Figures
Abstract
Several protozoan parasites have been shown to undergo a form of programmed cell death that exhibits morphological features associated with metazoan apoptosis. These include the rodent malaria parasite, Plasmodium berghei. Malaria zygotes develop in the mosquito midgut lumen, forming motile ookinetes. Up to 50% of these exhibit phenotypic markers of apoptosis; as do those grown in culture. We hypothesised that naturally occurring signals induce many ookinetes to undergo apoptosis before midgut traversal. To determine whether nitric oxide and reactive oxygen species act as such triggers, ookinetes were cultured with donors of these molecules. Exposure to the nitric oxide donor SNP induced a significant increase in ookinetes with condensed nuclear chromatin, activated caspase-like molecules and translocation of phosphatidylserine that was dose and time related. Results from an assay that detects the potential-dependent accumulation of aggregates of JC-1 in mitochondria suggested that nitric oxide does not operate via loss of mitochondrial membrane potential. L-DOPA (reactive oxygen species donor) also caused apoptosis in a dose and time dependent manner. Removal of white blood cells significantly decreased ookinetes exhibiting a marker of apoptosis in vitro. Inhibition of the activity of nitric oxide synthase in the mosquito midgut epithelium using L-NAME significantly decreased the proportion of apoptotic ookinetes and increased the number of oocysts that developed. Introduction of a nitric oxide donor into the blood meal had no effect on mosquito longevity but did reduce prevalence and intensity of infection. Thus, nitric oxide and reactive oxygen species are triggers of apoptosis in Plasmodium ookinetes. They occur naturally in the mosquito midgut lumen, sourced from infected blood and mosquito tissue. Up regulation of mosquito nitric oxide synthase activity has potential as a transmission blocking strategy.
Citation: Ali M, Al-Olayan EM, Lewis S, Matthews H, Hurd H (2010) Naturally Occurring Triggers that Induce Apoptosis-Like Programmed Cell Death in Plasmodium berghei Ookinetes. PLoS ONE 5(9): e12634. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0012634
Editor: Gordon Langsley, INSERM U1016, Institut Cochin, France
Received: March 30, 2010; Accepted: August 10, 2010; Published: September 9, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Ali et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Funding for insectary facilities was provided by The Wellcome Trust, (069162/Z/02/Z), www.wellcome.ac.uk. EMA and MA received scholarships from the Saudi Arabian Government and the Egyptian Government, respectively. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
There is a well established body of literature that recognizes programmed cell death (PCD) as a signal dependent, active process of cell suicide that occurs in unicellular eukaryotes as well as metazoans. Its origin predates the evolution of multicellularity and may have arisen during the endosymbiotic incorporation of the mitochondrial precursor into the ancestral eukaryote [1]–[4]. Galluzzi and colleagues speculate that many of the cell death regulators of metazoan cells may originally have been involved in stress regulation [5].
Three types of PCD have been well characterized in metazoans, including type 1 PCD, or apoptosis [6], [7] however, it is now recognized that overlapping pathways leading to different types of PCD death exist, and more complex nomenclature has been suggested [8]. Despite this, new recommendations concerning death-related terminology have recently been published and the used of just the three terms, necrosis, apoptosis and autophagic cell death are recommended [9]. Most of the features that are signatures of apoptosis in metazoans are also present in unicellular eukaryotes, including loss of mitochondrial outer membrane permeability (MOMP), nuclear chromatin condensation, cytochrome c release, DNA fragmentation and translocation of phosphatidylserine (PS) to the outer cell membrane (reviewed in [10], [11]). Despite this, much of the apoptotic molecular machinery common to multicellular eukaryotes is absent, and different pathways may be leading to the same endpoint [11]–[13].
Markers of apoptosis have been described in both the vertebrate and vector stages of the malaria parasite [14]–[17] although, as discussed by Arambage and colleagues [18], conflicting results have emerged from different laboratories, particularly regarding apoptosis in erythrocytic stages. In the mosquito midgut lumen, motile zygotes or ookinetes are formed around 18 h post-infection and move out of the blood meal bolus before traversing the midgut epithelium to form oocysts beneath the basal lamina. Within the midgut lumen of Anopheles stephensi, over 50% of ookinetes of the rodent malaria, Plasmodium berghei, exhibit markers of apoptosis by 24 h post-infection [16].This cell suicide may help to explain the huge loss of parasites between the ookinete and oocyst stage that has been reported during many Plasmodium/mosquito associations [19].
Cell suicide in protists can be triggered by various extra and intracellular events including nutrient deprivation, heat shock, drug treatment and the presence of nitric oxide (NO), reactive nitrogen species (RNS) and reactive oxygen species (ROS) (see for example reviews [11]–[13]). Many investigations of parasitic protists are conducted in vitro and apoptosis is induced experimentally by one or other of these triggers. However, protists have been shown to exhibit markers of apoptosis in vivo, without experimental manipulation, and apoptosis has been suggested to play an important role in the life history of some unicellular parasite populations. For example, in trypanosomatids it is thought to act as a mechanism to control population numbers and eliminate particular developmental stages [11], [20]–[23]. Extrinsic inducers of apoptosis in parasitic protozoans must therefore occur in vivo and would be expected to be found in the mosquito midgut lumen following an infective blood meal.
The mosquito midgut lumen is an environment that becomes increasing hostile as the blood meal is digested; in part this is due to the presence of NO, RNS and ROS. Peterson and colleagues [24] suggest that haemoglobin, present in the blood meal, catalyses the synthesis of NO metabolites in a reducing environment. An additional source of NO comes from the mosquito as nitric oxide synthase (NOS), present in midgut epithelial cells, catalyses the production of NO during the oxidative deamination of L-arginine to L-citrulline. Inducible NOS expression is upregulated in mosquito midgut epithelial cells in response to malaria infection [25], [26] and induction of NOS is proportional to the intensity of infection [27]. Herrera-Oritz and colleagues [28] also reported that NO is produced in midguts of Anopheles pseudopunctipennis cultured with P. berghei. In addition, NOS has been detected within midgut cells that have been invaded by ookinetes [29], [30].
NO, or its reactive derivatives, play a part in the immunological reaction of host defence against numerous pathogens [31]. They have been identified as important cytotoxic effector molecules in a variety of parasitic infections of vertebrates, including schistosomiasis, leishmaniasis and malaria infection [32]. NO has been shown to have a cytotoxic or cytostatic effect on erythrocyte stages of Plasmodium, depending on concentration [33]–[35] and Rockett and colleagues found that S-nitrosothiols displayed a far greater toxicity to P. falciparum than nitrate which, in turn, was more effective than nitrite [36]. The availability of NO for Plasmodium killing in the vertebrate circulatory system has been questioned [37], nevertheless, it has indisputable effects on malaria transmission [38]: killing gametocytes [39] and ookinetes [40] and nitrate concentration increases in the gut of Plasmodium-infected mosquitoes [41]. In the mosquito, inhibition of NOS activity has been shown to increase the number of oocysts developing on the midgut [26].
Herrera-Ortiz et al [28] found that ookinetes incubated with the NO donor, sodium nitroprusside (SNP) or the ROS generator, L-DOPA, significantly decreased viability and that a combination of both donors was synergistic. Similarly, L-DOPA dependent superoxide anion (O2-), produced in the haemolymph and midgut of Anopheles albimanus, is toxic to ookinetes [40]. L-DOPA, also caused loss of P. berghei gametocyte infectivity [42]. In addition to RNS, ROS are also generated within the midgut cells of An. stephensi during ookinete invasion [43]. We hypothesized that these toxic molecules may be naturally occurring extrinsic triggers of apoptosis in P. berghei ookinetes.
NO has been shown to create nitrosative stress which can promote apoptosis by the activation of mitochondrial apoptotic pathways [44] and mitochondrially derived ROS have also been associated with the initiation phase of apoptosis, acting as mediators for different signal transduction pathways. A role for ROS in ancient redox –sensitive pathways leading to apoptosis-like PCD has also been proposed and both RNS and ROS have been shown to act as triggers for apoptosis in Toxoplasma gondii [45] and kinetoplastid parasites of the genera Trypanosoma and Leishmania [46]–[49].
The purpose of this study was to investigate the hypothesis that NO and ROS cause the death of P. berghei ookinetes by an apoptosis-like (hereafter referred to as apoptosis) process. Investigations were performed in vitro and ookinetes examined for several markers of apoptosis following exposure to donors of NO and ROS. Experiments were then designed to determine whether natural sources of NO in the blood meal and mosquito midgut could also induce the display of markers of apoptosis in vivo. The results demonstrated that NO, or its derivatives, do trigger apoptosis in ookinetes in vitro and support the hypothesis that NOS activity is linked to the induction of apoptosis in P. berghei ookinetes whist they are in the mosquito midgut lumen. The role of ROS in inducing apoptosis is less marked, although we do demonstrate that it is toxic to ookinetes in vitro and causes the display of markers of apoptosis in a dose and time dependent manner.
Results
The effect of white blood cells on the induction of apoptosis
White blood cells (WBCs) contain NOS and thus represent a source of NO in the blood. In order to determine whether the removal of these cells from gametocytaemic blood prior to culture affected the proportion of ookinetes that exhibited signs of chromatin condensation, a comparison was made between blood with and without WBCs. Exposure to WBCs caused a small, but overall significant, increase in the proportion of ookinetes with acridine orange staining (depicting condensed chromatin) when maintained in Schneider's medium for 0.25 h, 3 h and 6 h respectively (∼5.5, 4 and 1% increase; F1,35 = 4.76; P<0.05) (see supplementary Figure S1). The remainder of ookinete incubations in this study was performed in the presence of WBCs.
The effect of NO donors on ookinetes in vitro
Newly formed ookinetes were exposed to 2 mM sodium nitroprusside (SNP) for 0.25 h, 1 h or 4 h and the percentage of ookinetes displaying condensed chromatin was detected using acridine orange staining. An overall significant increase in acridine orange-positive ookinetes occurred (F1,53 = 40.29; P<0.001) and pair wise comparisons showed that this increase was significant after 1 h (∼25% increase P<0.001) and 4 h (∼20%, P<0.01) incubations (see Figure 1A). Ookinetes were also cultured for 24 h but by this time the proportion of parasites with condensed chromatin in the control group had risen to over 70% and no significant differences were detected between control and treated groups (data not shown). NO thus accelerated the induction of apoptosis in a large proportion of the ookinete population. An investigation into the effect of different concentrations of SNP showed that the effect was dose dependent; although 10 µM SNP did not induce additional ookinetes to undergo chromatin condensation, 100 µM SNP caused a significant increase of 30% (P<0.001) and 500 µM SNP caused an increase of 32% (P<0.001) (Figure 1B). Further experiments incubating ookinetes with 1 mM, 2 mM and 4 mM SNP for 1 h and 4 h all showed significant increases in ookinetes displaying this marker for apoptosis compared with untreated groups at the same time points. However, in no case were all ookinetes induced to undergo apoptosis; between 20 and 30% never displayed chromatin condensation, even after 24 h incubation with SNP (data not shown).
Ookinetes were incubated in RPMI with or without the addition of SNP at different concentrations or for different time periods and then examined for the presence of different markers of apoptosis. A:The effect of 2 mM SNP on the proportion of ookinetes expressing a marker of apoptosis; data are means of 3 experiments (n = 3) with 300 ookinetes examined in each experiment. B,C: The effect of different concentrations of SNP following 1 h incubation; n = 3, with 100–150 ookinetes examined per experiment). D: The effect of different concentrations of SNP on ookinetes following 4 h incubation; n = 3, with 25–50 ookinetes examined in each experiment. Apoptosis markers examined were condensed nuclear chromatin (A, B), activated caspase-like molecules (C), and PS translocation without loss of membrane integrity (D). Error bars represent standard error of the mean (SEM). Bars with different letters are significantly different. White bars represent controls and patterned bars represent treated ookinetes.
Two additional markers for apoptosis-like death, the presence of activated caspase-like molecules and the translocation of PS to the outer membrane were monitored after SNP treatment. As the percentage of untreated ookinetes with apoptosis markers varied greatly between experiments, fold increases in the expression of each marker were calculated to facilitate comparison between experiments (Table 1). A similar pattern to chromatin condensation was seen with an overall significant increase in the percentage of ookinetes expressing active caspase-like molecules in SNP-treated ookinetes compared to that of untreated ookinetes (F3,23 = 9.6; P<0.001). This was caused by incubation with 100 µM and 500 µM SNP but not with the lower concentration of 10 µM SNP (see Figure 1C). Although the proportion of untreated ookinetes displaying caspase-like activity was much smaller than those displaying acridine orange staining in the previous experiment the proportion of apoptotic ookinetes in the untreated group was lower in these experiments and a similar fold increase in this marker occurred upon treatment (see Table 1). Examination of ookinetes for PS translocation revealed that incubation with SNP also caused a significant increase in this marker of apoptosis (F3,19 = 8.93; P<0.01) but that higher concentrations (1 mM) and a longer incubation period (4 h) were required for the proportion of annexin positive ookinetes (that did not have compromised membranes) to be significantly higher than untreated parasites (Figure 1D and Table 1). The yield of parasites available for this latter series of experiments was lower than the previous ones and thus the number of ookinetes examined was smaller.
Ookinetes that had been collected from gametocytaemic-blood following 18 h of culture were used to determine whether the execution pathway of NO-induced apoptosis involved the mitochondrion. Ookinetes were incubated for 2 h with 100 µM SNP and then examined for loss of MOMP using a JC-1 assay kit. Approximately 30% of untreated ookinetes exhibited loss of MOMP and a similar proportion to this contained nuclei with condensed chromatin (Figure 2). Further ookinetes were, instead, incubated with carbonyl cyanide 3-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP), which causes loss of MOMP, and compared with untreated samples and SNP treated samples. All the ookinetes in samples treated with CCCP had lost MOMP (Kruskal-Wallis p = 0.008), however SNP treatment did not induce further loss of MOMP. Overall, both SNP and CCCP treatments caused a significant increase in the proportion of ookinetes displaying condensed chromatin (F2.9 = 18.93; p = 0.001), and each group differed significantly from the untreated parasites (Figure 2). These data suggest expression of this apoptosis marker in ookinetes may occur via a pathway involving loss of mitochondrial membrane potential (Δ ψm), but that NO-induced apoptosis does not proceed in this way.
Ookinetes were maintained in RPMI alone (controls) or incubated with 100 µM SNP for 2 h or with CCCP for 30 min prior to examination for loss of mitochondrial membrane potential (MOMP) (black bars) or the presence of nuclear chromatin condensation (grey bars). Error bars represent standard error of the mean (SEM), n = 4 with 50–100 ookinetes examined in each experiment. Bars with different letters are significantly different.
In order to confirm that the induction of apoptosis seen following incubation with SNP was due to the NO produced by this donor some supplementary investigations were performed using two other donors to deliver NO to ookinetes in culture. It took 500 µM S-Nitroso-N-acetyl-DL-penicillamine (SNAP) to induced a significant increase in the proportion of ookinetes displaying caspase-like activity after 1 h incubation (P<0.01). However S-nitroglutathione (SNOG) only induced a significant increase in the proportion with condensed chromatin at a concentration of 2 mM after incubation for 6 h (P<0.001) (Supplementary Figure S2A and B).
Measurement of the nitrite produced by the three donors when dissolved in solutions of supplemented RPMI revealed large differences in the speed and amount of release, with SNAP producing more nitrite that the other two donors during short incubation times whereas SNOG produced much more after 24 h (Supplementary Figure S3). Some of the nitrite produced by these donors may have been oxidized to nitrate during these incubation periods but this would not be detected by the Griess reaction use in this study.
The effect of a nitric oxide synthase inhibitor on apoptotic ookinetes in vivo
In addition to WBCs in the blood meal, the mosquito midgut epithelium is a source of NO that could induce apoptosis in developing ookinetes. To test this hypothesis, mosquitoes were fed a NOS inhibitor, Nw-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester (L-NAME), the inactive isomer, Nw-nitro-D-arginine methyl ester (D-NAME), or infective blood meal alone. Analysis of the number of ookinetes in the midgut lumen that were exhibiting condensed chromatin in the presence of a NOS inhibitor or the inactive isomer indicated significant differences due to treatments, (F2,12 = 123.86, P<0.001), time post-infection, (F1,12 = 63.379, P<0.001), and treatments by time interaction (F2,12 = 7.05796, P<0.01). Specifically, the addition of L-NAME to the blood meal caused a significant reduction in the proportion of ookinetes exhibiting condensed chromatin (P<0.001) compared to those exposed to control treatments at 18 h and 20 h post-blood feeding. Additionally, significantly more L-NAME treated ookinetes were undergoing apoptosis at 20 h than 18 h post-infection (P<0.001) but this increase was not detected in the control treatments, suggesting that inhibition of NOS activity had delayed the induction of apoptosis (Figure 3A).
An. stephensi were fed on blood containing P. berghei gametocytes (black bars) with the addition of L-NAME (grey bars) or the inactive isomer D-NAME (white bars). A: The proportion of ookinetes with condensed nuclear chromatin at 18 h and 20 h post-infection. B, C:The proportion of ookinetes expressing caspase-like activity or with compromised membranes (CM) 15 h and 20 h post-infection respectively. Error bars represent standard error of the mean (SEM). Bars with different letters are significantly different.
In the anticipation that activation of cysteine proteases may occur upstream of chromatin condensation we monitored the effect of inhibition of NOS activity earlier, at 15 post blood- feeding. Approximately 50% of the 200 ookinetes examined stained positive for caspase-like activity in untreated and D-NAME treated mosquitoes by 15 h post-feeding and a further 20% were permeable to propidium iodide (PI) (which may have obscured staining for caspase-like activity) and thus classed as dead (Figure 3B). An overall significant change in these proportions had occurred by 20 h post-infection (F5,24 = 573.2 P<0.001 (caspase) F5,24 = 47.8 P<0.001(compromised membranes)) (Figure 3C) with the proportion of caspase positive ookinetes with intact membranes declining, those with compromised membranes increasing and lack of visible staining for caspase-like activity increasing. Intermediate values were recorded for each parameter at 18 h (data not shown). The addition of L-NAME to a blood meal significantly decreased the proportion of ookinetes with activated caspase-like molecules in their cytoplasm at 15 h (P<0.001) whereas D-NAME had no effect (P>0.1) but by 20 h there was no significant difference between NOS-inhibitor treated ookinetes and the control (P>1.0) or D-NAME (P>0.99). However, significantly fewer L-NAME treated ookinetes had compromised plasma membranes (P<0.02) at this time (Figure 3C). These data again suggest that inhibition of NOS activity gave some initial protection against apoptosis.
Further experiments demonstrated that the addition of the NOS inhibitor L-NAME to the blood meal significantly increased the number of P. berghei oocysts developing on the midgut of An. stephensi 12 days post-infection compared with those in the D-NAME treated groups and untreated mosquitoes (see Table 2). No differences in mosquito survivorship were observed across the treatments (data not shown).
The effect of an NO donor on mosquito longevity and ookinete development in vivo
An assessment was made of the feasibility of enhancing the natural production of NO by the mosquito as a means of killing ookinetes in vivo without affecting mosquito fitness. The effect on mosquito longevity of administration of the NO donor SNP with an infective blood meal was assessed. Neither 100 µM nor 1 mM SNP caused a significant change in the probability of survival compared with untreated mosquitoes (Wilcoxon analyses: 100 µM, P = 0.9 and 1 mM (P = 0.98) (Figure 4A and 4B), demonstrating that one blood meal containing elevated levels of NO did not affect longevity.
Four groups of 38–45 mosquitoes were fed on P. berghei-infected mouse blood (solid black lines, 2 groups), or P. berghei- infected mouse blood with the addition of 100 µM SNP (A) or 1 mM SNP (B) (dotted red lines). Mosquito deaths were recorded daily.
Additional NO in the blood meal did, however, have an effect on the prevalence of mosquito infections which fell significantly (P<0.01) when mosquitoes fed on an infective blood meal containing 100 µM SNAP (Figure 5A) and mean numbers of ookinetes found in the midgut lumen dropped from 969±120 to 207±62 (P<0.001) (See Figure 5B).
Mosquitoes were fed on gametocytaemic mouse blood alone or on blood containing 100 µM SNAP and midguts examined 16–18 h post-infection. A: Prevalence of ookinete infections (mean of 5 experiments). B: Intensity of infection (the number of ookinetes recovered from each midgut; infected blood, n = 60, infected blood with SNAP, n = 55.
The effect of reactive oxygen species on ookinetes
The effect of L-DOPA on ookinetes was both dose and time dependent. Thus, compared to controls, the increase in ookinetes expressing chromatin condensation after 1, 2 and 4 h exposure to 10 µM L-DOPA was not significantly different (P = 0.9, P = 0.7 and P = 0.9, respectively), but concentrations of 100 and 500 µM L-DOPA applied for 1 h did significantly increase this apoptosis marker (P<0.05). However, at higher concentrations and longer incubation times the proportion of parasites with condensed chromatin was no greater than that of untreated samples (Figure 6A). Instead, the proportion of ookinetes with compromised membranes rose steadily with time and concentration of L-DOPA (Figure 6B). It should be noted that the increase in apoptotic ookinetes seen when treated with 500 µM L-DOPA for 4 h was not significant (Figure 6B).
A: Ookinetes were incubated in supplemented RPMI containing different concentration of L-DOPA for 1 h (bars with small dots), 2 h (bars with strips) and 4 h (bars with large dots) and the proportion containing condensed nuclear chromatin was calculated. B: Ookinetes were incubated with L-DOPA for 4 h and those with compromised membranes (dead ookinetes) were identified by staining with erythrosin B (grey bars), while ookinetes showing chromatin condensation were identified with acridine orange (white bars). Bars are a mean of 3 experiments (n = 3) with at least 50 ookinetes examined in each experiment. Error bars represent SEM.
Another reactive oxygen species generator, H2O2, caused a significant loss of membrane integrity within 1 h of exposure to 100 µM, 500 µM or 1 mM concentrations (P<0.001) and a larger proportion of the population had compromised membranes when incubated with 100 µM, or 500 µM H2O2 for 4 h. However, no increase in the proportion of ookinetes displaying nuclear chromatin condensation occurred following 1 h or 4 h incubation with these concentrations of H2O2 (Figure 7A,B).
The effect of incubation with different concentrations of H2O2 for 1 h (A) or 4 h (B). Apoptotic ookinetes displaying chromatin condensation were detected with acridine orange (white bars); ookinetes with compromised membranes were detected with propidium iodide (grey bars). Bars represent means of 3 experiments and at least 25 ookinetes were counted per sample. Error bars represent SEM and bars with different letters are significantly different.
Discussion
We previously reported, that a proportion of P. berghei ookinetes that develop in vitro and in vivo express markers of apoptosis without the addition of known inducers of apoptosis. [16]. The findings reported herein strongly support our hypothesis that NO and/or RNS act as inducers of apoptosis in P. berghei ookinetes in vitro and that this induction is dose and time dependent. We show that incubation with the NO donor SNP significantly increased the proportion of newly formed ookinetes exhibiting nuclear chromatin condensation, caspase-like activity and PS translocation when present at concentration that our experiments suggest would produce between 5–10 µM nitrite after 1 h. SNAP also induced caspase-like activity within 1 h at doses that generated low levels of nitrite (∼10 µM nitrite after 1 h). In contrast, higher concentrations and longer incubation periods were used to study the effect of the NO donor SNOG but the proportion of ookinetes displaying condensed chromatin did not significantly increase after 3 h exposure and a significant increase was only observed after 6 h incubation (expected nitrite production of ∼50 µM). It is possible that induction of apoptosis occurs within a narrow range of concentrations of NO or RNS and exposure to high levels of these compounds may cause death by other means such as necrosis. However, this does not explain why we observed this significant increase in chromatin condensation following 6 h incubation. It will be necessary to use several apoptosis markers to confirm that we were definitely observing apoptosis rather than necrosis when ookinetes are exposed to high levels of NO.
It would appear that L-DOPA-induction of the expression of apoptotic markers in ookinetes is highly sensitive to concentration and time of exposure. Very low concentrations of L-DOPA did not generate enough ROS to have any effect, whereas exposure to 1 mM or more resulted in loss of membrane integrity without markers of apoptosis being displayed. Although none of the concentrations of H2O2 used in this study induced apoptosis, it is possible that lower concentration would have done so. RNS and ROS have been identified as inducers of apoptosis in a variety of protozoans and their effect has been reported to be concentration dependent (see reviews [10]–[12]). For example, H2O2 at low concentrations (500 µM) caused Tritrichomonas foetus to undergo apoptosis-like death whereas at concentration of 8 mM necrotic death was observed [50].
It is worth noting the large variation in the proportion of apoptotic ookinetes observed at the beginning of different experiments. This could be an unavoidable consequence of having to use different mice as the source of infectious blood. We speculate that parameters such as intensity of asexual infection, number of gametocytes present or parameters such as NO or cytokine levels in the mouse plasma may be responsible for these differences.
The steady rise in the proportion of apoptotic ookinetes over time may be due to an increase in the level of RNS in the culture medium, or differences in susceptibility of individual parasites to NO/RNS (possibly associated with differences in ookinete age as development is asynchronous). It is known that, in vitro, late erythrocytic stages of P. falciparum are more vulnerable to the effects of NO produced by SNAP than the early (ring) stages and this effect is dose dependent [33]. In this and our previous studies, we note that approximately 20% of ookinetes remain viable even when exposed to inducers of apoptosis for long periods. Herrer-Ortiz and colleagues [28] also found that 28% of P. berghei ookinetes survive the oxidative stress generated by the combined action of L-DOPA and SNP. They suggested that this was due to the presence of adaptive, protective, molecules produced by ookinetes to fight mosquito defenses such as antioxidants. Even though these parasites originated from a single clone some individuals may be more vulnerable than others.
The demonstration that NO or ROS will induce apoptosis-like death of ookinetes in vitro did not, however, demonstrate that NO- or ROS-induced apoptosis has a role to play in the life history of the sporogonic stages of the malaria parasite. To support this proposal it was necessary to identify a potential source of NO, RNS or ROS in the mosquito midgut lumen and to demonstrate that redox generated reactions initiate PCD pathways in developing zygotes and ookinetes in vivo. Both the blood meal and mosquito tissue have been shown to be sources of these apoptosis triggers.
Sources of nitric oxide
Plasmodium gametocytes are imbibed with a blood meal that, in addition to infected and uninfected erythrocytes, contains white blood cells, platelets and serum. Malaria infection elevates the level of cytokines such as TNF-α. IL-1 and IFN-γ that are known inducers of iNOS expression in mouse macrophages [51]. This induction acts synergistically with haemozoin in mouse [52], but not human, macrophages [53]. WBCs thus represent an endogenous source of NO. Cao et al. [38] reported that infected mouse serum, obtained 5 days after P. yoelii infection, blocks gametocyte infectivity to the mosquito via nitric oxide production and inactivation of gametocyte activity has been associated with the presence of WBCs. Furthermore, WBCs have been shown to remain active in the blood bolus for several hours and thus could contribute to killing mechanisms that operate in the mosquito midgut [39], [54]. It is likely that they are also active in gametocytaemic blood that is cultured to produce ookinetes in vitro. Previously, our data had shown that removal of WBCs from in vitro culture caused significant (13%), reduction in the number of apoptotic ookinetes (Al-Olayan and Hurd, unpublished). Here we confirm this finding. In both cases however the difference that the presence of WBCs made, to the proportion of ookinetes displaying markers of apoptosis was small. Therefore we note that the presence of WBCs is unlikely to account for induction of apoptosis in all the ookinetes in our untreated samples in vitro as this ranged from approximately 15 to 40% within 18 h of the culture of gametocytaemic blood, and rose steadily to a plateau that could be as high as 80% after 24 h. It is possible that the production of NO from WBCs might be low when cultured at 19°C (optimal developmental temperature for P. berghei ookinetes) and the NO they produce could play a more important role within mosquitoes, or in cultures kept at the higher temperatures conducive to the development of ookinetes of other species of malaria. However, within our system, we suggest there may be additional sources of NO, or other external triggers, that induce a large proportion of P. berghei ookinetes to undergo apoptosis.
Within the mosquito midgut, Luckhart and co-workers have identified inflammatory levels of reactive nitrogen intermediates in the blood meal [41] with nitrates and metal nitrosyls elevated following an infective blood meal Nitrogen oxides present in blood meals were measured using a nitric oxide analyzer and normalized against heme and were significantly elevated to ∼6 µM/heme mM at 12.5 h post infective blood meal [55]. These authors suggested that, in contrast to the situation in the mammalian host, haemoglobin drives the production of nitric oxide metabolites in the reducing environment of the blood meal [24]. NO can react with haemoglobin forming a variety of complexes including oxygen radicals and nitroxyl that are also implicated in apoptosis induction. It would seem that once infected blood enters the midgut, conditions there give rise to the generation of additional NO within the blood bolus.
In addition to NO and RNS imbibed with the blood meal, the mosquito midgut cells are themselves a source of NO. Blood meals containing P. berghei induce up-regulation of NOS expression in the midgut of An. gambiae [25] and An. stephensi [26]. This NOS activity has a biphasic induction in An. stephensi with a peak 6 h post-infection, when parasites are developing in the midgut lumen, and at 24–36 h, after ookinete invasion of the midgut [41]. Interestingly, P. falciparum glycosylphosphatidylinositols (GPIs), that would be released into the blood meal by both sexual and asexual stages of the parasite, have been shown to induce AsNOS expression in vivo and in vitro, with signaling likely to be mediated by an insulin signal transduction-like pathway [56]. The malaria pigment, haemazoin, has also been reported to induce NOS gene expression at 24 h post-feeding, thus producing complimentary activity to GPIs [57]. An additional signal, ingested by the mosquito and activated in the midgut, is mammalian latent transforming growth factor (TFG-β1). Acting as a cytokine, it is a potent regulator of AsNOS expression with low doses resulting in sustained induction of anti-parasitic AsNOS [41]. Finally, a TFG-β homologue, As60A, is inducibly expressed in the mosquito in a parasite density-dependent manner. This also induces NO production and acts to control parasite development [27]. Thus many factors contribute to the toxic, apoptosis-inducing environment in which ookinetes are developing in vivo.
Early activity of NOS has been shown to limit parasite development in vivo and supplementation of the blood meal with the NOS substrate, L-arginine, significantly reduces the number of oocyst on the midgut of P. berghei-infected An. stephensi. Furthermore, feeding the NOS inhibitor, L-NAME, increases parasite burden whilst D-NAME, the inactive isomer, has no effect [26] and Cao and co-workers [38] reported a similar effect when mosquitoes were fed on mice that had previously fed on L-NAME or D-NAME. These data do not, however, tell us whether NO/RNS are acting by inducing apoptosis in the parasites.
In this study, feeding mosquitoes blood meals mixed with an NO donor inhibited the development of ookinetes to such a marked degree that hardly any were available to be examined for markers of apoptosis thus the experiments reported here were not able to demonstrate that the death of ookinetes induced by the addition of a NO donor to the blood meal was by apoptosis. We estimate that the concentration of nitrite produced in the midgut by SNAP (the donor used in this experiment) would have been approximately 10 µM. As gametocytes are highly susceptible to the toxic effects of NO and Al-Olayan and co-workers [16] reported signs of apoptosis in the early zygotic stages, midguts containing sporogonic stages clearly need to be examined very shortly after feeding with NO donors to detect the affects in vivo. We did however demonstrate that addition of the NOS-activity inhibitor, L-NAME, to the infective blood meal significantly decreased the proportion of ookinetes expressing two markers of apoptosis and increased the number of parasites that transformed into oocysts in vivo. This is strong supportive evidence that NO/RNS generated within the mosquito are inducing ookinete death by apoptosis within the midgut lumen, although we acknowledge that NOS activity in WBSs in the blood bolus would also have been inhibited.
Sources of reactive oxygen species
Peterson et al. [24] suggest that haem and haematin, released within the mosquito midgut during haemoglobin digestion, could react with iron and oxygen in the blood bolus to form ROS. These toxic metabolites are also produced by the mosquito. Lanz-Mendoza and colleagues [40] found that O•2– is produced naturally in the haemolymph and midgut of An. albimanus and is toxic to ookinetes. Additionally, Kumar and colleagues [43] reported P. berghei-induced expression of peroxidase genes in the midgut of An. stephensi, one of which could produce superoxide anion, lead to the accumulation of high levels of hydrogen peroxide and Molina-Cruz et al [58] have shown that midgut catalase expression is suppressed during midgut traversal and suggest that this leads to high local levels of hydrogen peroxide that contribute to limiting Plasmodium infection. The death of ookinetes in vitro following combined treatments with SNP and L-DOPA was attributed to the toxicity of peroxynitrite which was formed from the combination of NO produced from SNP and •O2– produced from L-DOPA [28]. In vivo, ookinetes are developing in a complex redox-active environment (see [24] for a full discussion) and they are thus likely to be exposed to considerable oxidative stress, to which they are highly vulnerable.
Possible pathways of induction of apoptosis
Following initiation of apoptosis in mammalian cells, two pathways lead to its execution; the intrinsic or mitochondrial dependent pathway and the extrinsic pathway; with considerable cross-talk existing between the two [59]. The former can be initiated by the opening of the inner membrane permeability transition pore or the permeabilization of the outer mitochondrial membrane and release of inter membrane space molecules such as cytochrome c, and Ca+. The latter mechanism is mediated by apoptosis regulators, notably in the Bcl-2 family [60], [61].
A mitochondrial dependent pathway had been observed in several parasitic protozoans For example, in T. cruzi complement activation leads to an influx of Ca+, followed by MOMP loss, increase in oxygen radical production, a decrease in the mitochondrial cytochrome c content and initiation of apoptosis [46]. Although members of the Bcl2 family have not been identified in protozoans, homologues of the mitochondrial nuclease, endonuclease G (EndoG), have been described in yeast, T. brucei, L. donovani and L. infantum [62]–[64]. Additionally a recently described caspase-independent pathway, induced by the presence of a death stimulus, the drug edelfosine, involves the translocation of EndoG straight from the mitochondria of L. infantum to the nucleus. Here it is thought to be involved in DNA degradation [63].
Our findings lend support to the hypothesis that a mitochondrial dependent apoptotic pathway exists in Plasmodium [15], [18], but suggest that this is not likely to be the only signaling pathway. Examination of MOMP in newly developed ookinetes revealed that a similar proportion exhibited a loss of Δ ψm as contained pycnotic nuclei. Treatment to induce MOMP loss was 100% successful and also caused a significant increase in the number of parasites with condensed chromatin but, as with other experiments in this study, ∼20% did not exhibit this marker of apoptosis during the period under investigation. This adds more weight to our suggestion that a small proportion of ookinetes may be protected from apoptosis. In contrast to the effect of CCCP incubation, NO did not cause loss of MOMP, giving rise to the conclusion that nitrosative stress-induced apoptosis must operate via an alternative pathway. The induction of apoptosis via nitrosative stress may be attributed to protein nitrosylation [65]. In particular, cysteine proteases could be NO targets via modification of the Cys catalytic residues by S-nitrosylation [66], thus it is possible that NO is activating an apoptosis pathway in the malaria parasite via protein nitrosylation.
Extrinsic pathways leading to apoptosis may involve the proteolytic activation of a family of clan CD cysteine proteases, the caspases [67]. These appear to be confined to metazoans, and may form a secondary executive pathway that evolved after the symbiosis that led to the formation of the eukaryotic cell type. Furthermore, they are not found in all metazoan taxa and it is becoming increasing clear that apoptotic cell death does not always involve these cysteine proteases [68].
Despite the reported involvement of caspase-like molecules in PCD in a variety of single celled organisms (listed in [10]), no caspase homologues had so far been identified in any of their genomes [69]. However, other clan CD cysteine proteases, the metacaspases, have been described in several protozoan [70]. They appear to play a role in some apoptosis pathways in yeast (reviewed in [71]) and may be involved in PCD in Trypanosomatids, Cryptosporidium parvum and Tetrahymena thermophila [72]–[75]. Although metacaspases have been described in P. falciparum [15] and P. berghei [76] there is, as yet, no evidence that this is the caspase-like molecule that is involved in apoptosis in P. berghei [76] (Arambage and Hurd, unpublished) and clan CA cysteine protease have recently been implicated in programmed cell death in P. falciparum [77]. Indeed, the role that metacaspases play in apoptosis in plants, fungi and protozoans is now being debated; they may have additional or alternative functions [78]–[80] and the identity of the caspase-like molecule(s) associated with apoptosis in P. berghei and many other protozoans still remains to be determined.
Conclusions
The majority of ookinetes that form in the mosquito midgut do not succeed in transforming into viable oocysts. Parasite-killing mechanisms such as lysis and melanization operate once the ookinete has traversed the midgut epithelium and attention to date has largely focused on mosquito immune responses that operate at this time. Unless specific markers for apoptosis are used, the majority of ookinetes present in the midgut lumen appear, by light microscopy, to be viable. We suggest that they are not; many of them are already dying by apoptosis and will never invade the midgut. Furthermore NO, RNS and ROS may play a significant role as refractory mechanisms in the redox-active midgut lumen and provide the first line of defence against P. berghei.
It is still necessary to determine whether apoptotic death of ookinetes is also an important mechanism for limiting natural mosquito-infections of human parasites such as P. falciparum. We have previously shown that P. falciparum ookinetes do undergo apoptosis in the midgut of An. stephensi in the laboratory [18]. However, the importance of NOS activity in inducing apoptosis, and limiting these infections in the field, is still to be determined and conflicting evidence exists as to the response of NOS to natural Plasmodium infections in An. gambiae [81], [82]. If it does prove to be important, we suggest that it may be feasible to enhance the activity of NOS, using transgenic technology, in order to induce apoptosis in most, or all, of the ookinetes before they can traverse the midgut epithelium. We would not anticipate creating undue fitness affects by this strategy because the presence of extra NO, caused by feeding a NO donor with the blood meal, did not affect mosquito longevity, at least at the concentrations of nitrite generated in our experiments (which, in the case of 1 mM SNP is estimated to be approximately 10 µM and thus roughly equivalent to the concentration produced by SNAP that significantly reduced prevalence and intensity of infection). In addition, it may be possible to circumvent some of the loss of reproductive fitness that occurs when mosquito immune responses are up-regulated due to infection if all parasites die very early post-infection and are unable to invade the mosquito midgut [83], [84]. Enhancing the natural apoptotic death of ookinetes in the mosquito midgut lumen could be an important transmission blocking strategy.
Experimental evidence available to date does not supply clues as the evolutionary history or significance of the existence of an apoptosis phenotype in malaria ookinetes. We can speculate that it represents an adaptive, density control strategy that may limit the adverse effects of high infection intensities in the vector and benefit other members of the clone [41]. This could operate via the triggering of mosquito NOS activity in a density dependent way. Equally, density dependent triggers occurring in the mammalian host could be operative in the blood bolus in the midgut lumen. Alternatively, our view of apoptosis in protists may be coloured by knowledge of its functions in metazoans and we may be observing an unavoidable consequence of ookinetes being under oxidative stress or containing defective biochemical pathways and having passed the point of rescue. The latter implying that apoptosis was a mechanism that evolved to be used altruistically in multicellular organisms.
Materials and Methods
Products were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich Company Ltd. (Dorset, England, UK), unless stated otherwise.
Ethics statement
All animals were handled in strict accordance with good animal practice as defined by the UK Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986, and all animal work was approved by the UK Home Office, license number PPL 40/2997, and was also approved by the University of Keele Animal Care and Ethical Review Committee.
Development of ookinetes in vitro
Plasmodium berghei ANKA 2.34 was maintained in Charles River-Derived (CD1) mice by serial passage for a maximum of 8 passages. Mice were pre-treated by interperitoneal injection of phenylhydrazine two days prior to infection and thick and thin blood smears checked for the presence of infected red blood cells and exflagellating gametocytes from day 3 post infection. Blood was collected by cardiac puncture into a heparinized syringe when parasitaemia reached 5–15% and gametocytaemia was approximately 1–2%. Blood was immediately placed in T25 culture flasks and incubated for 16–19 h at 19°C in RPMI 1604 medium, supplemented with 0.4 mM hypozanthine, 24 mM sodium bicarbonate, 10,000 U penicillin and 10 mg streptomycin/l and 10% foetal calf serum (ookinete medium), as described previously [85], to allow the development of ookinetes. In the majority of experiments, ookinetes were separated from blood cells using MidiMacs (Miltenyi Biotec, Germany) magnetic columns [86], pelleted and resuspended in RPMI-1640 medium or Schneider's medium, before being subjected to different assays. For studies of loss of mitochondrial membrane potential, red blood cells were instead lysed by incubation on ice with 170 mM NH4Cl. Ookinetes were pelleted by centrifugation at 800 g for 10 min and ghost red blood cells removed with the supernatant.
Removal of white blood cells from infected blood
To determine the effect of removal of white blood cells (WBCs) from infected blood prior to incubation, blood was collected from infected mice and one half passed through a CF11 column (Whatman, England) [38] to remove WBCs. Infected blood, with or without WBCs was incubated in ookinete culture medium for 16 h at 19°C, and then ookinetes were collected and further incubated in Schneider's insect medium for 0.25, 3 and 6 h before examining for markers of apoptosis.
Assays for markers of apoptosis
Morphological markers for apoptosis were detected using slight adaptations of techniques applicable for metazoans, as described in [18]. Briefly, ookinetes exhibiting nuclear chromatin condensation were detected using acridine orange at a working concentration of 2.5 µg/ml. The nuclei of healthy ookinetes remained unstained whereas nuclei with condensed chromatin stained green and nuclear fragmentation was occasionally visible.
Activated caspases-like molecules that have been associated with PCD in P. berghei ookinetes were detected using the CaspaTag fluorescent caspase activity kit (Chemicon International, USA) as described in [16], [18]. This contains the pancaspase inhibitor carboxyfluorescein -Val-Ala-Asp- fluoromethyl ketone (FAM.VAD.fmk). PI was used to exclude cells with compromised membranes.
Translocation of phosphatidylserine to the outer surface of the cell membrane was detected with annexin-V FITC apoptosis detection kit according to manufacturer's instructions but incubation took place at 19°C. Ookinetes with compromised membranes were detected using PI. Ookinetes labeled with a green band around the plasma membrane and no PI staining were considered positive whereas those with both annexin and PI labeling were discounted because annexin could have penetrated the cell and stained PS that had not translocated. Thus late apoptosis could not be distinguished from death by non-apoptotic means (see [18] for a discussion of annexin staining and signs of early or late apoptosis).
Loss of mitochondrial trans-membrane potential was detected using a MitoProbeTM JC-I assay kit (Molecular probes, UK) according to manufacturer's instructions except that incubation with JC-1 was carried out at 19°C [18]. This kit included the mitochondrial membrane potential disrupter, CCCP, which was used to create loss of MOMP in ookinetes. In appropriate experiments, one group of ookinetes was incubated with CCCP for 30 min prior to examination for MOMP loss.
Fluorochrome markers of apoptosis were detected using a Leica DM IRB inverted fluorescence microscope under oil immersion (x1000) and recorded on Leica FW 4000 image software (Leica Microsystems, Germany).
Viability assays
Cells with compromised membranes were detected by staining with either 0.1% erythrosin-B, which stained cells pink (visible under white light), or 250 µM PI.
The effect of nitric oxide on ookinetes in vitro
In order to determine whether exposure to NO induces the display of markers of apoptosis, ookinetes were incubated with the NO donor SNP following elution from a magnetic column. SNP was added to ookinete medium at different concentrations ranging from 10 µM to 4 mM and ookinetes incubated at 19°C for periods of 15 min to 24 h. Following incubation, ookinetes were checked for signs of condensed chromatin, caspase-like activity, translocation of phosphatidylserine to the outer plasma membrane, loss of mitochondrial membrane potential or loss of plasma membrane integrity. The proportion of ookinetes displaying these markers was compared with those incubated in RPMI or Schneider's medium alone. Investigations were conducted in a similar manner using two other donors, SNOG and SNAP to demonstrate that induction of apoptosis markers could occur with other NO donors.
NO released by NO donors
The Griess reaction [87] was used to make a comparison of the production of NO, in the form of nitrite, by SNP, SNAP and SNOG. Donors were dissolved in supplemented RPMI-1640 (without phenol red) at concentrations ranging from 10 µM to 4 mM and incubated at 19°C for various periods up to 24 h. Nitrite production was determined using a standard curve made from serial dilution of sodium nitrite (range 200–3.125 µM).
The effect of reactive oxygen species (ROS) on ookinetes in vitro
Two sources were used to provide reactive oxygen species in the RPMI incubation medium; 3, 4-dihydroxy-L-phenylalanin (L-DOPA) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) at different concentrations ranging from 10 µM to 1 mM. Ookinetes were incubated at 19°C with or without these compounds for 1 h or 4 h and markers for apoptosis-like cell death monitored.
The effect of nitric oxide synthase activity on ookinetes in vivo
Three to six day-old female An. stephensi (Dubai) were starved overnight before blood feeding. Three groups of females were fed gametocytaemic mouse blood via an artificial membrane feeder (Haemotek Membrane Feeding System). The NOS inhibitor, L-NAME (1 mg/ml) was added to the blood in one feeder, 1 mg/ml of D-NAME, the inactive isomer, to the second feeder and gametocytaemic mouse blood alone was added to the third feeder, as a control. Fully engorged mosquitoes were separated and transferred to cages supplied with 10% glucose solution and maintained at 19–20°C. Midguts from five mosquitoes per group were dissected at 18 h and 20 h post-feeding, the contents stained with an equal volume of acridine orange (25 µg/ml PBS) and immediately observed using fluorescein filters. The percentage of ookinetes with condensed chromatin per midgut was determined in each of 3 experiments and 200 parasites were counted each time. In a further experiment that followed the same protocol, five mosquitoes from each treatment group were dissected at 15, and 20 h post-feeding and 200 ookinetes in the blood meal of each mosquito were examined for caspase-like activity using CaspaTagTM a fluorescein caspase activity kit (Intergen Company) according to manufacturers instructions, except that incubations were performed at 19–20°C. The proportion of ookinetes that had a compromised membrane was monitored by observing PI penetration.
This protocol was repeated with another generation of mosquitoes except that 50 infected mosquitoes were maintained for twelve days post-infection. A record was kept of the number of mosquitoes dying during the experiment. The remaining mosquitoes from each group were dissected, their guts stained with 0.05% mercurichrome to enhance oocyst visualization and the number of oocysts per midgut counted.
The effect of nitric oxide donors on mosquito fitness
To determine the effect on mosquito longevity of the presence of additional NO in a mosquito midgut during blood feeding, mosquitoes were fed on P. berghei -infected blood through an artificial membrane feeder. Three to six day-old mosquitoes from the same generation were either fed on blood from a gametocytaemic mouse containing 100 µM SNP or the infected blood alone. The experimental protocol was repeated with a new generation of mosquitoes, this time with the addition of 1 mM SNP to blood in one of the membrane feeders. Mosquitoes were maintained in standard conditions in the insectary and fed ad libitum on 10% glucose supplemented with 0.05% para-aminobenzoic acid, and antibiotics (10000 U penicillin and 7 mg streptomycin/l) and deaths recorded daily.
The effect of nitric oxide donors on Plasmodium development in vivo
Mosquitoes were fed via an artificial membrane feeder on blood from a gametocytaemic mouse with or without the addition of SNAP at a final concentration of 100 µM. Mosquitoes were dissected 16–18 h post-blood meal and the number of ookinetes in the midgut lumen, diluted 1∶4 with PBS, was counted. This experiment was repeated five times and the prevalence and intensity of ookinete infection in the NO donor-treated and untreated mosquitoes was compared.
Statistical analysis
Data were analysed using two-way ANOVA with a general linear model for two parameters, or one-way ANOVA for one parameter. Data were tested for normality using Shapiro-Wilks' W or Anderson-Darling normality tests and, where necessary, percentage data were first transformed using arcsine transformation before being submitted to analysis. Follow-up Tukey's paired comparison tests were run when significant differences were identified by ANOVA. Following log transformation of data, a t-test was used to compare means of ookinete prevalence and intensity in mosquitoes fed a blood meal with or without a NO donor. Kaplan-Meier analysis was used to analyse mosquito survivorship. An alpha value was set at 0.05 for all analyses. Analyses were performed using a Minitab 13.1 or Statistica' 99 Edition Package, version 5.5 for Windows (StatSoft Inc., Tulsa: OK, USA).
Supporting Information
Figure S1.
The effect of removal of WBCs from gametocytaemic blood culture on ookinete apoptosis at 0.25, 3 and 6h post collection. Ookinetes showing chromatin condensation were identified by staining with acridine orange. These data represent a mean of three experiments (n = 3) each with two replicates of counts and each count = 50 ookinetes. Error bars represent SEM. Bars with different letters are significantly different.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0012634.s001
(0.08 MB TIF)
Figure S2.
The effect of NO donors on the induction of apoptosis-like death in P. berghei ookinetes. Ookinetes were incubated in RPMI with or without the addition of NO donors at different concentrations or for different time periods and then examined for the presence of markers of apoptosis A: The effect of 2mM SNOG on ookinetes, n = 5 with 100–200 ookinetes examined in each experiment. B: The effect of different concentration of SNAP on ookinetes incubated for 1h; n = 3, 75 ookinetes were examined in each experiment. Apoptosis markers examined were condensed nuclear chromatin (A), activated caspase-like molecules (B). Error bars represent standard error of the mean (SEM). Bars with different letters are significantly different. Empty bars represent controls and patterned bars represent treated ookinetes.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0012634.s002
(0.19 MB TIF)
Figure S3.
Nitrite production by NO donors. The production of nitrite by different concentrations of SNOG (A), SNP (B) and SNAP (C) at different time points after dissolving the nitric oxide donors in RPMI-1640 without phenol red, supplemented as outlined in the text (ookinete medium). Measurements were made using the Griess reaction. Error bars represent SEM of 2 replicates.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0012634.s003
(0.19 MB TIF)
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to Ann Underhill for technical support, Tony Polwart for help with statistical analysis, and to Gwyn Williams and Anne Loweth for advice and comments.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: MA EMAO HH. Performed the experiments: MA EMAO SL HM. Analyzed the data: MA EMAO SL HM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: HH. Wrote the paper: MA HH.
References
- 1. Ameisen JC (2002) On the origin, evolution, and nature of programmed cell death: a timeline of four billion years. Cell Death Differ 9: 367–393.
- 2. Ameisen JC (2004) Looking for death at the core of life in the light of evolution. Cell Death Differ 11: 4–10.
- 3.
Fuertes AM, Nguewa PA, Castilla J, Alonso C, Perez Martin JM (2008) Programmed Cell Death in Protozoa: An Evolutionary Point of View. The Example of Kinetoplastid Parasites. In: J.M PM, editor. Programmed Cell death in Protozoa. New York: Landes Bioscience and Springer Science+Business Media LCC. pp. 1–6.
- 4. Koonin EV, Aravind L (2002) Origin and evolution of eukaryotic apoptosis: the bacterial connection. Cell Death Differ 9: 394–404.
- 5. Galluzzi L, Joza N, Tasdemir E, Maiuri MC, Hengartner M, et al. (2008) No death without life: vital functions of apoptotic effectors. Cell Death Differ 15: 1113–1123.
- 6. Kerr JF, Wyllie AH, Currie AR (1972) Apoptosis: a basic biological phenomenon with wide-ranging implications in tissue kinetics. Br J Cancer 26: 239–257.
- 7. Clarke PGH (1990) Developmental Cell-Death - Morphological Diversity and Multiple Mechanisms. Anat Embryol 181: 195–213.
- 8. Galluzzi L, Maiuri MC, Vitale I, Zischka H, Castedo M, et al. (2007) Cell death modalities: classification and pathophysiological implications. Cell Death Differ 14: 1237–1243.
- 9. Kroemer G, Galluzzi L, Vandenabeele P, Abrams J, Alnemri ES, et al. (2009) Classification of cell death: recommendations of the Nomenclature Committee on Cell Death 2009. Cell Death Differ 16: 3–11.
- 10. Deponte M (2008) Programmed cell death in protists. BBA-Mol Cell Res 1783: 1396–1405.
- 11. Duszenko M, Figarella K, Macleod ET, Welburn SC (2006) Death of a trypanosome: a selfish altruism. Trends Parasitol 22: 536–542.
- 12. Debrabant A, Lee N, Bertholet S, Duncan R, Nakhasi HL (2003) Programmed cell death in trypanosomatids and other unicellular organisms. Int J Parasitol 33: 257–267.
- 13. Bruchhaus I, Roeder T, Rennenberg A, Heussler VT (2007) Protozoan parasites: programmed cell death as a mechanism of parasitism. Trends Parasitol 23: 376–383.
- 14. Picot S, Burnod J, Bracchi V, Chumpitazi BF, Ambroise-Thomas P (1997) Apoptosis related to chloroquine sensitivity of the human malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 91: 590–591.
- 15. Meslin B, Barnadas C, Boni V, Latour C, Monbrison FD, et al. (2007) Features of apoptosis in Plasmodium falciparum erythrocytic stage through a putative role of PfMCA1 metacaspase-like protein. J Infect Dis 195: 1852–1859.
- 16. Al-Olayan EM, Williams GT, Hurd H (2002) Apoptosis in the malaria protozoan, Plasmodium berghei: a possible mechanism for limiting intensity of infection in the mosquito. Int J Parasitol 32: 1133–1143.
- 17.
Baton LA, Warr E, Hoffmann SA, Dimopoulos G (2008) Programmmed Cell Death during malaria Parasite Infection of the Vertebrate and Mosquito Vector. In: Perez Martin JMP, editor. Programed Cell Death in Protozoa. New York: Landes Bioscience and Springer Science+Buisness Media. pp. 75–90.
- 18. Arambage SC, Grant KM, Pardo I, Ranford-Cartwright L, Hurd H (2009) Malaria ookinetes exhibit multiple markers for apoptosis-like programmed cell death in vitro. Parasites Vectors 2:
- 19. Vaughan JA (2007) Population dynamics of Plasmodium sporogony. Trends Parasitol 23: 63–70.
- 20. Welburn SC, Barcinski MA, Williams GT (1997) Programmed cell death in trypanosomatids. Parasitol Today 13: 22–26.
- 21. Debrabant A, Nakhasi H (2003) Programmed cell death in trypanosomatids: is it an altruistic mechanism for survival of the fittest? Kinetoplastid Biol Dis 2: 7.
- 22. Nguewa PA, Fuertes MA, Valladares B, Alonso C, Perez JM (2004) Programmed cell death in trypanosomatids: a way to maximize their biological fitness? Trends Parasitol 20: 375–380.
- 23. Getti GT, Cheke RA, Humber DP (2008) Induction of apoptosis in host cells: a survival mechanism for Leishmania parasites? Parasitology 135: 1391–1399.
- 24. Peterson TM, Gow AJ, Luckhart S (2007) Nitric oxide metabolites induced in Anopheles stephensi control malaria parasite infection. Free Radic Biol Med 42: 132–142.
- 25. Dimopoulos G, Seeley D, Wolf A, Kafatos FC (1998) Malaria infection of the mosquito Anopheles gambiae activates immune-responsive genes during critical transition stages of the parasite life cycle. Embo J 17: 6115–6123.
- 26. Luckhart S, Vodovotz Y, Cui L, Rosenberg R (1998) The mosquito Anopheles stephensi limits malaria parasite development with inducible synthesis of nitric oxide. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 95: 5700–5705.
- 27. Crampton A, Luckhart S (2001) The role of As60A, a TGF-beta homolog, in Anopheles stephensi innate immunity and defense against Plasmodium infection. Infect Genet Evol 1: 131–141.
- 28. Herrera-Ortiz A, Lanz-Mendoza H, Martinez-Barnetche J, Hernandez-Martinez S, Villarreal-Trevino C, et al. (2004) Plasmodium berghei ookinetes induce nitric oxide production in Anopheles pseudopunctipennis midguts cultured in vitro. Insect Biochem Mol Biol 34: 893–901.
- 29. Han YS, Thompson J, Kafatos FC, Barillas-Mury C (2000) Molecular interactions between Anopheles stephensi midgut cells and Plasmodium berghei: the time bomb theory of ookinete invasion of mosquitoes. Embo J 19: 6030–6040.
- 30. Zieler H, Dvorak JA (2000) Invasion in vitro of mosquito midgut cells by the malaria parasite proceeds by a conserved mechanism and results in death of the invaded midgut cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 97: 11516–11521.
- 31. Nathan C (1995) Natural-resistance and nitroc oxide Cell 82: 873–876.
- 32. Rivero A (2006) Nitric oxide: an antiparasitic molecule of invertebrates. Trends Parasitol 22: 219–225.
- 33. Balmer P, Phillips HM, Maestre AE, McMonagle FA, Phillips RS (2000) The effect of nitric oxide on the growth of Plasmodium falciparum, P. chabaudi and P. berghei in vitro. Parasite Immunol 22: 97–106.
- 34. Taylor-Robinson AW, Looker M (1998) Sensitivity of malaria parasites to nitric oxide at low oxygen tensions. Lancet 351: 1630.
- 35. Mellouk S, Hoffman SL, Liu ZZ, Delavega P, Billiar TR, et al. (1994) Nitric oxide-mediated antiplasmodial activity in human and murine hepatocytes induced by gamma-interferon and the parasite itself -enhancement by exogneous tetrahydrobiopterin. Infect Immun 62: 4043–4046.
- 36. Rockett KA, Awburn MM, Cowden WB, Clark IA (1991) Killing of Plasmodium falciparum in vitro by nitric oxide derivatives. Infect Immun 59: 3280–3283.
- 37. Sobolewski P, Gramaglia I, Frangos J, Intaglietta M, van der Heyde HC (2005) Nitric oxide bioavailability in malaria. Trends Parasitol 21: 415–422.
- 38. Cao Y-M, Tsuboi T, Liu Y-J, Torii M (1998) Infected host serum blocks transmission of Plasmodium yoelii via a nitric oxide-dependent mechanism. Parasitol Int 47: 225–232.
- 39. Naotunne TS, Karunaweera ND, Mendis KN, Carter R (1993) Cytokine-mediated inactivation of malarial gametocytes is dependent on the presence of white blood cells and involves reactive nitrogen intermediates. Immunology 78: 555–562.
- 40. Lanz-Mendoza H, Hernandez-Martinez S, Ku-Lopez M, Rodriguez Mdel C, Herrera-Ortiz A, et al. (2002) Superoxide anion in Anopheles albimanus hemolymph and midgut is toxic to Plasmodium berghei ookinetes. J Parasitol 88: 702–706.
- 41. Luckhart S, Crampton AL, Zamora R, Lieber MJ, Dos Santos PC, et al. (2003) Mammalian transforming growth factor beta 1 activated after ingestion by Anopheles stephensi modulates mosquito immunity. Infect Immun 71: 3000–3009.
- 42. Harada M, Owhashi M, Suguri S, Kumatori A, Nakamura M, et al. (2001) Superoxide-dependent and -independent pathways are involved in the transmission blocking of malaria. Parasitol Res 87: 605–608.
- 43. Kumar S, Gupta L, Han YS, Barillas-Mury C (2004) Inducible peroxidases mediate nitration of anopheles midgut cells undergoing apoptosis in response to Plasmodium invasion. J Biol Chem 279: 53475–53482.
- 44. Kim KM, Kim PK, Kwon YG, Bai SK, Nam WD, et al. (2002) Regulation of apoptosis by nitrosative stress. J Biochem Mol Biol 35: 127–133.
- 45. Peng BW, Lin J, Lin JY, Jiang MS, Zhang T (2003) Exogenous nitric oxide induces apoptosis in Toxoplasma gondii tachyzoites via a calcium signal transduction pathway. Parasitology 126: 541–550.
- 46. Piacenza L, Irigoin F, Alvarez MN, Peluffo G, Taylor MC, et al. (2007) Mitochondrial superoxide radicals mediate programmed cell death in Trypanosoma cruzi: cytoprotective action of mitochondrial iron superoxide dismutase overexpression. Biochem J 403: 323–334.
- 47. Holzmuller P, Bras-Goncalves R, Lemesre JL (2006) Phenotypical characteristics, biochemical pathways, molecular targets and putative role of nitric oxide-mediated programmed cell death in Leishmania. Parasitology 132: SupplS19–32.
- 48. Figarella K, Uzcategui NL, Beck A, Schoenfeld C, Kubata BK, et al. (2006) Prostaglandin-induced programmed cell death in Trypanosoma brucei involves oxidative stress. Cell Death Differ 13: 1802–1814.
- 49. Das R, Roy A, Dutta N, Majumder HK (2008) Reactive oxygen species and imbalance of calcium homeostasis contributes to curcumin induced programmed cell death in Leishmania donovani. Apoptosis 13: 867–882.
- 50. Mariante RM, Guimaraes CA, Linden R, Benchimol M (2003) Hydrogen peroxide induces caspase activation and programmed cell death in the amitochondrial Tritrichomonas foetus. Histochem Cell Biol 120: 129–141.
- 51. Ding AH, Nathan CF, Stuehr D (1988) Release of reactive nitrogen intermediates and reactive oxygen intermediates form mouse peritoneal macrophages. J Immunol 141: 2407–2412.
- 52. Jaramillo M, Gowda DC, Radzioch D, Olivier M (2003) Hemozoin increases IFN-gamma-Inducible macrophage nitric oxide generation through extracellular signal-regulated kinase- and NF-kappa B-dependent pathways. J Immunol 171: 4243–4253.
- 53. Skorokhod OA, Schwarzer E, Ceretto M, Arese P (2007) Malarial pigment haemozoin, IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, IL-1beta and LPS do not stimulate expression of inducible nitric oxide synthase and production of nitric oxide in immuno-purified human monocytes. Malaria J 6:
- 54. Lensen AH, Bolmer-Van de Vegte M, van Gemert GJ, Eling WM, Sauerwein RW (1997) Leukocytes in a Plasmodium falciparum-infected blood meal reduce transmission of malaria to Anopheles mosquitoes. Infect Immun 65: 3834–3837.
- 55. Bai P, Bakondi E, Szabo E, Gergely P, Szabo C, et al. (2001) Partial protection by poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors from nitroxyl-induced cytotoxity in thymocytes. Free Radic Biol Med 31: 1616–1623.
- 56. Lim J, Gowda DC, Krishnegowda G, Luckhart S (2005) Induction of nitric oxide synthase in Anopheles stephensi by Plasmodium falciparum: mechanism of signaling and the role of parasite glycosylphosphatidylinositols. Infect Immun 73: 2778–2789.
- 57. Akman-Anderson L, Olivier M, Luckhart S (2007) Induction of nitric oxide synthase and activation of signaling proteins in Anopheles mosquitoes by the malaria pigment, hemozoin. Infect Immun 75: 4012–4019.
- 58. Molina-Cruz A, Dejong RJ, Charles B, Gupta L, Kumar S, et al. (2008) Reactive oxygen species modulate Anopheles gambiae immunity against bacteria and plasmodium. J Biol Chem 283: 3217–3223.
- 59. Vaux DL, Strasser A (1996) The molecular biology of apoptosis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93: 2239–2244.
- 60. Bras M, Queenan B, Susin SA (2005) Programmed cell death via mitochondria: different modes of dying. Biochemistry (Mosc) 70: 231–239.
- 61. Green DR, Kroemer G (2004) The pathophysiology of mitochondrial cell death. Science 305: 626–629.
- 62. Gannavaram S, Vedvyas C, Debrabant A (2008) Conservation of the pro-apoptotic nuclease activity of endonuclease G in unicellular trypanosomatid parasites. J Cell Sci 121: 99–109.
- 63. Rico E, Alzate JF, Arias AA, Moreno D, Clos J, et al. (2009) Leishmania infantum expresses a mitochondrial nuclease homologous to EndoG that migrates to the nucleus in response to an apoptotic stimulus. Mol Biochem Parasitol 163: 28–38.
- 64. Buttner S, Eisenberg T, Carmona-Gutierrez D, Ruli D, Knauer H, et al. (2007) Endonuclease g regulates budding yeast life and death. Mol Cell 25: 233–246.
- 65. Eu JP, Liu LM, Zeng M, Stamler JS (2000) An apoptotic model for nitrosative stress. Biochemistry 39: 1040–1047.
- 66. Colasanti M, Salvati L, Ascenzi P, Gradoni L (2001) Cysteine protease as a target for nitric oxide in parasitic organisms. Trends Parasitol 17: 575–575.
- 67. Hengartner MO (2000) The biochemistry of apoptosis. Nature 407: 770–776.
- 68. Borner C, Monney L (1999) Apoptosis without caspases: an inefficient molecular guillotine? Cell Death Differ 6: 497–507.
- 69. Aravind L, Dixit VM, Koonin EV (2001) Apoptotic molecular machinery: vastly increased complexity in vertebrates revealed by genome comparisons. Science 291: 1279–1284.
- 70. Uren AG, O'Rourke K, Aravind L, Pisabarro MT, Seshagiri S, et al. (2000) Identification of paracaspases and metacaspases: two ancient families of caspase-like proteins, one of which plays a key role in MALT lymphoma. Mol Cell 6: 961–967.
- 71. Madeo F, Carmona-Gutierrez D, Ring J, Buettner S, Eisenberg T, et al. (2009) Caspase-dependent and caspase-independent cell death pathways in yeast. Bioch Bioph Res Co 382: 227–231.
- 72. Kosec G, Alvarez VE, Aguero F, Sanchez D, Dolinar M, et al. (2006) Metacaspases of Trypanosoma cruzi: Possible candidates for programmed cell death mediators. Mol Biochem Parasitol 145: 18–28.
- 73. Lee N, Gannavaram S, Selvapandiyan A, Debrabant A (2007) Characterization of metacaspases with trypsin-like activity and their putative role in programmed cell death in the protozoan parasite Leishmania. Eukaryot Cell 6: 1745–1757.
- 74. Ojcius DM, Perfettini JL, Bonnin A, Laurent F (1999) Caspase-dependent apoptosis during infection with Cryptosporidium parvum. Microbes Infect 1: 1163–1168.
- 75. Kobayashi T, Endoh H (2003) Caspase-like activity in programmed nuclear death during conjugation of Tetrahymena thermophila. Cell Death Differ 10: 634–640.
- 76. Le Chat L, Sinden RE, Dessens JT (2007) The role of metacaspase 1 in Plasmodium berghei development and apoptosis. Mol Biochem Parasitol 153: 41–47.
- 77. Ch'ng J-H, Kotturi SR, Chong A-L, Tan K-W (2010) A programmed cell death pathway in the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum has general features of mammalian apoptosis but is mediated by clan CA cysteine proteases. Cell Death and Disease 1:
- 78. Vercammen D, Declercq W, Vandenabeele P, Van Breusegem F (2007) Are metacaspases caspases? J Cell Biol 179: 375–380.
- 79. Ambit A, Fasel N, Coombs GH, Mottram JC (2008) An essential role for the Leishmania major metacaspase in cell cycle progression. Cell Death Differ 15: 113–122.
- 80. Algeciras-Schimnich A, Barnhart BC, Peter ME (2002) Apoptosis-independent functions of killer caspases. Curr Opin Cell Biol 14: 721–726.
- 81. Tahar R, Boudin C, Thiery I, Bourgouin C (2002) Immune response of Anopheles gambiae to the early sporogonic stages of the human malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Embo J 21: 6673–6680.
- 82. Luckhart S, Li KY, Dunton R, Lewis EE, Crampton AL, et al. (2003) Anopheles gambiae immune gene variants associated with natural Plasmodium infection. Mol Biochem Parasitol 128: 83–86.
- 83. Ahmed AM, Hurd H (2006) Immune stimulation and malaria infection impose reproductive costs in Anopheles gambiae via follicular apoptosis. Microbes Infect 8: 308–315.
- 84. Marrelli MT, Li C, Rasgon JL, Jacobs-Lorena M (2007) Transgenic malaria-resistant mosquitoes have a fitness advantage when feeding on Plasmodium-infected blood. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 5580–5583.
- 85. Carter V, Nacer AM, Underhill A, Sinden RE, Hurd H (2007) Minimum requirements for ookinete to oocyst transformation in Plasmodium. Int J Parasitol 37: 1221–1232.
- 86. Carter V, Cable HC, Underhill BA, Williams J, Hurd H (2003) Isolation of Plasmodium berghei ookinetes in culture using Nycodenz density gradient columns and magnetic isolation. Malar J 2: 35.
- 87. Tsikas D (2007) Analysis of nitrite and nitrate in biological fluids by assays based on the Griess reaction: Appraisal of the Griess reaction in the L-arginine/nitric oxide area of research. Journal of Chromatography B-Analytical Technologies in the Biomedical and Life Sciences 851: 51–70.