Background
Methods
Literature search
Study selection
Data extraction
Quality assessment
Identification of herb-zheng associations
Translation of terminology
Results
CM zheng category and treatment criteria
CM zheng
| Therapeutic principle | Number of subjects diagnosed by the diagnosis | Number of frequency among all the studies | Percentage among the total zheng (190)/top 10 zheng diagnosis (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Dual deficiency of qi and blood qi-xue-liang-xu
| Tonify qi and replenish blood
| 948 | 48 | 16.8/6.2 |
Dual deficiency of qi and yin qi-yin-liang-xu
| Tonify qi and replenish yin
| 795 | 45 | 15.7/5.9 |
Excessive heat and qi stagnation qi-zhi-shi-re
| Soothe the liver and regulate qi
| 726 | 41 | 14.3/5.3 |
Yang deficiency of spleen and kidney pi-shen-yang-xu
| Warm the kidney and fortify the spleen | 636 | 32 | 11.2/4.2 |
Deficiency of qi and blood pi-xue-kui-xu
| Tonify qi and engender blood
| 595 | 26 | 9.1/3.4 |
Cold-heat complex han-re-cuo-za
| Treat cold with heat and heat with cold
| 513 | 21 | 7.3/2.7 |
Liver depression and spleen deficiency gan-yu-pi-xu
| Soothe the liver and fortify the spleen
| 495 | 20 | 7.0/2.6 |
Deficiency-excess complex xu-shi-jia-za
| Treat deficiency by tonification and excess by purgation | 483 | 20 | 7.0/2.6 |
Dual
yin deficiency of liver and kidney gan-shen-yin-xu
| Enrich the kidney and nourish the liver yin
| 410 | 17 | 5.9/2.2 |
Intestinal dryness and yin deficiency yin-xu-chang-zao
| Replenish yin and moisten dryness | 223 | 16 | 5.6/2.1 |
CM herbs and their relationships
Chinese name in pinyin | Latin name | Frequency of usage | Action | Indication |
---|---|---|---|---|
Da Huang
| Radix et Rhizoma Rhei
| 428 | Drains heat and purges accumulations; clears heat, transforms dampness and promotes urination; drains heat from the blood; invigorates the blood and dispels blood stasis | Intestinal heat excess with high fever, profuse sweating, thirst, constipation, abdominal distention and pain, delirium, a yellow tongue coat and a full pulse; blood stasis with amenorrhea, fixed abdominal masses or fixed pain |
Huo Ma Ren
|
Semen Cannabis
| 247 | Nourishes, moistens and lubricates the intestines; nourishes the yin; clears heat and promotes healing of sores; moistens dryness and benefits the hair | Constipation in the elderly; constipation after a warm febrile disease; postpartum constipation; constipation due to blood and yin
deficiency; sores and ulcerations (auxiliary-internal and topical); promotes hair growth and treats dry hair |
Fan Xie Ye
|
Folium Sennae
| 232 | Drains downward and guides out stagnation; eliminates excess heat and drains summer heat
|
Heat in the stomach and intestines with constipation and abdominal fullness; summer heat
|
Bai Zhu
| Rhizoma Atractylodis Macrocephalae
| 198 | Tonifies the spleen and augments qi; dries dampness and promotes water metabolism; stabilizes the exterior and stops sweating |
Spleen and stomach deficiency with diarrhea, fatigue; spleen damp or accumulation of fluids affecting the digestion; edema and reduced urination due to spleen deficiency; qi deficiency with spontaneous sweating |
Dang- Gui
| Radix Angelicae Sinensis
| 132 | Tonifies the blood and regulates the menses; invigorates and harmonizes the blood and disperses cold; moistens the intestines and unblocks the bowels | Blood deficiency with pale, ashen complexion, lusterless nails, tinnitus; blood deficiency associated irregular menstruation, amenorrhea and dysmenorrhea; dry Intestines due to blood deficiency |
Huang Qi
| Radix Astragali
| 126 | Tonifies qi and blood; strengthens the spleen and raises the yang qi of the spleen and stomach; tonifies wei qi, stabilizes the exterior and tonifies the lungs
| Postpartum fever due to qi and blood deficiency; spleen qi deficiency with anorexia, fatigue and diarrhea; excessive sweating with qi, yang or yin
deficiency; dampness in the head |
Gan Cao
| Radix Glycyrrhizae
| 112 | Tonifies the spleen and augments qi; moistens the lungs, resolves phlegm and stops cough; moderates spasms and alleviates pain; clears heat and relieves fire toxicity | Spleen qi deficiency with shortness of breath, lassitude and loose stools; qi and blood
deficiency with an irregular pulse and/or palpitations; productive or non-productive cough; raw for toxic heat with sore throat or carbuncles and sores |
Sheng Di
| Radix Rehmanniae
| 99 | Clears heat and cools the blood; nourishes yin, generates fluids, increases saliva and treats wasting and thirsting; cools heart fire |
Ying-stage heat with high fever, thirst and a scarlet tongue; hemorrhage due to blood heat; throat pain due to yin deficiency
|
Bai Shao
| Radix Paeoniae Alba
| 94 | Nourishes the blood and regulates menstruation; astringes yin and adjusts the ying and wei; calms liver yang and liver
wind and alleviates pain |
Liver blood deficiency with menstrual dysfunction, vaginal discharge and uterine bleeding; anemia; breast distention and pre-menstrual syndrome |
Lu Hui
| Aloe | 93 | Purges, drains fire and guides out accumulations; clears heat and cools the liver; kills parasites and strengthens the stomach
|
Heat accumulation with constipation, dizziness, red eyes, and irritability; chronic constipation; heat in the liver channel or liver fire with epigastric discomfort, dizziness, headache, irritability, tinnitus, constipation and fever |
CM zheng-based Chinese herbal formulae
Chinese name in pinyin | Composition in pinyin | CM zheng
| Number of frequency among all the studies | Actions in Chinese medicine |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ma-Zi-Ren-Wan
|
Huo Ma Ren
Xing Ren
Bai Shao
Zhi Shi
Hou Pu
Da Huang
| Excessive qi and heat
| 75 | Invigorates Blood
Dispels Blood Stasis Moves qi
Lubricates the intestines Moves the bowels Purges heat
Alleviates pain |
Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Tang
|
Huang Qi
Ren Shen
Bai Zhu
Zhi Gan Cao
Dang Gui
Chen Pi
Shen Ma
Chai Hu
|
Qi deficiency of spleen and stomach/Sunken middle qi
| 56 | Tonifies middle jiao qi
Benefits qi
Regulates qi
Raises sunken yang
Lifts prolapsed organs |
Ji-Chuan-Jian
|
Dang Gui
Niu Xi
Rou Cong Rong
Ze Xie
Shen Ma
Zhi Qiao
|
Yang deficiency of spleen and kidney
| 51 | Warms up the kidney
Replenishes vital essence Lubricates the intestines Induces defecation |
Zeng-Ye-Tang
|
Xuan Shen
Mai Dong
Sheng Di
|
Fluid-humor deficiency
| 40 | Generates Fluids Moistens dryness Unblocks the bowels Nourishes yin
Clears heat
|
Ba-Zhen-Tang
|
Ren Shen
Bai Zhu
Fu Ling
Zhi Gan Cao
Shu Di
Bai Shao
Chuan Xiong
Dang Gui
|
Dual deficiency of qi and blood
| 26 | Nourishes qi
Benefits blood
|
Proprietary CHMs
Chinese name in pinyin (manufacturer) | Composition in pinyin | Oral dosage | Number of frequency among all the studies | Indication |
---|---|---|---|---|
Run-Chang-Wan (Shang Dong Hua Yang Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd.) |
Tao Ren
| 4 pills t. i. d. for oral administration | 87 | Constipation with CM zheng of excessive qi and heat, and constipation for elderly people and postpartum women |
Da Hua
| ||||
Qiang Huo
| ||||
Dang Gui
| ||||
Huo Ma Ren
| ||||
Ma-Ren-Ruan-Jiao-Nang (Actavis (Foshan) Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.) |
Huo Ma Ren
| 2 capsules t. i. d. for oral administration | 62 | Constipation with CM zheng of excessive qi and heat
|
Xing Ren
| ||||
Bai Shao
| ||||
Zhi Shi
| ||||
Hou Pu
| ||||
Da Huang
| ||||
Ma-Ren-Run-Chang-Wan (Bei Jing Tong Ren Tang Co., Ltd.) |
Huo Ma Ren
| 1–2 big honey pills b. i. d. for oral administration | 52 | Constipation with CM zheng of heat in stomach and intestines
|
Xing Ren
| ||||
Da Hua
| ||||
Bai Shao
| ||||
Mu Xiang
| ||||
Chen Pi
| ||||
Liu-Wei-An-Xiao-Jiao-Nang (Gui Zhou Xin Bang Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.) |
Tu Mu Xiang
| 3–6 pills b. i. d. for oral administration | 50 | Constipation due to indigestion and bloating; stomachache; dyspepsia |
Da Huang
| ||||
Shan Nai
| ||||
Han Shui Shi
| ||||
Ke Zi
| ||||
Jian Hua
| ||||
Fu-Fang-Lu-Hui-Jiao-Nang (He Bei Wan Bang & Folon Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.) |
Lu Hui
| 1–2 capsules b. i. d. for oral administration | 35 | Constipation with CM zheng of intense fire in heart and liver
|
Qing Dai
| ||||
Zhu Sha
| ||||
Hu Po
| ||||
Ma-Ren-Zi-Pi-Wan (Bao Tou Chinese Medicine Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.) |
Huo Ma Ren
| 1 big honey pills b. i. d. for oral administration | 34 | Constipation with CM zheng of dryness and heat in large intestine |
Xing Ren
| ||||
Bai Shao
| ||||
Zhi Shi
| ||||
Hou Pu
| ||||
Da Huang
| ||||
Yu Li Ren
| ||||
Dang Gui
| ||||
Si-Ni-San (Fu Zhou Neptunus Futao Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.) |
Chai Hu
| 6–9 g granules b. i. d. for oral administration | 32 | Constipation with CM zheng of disharmony between spleen and liver
|
Zhi Shi
| ||||
Bai Shao
| ||||
Zhi Gan Cao
| ||||
Liu-Wei-Neng-Xiao-Jiao-Nang (Yang Zong Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.) |
Da Hua
| 2 capsules b. i. d. for oral administration | 27 | Constipation due to indigestion; obesity; hyperlipidemia |
Ke Zi
| ||||
Gan Jiang
| ||||
Zang Mu Xiang
| ||||
Jian Hua
| ||||
Hai Shui Shi
| ||||
Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Wan (Bei Jing Tong Ren Tang Co., Ltd.) |
Huang Qi
| 1–2 big honey pills b. i. d. for oral administration | 17 | Constipation with CM zheng of qi deficiency of spleen and stomach/Sunken middle qi
|
Dang Shen
| ||||
Bai Zhu
| ||||
Dang Gui
| ||||
Shen Ma
| ||||
Chai Hu
| ||||
Chen Pi
| ||||
Zhi Gan Cao
|
CM combined with Western medicine and adverse effects
Combined used Western medicine | Frequency of reported in all the trials (n > 5) | Adverse effect (N = , percentage, %) | |
---|---|---|---|
Single herb | |||
Da Huang
| Sodium bicarbonate tablets | 23 | Symptoms of the gastrointestinal tract (N = 4, 17.3 %) |
Insomnia (N = 1, 4.3 %) | |||
Skin rash (N = 1, 4.3 %) | |||
Headache (N = 1, 4.3 %) | |||
Fan Xie Ye
| Lactulose oral solution | 8 | Symptoms of the gastrointestinal tract (N = 2, 25 %) |
Dizzy and anorexia (N = 1, 12.5 %) | |||
CHM Proprietary | |||
Ma-Ren-Ruan-Jiao-Nang
| Lactulose oral solution | 6 | Symptoms of the gastrointestinal tract (N = 2, 33.3 %) |
Headache (N = 1, 16.7 %) | |||
Liu-Wei-An-Xiao-Jiao-Nang
| Mosapride citrate tablets | 6 | Symptoms of the gastrointestinal tract (N = 3, 50 %) |