Background
Facilitated knowledge translation intervention | Passive knowledge translation intervention | |
---|---|---|
Personnel | There was funding for two facilitators (one nurse and one therapist). | None |
Frequency and duration | 4 h/week/facilitator in each intervention site to promote guideline implementation over a 16-month period | Not applicable |
Components | At a two-day workshop: facilitators received change management education, a practice-change toolkit, information on successful guideline implementation strategies from the pilot study, slide presentations, and clinician-targeted media releases for marketing SCORE. They also completed training to apply treatments, compared current practice with recommended practice, identified barriers to practice change, developed a guideline implementation plan addressing barriers and incorporating behaviour change strategies, and learned how to conduct small group education/training sessions. In addition, stroke teams received SCORE guideline booklets with treatment recommendations and evidence-based treatment protocols, pocket reminder cards, and posters describing protocols designed for therapists or nurses. Teleconferences and a web-based platform were provided for facilitators to communicate and share successful strategies. | Sites in the passive KT intervention received a version of the SCORE guideline without treatment protocols, and a handbook and educational DVD on the use of standardized assessment tools post-stroke. In addition, clinicians were invited by email to participate in a list serve to obtain additional information or share experiences about the trial outcome measures. |
Research team involvement | The research team provided external facilitation to the facilitators; specifically, advice and support via teleconferences. | None |
Methods
Guiding conceptual framework
Design/Approach
Recruitment
Data collection
Data analysis
Ethics and trial registration
Results
Description of the rehabilitation centers
Overview of themes - facilitators and barriers influencing implementation of the SCORE-IT
Theme | Quote | Source |
---|---|---|
Facilitation | Without the facilitator and the model, I don’t think we would have gotten as far as we did with the implementation of best practice. | Manager, Facilitated Site 4 |
One of the physiotherapists initially oriented the staff as to what it was about, and I’ve always thought of her as the go-to person for information. | Nurse, Passive Site 3 | |
And what I tried to sort of make clear early on was that this, we were all in this project. Participation wasn’t an option so if either of the two sort of leaders of the project encountered any difficulties, be it with staff or lack of equipment, resources, anything like that, they were to let me know. Because if need be either [name] or I would have been the bad guy and stepped in. That never happened but they, I think they certainly felt that they weren’t out there on their own and we stressed at the beginning, it wasn’t their project, it was a [site name] project so they … We didn’t need to be the heavy but I think everyone understood that, you know, if need be we were there. | Manager, Facilitated Site 2 | |
I think [name] took a leadership role in regards to the project itself. | Therapist, Passive Site 5 | |
Agreement with the Intervention – Practical | Yes, we had our pocket cards, little laminated pocket cards, and those were quite useful. And also the posters in the rooms, for positioning, if you weren’t sure it was right there, so that was wonderful. | Nurse, Facilitated Site 2 |
The posters in the rooms were very helpful. The transfer and positioning posters were great to have above the beds, just to help make sure everything was done properly. The digital frame was also very helpful | Nurse, Facilitated Site 6 | |
Familiarity with the Recommended Treatments | We were doing the CMSA (Chedoke-McMaster Stroke Assessment) before so that wasn’t new... We were already doing some of the upper extremity tasks… | Therapist, Passive Site 4 |
From the recommendations, a lot of the stuff we were already doing. Things like aerobic conditioning, I found like the implementations reinforced that that was a good thing we were doing. | Manager, Passive Site 3 | |
Team Communication and Interdisciplinary Collaboration | We have good relationships. Certainly it is a good relationship but I think it only got better when we did this particular education piece of it or how we particularly did it. Because I think we gave each of the groups a little more respect for the other group in terms of what they do. Because, you know, a lot of nurses really don’t know what OTs actually do because O therapy is a little more objective in terms of working with muscle groups and joints and things like this. But with OT, you know, they sort of take the patients off to the bathroom or up to their work area or whatever and they just don’t know a heck of a lot of what they do. But with this little educational piece that we did, they learned. | Nurse, Passive Site 1 |
I think generally, among the physios, we tend to talk to each other a fair bit. And even among the OTs and the other team, if there’s issues, we’re talking. If not on a daily basis, then at least every 2 or 3 days. Definitely in rounds. Sort of even informally consulting in the corridors with stuff like that about various patients. | Therapist, Passive Site 1 | |
…we established early, early on was a committee, sort of a joint therapist, nursing staff, healthcare aid committee. So as we were moving forward communication happened within that committee. | Manager, Passive Site 2 | |
Team Communication and Interdisciplinary Collaboration | The workshop was very good at explaining the “why” behind the treatment modalities, and I think that was helpful. That was more helpful than just a list of recommendations, because having a rationale and a justification for why a treatment is the best choice was useful. | Therapist, Passive Site 3 |
Yes. From an interdisciplinary standpoint, PT and OT have a mixed office now. The stroke unit has an office now as well. There has been more collaboration and team work. The staff that has signed up to work on the dedicated stroke unit are working on the dedicated stroke unit. They interact more, and there is more collaboration | Manager, Facilitated Site 4 | |
And I think you’re also encouraging each other with it because now that you’ve gone through the education and been part of this project… | Nurse, Passive Site 1 |
Theme | Quote | Source |
---|---|---|
Lack of facilitation | It was good in theory, but we needed a person to continue with the program and reinforce it. After the booklets were handed out, we never went back to them, and I think the education needed to continue right away. If there had been someone whose main goal was to facilitate the implementation, without being pulled in different directions by other responsibilities, I think things would have gone much better. | Nurse, Facilitated Site 4 |
We didn’t have somebody who I thought could be an actual overseer of this. If we were trying to do this again, it might be better to either have a senior being the person overseeing the project, or even get the nurse educator we have on board doing that kind of thing. | Manager, Passive Site 3 | |
We did have some new staff that came in and watched the DVD but had a bit of trouble with it because it was a very busy time for us so there was very little mentorship I think. | Therapist, Passive Site 3 | |
So I think one of the things I would suggest too is that we get a champion on the nursing unit to really, somebody who works on the unit. I mean I don’t work on the unit. I’m all over the building as an educator but somebody like [name] who would get specific education and be the champion, be the one that could be, you know, the supporter on the units, be encouraging the other staff that she’s working with to be involved and to be doing it. I think that would help… | Nurse, Passive Site 1 | |
We had one nurse who was more involved in SCORE, but because she didn’t work full time she wasn’t there every day so we missed a bit of the information and the teaching we could have gotten because she wasn’t a full time worker. I think we needed a full-time worker to be involved to have a more significant influence in pushing SCORE. She tried to get everyone aware of the project and the recommendations, and she transferred the information along to the staff. She made sure everyone was involved, and that everyone was up to date on the information about the project. | Nurse, Facilitated Site 6 | |
Lack of agreement with the intervention – not practical | The DVD was a little dry. It was hard to stay awake during the presentation, so I really don’t remember much of it. At the time we were watching it we were short-staffed and trying to cram it into a lunch hour so it was hard to pay attention. I didn’t find the DVD all that useful. | Manager, Passive Site 3 |
I know, for example that one of the recommendations for the frequency of the FES for the upper extremity was feasible for clients that were completely independent for the setup of the FES, but I think the two 30 min sessions per day recommendation was difficult to complete. Some of the recommendations were not so realistic to follow due to time constraints. | Therapist, Facilitated Site 6 | |
Lack of familiarity with the recommended treatments | There were some knowledge barriers about the process of functional electrical stimulation. The specifics of being comfortable with doing it, and the intricacies, those were a barrier. | Manager, Passive Site 3 |
I think the one thing I really struggled with before I left on Mat leave was starting the muscle stim just because I didn’t have the background as to why it was being used. | Therapist, Facilitated Site 2 | |
It could have been nice to see how that worked but we didn’t have the equipment or the education, and we wouldn’t have been comfortable doing FES without the proper training and knowledge. | Therapist, Facilitated Site 4 | |
I think we struggled the most with the [spell out acronym] CAHAI because that was new for a lot of us, and that we needed to review the most. | Therapist, Facilitated Site 7 | |
Environmental factors [Lack of Space and Equipment] | Space was a bit of a barrier for the 6 min walk test, in terms of finding enough open space without obstacles. | Manager, Passive Site 5 |
Equipment was also a barrier. Some of the slings seemed to go missing, and we didn’t have FES equipment so those are just a few examples. | Therapist, Facilitated Site 4 | |
Environmental factors [Organizational Constraints] | It was a good experience, and I would do it again, but it was definitely a lot of work, and maybe it could have been more heightened with our leadership team. | Manager, Facilitated Site 4 |
I would say no. They were aware of the project, and were given updates at the quarterly meetings, but they did not have a direct involvement. | Manager, Passive Site 5 | |
Environmental factors [Time Pressure] | Another thing is I guess the implementation took more time than I thought it would, it was a bit harder to set things up than I expected. | Manager, Facilitated Site 4 |
The CMSA was very time consuming, so I think people struggled with the time aspect, spending so much time on all of the implementations. The value of the activities was appreciated, but going through all of the tools and processes was time consuming and people resented how much time it took to implement everything. | Manager, Passive Site 3 | |
…we just haven’t got time. We’ve got new people coming in, we’ve got measures to record that we didn’t do before and I think an underlying problem is that the unit now is so busy that it isn’t adequately staffed for both physio and OT. And that’s a pre-existing problem. I think the study maybe just highlighted it a little bit but I think the therapists were, did feel a certain pressure because they knew they hadn’t got their assessments done. They knew they hadn’t got their discharge paperwork done but the patients just kept coming and coming and coming. And I’m sure that’s not unique to us and I’m sure, you know, if we gave them ten more therapists in a year’s time they’d say, they were short of staff. But I think the time was the big thing. | Manager, Facilitated Site 2 | |
Environmental factors [Insufficient Staff] | We’ve been through a lot of change in the hospital, because our therapists rotate, so we were moved around a bit. That’s really part of the whole problem, because the staff that was up here got moved around, and the unit was closed for a bit around Christmas. It became difficult to incorporate best practices when we were dealing with all of these issues. I think we had to deal with therapists moving around and also being a bit understaffed. | Therapist, Passive Site 5 |
We had staffing issues, especially OT staffing issues. We still have those issues. We’ve been at about 60% of OT staffing for a while now. The staffing for RN as well, we couldn’t get those ratios to the level we wanted. | Manager, Passive Site 4 | |
It was quite difficult since we were short staffed for probably two thirds of the duration of the project; it was difficult to do new things. When we hired a senior therapist she came on board for the last 3 months and she was able to start implementing things we would have liked to have done, some of the recommendations. I think if you have the right people, it is much easier but when we were short staffed that limited us and we just tried to do our best. | Manager, Passive Site 3 | |
Environmental factors [Lack of Space and Equipment] | Space was a bit of a barrier for the 6 min walk test, in terms of finding enough open space without obstacles. | Manager, Passive Site 5 |
Equipment was also a barrier. Some of the slings seemed to go missing, and we didn’t have FES equipment so those are just a few examples. | Therapist, Facilitated Site 4 | |
Environmental factors [Organizational Constraints] | It was a good experience, and I would do it again, but it was definitely a lot of work, and maybe it could have been more heightened with our leadership team. | Manager, Facilitated Site 4 |
I would say no. They were aware of the project, and were given updates at the quarterly meetings, but they did not have a direct involvement. | Manager, Passive Site 5 | |
Lack of team communication and interdisciplinary collaboration | Well I haven’t even seen these recommendations, so I think getting together as a group and discussing it would have been useful. We should have had a meeting together to go over it, because I think we only really knew about the sheets where we ticked off the patients’ progress. | Nurse, Passive Site 5 |
Some of the feedback I heard was that it would have been great if we had a blog or if we had a bulletin board of some sort that people would go in, post their question, had their questions answered and that kind of thing. So it would have been a little more timely in terms of getting things off the ground and that kind of stuff. It would have provided more timely clarification I think. | Manager, Passive Site 1 | |
I would, like I was saying, just maybe more communication between the disciplines as to what’s going on. That nurse facilitators may be having a meeting every few months or whatever it is, just to make sure that everybody is on the same page. | Nurse, Passive Site 2 |