Background
Methods
Study eligibility
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
Information sources and search strategy
Study selection
Data extraction
Risk of bias and quality assessment of studies
Categorization of enablers and barriers of adherence to ART
Domain | Themes | References (study numbers) |
---|---|---|
Patient | Psychological | |
Shock/denial following a positive HIV result | [1, 6, 9, 14] | |
Motivation to protect infant/self/family | [6, 9, 10] | |
Patient knowledge on ART/PMTCT | ||
Poor knowledge of ART, MTCT | [4] | |
Good knowledge of ART | [3] | |
Self-efficacy | ||
Self-reported ability to adhere to ART | [6, 8] | |
Patient attitude and personal management | ||
Late ANC attendance an obstacle to early AZT prophylaxis and initiation on HAART | [2] | |
Missing clinical appointments | [1] | |
Interrupted personal routine | [4] | |
Patient belief system | ||
Religious belief | [13] | |
Use of traditional medicines | [5] | |
Patient condition | Disease progression | [13] |
Obstetric/ pregnancy | ||
Uncertainty about onset of labour in order to swallow NVP | [1] | |
Previous experience with PMTCT | [9] | |
Therapy | Side effects of ART | [6, 13] |
Perceived effectiveness of therapy | [6, 9] | |
Social and economic factors | Financial difficulty | |
Lack of transport fee to go to health facility for pick-up of ARVs | [1, 2, 3, 13] | |
Lack of money to buy food to eat | [3, 4, 13] | |
Women empowerment | ||
Economically dependent on husbands | [3] | |
Domestic violence either actual or threatened | [4] | |
Lack of male involvement | [2] | |
Cultural conditions and beliefs | ||
Traditional medicines/healers | [4, 5] | |
Religious beliefs | [13] | |
Partner and community – the challenges of disclosure and non-disclosure | ||
Fear of disclosure to partner/family members | [3, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 13, 14] | |
Disclosure to partner/family(facilitating) | [8, 13] | |
HIV infected relatives stealing tablets | [4] | |
Hiding ARVS within the house/taking ARVs in hiding in the house | [4, 5] | |
Pattern of misinformation on ART in the community | [14] | |
HIV related stigma | [2, 5, 9, 10, 13, 15] | |
Community view of HIV- infected persons had no bearing on their decision to begin or continue ART | [3] | |
Sharing medication with others | ||
Sharing ARVs with partner/friend | [1, 4] | |
Positive outlook of known patients living with HIV in the community | ||
Seeing positive results in the community of women taking ART and looking healthy | [9, 10, 12] | |
Health care team/health system | Staff related | |
Fear of mistreatment by HCWs | [1, 3, 7, 10] | |
HCWs providing good counselling on ART | [6, 7, 8] | |
Supply chain management system | ||
Delayed supply of ARVs | [2, 6, 7] | |
Resource/Infrastructure and service related | ||
Prolonged counselling to initiate prophylaxis or ART | [2, 3] | |
Lack of privacy and confidentiality | [2, 7] | |
Inadequate counselling and short contact time with patient | [2] | |
Long waiting time in the health facilities | [3, 11] |
Domain | Predictors | Total number with statistical evidence for association | *List of citations with statistical evidence for association | Total number without statistical evidence for association | List of citations with no statistical evidence for association |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patient | Socio-demographic | ||||
Age of mother | 3 | 13 | Kiarie, et al. 2003 [30], Delvaux, et al. 2009 [29], Bancheno, et al. 2010 [28], Peltzer, et al. 2010 [27], Kinuthia, et al. 2011 [26], Kirsten, et al. 2011 [25], Mirkuzie, et al. 2011 [24], Ekama, et al. 2012 [31], Buseri, et al. 2014 [23], Hampanda 2016 [21], Okawa, et al. 2015 [22], Schnack, et al. 2016 [10], Yotebieng, et al. 2016 [20]. | ||
Married/living with partner | 1 | Delvaux, et al. 2009 [29]. | 9 | ||
Education | 5 | 8 | |||
Illiteracy in primary language | 1 | Stringer, et al. 2003 [37]. | 0 | ||
Patient belief system | |||||
Religion | 0 | 1 | Delvaux, et al. 2009 [29]. | ||
Cultural beliefs: Use of traditional medicine/visiting traditional healer/birth attendant | 2 | 2 | |||
Patient knowledge about HIV/MTCT | 2 | 3 | |||
Patient knowledge of HIV diagnosis before pregnancy | 1 | Parisotto, et al. 2011 [33]. | 1 | Igwegbe, et al. 2010 [34]. | |
Patient knowledge of HIV diagnosis during pregnancy | 2 | 0 | |||
Patient attitude to MTCT | 0 | 2 | |||
Psychological | |||||
Forgetting to take ARV | 1 | Itoua, et al. 2015 [46]. | 0 | ||
Patient condition | Obstetric/ pregnancy history | ||||
Parity | 2 | 5 | |||
Cervical dilation | 1 | Megazzini, et al. 2009 [58] | 0 | ||
Stage of pregnancy/gestational age | 2 | 4 | |||
Exposed to PMTCT in previous pregnancy | 1 | Kuonza, et al. 2010 [36]. | 2 | ||
Premature delivery | 1 | Peltzer, et al. 2010 [27]. | 0 | ||
WHO Clinical staging | 2 | 0 | |||
CD4 count at admission | 1 | Ebuy, et al. 2015 [48], | 0 | ||
Therapy | Duration on therapy | 2 | 1 | Mirkuzie, et al. 2011 [24]. | |
Type of PMTCT drug regimen | 1 | Ebuy, et al. 2015 [48]. | 1 | Mepham, et al. 2011 [38] | |
ARV side effects | 1 | Kamuyango, et al. 2014 [77] | 1 | Itoua, et al. 2015 [46]. | |
Social and economic | Women empowerment | ||||
Not receiving financial support from a partner or husband | 1 | El-Khatib, et al. 2011 [35]. | 0 | ||
Income generating activities /occupation | 2 | Igwegbe, et al. 2010 [34], Bisio, et al.2013 [75]. | 7 | ||
Housing(monthly rent) | 1 | Igwegbe, et al. 2010 [34]. | 0 | ||
Financial difficulty | |||||
Distance to health facility | 0 | 2 | |||
Partner and community | |||||
Partner aware/informed of HIV test results/willing to have HIV test/partner came for HIV test/partner support use of ARV | 10 | 4 | |||
Partner uninformed about ARV | 1 | Itoua, et al. 2015 [46]. | 1 | Matthews, et al. 2016. [76] | |
Disclosure to someone(not partner)/discussion of PMTCT prophylaxis with family/friends/others | 6 | 3 | |||
male partner involvement in PMTCT/ANC | 2 | 1 | Schnack, et al. 2016 [10]. | ||
Partner violence | |||||
Sexual violence | 1 | Hampanda 2016 [21]. | 0 | ||
Emotional violence | 0 | 1 | Hampanda 2016 [21]. | ||
Physical violence | 0 | 1 | Hampanda 2016 [21]. | ||
Partners’ HIV status | |||||
Positive | 1 | Igwegbe, et al. 2010 [34]. | 0 | ||
Negative | 0 | 1 | Igwegbe, et al. 2010 [34]. | ||
Unknown | 0 | 1 | Igwegbe, et al. 2010 [34]. | ||
Attend support group/treatment supporter/partner support | 4 | 0 | |||
Place of residence | |||||
Living in a village where HIV research is being conducted | 1 | Barigye, et al. 2010 [57]. | 0 | ||
Living in rural or urban. | 0 | 1 | Ebuy, et al. 2015 [48] | ||
HIV related stigma/experienced discrimination | 3 | 0 | |||
Feeling embarrassed | 1 | Itoua, et al. 2015 [46]. | 0 | ||
Health care team/Health system | Number of ANC visits/clinic attendance | 3 | 1 | Mepham, et al. 2011 [38]. | |
Quality of post-test counseling/counseling on ARV side effects | 2 | 0 | |||
Confidentiality at health facility | 1 | Peltzer, et al. 2010 [27] | 0 |
Results
Characteristics of included studies
S/N | Author: Year | Country: Setting | Study Design | Participants/overall sample size | Type of PMTCT intervention implemented | QAR of studies |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Meda, et al. 2002 [64] | Cote’d Ivoire and Burkina Faso Urban in both countries. | Randomised clinical trial | HIV+ pregnant women enrolled in an open label cohort at 36–38 weeks gestation to receiving an oral course of zidovudine. (404) | ZDV | ** |
2 | *Kiarie, et al. 2003 [30] | Kenya: Urban | Randomised clinical trial | HIV+ pregnant women enrolled in a clinical trial in a tertiary HF. (124) | ZDV,SdNVP | **** |
3 | Stringer, et al. 2003 [37] | Zambia: Urban | Clustered-randomised clinical trial | HIV+ pregnant women attending two HF in the trial. (201) | SdNVP | ** |
4 | Farquhar, et al. 2004 [54] | Kenya: Urban | Prospective cohort study | Pregnant women attending one clinic; male partners.(1991) | SdNVP | **** |
5 | Banda, et al. 2007 [47] | Zambia: Urban | Clinical trial: sub-analysis | HIV + pregnant women enrolled in a clinical trial of perinatal HIV prevention strategies at two district delivery centres.(78) | SdNVP | * |
6 | Coffie,et al. 2008 [69] | Ivory Cost: Urban | Prospective cohort study | HIV + women pregnant registered in a PMTCT plus programme. (247) | cART (ZDV + 3TC + NVP) (94.7%): (D4T + 3TC + NVP) (2.8%): (ZDV + 3TC + EFV (2.1%): (D4T + 3TC + EFV) (0.4%). | *** |
7 | Msuya, et al. 2008 [53] | Tanzania: Urban | Prospective cohort study | HIV+ pregnant women attending ANC at two public clinics for PMTCT services; with/without male partner support. (184) | SdNVP | **** |
8 | Peltzer, et al. 2008 [52] | South Africa: Unclear | Cross sectional study | HIV+ pregnant women in a PMTCT cohort from five clinics (66). | SdNVP | **** |
9 | Delvaux, et al. 2009 [29] | Rwanda: Urban and rural | Case-control study | HIV + pregnant women who did not adhere (cases) and adhered (control) to PMTCT prophylaxis at 12 PMTCT sites. (236) | SdNVP | **** |
10 | Megazzini, et al. 2009 [58] | Zambia: Urban | Clustered randomised clinical trial: sub-analysis | Pregnant women in the trial intervention arm who had HCT in the labour ward.(23) | SdNVP | * |
11 | *Bancheno, et al. 2010 [28] | Swaziland: Rural | Retrospective cohort study | HIV + pregnant women registered for PMTCT services in a rural HF. (99) | SdNVP | * |
12 | Barigye, et al. 2010 [57] | Uganda: Rural | Prospective cohort study | HIV + pregnant women registered for PMTCT services at four clinics located in study and non-study villages. (83) | SdNVP | **** |
13 | Igwegbe, et al. 2010 [34] | Nigeria: Urban | Cross sectional study | HIV+ pregnant women attending PMTCT clinic in a tertiary HF.(368) | cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | *** |
14 | Kuonza, et al. 2010 [36] | Zimbabwe: Urban | Cross sectional study | HIV + pregnant women and their infants registered in PMTCT programme in four HF. (212) | SdNVP | *** |
15 | Megazzini, et al. 2010 [65] | Zambia: Urban | Clustered randomised clinical trial: | HIV + pregnant women receiving PMTCT services in 12 public delivery centres. (498) | SdNVP | * |
16 | Peltzer, et al. 2010 [27] | South Africa: Rural | Cross sectional study | HIV + pregnant women and their infants at 47 HFs. (815) | SdNVP | *** |
17 | Shapiro, et al. 2010 [66] | Botswana: Urban and rural | Randomised control trial | HIV + pregnant women enrolled into the trial at four HFs.(730) | cART (ABC + AZT + 3TC): Lopinarvir-ritonavir+AZT + 3TC): (NVP + AZT + 3TC). | ** |
18 | El-Khatib,et al. 2011 [35] | South Africa: Urban | Prospective cohort study | HIV + women pregnant registered in an ART programme in a single HF. (147) | cART (D4T + 3TC + NVor EFV). | *** |
19 | Kinuthia, et al. 2011 [26] | Kenya: Urban | Cross sectional study | Sub set of HIV+ women and their infants attending six MCH clinics.(318) | Short course AZT regimen, sdNVP. | **** |
20 | Kirsten, et al. 2011 [25] | Tanzania: Rural | Prospective cohort study | HIV + women pregnant registered in a single HF offering PMTCT services. (150) | AZT and cART (AZT + 3TC). | **** |
21 | *Mepham, et al. 2011 [38]. | South Africa: Rural | Randomised control trial | HIV + pregnant women receiving PMTCT services in a HF. (94) | cART(specific ARV drugs combination NR). | * |
22 | Mirkuzie, et al. 2011 [24] | Ethiopia: Urban | Prospective cohort study | HIV + pregnant women attending 15 HF and their infants.(282) | cART and ZDV prophylaxis. | *** |
23 | Parisotto, et al. 2011 [33] | Burkina Faso: Urban | Retrospective cohort study | HIV + pregnant women and their children at one HF.(229) | Short course ARV prophylaxis: Actual ARV drug(s) NR. | **** |
24 | Peltzer, et al. 2011 [50] | South Africa: Rural | Cross sectional study | HIV + pregnant and postnatal women and their infants recruited from 48 HFs.(746) | AZT | **** |
25 | Ekama, et al. 2012 [31] | Nigeria: Urban | Cross sectional study | HIV+ pregnant women registered for PMTCT services at ART treatment centre.(170) | cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | ** |
26 | Okonji, et al.2012 [67] | Kenya: Urban | Clinical trial: sub-analysis | HIV + women pregnant enrolled into the trial at a single HF rendering combination ART for PMTCT.(434) | cART (NVP + 3TC + ZDV, NFV + 3TC + ZDV). | ** |
27 | Bisio, et al. 2013 [75] | Republic of Congo: Urban and rural. | Prospective uncontrolled interventional study | HIV + women pregnant attending four Antenatal clinics.(415) | cART(AZT + 3TC + NVP, D4T + 3TC + NVP) | *** |
28 | Denoeud-Ndam, et al. 2013 [70] | Benin: Urban | Prospective cohort study | HIV + women pregnant at 5 hospitals attending ANC. (217) | cART (EFV/NVP/PI). | *** |
29 | Buseri, et al. 2014 [23] | Nigeria: Urban and rural. | Cross sectional study | HIV + pregnant women receiving PMTCT services at ANC in four hospitals. (312) | cART (AZT or D4T + 3TC + NVPor EFV). | ** |
30 | Kamuyango et al. 2014 [77] | Malawi: Urban and rural | Retrospective cohort study | HIV + women in ART sites who received ARV intervention for PMTCT.(292) | cART (D4T + 3TC + NVP: TDF + 3TC + EFV). | **** |
31 | *Murithi, et al. 2015 [41] | Kenya: Urban | Cross sectional study | HIV + women pregnant receiving care in a PMTCT clinic.(55) | cART(specific ARV drugs combination NR). | ** |
32 | Ebuy, et al. 2015 [48] | Ethiopia: Urban and rural | Cross sectional study | HIV + women pregnant registered for PMTCT in six hospitals. (263) | cART (EFV + 3TC + TDF). | **** |
33 | Itoua,et al. 2015 [46] | Republic of Congo: Urban | Cross analytical and transversal study | HIV + women pregnant and lactating enrolled in three treatment centres. (80) | cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | ** |
34 | Ngoma, et al. 2015 [71] | Zambia: Urban | Prospective cohort study | HIV + pregnant women with the ability to initiate combination ART AT 14–30 weeks at a public HF. (226) | cART (AZT + 3TC + Lopinavir/ ritonavir). | *** |
35 | Okawa, et al.2015 [22] | Zambia: Rural | Prospective cohort study | HIV + pregnant women registered in PMTCT service at eleven HFs. (481) | AZT, sdNVP, and cART (specific ARV drugs NR). | *** |
36 | *Granato, et al. 2016 [78] | Cote d’ Ivoire: Urban and Rural. | Cross sectional study | HIV positive pregnant women enrolled in PMTCT services attending 29 HFs. (219) | cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | **** |
37 | Haas, et al. 2016 [32] | Malawi: Urban and rural. | Retrospective cohort study | HIV + women pregnant and postpartum women who commenced ART regimen at 13 HFs. (4248) | cART(EFV + 3TC + TDF | **** |
38 | Hampanda 2016 [21] | Zambia: Urban | Cross sectional study | HIV + postpartum women and their infants at a large HF attending child immunization.(402) | SdNVP and cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | **** |
39 | Matthews, et al. 2016 [76] | Uganda: Rural | Prospective cohort study | HIV + pregnant women; a subset of more than 7000 HIV infected adults initiating their ART in a tertiary HF.(396) | cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | **** |
40 | *Napua, et al. 2016 [40] | Mozambique: Urban | Clustered(facility level) randomised controlled trial | HIV + women pregnant registered in 6 high volume HFs providing PMTCT and ART services. (141) | cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | * |
41 | Schnack, et al. 2016 [10] | Uganda: Urban. | Observational longitudinal study. | HIV + pregnant women attending ANC in two hospitals with PMTCT programme. (76) | cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | ** |
42 | Yotebieng, et al. 2016 [20] | DRC Congo: Urban. | Randomised clinical trial | Newly diagnosed HIV + pregnant women registering for ANC at 89 HFs. (300) | AZT, and cART (specific ARV drugs combination NR). | * |
S/N | Author: Year | Country: Setting | Study design | Participants and type of PMTCT intervention implemented | Sample size | QAR of studies |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | *Kiarie, et al. 2003 [30] | Kenya: Urban | FGDs | HIV+ pregnant and postpartum women enrolled in a clinical trial in a tertiary HF. (ZDV,SdNVP) | 7 FGDs (4 sessions with pregnant women and 3 sessions with postpartum women). | **** |
2 | *Bancheno, et al. 2010 [28] | Swaziland: Rural | IDIs | HIV + pregnant women registered for PMTCT services in a rural HF: Nurses, nurse assistants. (SdNVP) | 64 Interviews (nurses and nurse assistants) | *** |
3 | Duff, et al.2010 [39] | Uganda: Urban and rural | IDIs and FGDs | HIV + mothers registered in PMTCT programme. (cART) | 45 IDIs; 1 FGD (8 women). | **** |
4 | *Mepham, et al. 2011 [38]. | South Africa: Rural | IDIs | HIV + pregnant women receiving PMTCT services in a HF. (cART) | 20 interviews | **** |
5 | Ujiji, et al. 2011 [45] | Kenya: Rural | Narratives | HIV + pregnant women already receiving ART in two HFs. (cART) | 28; 12 urban and 16 rural. | *** |
6 | Buesseler, et al. 2014 [42] | Cote d’Ivoire:Rural | IDIs | HIV + mothers registered in PMTCT integration programme at four HFs: HCWs. (cART) | IDIs:24 women,5 HCWs. | *** |
7 | Gourlay, et al. 2014 [59] | Tanzania: Rural | PLA and IDIs | HIV + women attending four HF for PMTCT services: HIV- women: HCWs: Health officials. (specific short course antiretroviral regimen not mentioned) | 61 PLA (3male, 3 female groups with 8–12 participants): 30 IDIs (16 HIV + &5 HIV – women, 6 HCWs, 3 health officials. | **** |
8 | Kastner, et al. 2014 [51] | Uganda: Urban | IDIs | Women attending HIV clinic for follow up (HIV + pregnant women in their 2ND AND 3RD trimester. (cART) | IDIs:25 pregnant women | *** |
9 | *Murithi, et al. 2015 [41] | Kenya: | IDIs | HIV + women pregnant receiving care in a PMTCT clinic. (specific short course antiretroviral regimen not mentioned) | IDIs:15 pregnant women | ** |
10 | Elwell, 2016 [43] | Malawi: Urban and rural. | IDIs and FGDs | HIV + pregnant women in a PMTCT programme at four HFs: Community leaders: HCWs. (cART) | IDIs(25 women,19HCWs and 32 community leaders);FGDs(53 women, 32 community leaders) | *** |
11 | *Granato, et al. 2016 [78] | Cote d’ Ivoire: Urban and Rural. | IDIs | HIV positive pregnant women enrolled in PMTCT services attending 30 HFs. (cART) | 30 key informant interviews | **** |
12 | Katirayi, et al., 2016 [56] | Malawi: Urban, peri-urban and rural. | IDIs and FGDs | HIV + pregnant and postpartum women enrolled in a PMTCT programme: HCWs. (cART) | 39IDIs (19 pregnant women and 20 postpartum women): 16 FGDs (4 pregnant women, 4 HCWs, and 8 postpartum women). | **** |
13 | Kim, et al. 2016 [44] | Malawi: Urban and rural. | IDIs | HIV + pregnant women and postpartum attending ANC at four HF offering ART services. (cART) | 65IDIs | **** |
14 | *Napua, et al. 2016 [40] | Mozambique: Urban | IDIs and FGDs | HIV + women pregnant registered in 6 high volume HFs providing PMTCT and ART services: HCWS. (cART) | 49 IDIs (8 at 5 sites, and 9 at 1 site): 12 FGDs (ANC patients: 1 FGD per site with 5–10 participants, and with HCWs (1 per site with 6–9 participants). | **** |
15 | O’Gorman, et al. 2010 [55] | Malawi: Rural | IDIs and FGDs | Ante/post-natal women, fathers, grandmothers, TBAs, health workers, community leaders. (specific short course antiretroviral regimen not mentioned) | 26 interviews(4 antenatal women, 5 grandmothers, 4HCWs, 5 traditional birth attendants, 3 fathers, 3 church leaders, 2 chiefs): 5 FGDs in total(29 antenatal women in 3 FGDs, 6 postnatal women in 1 FGD, 9 fathers in 1 FGD. | **** |