Introduction
Methods
Search strategy
Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Literature screening and data extraction
Quality assessment
Assessment approach of body composition
Statistical analysis
Results
Literature selection
Characteristics of the included studies
Author | Year | Recruitment period | Design | Disease | Treatment | Total sample | Median age, year | Tumor stage (AJCC, I/II/III/IV) | Male, n (%) | Adjuvant therapy, n (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Yang, J. | 2019 | 2011–2017 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 417 | 57.9 | 80/190/149/0 | 251 (60) | – |
Hopkins, J. J. | 2019 | 2007–2009 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 968 | 65.8 | 100/374/494/0 | 589 (61) | 503 (52) |
van Vugt, J. L. A. | 2018 | 2007–2013 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 816 | – | 255/293/269 | 440 (54) | 158 (19) |
van der Kroft, G. | 2018 | 2012–2013 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 63 | – | 18/13/20/12 | 39 (62) | – |
Mosk, C. A. | 2018 | 2013–2015 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 251 | 76 | – | 141 (56) | 26 (10) |
Mauricio, S. F. | 2018 | 2013–2016 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 84 | 61.6 | 36/48 a | 39 (46) | 51 (61) |
Martin, L. | 2018 | 2013–2015 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 210 | 66.6 | 385/713/887/109 | 1270 (60) | – |
Chen, W. Z. | 2018 | 2014–2017 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 376 | 64.3 | 65/155/145/11 | 228 (61) | – |
Feliciano, E. M. C. | 2017 | 2006–2011 | Prospective | CRC | Surgery | 247 | 63 | 690/806/956/0 | 1251 (51) | – |
Black, D. | 2017 | 2006–2014 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 339 | 58/153/128/0 | 181 (53) | 66 (19) | |
Ouchi, A. | 2016 | 2012–2015 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 60 | 69 | 42/18 a | 35 (58) | – |
Malietzis, G. | 2016 | 2006–2013 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 805 | 69 | 189/265/267/84 | 472 (59) | 182 (23) |
Reisinger, K. W. | 2015 | 2010–2012 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 310 | – | – | 155 (50) | – |
Park, B. K. | 2015 | 2005–2012 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 543 | – | 185/314 a | 311 (57) | 51 (9) |
Miyamoto, Y. | 2015 | 2005–2010 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 220 | – | 77/84/59/0 | 54 (25) | |
Huang, D. D. | 2015 | 2014–2015 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 142 | 62 | – | 88 (62) | 5 (4) |
Lieffers, J. R. | 2012 | 2002–2006 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 234 | 63 | 0/74/83/77 | 135 (58) | – |
Pedziwiatr, M. | 2016 | 2014–2015 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 124 | 65.9 | 32/32/39/21 | 73 (59) | – |
Jones, K. I. | 2015 | 2011–2012 | Retrospective | CRC | Surgery | 100 | 68.6 | – | 60 (60) | – |
Guinan, E. M. | 2018 | 2014–2016 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 27 | – | – | – | 27 (100) |
Mayanagi, S. | 2017 | 2004–2013 | Prospective | EC | Surgery | 66 | 63.3 | 0/27/39/0 | 57 (86) | 66 (100) |
Elliott, J. A. | 2017 | 2010–2015 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 207 | 61.6 | – | 165 (80) | 207 (100) |
Black, D. | 2017 | 2006–2014 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 108 | – | 30/43/35/0 | 74 (69) | 65 (60) |
Nishigori, T. | 2016 | 2005–2014 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 199 | – | 33/99/63/6 | 164 (82) | – |
Grotenhuis, B. A. | 2016 | 2001–2012 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 120 | 62 | – | 88 (73) | 120 (100) |
Yip, C. | 2014 | NG | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 35 | 63 | 0/10/23/2 | 30 (86) | 35 (100) |
Nakashima, Y. | 2018 | 2004–2014 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 341 | – | 38/46/55/33 | 289 (85) | – |
Paireder, M. | 2017 | 2006–2013 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 130 | 61.4 | 15/22/76/3 | 106 (82) | 130 (100) |
Tamandl, D. | 2016 | 2006–2013 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 200 | 63.9 | 45/33/95/4 | 151 (76) | – |
Harada, K. | 2016 | 2005–2011 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 325 | – | 129/45/128/23 | 298 (92) | – |
Tan, B. H. | 2015 | 2010–2012 | Retrospective | EC | Surgery | 89 | 65.8 | 21/27/41/0 | 67 (75) | 89 (100) |
Zhang, Y. | 2019 | 2015–2017 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 156 | 59.1 | 48/27/81/0 | 115 (74) | 35 (22) |
Zhang, W. T. | 2018 | 2014–2016 | Prospective | GC | Surgery | 636 | – | 203/140/293/0 | 478 (75) | – |
Wang, S. L. | 2018 | 2009–2013 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 859 | 64 | 239/193/427/0 | 672 (78) | – |
Park, H. S. | 2018 | 2006–2009 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 136 | 55 | 0/57/79/0 | 96 (71) | 63 (46) |
O’Brien, S. | 2018 | 2008–2014 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 56 | 68.4 | 18/13/18/0 | 41 (73) | 28 (50) |
Nishigori, T. | 2018 | 2005–2013 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 177 | – | 0/100/77/0 | 127 (72) | 127 (72) |
Mao, C. C. | 2018 | 2014–2016 | Prospective | GC | Surgery | 682 | 64.6 | – | 513 (75) | – |
Lin, J. | 2018 | 2015–2016 | Prospective | GC | Surgery | 670 | 65 | – | – | – |
Choi, M. H. | 2018 | 2007–2009 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 98 | – | – | – | – |
Beuran, M. | 2018 | 2014–2016 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 78 | – | 6/28/41/13 | – | – |
Zhou, C. J. | 2017 | 2014–2015 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 240 | 73 | 74/55/111/0 | 190 (79) | – |
Zheng, Z. F. | 2017 | 2009–2013 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 639 | – | 525 (82) | 408 (64) | |
Lou, N. | 2017 | 2014–2015 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 206 | 64.1 | 80/45/81/0 | 161 (78) | – |
Kudou, K. | 2017 | 2005–2016 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 148 | – | – | – | – |
Huang, D. D. | 2017 | 2014–2015 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 470 | 65 | 163/103/204/0 | 364 (77) | – |
Zhuang, C. L. | 2016 | 2008–2013 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 937 | 64 | 271/219/447 | 730 (78) | – |
Wang, S. L. | 2016 | 2014–2015 | Prospective | GC | Surgery | 255 | 65.1 | 81/48/126/0 | 190 (75) | – |
Takeuchi, M. | 2016 | 2009–2015 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 75 | – | 25/16/28/6 | 57 (76) | 3 (4) |
Huang, D. D. | 2016 | 2014–2015 | Prospective | GC | Surgery | 173 | 72 | 53/40/80/0 | 135 (78) | – |
Tegels, J. J. | 2015 | 2005–2012 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 152 | 69.6 | 42/27/47/57 | 87 (57) | 71 (47) |
Li, X. T. | 2015 | 2005–2008 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 84 | 57 | 0/31/53/0 | 60 (71) | – |
Sakurai, K. | 2017 | 2007–2013 | Retrospective | GC | Surgery | 569 | 66.7 | 264/121/126/58 | 396 (70) | 91 (16) |
Chen, F. F. | 2016 | 2014–2016 | Prospective | GC | Surgery | 158 | 66.9 | 33/37/88/0 | 126 (80) | – |
Takeda, Y. | 2018 | 2004–2011 | Retrospective | RC | Surgery | 144 | – | 0/45/99/0 | 102 (71) | 63 (44) |
Park, S. E. | 2018 | 2005–2015 | Retrospective | RC | Surgery | 65 | 71 | 8/24/27/0 | 46 (71) | 65 (100) |
Choi, M. H. | 2018 | 2009–2013 | Retrospective | RC | Surgery | 188 | 61.3 | 0/34/154/0 | 117 (62) | 188 (100) |
Heus, C. | 2016 | 2006–2013 | Retrospective | RC | Surgery | 74 | 64 | – | 39 (53) | – |
Souza, B. U. | 2018 | 2015–2016 | Retrospective | CRC | All | 197 | 60.5 | 54/138 a | 112 (57) | – |
Kurk, S. A. | 2018 | NG | Prospective | CRC | AT | 450 | – | – | 285 (63) | n/a |
Chemama, S. | 2016 | 2008–2010 | Retrospective | CRC | AT | 97 | 53 | – | 37 (38) | n/a |
Blauwhoff-Buskermolen, S. | 2016 | 2011–2014 | Retrospective | CRC | AT | 67 | 66.4 | – | 42 (63) | n/a |
Barret, M. | 2014 | NG | Retrospective | CRC | AT | 51 | 65 | – | 38 (75) | n/a |
Guiu, B. | 2010 | 2002–2008 | Retrospective | CRC | AT | 120 | – | – | 55 (46) | n/a |
Anandavadivelan, P. | 2016 | 2006–2012 | Retrospective | EC | AT | 72 | – | 2/20/50/0 | – | n/a |
Awad, S. | 2012 | NG | Retrospective | EC | AT | 47 | – | – | 34 (72) | n/a |
Sugiyama, K. | 2018 | 2013–2015 | Retrospective | GC | AT | 118 | 64 | – | 59 (50) | n/a |
Palmela, C. | 2017 | 2012–2014 | Retrospective | GC | AT | 47 | 68 | 0/5/42/0 | 32 (68) | n/a |
Mirkin, K. A. | 2017 | 2000–2015 | Retrospective | GC | AT | 41 | – | – | – | n/a |
Hayashi, N. | 2016 | 2009–2014 | Retrospective | GC | AT | 53 | – | – | – | n/a |
Nipp, R. D. | 2018 | 2011–2015 | Retrospective | GIC | AT | 103 | – | – | – | n/a |
Sarcopenia definition, assessment of prevalence
No | Modality | Index | Cut-off, Male | Cut-off, Female | Method | Prevalence | Reference | Country | NOS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | CT/L3 | SMI | 32.5 | 28.6 | Cut-off from 3-year overall survival | 16.1% | Zheng, Z. 2017 | China | 7 |
2 | CT/L3 | SMI | 36 | 29 | Cut-off from Iritani et al. | 3.4% | Nishigori, T. 2018 | Japan | 7 |
12.5% | Wang, S. 2016 | China | 7 | ||||||
12.0% | Huang, D. 2015 | China | 8 | ||||||
3 | CT/L3 | SMI | 40.8 | 34.9 | Cut-off from Zhuang et al. | 15.4% | Zhang, Y. 2019 | China | 7 |
19.7% | Zhang, W. 2018 | China | 6 | ||||||
17.5% | Nishigori, T. 2018 | Japan | 7 | ||||||
19.4% | Mao, C. 2018 | China | 6 | ||||||
15.5% | Lin, J. 2018 | China | 5 | ||||||
24.5% | Chen, W. 2018 | China | 7 | ||||||
28.8% | Zhou, C. 2017 | China | 7 | ||||||
6.8% | Lou, N. 2017 | China | 7 | ||||||
37.4% | Huang, D. 2017 | China | 7 | ||||||
41.5% | Zhuang, C. 2016 | China | 8 | ||||||
30.1% | Huang, D. 2016 | China | 7 | ||||||
24.7% | Chen, F. 2016 | China | 6 | ||||||
4 | CT/L3 | SMI | 43.2 | 34.6 | Cut-off from Sakurai et al. | 22.0% | Nishigori, T. 2018 | Japan | 7 |
25.0% | Sakurai, K. 2017 | Japan | 8 | ||||||
5 | CT/L3 | SMI | 44.5 | 36.5 | Cut-off from the third quartile cases | 25.8% | Harada, K. 2016 | Japan | 6 |
6 | CT/L3 | SMI | 45 | 33.8 | Cut-off from the third quartile cases | 25.7% | Takeda, Y. 2018 | Japan | 7 |
7 | CT/L3 | SMI | 47.2 | 36.9 | Cut-off from the median of SMI | 49.9% | Nakashima, Y. 2018 | Japan | 8 |
8 | CT/L3 | SMI | 49 | 31 | Cut-off from Kim et al. | 38.5% | Park, S. 2018 | Korea | 6 |
9 | CT/L3 | SMI | 49.5 | 42.1 | Cut-off from the third quartile cases | 25.0% | Miyamoto, Y. 2015 | Japan | 7 |
10 | CT/L3 | SMI | 52.4 | 38.9 | Cut-off from Prado et al. | 14.6% | Yang, J. 2019 | China | 6 |
35.7% | O’Brien, S. 2018 | Ireland | 7 | ||||||
64.4% | Nishigori, T. 2018 | Japan | 7 | ||||||
7.4% | Guinan, E. 2018 | Ireland | 4 | ||||||
39.4% | Choi, M. 2018 | Korea | 7 | ||||||
39.8% | Choi, M. 2018 | Korea | 6 | ||||||
71.8% | Beuran, M. 2018 | Romania | 5 | ||||||
83.3% | Mayanagi, S. 2017 | Japan | 7 | ||||||
23.7% | Elliott, J. 2017 | Ireland | 6 | ||||||
74.9% | Nishigori, T. 2016 | Japan | 7 | ||||||
60.2% | Malietzis, G. 2016 | UK | 7 | ||||||
45.0% | Grotenhuis, B. 2016 | Netherlands | 8 | ||||||
43.1% | Anandavadivelan, P. 2016 | Swede | 5 | ||||||
47.7% | Reisinger, K. 2015 | Netherlands | 6 | ||||||
25.7% | Yip, C. 2014 | UK | 5 | ||||||
38.9% | Lieffers, J. 2012 | Canada | 7 | ||||||
2.1% | Awad, S. 2012 | UK | 4 | ||||||
49.4% | Tan, B. 2015 | UK | 5 | ||||||
Sugiyama, K. 2018 | Japan | 5 | |||||||
11 | CT/L3 | SMI | 55.4 | 38.9 | Cut-off from Prado et al. | 70.6% | Barret, M. 2014 | France | 5 |
12 | CT/L3 | SMI | 55 | 39 | Cut-off from Voron et al. | 57.3% | Nipp, R. 2018 | USA | 4 |
38.5% | Paireder, M. 2017 | Austria | 8 | ||||||
65.0% | Tamandl, D. 2016 | Austria | 7 | ||||||
13 | CT/L3 | SMI | 43/53 (BMI lower or higher than 25) | 41 | Cut-off from Martin et al. | 27.5% | Hopkins, J. 2019 | Canada | 7 |
50.5% | van Vugt, J. 2018 | Netherlands | 8 | ||||||
52.4% | van der Kroft, G. 2018 | Netherlands | 6 | ||||||
14.7% | Souza, B. 2018 | Brazil | 4 | ||||||
32.4% | Park, H. 2018 | Korea | 6 | ||||||
42.9% | Nishigori, T. 2018 | Japan | 7 | ||||||
24.3% | Mosk, C. 2018 | Netherlands | 6 | ||||||
34.5% | Mauricio, S. 2018 | Brazil | 7 | ||||||
38.0% | Kurk, S. 2018 | Netherlands | 4 | ||||||
23.4% | Palmela, C. 2017 | Portugal | 4 | ||||||
28.4% | Kudou, K. 2017 | Japan | 8 | ||||||
21.3% | Black, D. 2017 | UK | 7 | ||||||
23.9% | Black, D. 2017 | UK | 7 | ||||||
40.2% | Chemama, S. 2016 | France | 6 | ||||||
56.7% | Blauwhoff-Buskermolen, S. 2016 | Netherlands | 6 | ||||||
56.6% | Tegels, J. 2015 | Netherlands | 6 | ||||||
27.4% | Pedziwiatr, M. 2016 | Poland | 7 | ||||||
69.8% | Hayashi, N. 2016 | Japan | 6 | ||||||
14 | CT/L3 | SMI | 52/54 (BMI lower or higher than 30) | 38/47 (BMI lower or higher than 30) | Cut-off from Caan et al. | 45.9% | Feliciano, E. 2017 | USA | 6 |
15 | CT/L3 | SMI | – | – | z-score below - 0.5 for SMI in different ages | 6.7% | Martin, L. 2018 | Canada | 6 |
16 | CT/L3 | TPA | 538 | 346 | normal TPA in the lowest sex-specific quartile | 33.3% | Ouchi, A. 2016 | Japan | 6 |
17 | CT/L3 | TPA | 545 | 385 | Cut-off from Fearon et al. | 29.3% | Mirkin, K. 2017 | USA | 5 |
15.0% | Jones, K. 2015 | UK | 4 | ||||||
18 | CT | VEV | 1.92 | 1.92 | Cut-off from the quartiles | 25.0% | Park, B. 2015 | Korea | 5 |
19 | CT | VFA | 100 | 100 | Cut-off from the Japanese Society for study of Obesity | 35.9% | Wang, S. 2018 | China | 7 |
65.3% | Takeuchi, M. 2016 | Japan | 6 | ||||||
40.5% | Heus, C. 2016 | Netherlands | 4 |
Quality assessment
Long-term outcome assessment
Subgroup | Cohort | HR or RR | 95%CI | P value | I2 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Long-term outcome (HR)-Overall survival | |||||
Overall | 20 | 1.602 | 1.369–1.873 | < 0.001 | 59.5% |
Asian countries | 12 | 1.776 | 1.556–2.026 | < 0.001 | 41.9% |
Non-Asian countries | 8 | 1.368 | 1.117–1.676 | 0.002 | 60.1% |
Zhuang criteria | 2 | 1.622 | 1.326–1.983 | < 0.001 | 0% |
Martin criteria | 5 | 1.343 | 1.200–1.503 | < 0.001 | 0% |
Prado criteria | 6 | 1.976 | 0.934–4.182 | 0.075 | 74.2% |
CRC surgery | 7 | 1.523 | 1.201–1.930 | 0.001 | 63.1% |
EC surgery | 5 | 1.567 | 1.089–2.253 | 0.015 | 52.9% |
GC surgery | 8 | 1.703 | 1.281–2.262 | < 0.001 | 60.6% |
Long-term outcome (HR)-Disease-free survival | |||||
Overall | 11 | 1.461 | 1.297–1.646 | < 0.001 | 0% |
Asian countries | 9 | 1.566 | 1.357–1.808 | < 0.001 | 0% |
Non-Asian countries | 2 | 1.255 | 1.014–1.553 | 0.037 | 0% |
Zhuang criteria | 2 | 1.568 | 1.274–1.930 | < 0.001 | 0% |
Martin criteria | 3 | 1.249 | 1.024–1.523 | 0.028 | 0% |
Prado criteria | 3 | 1.271 | 0.778–2.075 | 0.338 | 0% |
CRC surgery | 4 | 1.282 | 1.058–1.554 | 0.011 | 0% |
EC surgery | 1 | 2.060 | 0.626–6.783 | 0.235 | – |
GC surgery | 6 | 1.578 | 1.355–1.839 | < 0.001 | 0% |
Short-term outcome (RR)-Total complication after surgery | |||||
Overall | 15 | 1.188 | 1.083–1.303 | < 0.001 | 26.4% |
Asian countries | 10 | 1.165 | 1.046–1.298 | 0.005 | 43.9% |
Non-Asian countries | 5 | 1.252 | 1.045–1.499 | 0.015 | 0% |
Zhuang criteria | 4 | 1.423 | 1.214–1.667 | < 0.001 | 0% |
Martin criteria | 5 | 1.246 | 1.017–1.527 | 0.034 | 0% |
Prado criteria | 2 | 1.074 | 0.842–1.371 | 0.565 | 0% |
CRC surgery | 6 | 1.314 | 1.101–1.568 | 0.002 | 0% |
EC surgery | 4 | 1.051 | 0.900–1.226 | 0.531 | 0% |
GC surgery | 5 | 1.218 | 1.046–1.419 | 0.011 | 61.9% |
Short-term outcome (RR)-Major complication after surgery | |||||
Overall | 14 | 1.228 | 1.042–1.448 | 0.014 | 12.1% |
Asian countries | 7 | 1.244 | 1.001–1.545 | 0.049 | 45.9% |
Non-Asian countries | 7 | 1.206 | 0.936–1.553 | 0.148 | 0% |
Zhuang criteria | 2 | 2.084 | 1.359–3.196 | 0.001 | 50% |
Martin criteria | 5 | 0.988 | 0.690–1.413 | 0.946 | 0% |
Prado criteria | 4 | 1.309 | 0.978–1.750 | 0.070 | 0% |
CRC surgery | 4 | 0.899 | 0.545–1.481 | 0.675 | 0% |
EC surgery | 4 | 1.181 | 0.932–1.495 | 0.169 | 0% |
GC surgery | 6 | 1.393 | 1.076–1.803 | 0.012 | 48.3% |