Introduction
New treatment strategies for multiple myeloma (MM), a malignant hematopathy derived from plasma cells, are yet to be developed due to increasing prevalence of refractory/relapsed cases showing resistance to conventional therapy [
1‐
4]. The POEMS syndrome, characterized by a collection of polyneuropathy, organomegaly, endocrinopathy, myeloma protein, and skin changes, is a rare paraneoplastic disorder caused by plasma cell dyscrasia, with poor prognosis and lack of standard treatment. Recent studies have shown that therapy by chimeric antigen receptor T (CAR-T) cells had a good effect on malignant hematological diseases including MM [
5‐
10]. Carpenter et al. for the first time reported in vitro and in vivo anti-myeloma effects of anti-BCMA CAR-T cells [
11]. Succeeding clinical investigations taking anti-BCMA CAR-T cells against relapsed/refractory MM (RRMM) have observed improved response and possibly curable effects [
9,
10]. Considering the close similarity in pathology and potential efficacy of anti-myeloma regimens against POEMS can be expected a treatment effect by anti-BCMA CAR-T cells in subjects with POEMS [
12,
13]. In this report, two cases with plasma cell dyscrasia (a POEMS and an RRMM) treated with anti-BCMA CAR-T cells are presented and reviewed the literature on clinical trials concerning anti-BCMA CAR-T cells in MM.
Discussion
Our work demonstrated that anti-BCMA CAR-T cell treatment has a significant effect in patients with plasma cell dyscrasia, i.e., POEMS syndrome and RRMM. The POEMS syndrome case we describe had a rapidly progressing and disability-causing neurological disease that showed poor response to conventional therapy. She responded favorably to anti-BCMA CAR-T cells therapy. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first case report of anti-BCMA CAR-T cell treatment for POEMS syndrome. The patient had a dramatic improvement in neuropathy and functional status. Ten months after infusion, the anti-BCMA CAR-T cells were still detectable, and the number of B cells returned to normal levels in peripheral blood. An extended duration of CR without any treatment is expected, and the patient’s immune system recovered steadily. Another primary concern is the safety of anti-BCMA CAR-T cell treatment for POEMS syndrome. In this case, the patient developed grade 1 CRS. During the procedure, red blood cells and platelets were not infused, and white blood cells recovered quickly, which significantly reduced the risk of infection in the patient.
The study also suggested that anti-BCMA CAR-T cells have substantial anti-MM activity. A female patient with RRMM achieved CR after infusion of anti-BCMA CAR-T cells. The patient presented grade 1 CRS, which was characterized by fever and nausea. However, MM recurred with disease-free survival of 7.6 months. Our results were consistent with published studies [
9,
10]. MM has been shown to be a phenotypically heterogeneous malignancy, with numerous sub-clones within the same patient [
19‐
21], which may increase the risk of failure from single-antigen therapies; another cause of recurrence may be a loss of BCMA expression on malignant plasma cells. Because the patient refused further bone marrow examination, the proportion of malignant plasma cells and the expression of BCMA in the bone marrow were unclear. Ongoing efforts are attempting to make anti-BCMA CAR-T therapy more potent, safe, and affordable for patients. The CAR-T therapies are being developed to overcome relapse due to a reduced tumor antigen, including modification of T cells with two distinct CAR molecules with two different binding domains or one CAR molecule with two different binding domains in tandem [
22‐
24].
It has been recently shown that serum BCMA levels correlated with clinical status and tumor burden of MM patients [
9,
10,
25]. In our study, serum BCMA in both patients was largely elevated before anti-BCMA CAR-T cell infusion, decreased substantially after treatment, and maintained a lower level during disease remission. As the disease recurred and progressed, the serum monoclonal protein and free light chains started to increase, so as serum BCMA. Our results confirmed previous findings [
25] and validated that serum BCMA level may be a reliable marker for monitoring and outcome prediction in MM patients [
26].
Anti-BCMA CAR-T cell therapies have shown impressive anti-myeloma activities (some reaching 90–100%) in certain preclinical and/or clinical investigations (see Table
1), which is reviewed below.
Table 1
Clinical trials of anti-BCMA CAR-T cells for MM
Institution | NCI | Upenn | Bluebird Multi-Inst (Bb2121) | Nanjing Legend (LCAR-B38M) | MSK |
Scfv derived from | Murine hybridoma | Human library | Murine hybridoma | Murine hybridoma | Human library |
Co-stimulatory domain | CD28 | 4-1BB | 4-1BB | 4-1BB | 4-1BB |
Gene transfer | Retrovirus | Lentivirus | Lentivirus | Lentivirus | Retrovirus |
Conditioning | Cy + Flu | Cohort 1: none Cohorts 2 and 3: Cy | Cy + Flu | Cy | Cy + Flu |
BCMA Ag required | > 50% | No requirement | > 50% | “Clear expression” | > 1% |
ClinicalTrials.gov identifier/reference | NCT022159679,10 | NCT0254616727 | NCT0265892928 | NCT0309065929 | NCT03070327 |
Median prior lines | 7 | 9 | 7 | 3 | Not yet reported |
Accrual | Completed (26 patients) | Completed (24 patients, data reported) | Ongoing (21 patients, data reported) | Ongoing (19 patients, data reported) | Not yet reported |
Response | 13 Of 16 (81%) ORR at highest dose | 6 Of 10 (60%) ORR at high dose with Cy conditioning | 17 Of 18 (94%) ORR at higher doses | 19 Of 19 (100%) ORR | Not yet reported |
Elimination gene | No | No | No | No | Truncated EGFR |
The National Cancer Institute (NCI) investigators for the first time published pre-clinical data on MM treatment using anti-BCMA CAR-T cells [
9,
10]. Twenty six heavily treated MM patients were enrolled. They have continued to conduct a dose escalation trial demonstrating the potential for dramatic responses induced by this treatment modality for MM. Of the 10 patients treated with lower doses of anti-BCMA CAR-T cells (0.3–3.0 × 10
6/kg), one patient experienced a very good partial response (VGPR) that lasted 8 weeks, eight patients had a stable disease that lasted from two to 12 weeks, and one patient had a transient partial response (PR). Of 16 patients treated at the highest dose level (9 × 10
6 CAR-T cell/kg), 13 had PR or better response. The overall response rate for patients receiving 9 × 10
6/kg was 81%, with 63% as VGPR or CR. Median event-free survival was 31 weeks. Treatment toxicity was mild at lower dose levels, with no CRS of grades 3 or 4 at cell doses of 0.3 to 3 × 10
6/kg. At a cell dose of 9 × 10
6/kg, CRS-related toxicities were substantial.
Cohen et al. [
27] also reported their initial findings from a phase I trial at the University of Pennsylvania to explore the effects of anti-BCMA CAR-T cells in RRMM. This study used an anti-BCMA CAR with fully human antibody variable regions. The patients included in this trial were not screened for BCMA expression. Three cohorts were enrolled sequentially, and the objective was to collect preliminary data about safety, efficacy, and kinetics of expansion with the following protocols: (1) CAR-T cells alone at a dose of 1 to 5 × 10
8/kg, (2) 1.5 g/m
2 of cyclophosphamide with 1 to 5 × 10
7/kg CAR-T cells, and (3) 1.5 g/m
2 of cyclophosphamide with 1 to 5 × 10
8/kg CAR-T cells. CAR-T cells were given as split-dose infusions. Twenty-four patients (median prior lines of therapy were seven) were evaluable; 96% had high-risk cytogenetics, including 71% with del(17p) or TP53 mutation, and a median 70% plasma cells on bone marrow biopsy. In cohort 1 (nine patients), four patients (44%) achieved ≥ PR response after CAR-T singlet treatment. In cohort 2, only one (20%) of five patients responded to the combination of cyclophosphamide and a tenfold lower dose of CAR-T, and this cohort was stopped early. In cohort 3, incorporation of cyclophosphamide with the higher dose (i.e., 1 to 5 × 10
8) of CAR-T cells led to a disease response in six (60%) of ten patients. The median duration of response was 4 months, and there were ongoing responses in four patients (range, 3 to 24 months). Toxicities were similar with those reported in earlier studies, with severe CRS in 33% (8 of 24 patients) and severe neurotoxicity in 12.5% (3 of 24 patients).
Berdeja et al. [
28] reported updated data about the dose escalation part of an anti-BCMA CAR-T multicenter trial conducted by bluebird bio. Four dose levels (50, 150, 450 and 800 × 10
6 CAR-T cells) were explored in 21 patients with RRMM (median prior lines of therapy was 7). Responses were seen in 18 (86%) of 21patients, including 17 (94%) of 18 patients treated at doses of 150 × 10
6 CAR-T cells or higher. Ten patients achieved PR (seven confirmed). With a median follow-up of 40 weeks, only four patients who experienced a response had subsequent progression, and the median progression-free survival was not reached; five patients had ongoing responses for more than 1 year. No treatment-related grade 3 or higher neurotoxicities were observed. CRS was primarily grade 1 or 2.
Nanjing Legend is conducting a trial in China with exciting early results [
29]. A total of 19 patients with RRMM were enrolled in the trial. The median number of infused LCAR-B38M CAR-T cells was 4.7 (0.6 ~ 7.0) × 10
6/kg. The median follow-up was 208 (62 ~ 321) days. A 100% objective response rate (ORR) was observed in RRMM patients. Eighteen out of 19 (95%) patients reached CR or VGPR status without myeloma-related biochemical and hematologic abnormalities in a median follow-up of 6 months. The majority (
n = 14) of the patients experienced mild or manageable CRS, and the rest (
n = 5) were even free of diagnosable CRS. This trial differs from the others in that the patients were treated at a significantly earlier phase in their treatment course, with median prior lines of therapy being 3, compared to 7–9 in other trials reported.
In addition to the trials described here, other trials of anti-BCMA CAR-T cells [
30], including three in combination with other CAR-T cells, have been opened since March 2018. Initial data are expected by late 2018 or early 2019.