Maternal atopic conditions and autism spectrum disorder: a systematic review
- Open Access
- 03.09.2023
- Review
Abstract
Introduction
Methodology
Literature search
Study selection
Data extraction and synthesis
Quality assessment
Results
Study selection
References | Country | Type of study | Number of subjects | Age | Method of assessment of maternal asthma | Method of assessment of autism | Study outcomes (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Croen et al. [16] | USA | Case–control | 2502 (407/2095) | 3–7 | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9; within 2 years of delivery) | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9) | Asthma: 1.6 (1.2–2.2) |
Previous History: 1.2 (1.2–2.4) | |||||||
Trimester 1: 2.8 (1.3–6.1) | |||||||
Trimester 2: 2.2 (1.1–4.2) | |||||||
Trimester 3: 1.7 (1.0–2.8) | |||||||
Postnatal: 1.4 (0.8–2.3) | |||||||
Croen et al. [40] | USA | Case–control | 1647 (663/984) | 2–5 | Computer assisted telephone interview or Recorded Physician Diagnosis | SCQ if ≥ 11 then ADOS and ADI-R | Asthma: 1.26 (0.99–1.60) |
Asthma Treated During Pregnancy | |||||||
1.41 (1.07–1.85) | |||||||
Hisle-Gorman et al. [38] | USA | Case–control | 35,040 (8760/26,280) | 2–18 | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9; Lifetime)/Prescription Record | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9) | Diagnosis: 1.14 (1.01–1.29) |
Diagnosis and Prescription: 1.49 (1.29–1.74) | |||||||
Prescription: 1.29 (1.12–1.48) | |||||||
Langridge et al. [39] | Australia | Case–control | 383,153 (1179/376,529) | 0–6 | Prenatal Medical Record (Lifetime) | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (DSM IIIR-IV-TR) | Asthma + ASD with ID: 0.98 (0.71–1.36) |
Asthma + ASD without ID: 1.41 (0.98–2.04) | |||||||
Leonard et al. [44] | Australia | Case–Control | 237,155 (236,964/191) | 0–16 | Prenatal Medical Record (Lifetime) | Medical Record | Asthma + ASD with ID: 1.32 (0.65–2.67) |
Lyall et al. [41] | USA | Case–control | 951 (560/391) | 2–5 | Either by Parental Questionnaire or Recorded Physician Diagnosis (lifetime history) | Recorded Physician Diagnosis verified by ADOS and ADI-R | Asthma: 1.0 (0.69–1.44) |
Results unchanged when considering asthma during pregnancy only | |||||||
Micali et al. [42] | UK | Case–Control | 303 (97/206) | 2.5–6.5 | Self-Report Questionnaire validated by Medical Records | Clinical Screening then ADI-R | Nonsignificant |
Mouridsen et al. [43] | Denmark | Case–control | 441 (111/330) | Children with mean age of 5.4 | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-8/10)—lifetime | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9) | No association between lifetime history of maternal asthma and autism (p = 0.31) |
Patel et al. [18] | Australia | Cohort | 363 children with ASD | Children with mean age of 3.07 | Self-Report Questionnaire—lifetime | ADOS; Social Responsiveness Scale (measure of severity) | Maternal asthma and allergy condition, more common in male children with ASD comparing to female children with ASD (p = 0.009) |
References | Country | Type of study | N (case/control) | Age | Method Assessment of Maternal Allergy | Method Assessment of Autism | Study Outcome (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Croen et al. [16] | USA | Case–control | 2502 (407/2095) | 3–7 | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9) within 2 years of delivery | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9) | Allergy: 1.5 (1.2–1.9) |
Croen et al. [40] | USA | Case–control | 1647 (663/984) | 2–5 | Computer assisted telephone interview; Prenatal record | SCQ if ≥ 11 then ADOS and ADI-R | Allergy: (0.91–1.41) |
Lyall et al. [41] | USA | Case–control | 951 (560/391) | 2–5 | Parental Questionnaire or Recorded Physician Diagnosis (lifetime history and within 2 years of delivery) | Recorded Physician Diagnosis verified by ADOS and ADI-R | All Allergy: 0.97 (0.71–1.32) |
Food 1.23 (0.73–) | |||||||
Dairy: 4.31 (1.13–16.5) | |||||||
Fruit 1.27 (0.60–2.7) | |||||||
Nut 1.42 (0.27–7.64) | |||||||
Seafood 2.73 (0.87–8.75) | |||||||
Environmental 1.15 (0.82–1.61) | |||||||
Medication 0.120 (0.85–1.68) | |||||||
Patel et al. [18] | Australia | Cohort | 363 children with ASD | Children with mean age of 3.07 | Self-Report Questionnaire | ADOS; Social Responsiveness Scale (measure of severity) | Maternal asthma and allergy condition, more common in male children with ASD comparing to female children with ASD (p = 0.009) |
References | Country | Type of study | N (case/control) | Age | Method assessment of maternal eczema | Method assessment of autism | Study outcome (95% CI) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Croen et al. [16] | USA | Case–control | 2502 (407/2095) | 3–7 | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9) within 2 years of delivery | Recorded Physician Diagnosis (ICD-9) | Eczema: 1.8 (1.0–3.4) |
Previous History: 1.5 (1.1–2.1) | |||||||
Trimester 1: 1.0 (0.4–2.3) | |||||||
Trimester 2: 2.5 (1.2–5.2) | |||||||
Trimester 3: 1.9 (0.7–4.9) | |||||||
Postnatal: 1.5 (1.1–2.0) | |||||||
Croen et al. [40] | USA | Case–control | 1647 (663/984) | 2–5 | Computer assisted telephone interview; Prenatal record | SCQ if ≥ 11 then ADOS and ADI-R | Eczema and Psoriasis: 1.39 (1.00–1.95) |
Micali et al. [42] | UK | Case–control | 303 (79/61) | 2.5–6.5 | Self-Report Questionnaire validated by Medical Records | Clinical Screening then ADI-R | Lifetime History of Eczema: Nonsignificant |
Lyall et al. [41] | USA | Case–control | 951 (560/391) | 2–5 | Parental Questionnaire or Recorded Physician Diagnosis (lifetime history and within 2 years of delivery) | Recorded Physician Diagnosis verified by ADOS and ADI-R | Eczema: 1.43 (0.84–2.46) |
References | Selection (****) | Comparability (**) | Outcome/exposure (***) | Total score (out of max. 9) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Croen et al. [16] | ** | ** | ** | 6 |
Croen et al. [40] | *** | ** | * | 6 |
Hisle-Gorman et al. [38] | ** | ** | ** | 6 |
Langridge et al. [39] | ** | – | ** | 4 |
Leonard et al. [44] | ** | ** | ** | 6 |
Lyall et al. [41] | *** | ** | ** | 7 |
Micali et al. [42] | ** | – | * | 3 |
Mouridsen et al. [43] | ** | ** | ** | 6 |
Patel et al. [18] | * | – | ** | 3 |