The Effect of Spiritual Care on Depression in Patients Following Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

The aim of this study was to determine the effect of a nurse-delivered spiritual care intervention on depression following coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery. A semi-experimental study was performed in Baqiyatallah al-Azam Military Hospital of Tehran, Iran in 2013. Sixty-eight patients undergoing coronary artery grafts were purposefully selected and randomly assigned into the intervention (n = 34) and control (usual care) groups (n = 34). The intervention group received five sessions of spiritual care lasting between 45–60 minutes using the approach of Bergin Richards (2005). The control group received only routine standard care. The mean depression scores were measured using the depression subscale of the Depression Anxiety Stress Scale (DASS-21). At baseline (p = 0.051), there were no differences in the mean depression scores. Post intervention, statistically significant differences were observed in the mean depression scores between groups (p < 0.001). The results showed that the use of spiritual care can decrease depression in the intervention group. These findings suggested that nurses could use spiritual care to improve psychological care.

1. Introduction

Coronary artery bypass surgery is among the most common surgical procedures performed in the United States of America, amounting to more than 515,000 per year. (Gallagher and MicKinley 2009) Although this procedure markedly improves morbidity and mortality (Eisenberg et al. 2005), many patients experience psychological distress postoperatively (Duits et al. 2002). Depression and coronary artery disease are highly comorbid conditions with estimates of comorbidity from 14% to 47% (Simha Ravven et al. 2013). Almost one in every five patients experience major depressive symptoms or at least a mild form of depression according to the DSM-IV criteria, periodically during recovery after open-heart surgery (Freedland et al. 2009). Postoperative depression impaired physical–mental recovery; it also delayed wound healing and wound infection (Doering et al. 2005), and adverse cardiovascular events challenged recovery (Rafanelli et al. 2006). Depressive symptoms reduce the individual’s capacity to control their diet, engage in physical activity, visit a doctor regularly, and adhere to other standards of treatment (Vural et al. 2008). Many studies have shown that depression increases the risk of myocardial infarction, has a negative impact on participation in rehabilitation programs (Stafford et al. 2007), increases morbidity, mortality, and hospital admissions (Holzapfel et al. 2009; Carney and Freedland 2008), decreases the efficacy of self-care behaviors, and raises health care costs and burden (Rutledge et al. 2009).

The World Health Organization stated that health has four dimensions: physical, mental, social, and spiritual. Addressing each of these dimensions is an important consideration for nurses, and it helps patients cope and adjust to illness and find meaning in their life (Karimollahi et al. 2008). Nurses should be committed to the concept of holistic care and pay attention to the physical, psychological, emotional, social, and spiritual aspects of patients’ care needs (Adib-Hajbaghery and Saeadnejad 2016). One component of a healthy life is paying attention to the individual’s spiritual needs (azhdarifard, ghazi, and nouranipour 2010). Spiritual care is defined as “actions to meet the spiritual needs of the patient and family” (Melhem et al. 2016). Spiritual care has negative correlations with stress, anxiety, depression, aggression, and obsession in both patients and caregivers (Hosseini et al. 2013). Spiritual care is an important consideration for nursing care (Ross 2006). Nurses provide spiritual care to meet the spiritual needs of the patients and their family, in an attempt to improve the quality of life during the course of the patient’s disease (Melhem et al. 2016). Between 1984–2005, studies on spiritual therapy showed positive benefits in persons with mental health problems such as eating disorders, stress, anxiety, and depression (Smith et al. 2007). Whelan-Gales et al. (2009) investigated the relationship between spiritual health and spiritual care with depressive symptoms among 24 patients with acute heart failure, and demonstrated an inverse relationship between spiritual care and depression (Whelan-Gales et al. 2009). In their study, Braxton et al. (2007) evaluated the relationship between spirituality and depression, and determined that spirituality improved mental health (Braxton et al. 2007). Koenig (2007) showed that frequent religious activities such as worship, prayer, Bible reading, and a high intrinsic religiosity improved the remission of depression (Koenig 2007). In a study conducted in the United Kingdom by McCoubrie and Davies, it was observed that there was an inverse correlation between spirituality and anxiety and depression (McCoubrie and Davies 2006). Oxman et al. found that a lack of religious belief is a risk factor for postoperative mortality in cardiac patients (Oxman et al. 1995). As a coping strategy, religion can have a positive effect in helping individuals cope (Rippentrop et al. 2005).

In an integrative review article in Iran, Hosseini et al. (2013) reported that spirituality plays an important role in the way people live and die. The majority of studies on spiritual and religious interventions in Iran’s health care system have focused on patients’ needs toward spiritual care and health professionals’ spiritual approaches, as well as factors that influence their spirituality. In addition, this review demonstrated the positive correlation among spiritual care and hope, well-being, quality of life, coping, job satisfaction, happiness, and mental health. Moreover, there was a negative correlation between spiritual care and depression, anxiety, stress, aggression, and obsession (Hosseini et al. 2013).

Hosseini’s study indicated a positive impact of spiritual care on reducing anxiety and depression, coping with illness, and enhancing hope (Hosseini et al. 2013). To the best of the authors’ knowledge, there are limited data on the impact of spiritual care on depression in patients undergoing coronary artery bypass graft (CABG). The aim of this study was to examine the effect of spiritual care on patients’ depression after coronary bypass surgery, using a culturally appropriate intervention.

2. Methods

2.1. Design

A randomized controlled trial was conducted to compare two groups: intervention and control before and after spiritual care. This study was performed from September 2013 to March 2014 in the Baqiyatallah hospital rehabilitation center in Tehran, Iran. The study population consisted of patients who participated in a cardiac rehabilitation program following CABG surgery. Based on prior studies, with 97% confidence level, a test power (1 − β) of 0.9, the mean difference (d) of 6.5, and an anxiety variance of s₂ = 11.7, data were calculated for 68 persons: (n1 = n2 = {2 [Z (1 − a/2 ) + Z(1 − β) ]2 s2}/d2). (Hosseini et al. 2013) Participants scheduled for coronary artery bypass graft were recruited considering the following inclusion criteria: (a) ability to communicate with the researcher effectively during the initial interview; (b) willingness to participate in the research; (c) ability to handle meetings and spiritual interventions; (d) physical and mental fitness to answer the questions; (e) sufficient reading and writing ability; (f) ability to speak Persian language; and (g) either Muslim and Shia. The following patients were excluded: (a) inability to participate in cardiac rehabilitation; and (b) patients who had severe depression or a history of other psychological disorders (based on the last medical records). A statistician generated a randomly assigned schedule. All 68 patients were selected based on the inclusion criteria, and were then randomly assigned to intervention (n = 34) and control (n = 34) groups by simple random sampling, based on a table of random numbers (Figure 1). After obtaining consent for inclusion, participants in the intervention groups, in addition to the routine care, received spiritual care based on Richards and Bergin’s model, which focuses on the Islamic religion for five sessions by a researcher under the supervision of a clergy. Each session lasted for between 45 minutes and one hour. The following spiritual–religious strategies were proposed: (1) reading a sacred religious book (The Holy Quran); (2) prayer; (3) expression of a religious patterns story; (4) participating in religious–spiritual programs; (5) repentance and forgiveness; and (6) intellectual analysis of ethical values. The control group only received routine nursing care, which included physical care and emotional reassurance as part of the postoperative routine care. Participants and outcome assessors were aware of the treatment assignments. Consequently, upon the instruction of the ethics committee after testing, researchers presented some spiritual care for patients in the control group (after surgery), and a condensed version of the intervention was provided post intervention, including the provision of a CD containing all of the education materials.

2.2. Instrument and Data Analysis

The researchers used the demographic information inventory, which was aimed at collecting the patients’ demographic characteristics (age, gender, marital status, employment, education, history of hospitalization, history of mental illness, surgery, previous teaching experience about spiritual care), and Depression Anxiety Stress Scale (DASS-21) for measuring patients’ depression levels. The DASS consists of 21 items in three subscales: seven for anxiety, seven for depression, and seven for stress; it is ranked as: Normal = 0–9, Mild = 10–13, Moderate = 14–20, Severe = 21–27, Extremely Severe = 28+. The minimum score of any questions is zero, and the maximum score is three. Several studies conducted in Iran have confirmed the validity of this Persian type of DASS tool. Hanifi et al. confirmed the reliability of this tool: anxiety Cronbach’s alpha = 0.95, stress alpha = 0.89, and depression alpha = 0.99 (Hanifi et al. 2012), based on the total sample. Jamshidi et al.’s study demonstrated the overall reliability of the questionnaire, with a Cronbach’s alpha coefficient of 93% (Jamshidi et al. 2012). In another study, the reliability of this scale in a sample population of 400 people was reported as follows: depression (0.70), anxiety (0.66), and stress (0.76) (Sahebi et al. 2005). For data analysis, SPSS software version 20, and the Chi-square test was used to check the consistency of demographic groups with regard to spiritual care, and an independent t-test was used to compare the mean of the depression subscale score before and after spiritual care between the intervention and control groups. Prior to their participation in the study, the patients completed the informed consent form. Research permission was obtained from the ethical committee of the University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences (30 March 2013-No, 92/801/2/8400). In addition, studies were approved by the Iranian Registry of Clinical Trials (2014; Registration ID: IRCT2014112420072N1).

3. Results

As illustrated in

Table 1. Distribution of demographic variables of participants.

p-Value	Intervention		Control		Groups	Variables
	%	Count	%	Count
0/307	48/4	15	61/3	19	Male	Gender
	51/6	16	38/7	12	Female
	6/5	2	12/9	4	Illiterate	Education
0/233	35/5	11	32/3	10	Elementary
	22/6	7	38/7	12	Junior high school
	35/5	11	16/1	5	High school
	93/5	29	80/6	25	Parents	Tutelage
0/130	6/5	2	19/4	6	Care center
	41/9	13	45/2	14	ALL *	Cancer type
0/851	16/1	5	19/4	6	CLL *
	29	9	29	9	AML *
	12/9	4	6/5	2	CML *
	9/7	3	12/9	4	Yes	History of psychological disorders
1/000	90/3	28	87/1	27	No
0/508	14/5/(2/02)		15 (2/86)		Age
0/871	28 (12)		30 (16)		Hospitalization period (days)
0/622	5/9(3/65)		6/38(4/03)		Number of chemotherapies

* Acute lymphocytic leukemia (ALL) * Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) * Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) * Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL).

, participants’ demographic conditions showed that both groups were matched before the study. Overall, 55% of participants had a one-time hospitalization history, and 32% had a history of one-time surgery.

There was no significant difference between the two groups before the study, and both groups were matched.

Table 2. Comparison of pain and depression in pre-test between intervention and control groups.

p-Value	t	SD	Mean	Group
0/606	-0/519	13/99	58/93	Intervention	Pain
		7/59	57/45	Control
0/331	-0/980	6/89	36/16	Intervention	Depression
		10/16	34/00	control

shows that there was a significant within-group difference regarding the mean scores for depression and pain before and after intervention in each group (p < 0.05). The present study focused on depression; there was no significance between-group differences before the study, and both groups were matched in depression scores.

At baseline, there were no significant differences.

Table 3. Comparison of pain and depression in post-test between intervention and control groups.

P **	P *	Mean ± SD	Group
0/001	<0/001	58/9±13/99	Before	Intervention	Pain
		32/7±6/58	After
	0/126	57/4±4/59	Before	Control
		53/29±13/25	After
<0/001	<0/001	34/10±0/16	Before	Intervention	Depression
		30/09±10/46	After
	0/221	36/16±6/89	Before	Control
		18/19±9/31	After

* paired t-test; ** ANCOVA test.

presents, according to the probability value obtained based on the independent t-test, that there were no between-group differences in mean depression scores in the intervention and control groups before intervention. Whereas, after intervention, there were significant between-group differences (p < 0.001).

Table 3 shows that according to the probability value obtained by a paired t-test, the average depression before and after the intervention in the intervention group was significantly different (p < 0.001). However, there was no significant difference in the control group.

Table 4. Effect size of post-intervention difference between intervention and control groups.

Effect size	Mean ± SD	Group
−3.12	32/7± 6/58		Intervention	Pain
	53/29± 13/25		Control
−1.13	30/09 ± 10/46		Intervention	Depression
	18/19 ±9/31		Control

presents the effect size of pain and depression calculated after intervention in the intervention and control groups.

4. Discussion

This study determined the effect of spiritual care on depression after coronary artery bypass surgery. The results showed that the mean depression score had a significant difference between the intervention and control groups after spiritual care (p < 0.001). This finding is consistent with the results of other researchers.

Nabolsi and Carson (2011) found that patients’ faith and spiritual beliefs may facilitate and enhance patients’ acceptance and coping with illness, strengthen their inner strength, hope, acceptance, and self-care, and would help them understand that life has meaning (Nabolsi and Carson 2011). Beckelman et al. studied people with heart disease between 2004–2005, and indicated that spiritual well-being is inversely associated with depression (Bekelman et al. 2007). Bussing demonstrated the role of spiritual beliefs in reducing depression, pain and social isolation, and increasing life satisfaction (Büssing et al. 2005). Hosseini et al.’s findings showed that spiritual care could reduce anxiety in Shia Muslim patients undergoing CABG (Hosseini et al. 2013). Spiritual activities such as non-organic and rehabilitation intervention can lead to improved self-care in patients (Fallahi-Khoshknab and Ghazanfari 2007). Spirituality is a part of nursing care, and it can enhance patients’ satisfaction effectively (Fatemi et al. 2016).

The results showed that patients’ depression decreased after spiritual care among patients who underwent CABG. Spiritual care should be part of nursing holistic care and appropriate to the needs of individual patients. Spiritual beliefs help to focus perceptions considering the individual and their relationship with the world. Such belief gives them an inner strength that will blend very closely with their physical and mental health.

Our findings indicated that a spiritual/religious intervention had a positive effect on reducing patients’ postoperative depression in Shia Muslim patients. Despite these strengths, this study has several limitations. These limitations were that the intervention was limited in use to a Shia Muslim population (using words associated with the Shia faith, and sentences based on Islamic Supplication Zikr), and there was no measure of the impact of social or environmental factors.

The results show that the potential effect of spiritual care is to reduce postoperative depression of patients after CABG surgery. For nursing professionals, it is necessary to accommodate and consider the spiritual needs of patients. Overall, nurses’ attention to patients’ spiritual needs and providing this care may be useful in minimizing patients’ depression. It is necessary to undertake similar studies in other religious populations.

5. Limitations

The limitations of this study were that the intervention was limited in use to a Shia Muslim population (using words associated with the Shia faith, and sentences based on Islamic Supplication Zikr), and there was no measure of the impact of social or environmental factors.

6. Conclusions

This study identified the role of spiritual care as a potentially useful and culturally appropriate intervention to decrease depression following CABG in Shia Muslim patients, and suggested that it may have utility in other populations and care settings.