Low distribution of genes encoding virulence factors in Shigella flexneri serotypes 1b clinical isolates from eastern Chinese populations

Shigellosis is major health burden in many parts of the world. It is an acute invasive enteric infection caused by four members of Shigella species (S. dysenteriae, S. flexneri, S. boydii, and S. sonnei). Different serotypes for these species exist including more than 30 serotypes of S. flexneri which are categorized based on their O antigens, [1]. Although the role of shigellosis in contributing to childhood mortality has been decreased significantly over the past few years, there are still about 28,000 children younger than 5 years of age who died of shigellosis every year [2]. In a systematic review, [3] it was reported that due to low economic conditions and large population density in Asian countries, over 125 million Shigella-related infections led to 14,000 deaths per year. There are some factors contributing to the high prevalence of human Shigella infection. One reason for the high infection rate in some developing countries is the low sanitary conditions, knowing that Shigella spp. is transmitted via the fecal–oral route. Another important factor is that S. flexneri possess protective mechanisms that help it to survive even at high levels of acid in the stomach, which makes it highly infectious with only 10–100 microorganisms required to cause a disease [4].

In children, main symptoms of shigellosis vary from mild to severe which include: diarrhoea characterized by presence of blood in stool, abdominal cramping, fever, among other gastrointestinal complications. Its clinical phenotypes are determined by different virulence genes and the activity of immune system of the host. Among the many Shigella spp.—associated virulence factors, invasion plasmid antigen (ipa) B, C, D, and H as well as invasion-associated locus (ial) facilitates its penetration into intestinal cells [4]. As with gram-negative bacteria, these genes are important for S. flexneri because they are components of the type III secretion system (T3SS) which is important for S. flexneri and other gram-negative pathogenic or symbiotic bacteria in manipulating the host cell processes and establish a successful infection [5]. Shigella enterotoxin 1 (ShET-1), Shigella enterotoxin 2 (ShET-2) and shiga toxin (stx) are among virulence genes encoding Shigella enterotoxins. A group of genes mostly found in S. flexneri serotype 2 clinical samples encode ShET1, a 55 kDa protein complex [6, 7]. ShET2 has been reported in different species of Shigella [7]. The stx is produced exclusively by S. dysenteriae 1, but this species is rare in China [8]. The transcription of invasion-related genes is controlled by two proteins, virF and virB (InvE) which are derived from plasmids [9]. Finally, Shigella spp. harbors toxic factors like serine protease autotransporters of enterobacteriaceae (SPATE) of which there are two phylogenetic classes [10]. Shigella IgA-like protease homologue (sigA) and secreted autotransporter toxin (sat) belong to class 1 which are toxic to epithelial cells, while non-toxic SPATE class 2 toxins includes sepA, which facilitates intestinal inflammation and pic, a mucinase associated with colonization.

Although some studies reported the prevalence and distribution of S. flexneri virulence genes in some regions in China, investigations to dozen virulence genes of Shigella spp. mentioned above are still rare throughout the world, and to the best of our knowledge there is no report in China. To develop effective control strategies, it is important to conduct an epidemic study about Shigella in terms of its drug resistance and genetic features [11]. For this reason, we sought to explore the distribution profile and prevalence of 12 Shigella-related virulence genes obtained from patients with diarrhea in Jiangsu Province of China, and discussed the genetic diversity and clinical applications of these genes.

Due to inadequate supply of quality water and low hygienic conditions in less developed countries, Shigella—a cause of inflammatory diarrhea and dysentery, poses major challenges to public health sectors. S. flexneri was the most common of the four species in many developing countries [19, 20]. However, in developed countries, S. sonnei is the commonest Shigella species isolated [21, 22]. The reason for this difference is unclear, however, it is apparent that efforts to boost sanitation and local hygiene have greatly decreased the prevalence of shigellosis and even changed the pattern in which Shigella species are most distributed. Jiangsu Province is located in the eastern part of China, with a population about 80 million. Epidemiological analysis of Shigella will be beneficial to the prevention and control of the infectious diseases in the region. The results of analysis of the distribution characteristics of S. flexneri in Jiangsu Province in the present study showed that S. flexneri 2a was the most common of the eleven serotype, which is different from the study conducted in Beijing in China reporting that S. flexneri 4c was the most prevalent serotype among 19 serotypes [23]. In Jiangsu Province, serotype 4c accounted for only 3.3%. However, our results matched the findings in developing countries [19, 24] and Zhejiang Province of China [25]. Even in Jiangsu Province, there were also differences between the various cities (Additional file 2). For example, most prevalent serotypes in Nanjing are serotypes 2b, serotypes 1b in Zhenjiang and serotypes 1a in Taizhou. What’s more, some rare serotypes were detected at specific times in specific cities, such as serotype 6 was only separated from Nanjing in 2010. High heterogeneity with regard to temporal distribution was noted in Shigella species and serotypes, which further suggested the need for serotype-level identification to enhance the effectiveness of control strategies.

Since the information on the variety of Shigella virulence genes in China is limited, to fully understand its pathogenicity, further research is required to advance the search for virulence-related genes for Shigella. In the present study, the prevalence and distribution of 12 such genes was examined. In the present study, ipaH gene was highly conserved in various serotypes. Similar findings have been shown in many other studies [25]. The presence of many copies of this gene i.e. seven in chromosomes and five in plasmids may explain why the gene tested positive in all strains. Considering that this gene can be detected even after the loss of plasmid, it is promising target for diagnostic purposes. In Shigella, the ability to enter host cells depends on the availability of type III-secretion-system (T3SS) which are encoded by large virulence plasmids [26, 27]. ial gene has been identified in invasion processes and on inv plasmid [28]. Many proteins form part of the T3SS complex which includes a needle-shaped oligomer that connects the inner and outer membrane of the bacteria. The oligomer contains invasive plasmid antigens ipaB, ipaC, and ipaD at its tip end [26‐29], which can be identified using upstream region of ipaB, acting as marker. The effects of deleting ial and ipaBCD on invasiveness of S. flexneri are not known. Numerous studies have shown that there is a link between the ability of the Shigella spp. strains to cause diarrhea and the presence of invasive genes in the bacteria. Mokhtari et al. [30] showed that, unlike in asymptomatic patients, isolates from stools of patients with diarrhea contained invasive genes, ial and/or ipaBCD. A study by Phantouamath et al. [31], showed that ial gene was found only in isolates from cases. In our study, 47.0% S. flexneri’ isolates were positive for ial gene, and 50.5% S. flexneri’ isolates were positive for ipaBCD gene. Comparison with other similar studies, 78.9% S. flexneri’ isolates were positive for ial gene in Iran [32], and even 100% in Zhejiang of China [25]. For the ipaBCD gene, our result is similar to that of a study in Peru (49%) [19], but lower than that of a study in Brazil (100%) [33]. in this sense, the invasive ability of S. flexneri in Jiangsu Province is not strong compared with other areas. Moreover, prevalence of virulence genes showed obvious serotype characteristics, such as none S. flexneri 1b expressed both ial and ipaBCD strains. But it should be noted that the pathogenicity of S. flexneri is also related to both the number of infected bacteria and the immunity of infected people.

Expression of Shigella virulence genes is regulated by heat-stable nucleoid structural protein (H-NS) which downregulates their transcription during unfavorable conditions for invasion. In response to favorable environmental signals, transcription of a series of genes is activated starting from AraC-like protein gene virF, which subsequently turns on transcription of virB regulatory genes. Thereafter, virB protein reverses the H-NS-induced inhibition on transcription which eventually turns on the virulence genes on the plasmid [9, 34].In the present study, both virF and virB were found in 45.0% S. flexneri isolates, indicating that there might be other pathways for regulating gene expression. In addition, virF but not virB was found in 19.8% S. flexneri isolates, suggesting that virF regulated virulence genes not only through virB pathway. Interestingly, of the 545 S. flexneri, 11 strains had only virB, which may be due to loss of the virF gene. On the other hand, because of the importance of virF in regulating virulence genes, potential novel antibiotics targeting virF have gained increasing attention [35, 36]. However, only 64.8% of the positive rate of this gene might limit this antibiotics application.

Two new enterotoxins have recently been described in S. flexneri. One is called Shigella enterotoxin 1 (ShET-1), which is encoded in the set1 chromosomal gene. It has been suggested that in its active form, the ShET-1 toxin is composed of a subunit A (encoded by set1A) and five B subunits (encoded by set1B) [37]. Other is plasmid-encoded ShET-2 (encoded by sen). ShET-1 and ShET-2 could alter electrolyte and water transport in the small intestine [28], which is closely related to the symptoms of dehydration in the shigellosis. Prior studies reported that set1 genes were only detected in S. flexneri serotype 2 (2a and 2b) isolates and less so in other serotypes. In contrast, in the current study, many S. flexneri serotypes tested positive for set1 genes [7, 12, 38]. In some serotypes, however, the prevalence of set1 (set1A and/or set1B) was significantly lower than in other serotypes, such as S. flexneri 1b, S. flexneri 3b (Table 3). And interestingly, 14.9% of S. flexneri had only one subunit of ShET-1, the question about whether a single subunit would affect the pathogenicity of ShET-1 remains to be answered, but which needs further study for verification. The association remains to be further studied. sen gene was found in 11 serotypes, with a majority between 40 and 80%, but the serotype 1b positive rate was only 14%. The low positive rate of ShET-1 and ShET-2 in S. flexneri 1b means that this serotype has a low ability to cause dehydration.

Another factor that possess virulence activities is the Serine protease autotransporters of Enterobacteriaceae (SPATEs), which are toxins secreted from gram-negative bacteria. Nevertheless, only a few studies have searched for the presence of their encoding genes in large Shigella collections. A similar study in Iran found that the sat gene was present in all S. flexneri isolates, and the presence of sigA, pic and sepA genes simultaneously were existed in 35.5% of S. flexneri [32]. Comparing the similar study, unsurprising, the most common SPATEs among Shigella was sat in our study, but the positive rate of the other three genes of SPATEs was significantly higher than that of Iran. Interestingly, sat is now recognized as a pathogenic E. coli, although it was initially studied in uropathogenic E. coli strains. In comparison with previous studies on the frequencies of sat gene in E. coli [39, 40], however, the presence of sat gene in Shigella was found to be higher. It should be noted that except for sat gene, SPATEs of serotype 1b was significantly less than that of the other serotypes.

The virulence gene can be used to identify Shigella, which had been confirmed by previous studies. Some studies [41, 42] reported that the positive rate of detecting Shigella by a PCR assay targeting the ipaH gene was higher than that by the traditional culture method. The disadvantage of this method is that it can only identify one virulence gene at a time, though this disadvantage could probably be overcome by multiple PCR techniques by screening the amplified genes in view of the difficulty of multiple PCR and the restriction of the number of amplified genes. IpaH can be used as a marker gene of Shigella to detect the Shigella. Four genes (pic, set1A, set1B and sigA) are located on the chromosome SHI-1 Island, and the pic gene overlaps with set1A and set1B. When Shigella flexneri set1A gene was positive for Shigella flexneri, 94.1% Shigella set1B was positive, and 92.4% Shigella isolates were positive for pic and sigA. set1A positive Shigella had a stronger representation of the integrity of this segment of the gene. Because of the high expression of sat in Shigella, the clinical value of its amplification is not significant. Other virulence genes include ial, ipaBCD, virF, virB, sen and sepA, all of which are located on the large virulence plasmid (140 MDa). To reflect these virulence genes of Shigella, we chose the lowest existent ial gene as a marker and found that the positive rate of ial positive S. flexneri, ipaBCD was 98.8%, the positive rate of virF was 96.1%, the positive rate of virB was 92.6%, and the positive rate of sen and sepA was 94.5%. To sum up, multiplex PCR combination ipaH + set1A + ial can comprehensively reflect the virulence of Shigella.

In the present study, we provided some baseline information about the distribution of some virulence genes in clinical strains of S. flexneri in Jiangsu Province in China. It was found that the prevalence of these virulence genes varied greatly, leading to different severities of the disease. The profile of these virulence genes correlated with serotype, period and region. We found a low pathogenicity serotype (1b) and combination between those genes. These findings may help better control and identify Shigella strains.