Figures
Abstract
We assessed cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk factor prevalence and risk stratification amongst adults on antiretroviral therapy in South Africa. Of the 175 patients screened, 37.8% had high blood pressure (HBP), 15.4% were current smokers, 10.4% had elevated cholesterol, and 4.1% had diabetes, but very few (3.6%) had a 10-year CVD risk >10%. One-third of those with HBP, 40% of those with diabetes, and two-thirds of those with high cholesterol had not previously been diagnosed. Although participants were adherent with chronic HIV care, screening for and management of CVDRF were suboptimal, representing a missed opportunity to reduce non-AIDS morbidity and mortality.
Citation: Rabkin M, Mutiti A, Chung C, Zhang Y, Wei Y, El-Sadr WM (2015) Missed Opportunities to Address Cardiovascular Disease Risk Factors amongst Adults Attending an Urban HIV Clinic in South Africa. PLoS ONE 10(10): e0140298. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0140298
Editor: Giuseppe Vittorio De Socio, Azienda ospedaliero-universitaria di Perugia, ITALY
Received: June 23, 2015; Accepted: September 23, 2015; Published: October 8, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Rabkin et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: Funding for the study was provided by Medtronic Philanthropy.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Although HIV remains the leading cause of death among adults in sub-Saharan Africa, the burden of non-communicable disease (NCD) is high and rising rapidly [1]. In many African countries, cardiovascular disease (CVD) is a leading cause of death [2,3], and the prevalence of CVD risk factors (CVDRF) such as diabetes, dyslipidemia, hypertension, and tobacco use is significant [4,5,6]. South Africa, for example, is tackling one of the world’s most severe HIV epidemics, while also confronting a growing CVD burden [7]. CVD causes 18% of deaths in the country, and CVDRF have been described as a “time bomb” for South Africa’s health system [8,9]. This convergence of HIV and NCDs presents both challenges and opportunities for public health.
The scale-up of HIV care and treatment has led to growing survival and longevity of people living with HIV (PLWH), who are increasingly at risk for the NCDs prevalent in their communities. Data from sub-Saharan Africa are limited, but PLWH appear to be at higher risk than the general population for CVD and CVDRF [10,11,12]; dyslipidemia and diabetes are also associated with some antiretroviral drugs [13]. As PLWH age on antiretroviral therapy (ART), determining the best approaches for integrating HIV services and the management of common CVDRF will be critical to maintain the advances of treatment scale-up, and to assure optimal overall health outcomes.
Developing strategies that effectively reduce CVD risk, optimize resource utilization, and do not undermine HIV-related program and patient outcomes is an important challenge [14]. In order to be effective, interventions must be contextually appropriate, feasible for low-resource settings, and cognizant of limited human resources and fragile health systems.
This study assessed the prevalence of CVDRF among adults on ART at an urban HIV clinic in South Africa and explored the feasibility of using CVD risk stratification to streamline CVDRF management.
Methods
Study setting and participants
The study was conducted at an urban Community Health Centre (CHC) in South Africa’s Free State Province. The CHC serves an urban population and provides approximately 3,000 outpatient visits a month; its HIV clinic has enrolled 1,900 adults, 65% of whom are female. Nurses and counselors typically manage HIV patients, although a physician is available one day per week for consultation on complex cases.
The study recruited a convenience sample of adult PLWH from the HIV clinic within the CHC. Patients were eligible if they were 30 years or older, had been receiving ART for at least one year, had access to a mobile phone, and were not acutely ill, pregnant, or breastfeeding. Eligible patients were informed of the study by their HIV clinicians; those interested in participating were referred to study staff for screening. The study was explained, as was the right to decline participation, and informed consent was obtained from interested patients.
Ethical approvals were provided by the Institutional Review Boards at Columbia University (IRB-AAAM4408) and the University of the Free State (143/2013). Participants provided written informed consent to participate in the study.
Data collection procedures
Survey and consent forms were developed in English, translated into Sesotho, back-translated into English, revised, and then piloted in Sesotho for clarity. Trained bilingual study nurses administered the survey in the participant’s choice of Sesotho or English; the survey took approximately 90 minutes and included questions on demographics, household characteristics, health status, family history, and CVDRF. Questions regarding physical activity were excerpted from the International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) short form [15,16]. Questions regarding diet were adapted from the WHO STEPS survey instrument [17]. The study nurses used structured chart abstraction forms to collect data on participant medical history.
Weight was measured using calibrated digital scales, with shoes and outwear removed. Height was measured using a calibrated stadiometer. Sitting blood pressure (BP) was measured using a digital BP cuff; two measurements were taken at least five minutes apart. Blood was collected via phlebotomy and sent to an accredited local laboratory.
Results of the survey, physical examination, chart abstraction and laboratory testing were entered onto paper-based case report forms. Forms were reviewed for completeness and accuracy, and data were entered into SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina).
Measures
The primary outcome measures were the prevalence of four CVDRF (hypertension, high cholesterol, diabetes, and tobacco smoking) and participants’ 10-year risk of a cardiovascular event, as defined by the WHO/ISH risk stratification tool [18,19]. For hypertension, the average of the first and second BP measurement was used and participants were categorized as having high blood pressure if the average systolic BP was greater than or equal to 140 mmHg and/or if the average diastolic BP was greater than or equal to 90 mmHg, as per standard staging guidelines [20]. Diabetes was defined as HbA1c measurement above 6.5% and high cholesterol was defined as a random total cholesterol measurement above 240 mg/dL. Active tobacco smoking was defined as self-reported cigarette, pipe, or cigar smoking within the past 30 days. Overweight was defined as a body mass index (BMI) of 25.0–29.9 and obese was defined as a BMI of 30.0 or greater.
Ten-year risk of a cardiovascular event was defined using the WHO/ISH risk stratification charts, which use six variables (gender, age, systolic blood pressure, total cholesterol, smoking and presence/absence of diabetes) to stratify the ten-year absolute risk of stroke and heart attack in adults aged 40–79 into five risk categories. The WHO/ISH risk charts are based on modeling using regional population-level data on the relative and absolute risk of each risk factor [21].
Statistical analysis
Data were imported into SAS 9.4 for analysis. Descriptive statistics including means/proportions and their standard deviation were calculated for all variables of interest. Due to small expected cell counts, Fisher’s exact tests were used to determine whether the differences in current tobacco use, high cholesterol, diabetes, underweight and obesity were statistically significant between male and female at significant level of 0.05.
Results
Between March and June of 2014, complete data were collected for 175 participants, of whom 130 (74.2%) were female. Average age was 45.4 years (SD ± 8.8). Table 1 shows participant demographics, medical history, and CVDRF prevalence. On average, participants had been attending the HIV clinic for four years, and their mean CD4+ count was 411/mm3 (SD±184). Of the 143 participants with a documented viral load, 65.7% had undetectable levels. Most participants (82.2%) were taking ART regimens that included a nucleoside analog backbone of lamivudine and tenofovir, and (90.9%) were taking nevirapine or efavirenz; none were on protease inhibitors. Only 8% of participants reported missing a dose of ART in the past month, and only 5.1% reported missing an appointment at the HIV clinic within the past three months.
At the time of the study visit, 37.7% of participants had high blood pressure (HBP). Of those with HBP, 64.9% had a documented prior diagnosis of hypertension, and their previous BP control had been poor, with nearly two-thirds of these participants (63.5%) having documented HBP at their most recent HIV clinic visit. More than half of participants (52.5%) reported an immediate family member with hypertension.
Tobacco smoking had been documented in less than 1% of charts, however when interviewed, 30.9% of participants reported a prior history of tobacco use and 15.4% were current tobacco smokers (3.1% women, 51.1% men, p < 0.001). More than half (53.1%) of smokers had attempted to quit within the past year.
10.4% of participants had random total cholesterol > 240 mg/dL; hyperlipidemia was previously documented in less than a third (27.9%) of these patients. Diabetes was found in seven patients (4.1%); it had been previously documented in only four of the seven (57%). Notably, although self-reported activity levels were relatively high, 21.1% of participants were overweight (22.3% women, 17.8% men) and 28.6% were obese (36.9% women, 2.0% men, p < 0.001). Almost all participants (99.4%) had at least one documented weight in their clinic chart, although only 10.9% reported being told of obesity or overweight by their clinicians.
CVD risk was stratified for the 110 participants (76 women, 36 men) who were 40 years and older. Almost all (96.4%) had a 10-year CVD risk of less than 10%. Two (1.8%) had CVD risk of 10–19%, one (0.9%) had CVD risk of 20–29% and one (0.9%) had CVD risk of ≥ 40%. Fig 1 shows risk stratification for the entire group.
Discussion
CVDRF were common amongst PLWH on ART at this urban HIV clinic, as they are in the general population of Free State Province [22]. Rates of overweight and obesity were also similar to those reported for the general population of Free State, where estimated rates are 19.5% and 5.8% respectively amongst men and 20.7% and 43% respectively amongst women [22]. Compared to other studies of South Africa PLWH on ART, the rate of diabetes was similar [23] and the rate of HBP was somewhat higher [24,25], likely due to the older age of the study participants. Few studies have described rates of tobacco smoking or high total cholesterol amongst comparable cohorts in South Africa.
Although the participants in this study were enrolled in and adherent with longitudinal chronic care, visiting the HIV clinic every one to three months for years, one-third of those with HBP, 40% of those with diabetes, and two-thirds of those with high cholesterol had not previously been diagnosed with these conditions. Overweight, obesity, and tobacco smoking were rarely documented in clinic charts, and few patients reported receiving behavioral counseling regarding weight loss and smoking cessation. Hypertension was poorly controlled, with 34.9% of participants having HBP at their most recent clinic visit and 37.7% found to have HBP at the study visit. The fact that participants were likely somewhat older, retained in care for longer, and more adherent to treatment than other PLWH suggests that they might be more likely to have been screened and treated for CVDRF than other patients. The fact that even these patients had not been adequately screened for CVDRF and managed appropriately suggests that there may be an important gap in these services.
CVD risk stratification is useful in guiding the intensity of CVDRF management and in prioritizing high-risk individuals [26,27]. In this study, almost all participants fell into the same risk category, limiting the use of WHO/ISH risk charts for triage purposes. The fact that 96.4% of participants 40 years and older had less than 10% ten-year risk of a cardiovascular event suggests that initial management of CVDRF within HIV clinic, rather than immediate referral to specialists, may be an effective approach.
Little has been published regarding optimal approaches to screening PLWH for CVDRF in low-resource settings, and this study adds to the scant literature on the topic. This study has some limitations, notably its focus on a single urban HIV clinic and its non-random sampling, both of which limit generalizability. Blood pressure was measured during a single visit, rather than on different days as suggested by clinical guidelines. However, this approach has been utilized widely in comparable studies, and in the 2013 South Africa National Health and Nutrition Survey (SANHANES-1) [28,29]. Nonfasting total cholesterol was used to diagnose hypercholesterolemia, which may therefore have been overestimated.
The results of this study have implications for policy-makers and program directors, indicating a substantial missed opportunity to identify and treat CVDRF amongst PLWH enrolled in continuity care for HIV. As CVDRF become increasingly common amongst both PLWH and the general population, health systems must confront both HIV and CVD risk factors if the successes of HIV scale up are to be maintained.
Supporting Information
S1 Table. Demographic information, assets, and HIV history.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0140298.s001
(XLSX)
S2 Table. Prevalence of CVD risk factors (self report, chart review and study visit).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0140298.s002
(XLSX)
Acknowledgments
MR and WME conceived of the study. MR, WME, AM and CC gave input to study design and instruments. MR, AM and CC supervised training and data collection. YZ and YW led data analysis. MR drafted the paper. All authors assisted with interpretation of the results, made critical revisions to the manuscript, reviewed the final manuscript and approved submission. The corresponding author had full access to all the data in the study and had final responsibility for the decision to submit for publication.
The African Clinical Research Organisation (ACRO) assisted with data collection and management. Dr. Raphael Ntumy participated in study planning and design. Dr. Fortune Sefanyetso and Dr. Batanayi Muzah assisted with training and data collection.
Funding for the study was provided by Medtronic Philanthropy.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: MR WME AM CC. Performed the experiments: MR AM CC. Analyzed the data: YZ YW. Wrote the paper: MR. Conceived of the study: MR WME. Gave input to study design and instruments: MR WME AM CC. Supervised training and data collection: AM CC. Led data analysis: YZ YW. Drafted the paper: MR. Assisted with interpretation of the results, made critical revisions to the manuscript, reviewed the final manuscript and approved submission: MR AM CC YZ YW WME. Had full access to all the data in the study and had final responsibility for the decision to submit for publication: MR.
References
- 1. Dalal S, Beunza JJ, Volmink J, Adebamowo C, Bajunirwe F, Njelekela M, et al. Non-communicable diseases in sub-Saharan Africa: what we know now. Int J Epidemiology 2011;40:885–901. pmid:21527446
- 2.
Global Atlas on Cardiovascular Disease Prevention and Control. Mendis S, Puska P, Norrving B, editors. World Health Organization, Geneva 2011.
- 3. Mayosi BM, Flisher AJ, Lallo UG, Sitas F, Tollman SM, Bradshaw D. The burden of non-communicable diseases in South Africa. Lancet 2009;374:934–47. pmid:19709736
- 4. Peer N, Kengne AP, Motala AA, Mbanya JC. Diabetes in the Africa Region: an update. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2014;103:197–205. pmid:24315460
- 5. Ogah OS, Rayner BL. Recent advances in hypertension in sub-Saharan Africa. Heart 2013;99:1390–7. pmid:23708775
- 6. Sreeramareddy C, Pradhan PMS, Sin She. Prevalence, distribution and social determinants of tobacco use in 30 sub-Saharan African countries. BMC Medicine 2014;12:243. pmid:25518855
- 7. Levitt NS, Steyn K, Bradshaw D. Chronic noncommunicable diseases and HIV-AIDS on a collision course: relevance for health care delivery, particularly in low-resource settings–insight from South Africa. Am J Clin Nutr 2011;94:1690S–1696S. pmid:22089433
- 8.
WHO NCD Country Profiles for South Africa. Available: http://www.who.int/nmh/countries/zaf_en.pdf?ua=1 [Accessed 2 January 2015]
- 9. Tibazarwa K, Ntyuntyane L, Sliwa K, Gernholtz T, Carrington M, Wilkinson D, et al. A time bomb of cardiovascular risk factors in South Africa: results from the Heart of Soweto study “Heart Awareness Days”. Int J Cardiol 2009;132(2): 233–9. Epub 2008 Jan 30.
- 10. Triant VA, Lee H, Hadigan C, Grinspoon SK. Increased acute myocardial infarction rates and cardiovascular risk factors among patients with human immunodeficiency virus disease. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2007;92:2506–12. pmid:17456578
- 11. Dillon DG, Gurdasani D, Riha J, Ekoru K, Asiki G, Mayanja BN, et al. Association of HIV and ART with cardiometabolic traits in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Epidem 2013;42:1754–1771. pmid:24415610.
- 12. Hemkens LG, Bucher HC. HIV infection and cardiovascular disease. European Heart J 2014;35:1373–1381. pmid:24408888.
- 13. Kiage JN, Heimburger DC, Nyirenda CK, Wellons MF, Bagchi S, Chi BH, et al. Cardiometabolic risk factors among HIV patients on antiretroviral therapy. Lipids Health Dis 2013;12:50. pmid:23575345.
- 14. Narayan KMV, Miotti PG, Anand NP, Kline LM, Harmston C, Gulakowski R 3rd, et al. HIV and noncommunicable disease comorbidities in the era of antiretroviral therapy: a vital agenda for research in low- and middle-income country settings. J Acquir Immun Defic Syndr 2014;67:S2S–7. pmid:25117958.
- 15.
International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ). Available: https://sites.google.com/site/theipaq/home [Accessed 2 January 2015]
- 16. Bauman A, Bull F, Chey T, Craig CL, Ainsworth BE, Sallis JF, et al. The International Prevalence Study on Physical Activity: results from 20 countries. Int J Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 2009;31:21. pmid:19335883.
- 17.
The STEPS Instrument and Support Materials. Available: http://www.who.int/chp/steps/instrument/en/ [Accessed 2 January 2015]
- 18. World Health Organization, International Society of Hypertension writing group. 2003 World Health Organization (WHO)/International Society of Hypertension (ISH) statement on management of hypertension. J Hypertension 2003;21(11):1983–1992.
- 19.
World Health Organization. Prevention of cardiovascular disease: Guidelines for assessment and management of total cardiovascular risk. Geneva 2007.
- 20. Weber MA, Schiffrin EL, White WB, Mann S, Lindholm LH, Kenerson JG, et al. Clinical practice guidelines for the management of hypertension in the community: a statement by the American Society of Hypertension and the International Society of Hypertension. Journal of clinical hypertension 2014; 16(1): 14–26. pmid:24341872.
- 21. Mendis S, Lindholm LH, Mancia G, Whitworth J, Alderman M, Lim S, et al. World Health Organization (WHO) and International Society of Hypertension (ISH) risk prediction charts: assessment of cardiovascular risk for prevention and control of cardiovascular disease in low and middle-income countries. J Hypertens 2007;25(8):1578–82. pmid:17620952
- 22.
Shishana O, Labadarios D, Rehle T, Simbayi L, Zuma K, Dhansay A, et al. and the SANHANES-1 Team (2014). South African National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (SANHANES-1): 2014 Edition. Cape Town: HSCR Press.
- 23. Dave JA, Lambert EV, Badri M, West S, Maartens G, Levitt NS. Effect of nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor-based antiretroviral therapy on dysglycemia and insulin sensitivity in South African HIV-infected patients. J Acquir Immun Def Syndr 2011;57:284–289. pmid:21602696.
- 24. Julius H, Basu D, Ricci E, Basu JK, Pocaterra D, Bonfanti P. The burden of metabolic diseases among HIV positive patients on HAART attending the Johannesburg Hospital. Curr HIV Res 2011;9:247–52. pmid:21631427
- 25. Bärnighausen T, Welz T, Hosegood V, Bätzing-Feigenbaum J, Tanser F, Herbst K, et al. Hiding in the shadows of the HIV epidemic: obesity and hypertension in a rural population with very high HIV prevalence in South Africa. J Human Hypertension 2008;22:236–239. pmid:18046436.
- 26. Cooney MT, Dudina AL, Graham IM. Value and limitations of existing scores for the assessment of cardiovascular risk: a review for clinicians. J Am Coll Cardio 2009;54:1209–27. pmid:19778661.
- 27. Otgontuya D, Oum S, Buckley BS, Bonita R. Assessment of total cardiovascular risk using WHO/ISH risk prediction charts in three low and middle income countries in Asia. BMC Public Health 2013;13:539. pmid:23734670.
- 28. Hendriks ME, Wit FW, Roos MT, Brewster LM, Akande TM, de Beer IH, et al. Hypertension in sub-Saharan Africa: cross-sectional surveys in four rural and urban communities. PLoS One 2012;7(3):e32638 pmid:22427857.
- 29. Chow CK, Teo KK, Rangarajan S, Islam S, Gupta R, Avezum A, et al. Prevalence, awareness, treatment, and control of hypertension in rural and urban communities in high-, middle-, and low-income countries. JAMA 2013;310(9):959–68 pmid:24002282.