Introduction
Aims and research questions
-
What qualitative evidence is available that explores the experience of living with both cancer and one or more comorbidities from patient, carer and provider perspectives?
-
What are the psychosocial support needs of people living with cancer and one or more comorbidity as identified in the literature?
-
What are patient, carer and provider experiences of service provision for cancer and comorbid conditions reported in the literature and what research priorities can be derived from the available evidence?
Methods
Design and ethics
Eligibility criteria
Dimensions of interest
Information sources
Search strategy
Data collection and analysis
Study records and screening
Findings
Author (year) | Country of study/setting | Study type/method used | Study focus | Subjects/gender (N) | Age of subjects | Analysis/theoretical underpinnings reported | Cancer type (years since diagnosis) | Comorbid illness(es) reported | Themes evidenced in article |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Baker [33] 2015 | USA | QL/in-depth semi-structured interviews at two time points | Clinical care providers’ views on survivors’ weight management | Professionals: oncologists, surgeons, PCPs, nurses, dieticians. (N = 33) | ? | Constant comparative analysis | Prostate, breast, non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (years not reported) | Diabetes, hypertension | 1, 2, 4, 5 |
Bartlett [34] 2012 | UK | QL/in-depth interviews | Health professional views on needs assessment and communication with cancer patient with dementia | Healthcare professionals (N = 5) | ? | Heidegger’s phenomenological approach | Not reported; professional interviews | Dementia | 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 |
Beck [35] 2009 | USA | Mixed/interviews and psychometric tests | Symptom experience, QoL and functional performance of cancer survivors at 1 and 3 months post-treatment | Male and female cancer patients (N = 52) | 65+ | Not reported | All—most common breast and prostate (1 and 3 years after diagnosis) | Arthritis, hypertension, diabetes, heart disease, lung disease, neuromuscular disease | 1, 2, 3, 5 |
Clarke [36] 2013 | Canada | QL/semi-structured interviews at two time points | Experience of multiple conditions in later life and influence of gender and age. | Male and female patients with multi-morbidity (N = 35) | 73+ | Patton’s thematic analysis | Not clearly reported (one bladder cancer) | Arthritis, back pain, heart disease, COPD | 1, 2, 3, 4 |
Corner [37] 2013 | UK | Mixed/QL free text comments analysis | How free text comments on PROMs added to understanding of QoL issues for survivors | Male and female cancer patients (N = 1056) | Over 16 | Content analysis | Breast cancer, colorectal cancer, non-Hodgkin lymphoma, prostate cancer (1–5 years) | Hypertension, arthritis, osteoporosis, back pain | 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 |
Courtier [38] 2016 | UK | QL/case studies | Outpatient experiences of patients with dementia and oncology management | Male and female cancer/dementia patients and five HCPs (N = 16) | ? | Wolcott’s framework for qualitative data analysis | Breast cancer, prostate cancer, head and neck cancers, pelvic cancer, colorectal (years not reported) | Dementia | 1, 3, 4, 5 |
Dahlhaus [39] 2014 | Germany | QL/semi-structured telephone interviews | German GPs’ views on involvement in patients’ cancer care | Male and female GPs (N = 30) | ? | Mayring’s qualitative content analysis | Any professional interviews | Dementia, hypertension | 5 |
Fenlon [40] 2013 | USA | QL/in-depth semi-structured interviews | Lived experience, support and information needs of breast cancer patients with comorbid illness | Male and female patients (N = 48, 43 are male) | 70–90 years | Braun and Clarke’s thematic analysis | Breast cancer (up to 10 years) | Cardiac conditions, arthritis, hypertension, diabetes | 1, 2, 3, 5 |
Fix [41] 2014 | USA | QL/longitudinal interviews | Hypertension self-management in patients with comorbidities | Male and female patients (N = 48, 43 are male) | Mean age 60 years | Grounded theory approach; Kleinman’s explanatory model as a framework | Prostate cancer, renal cancer (years not reported) | Hypertension, anxiety, arthritis, back pain, cardiovascular disease, COPD, depression, glaucoma, Parkinson’s disease | 1, 2, 4, 5 |
Hannum [42] 2016 | USA | QL/longitudinal interviews | Narratives of cancer among chronically ill older adults | Male and female patients (N = 16, 13 are female) | 65 and over | Thematic analysis based on symbolic interactionism, constructivism and phenomenology | Breast, colon, brain, endometrial, oesophageal, GIST, large B cell lymphoma, pancreatic, stomach (within 1 year) | Diabetes, glaucoma | 2, 3 |
Hershey [43] 2012 | USA | Mixed/phone survey with two open-ended questions | Impact of cancer and its treatment on diabetes self-management | Male and female patients (N = 37) | 50 and over | Qualitative content analysis | Breast, lung and pancreas (years not reported) | Diabetes (type I and II) | 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 |
Kantsiper [44] 2009 | USA | QL/focus group interviews | Needs and priorities of breast cancer patients, oncologists and PCPs. | Female patients; male and female professionals (N = 52) | ? | Qualitative thematic analysis | Breast (1 year or more) | Diabetes, hypertension, renal issues | 5 |
Loerzel [45] 2012 | USA | QL/semi-structured interviews | Understanding post-treatment survivorship in older women with breast cancer | Female patients (N = 20) | 65–86 years | Grounded theory approach and analysis | Breast (within 1 year) | Fibromyalgia, arthritis | 1, 2, 3 |
Loerzel [46] 2013 | USA | QL/semi-structured interviews | Understanding post-treatment survivorship in older women with breast cancer | Female patients (N = 20) | 65–86 years | Grounded theory approach and analysis | Breast (within 1 year) | Fibromyalgia, arthritis | 2, 3 |
Mason [23] 2014 | UK | QL/in-depth serial interviews | Experience of advanced multi-morbidity and implications for palliative and end of life care | Male and female patients and carers (N = 37) | 55–62 years (mean 76) | Thematic analysis; constructionist approach | Lung (years not reported) | Heart disease, respiratory, liver, renal failure, neurological conditions, dementia | 2, 3, 4, 5 |
Morgan [47] 2015 | UK | QL/in-depth serial interviews | Experience of advanced multi-morbidity and implications for palliative and end of life care | Male and female patients and carers (N = 37) | 55–62 years (mean 76) | Thematic analysis; constructionist approach | Breast; professional interviews | Dementia and others non-specified | 1, 5 |
Nanton [48] 2016 | UK | QL/in-depth serial interviews | To examine the impact of uncertainty on identity in people with advanced multi-morbidity and the role of HCPs and health systems | Male and female patients and carers (N = 37) | 41–92 years | Thematic analysis; based on social constructionism and ethnography | Lung, prostate (years not reported) | Stroke, ischaemic heart disease, dementia, osteoarthritis, hypertension | 2, 3, 4, 5 |
Norman [49] 2001 | Canada | QL/semi-structured interviews | Palliative care patients’ relationships with their family physicians | Male and female patients (N = 25) | 28–84 years | Grounded theory approach | 12 types of cancer (1 month-12 years) | Diabetes | 5 |
Palmer [50] 2011 | USA | Mixed/survey and interviews | Health-related goals of post-treatment colorectal cancer survivors | Male and female patients (N = 41) | 33–87 years | Unclear; thematic analysis described | Colorectal (within 2 years) | Diabetes, chronic pain | 2, 3, 4 |
Palmer [51] 2013 | USA | QL/semi-structured interviews | Health-related goals of post-treatment colorectal cancer survivors | Male and female patients (N = 41) | 33–87 years | Content analysis | Colorectal (within 2 years) | Diabetes, chronic pain | 2, 4 |
Sada [52] 2011 | USA | QL/semi-structured interviews | PCP and oncologists’ roles and communication in shared care of cancer patients | Male patients, male and female professionals (N = 24) | 40–80+ | Unclear; some form of thematic analysis | Colorectal (within 2 years) | COPD, cardiovascular disease, diabetes and others non-specified | 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 |
Saunders-Sturm [31] 2003 | USA | QL/semi-structured interviews | Lived experience of breast cancer | Female patients (N = 33) | 47 years and over | Grounded theory approach; social constructionist | Breast (18 months-4 years) | Arthritis, asthma, chronic bronchitis, high blood pressure and diabetes | 2, 3, 4 |
Sawin [54] 2012 | USA | QL/semi-structured interviews | Ageing related experiences of women with breast cancer in unsupportive relationships | Female patients (N = 16) | 50–84 years (mean 68.1) | Hermeneutic phenomenological analysis | Breast (1–31 years; mean 7.4) | Hypertension, chronic pain, COPD | 1, 2, 3 |
Sinding [55] 2008 | Canada | QL/semi-structured interviews at two time points | Older women’s experiences of cancer | Female patients (N = 15) | 70 years and over | Grounded theory approach and analysis | Breast and gynaecological (within 3 years) | Diabetes, Chrohn’s disease, ‘mental illness’ | 1, 2, 3 |
Sowerbutts [56] 2015 | UK | QL/in-depth interviews | Surgery decisions in older women with breast cancer | Female patients (N = 28) | 70–99 years | Framework analysis | Breast (within 30 days) | Non-specified | 1, 3, 5 |
Thomé [57] 2003 | Sweden | QL/interviews | Experiences of older people living with cancer and its impact on daily life | Male and female patients (N = 64) | 76–99 years (mean 87) | Latent content analysis | Breast, prostate, gastro, gynae, urogenital, skin, lung/larynx, haematological | Within 5 years | 1, 2, 3, 4 |
Volker [58] 2013 | USA | QL/focus group interviews | Cancer diagnosis for people with pre-existing functional limitations and topics for a wellness intervention programme | Female patients (N = 19) | 21 and over (mean 59.5) | Patton’s qualitative content analysis | Breast, colorectal, bladder, gynae, melanoma, thyroid, kidney (10 years on average) | Arthritis, multiple sclerosis | 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 |
Wallace [59] 2015 | USA | QL/semi-structured interviews at two time points | Treatment experiences of newly diagnosed head and neck cancer patients and influence of age and time | Male and female patients (N = 41, 32 are male) | 45–91 (mean 58.4) | Cresswell’s qualitative analysis; based on socio-emotional selective theory and Leventhal’s self-regulation model | Head and neck (within 2 weeks) | Heart disease, diabetes, Alzheimer’s, COPD, arthritis, fibromyalgia, liver failure | 3, 4, 5 |
Wimberley [60] 2012 | USA | QL/in-depth serial interviews | Influence of breast cancer on women’s meanings, understanding and self-identities over time. | Female patients (N = 15) | 41–76 years (mean 59.4) | Hermeneutic analysis; phenomenological underpinnings | Breast (5–25 years) | Scleroderma and hypothyroidism | 1, 2, 3, 4 |
Yoo [61] 2010 | USA | QL/in-depth interviews | Psychosocial impact of breast cancer and social support for older women | Female patients (N = 47) | 65–83 years | Grounded theory approach and analysis | Breast (within 4 years) | Heart disease and others non-specified | 1, 2, 3, 4 |
Zhang [62] 2015 | USA | Mixed/psychometric test and interviews | Universal and unique depressive symptoms in African American cancer patients | Male and female patients (N = 74) | Mean 62 years | Unclear; thematic analysis described | Not reported | Depression | 2 |
Synthesis
Interaction and impact of cancer and comorbidity
There is an indication in the literature reviewed that this complexity influences not only quality of life, and recovery (e.g. Corner et al. [37]), but also treatment decisions,‘They're morbidly obese, they have heart disease, diabetes, they all have orthopedic issues... breast cancer's just one thing’. (Nurse navigator, [33])
‘I could not have [general anaesthetic] because it affects my heart, you see’. (Patient 23, [56])‘If you have got umm a person with reduced mental capacity [because of dementia] living on their own then the safety of giving chemotherapy is a risk’. (Oncologist, [38])
Symptom experience
‘Dr C said that he doesn't really feel that I got too much to worry about, that they got it in time, but then how do they know if they got everything? ...And when my lungs are bad [asthma], it frightens you’. (Judith, [55])
Illness expectations and identity
‘One feels sorry for oneself, in the sense that one loses one's independence and you become dependent on others’. (91 year old patient with back problems, cancer, heart disease and other conditions, [36])
Managing medications and self-management
In terms of self-management, studies emphasised the need for shared care or supported self-management (including looking after overall health and well-being), and the need for resources to enable this and to take the pressure off primary care in providing follow-up care and support for this patient group.‘The fact that I'm on this pain control regimen, doctors wanted to ignore it, he didn't want to deal with someone on Fentnyl patch and Oxycodone, just didn't want to deal with that. So if you don't advocate for yourself, forget it...sometimes you get tired of fighting for yourself and trying to educate everybody’. (Cancer patient, [58])
Role of primary and secondary care
However, primary care practitioners did not always feel comfortable managing advanced cancer symptoms, potentially leading to a fragmented experience of care, as another study suggests:‘I encourage patients to continue the management of their [chronic illness] with their PCP...I'm so subspecialised that I don't really feel comfortable managing [it]’. (Medical oncologist 6, [52])
Managing cancer multi-morbidity in primary care carries many challenges:‘[The FP (family physician) is] still looking after their diabetes…One kind of doctor does this; he does that: [to] each their own. Symptom control is not in their hands…You leave that to the specialists. She’s just a family physician’. (Cancer patient, [49]).
‘…Actually most of our patients have five or six issues, and so we’re trying to manage their diabetes or hypertension or renal insufficiency and then end up with a breast issue, and it’s impossible…that’s like more than an hour’s worth of time where you have like four patients scheduled in 15-min increments, and it’s overwhelming’. (Primary Care Professional, [44])