Twenty-three face-to-face interviews were conducted with individuals taking part in the intervention arm of the study; 17 were female and 6 male (73 % female compared with 60 % female in the intervention group). The interviews were analysed without relating them to any additional information about the interviewees, such as work role, educational background or socio-economic status. Nine key themes are discussed below.
The workplace food environment and eating habits
Of those interviewed, many described bringing their own food into work with occasional visits to the workplace canteen or shop. Respondents indicated it was cheaper and more time efficient to bring their own lunch to work and avoiding queuing in the canteen. The canteen was associated with queuing, having cooked meals and lack of availability of healthier choices. Despite the perception that the canteen food had improved over time, there was an observation that the food was not of a good quality and was expensive. Fruit (not provided by the intervention) was available in the workplace but it was described as lacking in variety, expensive and not popular.
“Just not very much attention paid to what’s cooked I don’t think, and it’s just… I don’t think they’re fresh foods, very fresh.” [Female_4_I_FW218]
The lack of a microwave in offices and floor kitchens was seen as limiting food options at work.
The desk relationship with food emerged as a theme; described as a preferred and common venue for eating. Eating at desks limited the time taken on breaks so the workforce could take more time off or leave early using flexitime:
“…I think the issue is probably one of culture and how busy people are… you really need to eat at your desk because you’ve got so much work to do” [Male_2_I_FW153]
Another emergent theme was that of the office relationship with food. Many respondents discussed the wide availability of biscuits, cakes and sweets in offices despite the fact that many people were on weight reducing diets:
“… at birthdays people bring in some cakes or biscuits, if they’ve been on holiday they have to bring back some cakes or biscuits, and at Christmas time we all take turns of buying those big 1 kg tins. .” [Male_2_I_FW153]
Dieting was a common theme within the workplace, with colleagues following different weight loss regimes, and diets, food preferences and food a popular topic of conversation:
“we’re all quite focused at the moment, so we’re all sort of bringing salads in, eating our fruit, and yoghurts, you know, things like that, so I don’t know how we could become more healthy.” [Female_2_I_FW149]
Perceived behaviour changes: Effect of the intervention on participants
The majority agreed that participation in the intervention meant they were eating more fruit. The start of the intervention was close to New Year, and for many respondents they had the ambition that it would herald weight loss. Additionally there was the perception that the fruit was helping them to start other healthy behaviours:
“Certainly from my point of view, I think, ‘Well, I’m doing this, I’m getting the fruit, let’s add it to,’ … ‘other lifestyle changes and let’s go out for a walk and let’s do more exercise and see what happens at the end of it.’” [Female_3_I_FW183].
Respondents acknowledged that they had not substituted fruit for other less healthy snacks:
“…but I’m also still eating the chocolate bars and still drinking the cans of pop. So I’m probably just eating more, not substituting.” [Male_2_I_FW153]
This was despite a perception that biscuits and chocolates in the office had decreased since the start of the intervention. Guilt was a reoccurring emergent theme associated with eating less healthy food and the need to eat more healthily:
“We feel a bit more guilty about eating chocolate and cakes all the time, or we eat fewer of them I think.” [Male_4_I_FW240]
However, for most, being part of the intervention appeared to be a driver for increased fruit consumption at work, with respondents feeling obliged to consume fruit at work, but not necessarily at home:
“I probably eat more fruit, definitely, because sometimes I would look at what I’ve got in the fruit bowl at home and think, ‘I don’t fancy any of those.’ But when it’s here and I feel like because I’m part of the study I think, ‘Oh, I should eat it, really,’ …” [Female_3_I_FW271]
A number of respondents commented that as a result of the intervention they were more likely to consume more fruit at the weekend ([Female_4_I_FW229] and [Male_4_I_FW422]).
“…at home I would never dream of just going to the fruit bowl and just picking an apple up, or picking a banana up, but now I’m actually starting to… if I’m having a cup of tea, after my cup of tea, rather than going for a biscuit I’m going to the fruit bowl.” [Female_4_I_FW217]
There was a common theme running through a number of responses that the fruit being provided in the workplace established a ‘habit’, which was easy to maintain outside of work:
“… I just seem to have got into the habit and to be honest I do enjoy it and there are even times when I’ve—especially when it’s come to holiday time and I’m thinking to myself, ‘I’ll have banana on Ryvita today instead of sandwiches,’ so probably eat more fruit and cut down on chocolate bars, because I certainly haven’t eaten as much of those.” [Female_4_I_FW215]
One female respondent described fruit as a weekday food which was not eaten either in the evenings or at the weekend [Female_2_I_FW150]. However, others did see the intervention as a driver to eat more fruit at home as well as at work, including for one, the purchase of a juicer to be used at home:
“… reducing the sweet things, and actually buying more fruit at home as well to kind of keep this up. “[Female_3_I_FW183]
Respondents suggested that taking part in the intervention had meant an increase in the variety of fruits they consumed.
Additionally, taking part in the intervention had highlighted fruit as an alternative snack option to chocolate bars.
Respondents discussed how the intervention had raised awareness around issues of healthy eating and health and how the intervention had a positive effect on them:
“… I’m filling myself up with fruit and I think subconsciously I’ve got that healthy frame of mind, ‘Don’t spoil it by eating a chocolate bar, have fruit today.’ So I think it definitely has had a positive impact. It’s how long I can keep it up for once we don’t get the fruit at work.” [Female_4_I_FW215]
As with the effect on others, guilt was described as a driver for the decreased consumption of other foods:
“Less biscuits and things, … Just guilt because there’s fruit there I think.” [Female_4_I_FW218]
The fruit, provided by the study, was perceived as providing a healthy option without which the workplace option would be “biscuits or nothing” [Female_4_I_FW218].
Respondents were reporting a range of benefits of free fruit, for example improvements in fitness (see section Other Health Behaviours). While respondents described the benefits of consuming the free fruit provided; the ‘medicals’, health checks’ or “weigh ins”, as the ‘measurement aspect of the intervention was frequently described and in particular being weighed was seen as an important aspect of the intervention.
Within offices, the health checks generated much discussion. Having their blood pressure and their anthropometric measurements recorded seemed to be a talking point:
“I think the medicals that we’ve had were comparing you know how’s your blood pressure been this time? Has it gone up or down? You know what’s your waist measurement? What’s your weight? Has that gone up or down? So I think amongst the group that’s taken part we’ve sort of shown a common interest in how we’re all doing and the effect of the fruit.” [Male_4_I_FW249]
Another emergent theme was that of peer support. In one male dominated office there appeared to be a lot of fun around the intervention. The office had fruit eating competitions and one office member described how they “ jilded [encouraged] each other on with the surveys” [Male_4_I_FW177]. The same respondent described how in their office a manager would encourage consumption through using sell-by-dates:
“… we’ve got an office manager who wanders around minesweeping the fruit he sort of cleans it up. He puts the sell by dates on the bananas last week. He writes biro sell by date and it’s still there a week later…” [Male_4_I_FW177]
Perceived behaviour changes: Other health behaviours
In addition to eating more fruit respondents saw their participation in the study as a way to initiate other health behaviours Their consenting to take part in the study coincided with New Year resolutions:
“…So I said that I would cut the Coke out and try and cut down on the chocolate and biscuits and what have you, and try and eat a bit more healthily… and obviously the Fruit At Work kind of kick-started it.” [Female_4_I_FW217]
The opportunity to add other behaviours to the fruit intervention was discussed by a number of respondents:
“.. I think, ‘Well, I’m doing this, I’m getting the fruit, let’s add it to,’ …, ‘other lifestyle changes and let’s go out for a walk and let’s do more exercise and see what happens at the end of it.’” [Female_3_I_FW183]
One male respondent found the intervention made him more generally aware of what he was eating generally and he had started looking at food labels:
“… I find myself looking at the labels on stuff more just, you know, to think, ‘Well, how much is in that?’, or, ‘I wonder if they put salt in that,’ and I’ll find myself turning away stuff that normally I wouldn’t have thought twice about doing, and I don’t know it that’s just… well, it has to be something to do with it because I would never have really done that before.” [Male_4_I_FW422]
There were reflections that the intervention had not necessarily meant an increase in fruit purchases but for example, buying more low fat foods.
Effect of the intervention on others
While interviews were not conducted with non-participants or the control group, increasing the fruit in the office was perceived to have influenced the behaviours of individuals not taking part:
“Somebody who’s in the office who sits opposite me always used to just buy a sandwich at the shop, now I’ve noticed he brings fruit in from work with his sandwich. Now I don’t know if that’s anything to do with it or not, but he does bring fruit in and he didn’t used to.” [Female_4_I_FW215]
Taking part in the study introduced some participants to new terms. For example, the concept of ‘body mass index (BMI)’, and male respondents described that they had started using scales in the office that pre-intervention only women had used. Another intervention office had a juicer—purchased by an office manager as there was surplus (uneaten) fruit in the office to juice.
The effect of the intervention on the office culture was described as making the office feel “more guilty” in terms of consuming cakes and sweets [Male_4_I_FW240]:
“…, at one time we were sort of having snacks, the cakes and the sweets, on a regular basis, but I think we feel more guilty about doing it now, and obviously if you’ve got fruit to eat anyway it takes the edge off your hunger pangs …” [Male_4_I_FW240]
When asked to reflect on the effect of the intervention it was perceived that it may
not have influenced their dietary behaviour, but that it had made them think about their food intake:
“… it’s made everyone think a little bit more about what they eat, because you’re having to record it and that kind of thing… so all it’s done for me is meant that instead of buying fruit and bringing it in, I’ve just had it handed out, which is great, free of charge.” [Male_2_I_FW357]
Aside from their colleagues, respondents noted that their partners and children were eating more fruit as a result of them taking part in the study. For some this was because they were taking extra fruit home, but for others it was about eating fruit at home in front of children and setting a good example.
Sustainability of the intervention
Most respondents were aware that their employers were not paying for the fruit and agreed it would be a very good idea to continue with the free fruit at work. However, they perceived it would be unrealistic. An emergent theme of the fact that their employer was publically funded was dominant in the discussion around the sustainability of the intervention:
“… we’re paid for through public funds and why should taxpayers pay for us to have fruits, I don’t think they should, at the end of the day we’re in jobs, we can afford to buy fruit ourselves. There are a lot of people out there at the moment not in jobs and they could probably do with the fruit more than what we could.” [Male_2_I_FW153]
Given that the expectation to receive free fruit would not be realistic, one respondent suggested that the council provide more fruit in the canteen and at a reduced price.
How to make the workplace healthier
Respondents gave suggestions of how to improve health and eating behaviours at work. There was an acceptance that with flexi-time, people were not going to want to ‘waste’ time getting food. Therefore the solution would be to make desk-based eating healthier, which emerged as a theme. The key to successful desk based eating required minimum preparation:
“You can definitely have healthy food at your desk. But I think the key is it’s got to be pre-prepared. You don’t want to have to try and find a knife and fork or a sharp knife to cut something and prepare the food at your desk” [Male_2_I_FW153]
Another suggestion was the replacement of the tea-trolley with a fruit trolley, where workers are a ‘captive’ audience and the trolley provides healthy options and brings fruit to all floors of the building. One respondent suggested that having someone monitor their weight and BMI made them more conscious of their behaviours:
“What’s to stop trolleys coming round with fruit if they want to keep people healthy at work? [Male_4_I_FW174]
“I’ve never really taken any notice of BMI or what my body fat or waist size, apart from buying clothes. So it’s kind of interesting getting that over a period of time, and it does make you think, ‘Oh, yeah, I want to try and keep that down and make sure it doesn’t increase.’” [Male_2_I_FW357]
Suggestions to improve the healthiness of the workplace included making healthier options available at the canteen and to have a greater variety of fruit available.
“…I definitely think rather than just the bog-standard fruit bowl, you know, with your banana at 50p and your apple at… maybe if there’s a bit more variety in the fruit?” [Female_4_I_FW217]
“It’s just your apples, your oranges, the odd pear and bananas… there is always that… when it’s plonked in a fruit bowl it doesn’t inspire you to eat it…” [Female_4_I_FW217]
Additionally to subsidise the healthier options within the workplace canteen.
There were a number of comments around increasing the availability and variety of foods available in the canteen:
“…the main thing would be if the canteen could offer us more proper fresh vegetables rather than vegetables, you know canteen vegetables that, over necessity, have to sit there for longer than you would like them to.” [Female_4_I_FW261]
There were suggestions that biscuits needed to be removed and the shop that sold scones needed to be taken away [Female_4_I_FW229], while another suggested a “ban” on chocolate and cakes [Female_2_I_FW436]. A number of respondents suggested the workplace continue to provide them with free fruit, however all felt this was unrealistic (see section ‘Sustainability’)
Respondents suggested that workplaces encourage peer support and teams of people in place who could be physically active together:
“…I just think it helps with motivation if you’ve got a group of people doing stuff. So that office environment can help motivate you, it’s that kind of group thing, isn’t it?” [Male_2_I_FW357]
While respondents acknowledged they got preferential membership at a nearby gym, there were suggestions that free gym membership or free classes would be a good motivator.