Background
Evidence-based smoking cessation care
The Indigenous Counselling and Nicotine QUIT in Pregnancy intervention
Underpinning models and frameworks
Behaviour Change Wheel
Theoretical Domains Framework
Indigenous-specific factors
Methods
Aim, design and setting
Materials and processes
-
Smoking by Indigenous women during pregnancy is a complex challenge and has multiple contributing factors.
-
Clinicians ask and advise about smoking but less frequently assess, assist and arrange follow-up.
-
Clinicians report a lack of confidence and optimism for helping their pregnant patients stop smoking. NRT prescription rates are also low.
-
Aboriginal pregnant women report deficiencies in being provided important elements of smoking cessation care, such as being prescribed NRT, and being given consistent messages.
Use of the BCW and TDF by the research team
Results
Designing approach to health provider behaviour change
Stage 1: understand the behaviour
Step 1: define problem in behavioural terms
Health provider behaviours
Step 2: select the target behaviour
Step 3: specify the target behaviour
Step 4: identifying what needs to change
Barriers to smoking cessation care | COM-B | TDF | Intervention function | BCTs | Translation of BCTs within the ICAN QUIT in Pregnancy intervention |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clinicians infrequently provide cessation support during pregnancy. Clinicians lack knowledge, skills and confidence to counsel women who smoke during pregnancy and to prescribe NRT. Lack of clinician training relevant to smoking cessation during pregnancy Women report infrequently receiving assistance from clinicians | Psychological capability | Cognitive and interpersonal skills | Education Training Enablement | Information on health, social, emotional and environmental consequences Information antecedents Instruction on how to perform behaviour | Webinar training on how to consult Indigenous pregnant smokers and prescribe NRT Training manual Videos of providers and patients |
Memory, attention and decision | Environmental restructuring | Restructuring physical environment Prompts, cues | Flipchart and desktop guide Patient resources | ||
Behaviour regulation | Modelling Incentivisation | Demonstration of behaviour Feedback on behaviour Rewarding completion | Audit and feedback about NRT prescribed CPD points for training | ||
Clinicians lack optimism that their treatment will be successful during pregnancy | Reflective motivation | Belief about capability Belief about consequences Optimism | Education Training Persuasion Enablement | Information on health, social, emotional and environmental consequences Credible source Persuasion about capability Framing/reframing Salience of consequences Social comparison Adding objects to the environment | Provide resources Smoking reframed as an addiction, not a choice Inform re standard practices and evidence-based practices Building self-efficacy Build response efficacy—it is worthwhile—NNT only 16–17 for quitting Motivational videos, testimonials and success stories Celebrating small wins and turning ‘near misses’ into success |
Automatic motivation | Reinforcement Emotion | Environmental restructuring Persuasion | Credible source Exposure Framing/reframing Social comparison | Provide resources Emotive videos of health providers and patients | |
Clinicians lack time and resources to provide smoking cessation care. Oral NRT is not subsidised in Australia forming a barrier to prescribing | Physical opportunity | Environmental context Resources | Environmental restructuring Enablement | Adding objects to the environment Problem solving Self-monitoring of behaviour | Free NRT samples and oral NRT vouchers Referral pads Flipchart and desktop guide Patient booklets |
Few clinicians perform comprehensive smoking cessation care so there are few role models | Social opportunity | Norms Social influences | Modelling Education and training | Social comparison Credible source Instruction on how to perform behaviour Self-monitoring of behaviour | Whole of service training Interactive webinar Audit and feedback Videos of positive attitudes of other health providers |
Stage 2: identify intervention options
Step 1: intervention functions
Step 2: policy categories
Stage 3: identifying content and implementation options
Step 1: behaviour change techniques
Step 2: mode of delivery
Design approach to patient resources
Barriers to smoking cessation care | COM-B | TDF | Intervention function | BCTs | Translation of BCTs within the ICAN QUIT in Pregnancy intervention |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Indigenous pregnant women report symptoms of nicotine dependence and withdrawal effects from attempts to quit. Increased nicotine metabolism in pregnancy can increase cigarette consumption and also requires higher doses of NRT | Physical capability | Physical skills | Education Enablement | Provide feedback on current behaviour and dependence levels Assess withdrawal symptoms Biofeedback with carbon monoxide readings Making a quit plan and/or setting quit date Advise on stop-smoking medication Enable clients to obtain free medication | Free NRT for physical addiction Videos on how to use different types of NRT |
Aboriginal women lack detailed knowledge about the harms of smoking. Stressful life circumstances may also impact on a women’s psychological capability to quit. Historical antecedents of smoking in Indigenous communities, racism, health disparities and low socio-economic status can impair capability to quit | Psychological capability | Knowledge | Education | Provide information on consequences of smoking and smoking cessation Instruction on how to quit smoking Offer appropriate written materials | Health booklet, supportive counselling and videos showing effects of smoking on mother and child Discuss psychosocial contexts of smoking |
Cognitive and interpersonal skills | Persuasion | Facilitate goal setting Facilitate barrier identification and problem solving Facilitate relapse prevention and coping Facilitate action planning and develop quit plan Advise on conserving mental resources | Discussion of psychosocial context of smoking Build self-efficacy for quitting Culturally appropriate colouring-in pages for diversion and relaxation | ||
Memory, attention and decision | Environmental restructuring Enablement | Advise on avoiding social cues for smoking Elicit client views Provide reassurance | Text and video on how to make a smoke-free home Personalised quit plan and goal setting Patient resources | ||
Behaviour regulation | Enablement Modelling | Messages from salient others—peers and experts NRT to reduce withdrawal effects Carbon monoxide readings Videos of role models Counselling on stressors and triggers | |||
Few positive role models, as Indigenous smoking prevalence is high Targeted messages preferred Existing media messages may lack salience. Not wanting to be ‘told what to do’. Didactic counselling styles are unwelcome | Reflective motivation | Social role/identity Belief about capability Belief about consequences Intentions Goals Optimism | Persuasion Education Enablement Incentivisation Modelling | Credible sources for messages Explain the importance of abrupt cessation Boost motivation and self-efficacy Rewards contingent on effort or progress Emphasise choice | Targeted salient messages Build self-efficacy Building response efficacy—stopping smoking is worthwhile Smoking as an addiction Link nicotine withdrawal and symptoms of ‘stress’ Emphasising choice to quit Resources and support Success stories and role models via videos Goal setting, quit plan and quit date Dealing with challenges |
Change of role on becoming pregnancy positively reinforces need to quit. Protective attitudes to baby Cravings can impair motivation | Automatic motivation | Reinforcement | Self-rewards in quit plan Celebrating small wins Free NRT ameliorates withdrawal symptoms | ||
Lack of optimism for quitting | Emotion | Environmental restructuring Persuasion Enablement | Addressing challenges in quit plan Emotive videos Free NRT ameliorates withdrawal/stress symptoms | ||
Lack of access to services or presenting late to antenatal care Lack of targeted resources Lack of subsidised NRT Health providers not frequently offering assistance to quit | Physical opportunity | Environmental context Resources | Environmental restructuring Enablement Education | Advise on environmental restructuring Advise on changing routine | Trained providers to support their quit attempts Referrals to other services Flipchart Patient booklets |
Few role models who have quit during pregnancy | Social opportunity | Social influences | Modelling | Provide normative information about others’ behaviour and experiences Advise on/facilitate use of social support | Involving family members Making a smoke-free home Increasing social support Positive peer role models through video stories |