity/overweight, Nutrition | USA | Grades 4-6 | 2 years | None stated |
Hoffman 2010 [23] | Athletes in Service, Fruit and Vegetable Promotion Program | Nutrition | USA | Kindergarten and Grade 1 | 2.5 years | Social learning theory |
Hoppu 2010 [24] | - | Nutrition | Finland | Grade 8 | 8 months | Social cognitive theory |
Lytle 2004 [25] | TEENS | Nutrition | USA | Grades 7-8 | 2 years | Social cognitive theory |
Nicklas 1998 [26] | Gimme 5 | Nutrition | USA | Grade 9 | 3 years | PRECEDE Model of Health Education |
Perry 1998 [27] | 5 A DAY Power Plus | Nutrition | USA | Grades 4-5 | 6 months | Social learning theory |
Radcliffe 2005 [28] | - | Nutrition | Australia | Grade 7 | 11 months | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Reynolds 2000 [29] | High 5 | Nutrition | USA | Grade 4 | 1 year | Social cognitive theory |
Te Velde 2008 [30] | Pro Children Study | Nutrition | Netherlands, Norway, Spain | Grades 5-6 | 2 years | Social cognitive theory, Ecological model |
Physical Activity Interventions
| ||||||
Eather 2013 [31] | Fit-4-Fun | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity | Australia | Grades 5-6 | 8 weeks | Health Promoting Schools framework, Social cognitive Theory, Harter’s Competence Motivation Theory |
Kriemler 2010 [32] | KISS | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity | Switzerland | Grades 1 and 5 | 11 months | None stated |
Simon 2006 [33] | ICAPS | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity | France | Grade 6 | 4 years | “Theory based” but no details of a named theory provided |
Wen 2008 [34] | - | Physical Activity | Australia | Years 4-5 | 2 years | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Physical Activity + Nutrition Interventions
| ||||||
Arbeit 1992 [35] | Heart Smart | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity, Nutrition | USA | Grades 4-5 | 2.5 years | Social cognitive theory |
Brandstetter 2012 [36] | URMEL ICE | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity, Nutrition | Germany | Grade 2 | 9 months | Social cognitive theory |
Caballero 2003 [37] | Pathways | Physical Activity, Nutrition | USA | Grade 3 | 3 years | Social learning theory |
Colín-Ramírez 2010 [38] | RESCATE | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity, Nutrition | Mexico | Grades 4-5 | 1 year | None stated |
Crespo 2012 [39] | Aventuras para Niños | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity, Nutrition | USA | Kindergarten-Grade 2 | 5 semesters | Social ecological theory, Social cognitive theory, Health belief model, structural model of health behavior |
Foster 2010 [40] | HEALTHY | Obesity/overweight | USA | Grades 6-8 | 3 years | None stated |
Grydeland 2013 [41] | Health in Adolescents (HEIA) | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity, Nutrition | Norway | Grade 6 | 20 months | Socio-ecological framework |
Haerens 2006 [42] | - | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity | Belgium | Grades 7-8 | 2 years | Theory of planned behaviour, Transtheoretical model, Social cognitive theory, Attitude, social influence and self-efficacy (ASE) model |
Jansen 2011 [43] | Lekker Fit | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity | Netherlands | Grades 3-8 | 8 months | Theory of planned behaviour, Ecological model |
Llargues 2011 [44] | AVall | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity, Nutrition | Spain | 5-6 year olds | 2 years | Educational methodology ‘IVAC’ |
Luepker 1996 [45] | CATCH | Physical Activity, Nutrition | USA | Grade 3 | 3 years | Social cognitive theory, Social learning theory |
Rush 2012 [46] | Project Energize | Obesity/overweight | New Zealand | 5 and 10 year olds | 2 years | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Sahota 2001 [47] | APPLES | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity, Nutrition | UK | Years 4-5 | 10 months | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Sallis 2003 [48] | M-SPAN | Physical Acivity, Nutrition | USA | Grades 6-8 | 2 years | Ecological model |
Shamah Levy 2012 [49] | Nutrición en Movimiento | Obesity/overweight, Nutrition | Mexico | Grade 5 | 6 months | Not explicitly theory-based, but mentions use of theory of peer learning for one element of the intervention (puppet theatre) |
Trevino 2004 [50] | Bienestar (1) | Physical Activity, Nutrition | USA | Grade 4 | 5 months | Social cognitive theory, Social ecological theory |
Trevino 2005 [51] | Bienestar (2) | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity | USA | Grade 4 | 8 months | Social cognitive theory |
Williamson 2012 [52] | Louisiana (LA) HEALTH | Obesity/overweight, Physical Activity, Nutrition | USA | Grades 4-6 | 2.5 years | Social learning theory |
Tobacco Interventions
| ||||||
De Vries (Denmark) 2003 [53] | ESFA (Denmark) | Tobacco | Denmark | Grade 7 | 3 years | Attitude, social influence and self-efficacy (ASE) model |
De Vries (Finland) 2003 [53] | ESFA (Finland) | Tobacco | Finland | Grade 7 | 3 years | Attitude, social influence and self-efficacy (ASE) model |
Hamilton 2005 [54] | - | Tobacco | Australia | Grade 9 | 2 years | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Perry 2009 [55] | Project MYTRI | Tobacco | India | Grades 6-8 | 2 years | Social cognitive theory, social influences model |
Wen 2010 [56] | - | Tobacco | China | Grades 7-8 | 2 years | Socio-ecological framework, PRECEDE-PROCEED model |
Alcohol Interventions
| ||||||
Komro 2008 [57] | Project Northland (Chicago) | Alcohol, Tobacco, Drugs | USA | Grade 6-8 | 3 years | Theory of triadic influence |
Perry 1996 [58] | Project Northland (Minnesota) | Alcohol, Tobacco, Drugs | USA | Grades 6-8 | 3 years | Social learning theory |
Multiple Risk Behaviour Interventions
| ||||||
Beets 2009 [59] | Positive Action (Hawai’i) | Tobacco, alcohol, drugs, violence, sexual health, academic and school-related outcomes | USA | Grades 2-3 | 3 years | Theory of self-concept, Theory of triadic influence |
Eddy 2003 [60] | LIFT | Tobacco, alcohol, drugs | USA | Grades 1 and 5 | 10 weeks | Coercion theory |
Flay 2004 [61] | Aban Aya | Violence, drugs, sexual health | USA | Grade 5 | 4 years | Theory of triadic influence |
Li 2011 [62] | Positive Action (Chicago) | Tobacco, alcohol, drugs, violence, academic and school-related outcomes | USA | Grade 3 | 6 years | Theory of self-concept, Theory of triadic influence |
Perry 2003 [63] | DARE Plus | Tobacco, alcohol, drugs, violence | USA | Grade 7 | 2 years | Theory of triadic influence |
Schofield 2003 [64] | Hunter Region Health Promoting Schools Program | Tobacco | Australia | Years 7-8 | 2 years | Health Promoting Schools framework Community Organization Theory |
Simons-Morton 2005 [65] | Going Places | Tobacco, alcohol | USA | Grades 6-8 | 3 years | Social cognitive theory |
Sexual health Interventions
| ||||||
Basen-Engquist 2001 [66] | Safer Choices | Sexual health | USA | Grade 9 | 2 years | Social cognitive theory, social influence theory and models of school change |
Ross 2007 [67] | MEMA Kwa Vijana | Sexual health | Tanzania | Students aged 14+ years | 3 years | Social learning theory |
Mental Health and Emotional Well-being Interventions
| ||||||
Bond 2004 [68] | Gatehouse Project | Mental health and emotional well-being, tobacco, drugs, bullying | Australia | Grade 8 | 3 years | Health Promoting schools framework, attachment theory |
Sawyer 2010 [69] | beyondblue | Mental health and emotional well-being | Australia | Year 8 | 3 years | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Violence Prevention Interventions
| ||||||
Orpinas 2000 [70] | Students for Peace | Violence | USA | Grades 6-8 | 3 semesters | Social cognitive theory |
Wolfe 2009 [71] | Fourth R | Violence, sexual health | Canada | Grade 9 | 15 weeks | None stated |
Anti-bullying Interventions
| ||||||
Cross 2011 [72] | Friendly Schools | Bullying | Australia | Grade 4 | 2 years | Health Promoting Schools framework, Social cognitive theory, Ecological theory, Social control theory, Health belief model, Problem behaviour theory |
Cross 2012 [73] | Friendly Schools, Friendly Families | Bullying | Australia | Grades 2, 4 and 6 | 2 years | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Fekkes 2006 [74] | - | Bullying | Netherlands | 9-12 year-olds | 2 years | No specific theory but based on Olweus bullying programme |
Frey 2005 [75] | Steps to Respect | Bullying | USA | Grades 3-6 | 1 year | None stated |
Kärnä 2011 [76] | KiVa (1) | Bullying | Finland | Grade 4-6 | 9 months | Social cognitive theory |
Kärnä 2013 [77] | KiVa (2) | Bullying | Finland | Grade 1–3 and 7-9 | 9 months | Social cognitive theory |
Stevens 2000 [78] | - | Bullying | Belgium | 10 to 16 year-olds | Not clear | Social learning theory |
Hand-washing Interventions
| ||||||
Bowen 2007 [79] | - | Illness from infectious diseases | China | Grade 1 | 5 months | None stated |
Talaat 2011 [80] | - | Illness from infectious diseases | Egypt | Grades 1–3 (for data collection, but all children in school targeted) | 12 weeks | None stated |
Miscellaneous Interventions
| ||||||
Hall 2004 [81] | School Bicycle Safety Project/The Helmet Files | Safety/accidents | Australia | Grade 5 | 2 years | Health Promoting Schools framework |
McVey 2004 [82] | Healthy Schools- Healthy Kids | Body image | Canada | Grade 6-7 | 8 months | Health Promoting Schools framework, Ecological approach |
Olson 2007 [83] | SunSafe | Sun safety | USA | Grades 6-8 | 3 years | Social cognitive theory, Socio-ecological theory, Protection motivation theory |
Tai 2009 [84] | - | Oral health | China | Grade 1 | 3 years | Health Promoting Schools framework |
Impact on health outcomes
Outcome | Intervention focus | Number of studies | Intervention participants | Control participants | Mean difference | 95% CI | I2 | τ |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BMI
|
Nutrition only
| 1 | 479 | 364 | −0.04 | −0.28, 0.20 | n/a | n/a |
Physical Activity only
| 3 | 772 | 658 | −0.38 | −0.73, −0.03* | 86% | 0.08 | |
Physical Activity & Nutrition
| 9 | 6520 | 7108 | −0.11 | −0.24, 0.02 | 84% | 0.03 | |
zBMI
|
Nutrition only
| 1 | 479 | 364 | −0.01 | −0.09, 0.07 | n/a | n/a |
Physical Activity only
| 1 | 102 | 94 | −0.47 | −0.69, −0.25* | n/a | n/a | |
Physical Activity & Nutrition
| 7 | 5672 | 5512 | 0 | −0.04, 0.03 | 41% | 0 | |
Standardised mean diff.
|
95% CI
|
I
2
|
Tau
| |||||
Physical Activity
|
Nutrition only
| 1 | 416 | 335 | 0.02 | −0.02, 0.06 | n/a | n/a |
Physical Activity only
| 2 | 671 | 563 | 0.17 | −0.16, 0.50 | 93% | 0.05 | |
Physical Activity & Nutrition
| 6 | 3244 | 2946 | 0.14 | 0.03, 0.26* | 66% | 0.01 | |
Physical Fitness
|
Physical Activity only
| 2 | 396 | 298 | 0.35 | −0.20, 0.90 | 95% | 0.15 |
Physical Activity & Nutrition
| 3 | 2059 | 2171 | 0.12 | 0.04, 0.20* | 0% | 0 | |
Fat intake
|
Nutrition only
| 7 | 2205 | 2011 | −0.08 | −0.21, 0.05 | 68% | 0.02 |
Physical Activity & Nutrition
| 10 | 6498 | 5962 | −0.04 | −0.20, 0.12 | 95% | 0.06 | |
Fruit & Vegetable intake
|
Nutrition only
| 9 | 3293 | 2917 | 0.15 | 0.02, 0.29* | 83% | 0.03 |
Physical Activity & Nutrition
| 4 | 3507 | 3105 | 0.04 | −0.18, 0.26 | 79% | 0.04 | |
Depression
|
Emotional well-being
| 2 | 3252 | 2847 | 0.06 | −0.00, 0.13 | 0% | 0 |
Anti-bullying
| 1 | 1106 | 1118 | 0 | −0.08, 0.08 | n/a | n/a | |
Odds ratio
|
95% CI
|
I
2
|
Tau
| |||||
Tobacco use
|
Tobacco only
| 3 | 2244 | 2503 | 0.77 | 0.64, 0.93* | 16% | 0 |
Multiple Risk Behaviour
| 5 | 5503 | 4489 | 0.84 | 0.76, 0.93* | 0% | 0 | |
Emotional well-being
| 1 | 315 | 315 | 0.79 | 0.59, 1.06 | n/a | n/a | |
Alcohol only
| 1 | 1005 | 896 | 0.74 | 0.61, 0.90* | n/a | n/a | |
Alcohol use
|
Alcohol only
| 2 | 3506 | 3975 | 0.72 | 0.34, 1.52 | 82% | 0.25 |
Multiple Risk Behaviour
| 4 | 4496 | 3644 | 0.75 | 0.55, 1.02 | 78% | 0.07 | |
Emotional well-being
| 1 | 809 | 810 | 1.13 | 0.76, 1.67 | n/a | n/a | |
Substance use
|
Multiple Risk Behaviour
| 3 | 3804 | 3016 | 0.57 | 0.29, 1.14 | 71% | 0.26 |
Alcohol only
| 2 | 3506 | 3975 | 0.94 | 0.78, 1.12 | 0% | 0 | |
Emotional well-being
| 1 | 233 | 233 | 0.81 | 0.57, 1.15 | n/a | n/a | |
Violence
|
Violence prevention
| 1 | 929 | 1161 | 1.13 | 0.61, 2.07 | n/a | n/a |
Multiple Risk Behaviour
| 3 | 3806 | 3014 | 0.5 | 0.23, 1.09 | 93% | 0.42 | |
Being bullied
|
Anti-bullying
| 6 | 13993 | 12263 | 0.83 | 0.72, 0.96* | 61% | 0.02 |
Multiple Risk Behaviour
| 1 | 2635 | 2108 | 0.97 | 0.90, 1.05 | n/a | n/a | |
Emotional well-being
| 1 | 481 | 482 | 0.88 | 0.68, 1.13 | n/a | n/a | |
Bullying others
|
Anti-bullying
| 6 | 13949 | 12227 | 0.9 | 0.78, 1.04 | 67% | 0.02 |
Multiple Risk Behaviour
| 1 | 195 | 168 | 0.49 | 0.34, 0.71* | n/a | n/a |
BMI/zBMI
Physical activity/fitness
Nutrition
Tobacco
Alcohol
Drugs
Mental health
Violence
Bullying
Other health outcomes
Educational outcomes
Study reference | Intervention type | Authors’ conclusions |
---|---|---|
Li 2011 [62] | Multiple Risk Behaviour | Positive intervention effects found for: student disaffection with learning (P < 0.01); teachers’ ratings of academic motivation (P < 0.05); absenteeism rates (P < 0.05) |
No effect found for: teachers’ ratings of academic performance; standardised test scores for reading and maths | ||
Beets 2009 [59] | Multiple Risk Behaviour | Positive intervention effects found for: standardised test scores for reading and maths (P = 0.043 and 0.006, respectively); absenteeism (P = 0.001); suspensions (P = 0.028); student, teacher and parent ‘School Quality Composite’ scores (P = 0.015, 0.006 and 0.007, respectively) |
No effect found for: student retentions in grade | ||
Fekkes 2006 [74] | Anti-bullying | No effect found for: general satisfaction with school life; satisfaction with contact with other pupils; or satisfaction with contact with teachers |
Bond 2004 [68] | Mental health | Positive intervention effect found for: school attachment (Adj. OR 1.33, 95%CI 1.02 to 1.75; un-adjusted OR non-significant) |
Sahota 2001 [47] | Physical Activity and Nutrition | No effect found for: self-perceived scholastic competence |
Sawyer 2010 [69] | Mental health | Positive intervention effect found for: teacher ratings of school climate over time (intervention x time β = 0.43, P < 0.05) |
No effect found for: student rating of school climate | ||
Bowen 2007 [79] | Hand hygiene | Positive intervention effect found for: attendance. Intervention schools (expanded group) experienced 42% fewer absence episodes (P = .03) and 54% fewer days of absence (P = .03) than control schools |
Talaat 2011 [80] | Hand hygiene | Positive intervention effect found for: attendance. Overall, absences caused by illness were reduced by 21% in intervention schools (5.7 vs. 7.2 median episodes, P < 0.001) |
Simons-Morton 2005 [65] | Multiple Risk Behaviour | No effect found for: students’ perceptions of school climate |
McVey 2004 [82] | Eating disorders | No effect found for: teachers’ perceptions of school climate |
Kärnä 2011 [76] | Anti-bullying | Positive intervention effect found for: well-being at school in intervention students (0.096, P = 0.011) |