Introduction
Study 1: discussion forum
Method
Participants
Procedure
Analysis
Results
Participants
Research priorities
Study 2: priority-setting survey
Method
Participants
Procedure
Analysis
Results
Participants
Number | Percent | |
---|---|---|
Group | ||
Consumer | 37 | 52.9 |
Carer | 12 | 17.1 |
Consumer and Carer | 21 | 30.0 |
Total N | 70 | 100 |
Gender | ||
Male | 14 | 20.0 |
Female | 52 | 74.3 |
Othera | 3 | 4.3 |
Prefer not to say | 1 | 1.4 |
Total N | 70 | 100 |
State or Territory | ||
Australian Capital Territory | 26 | 38.2 |
New South Wales | 16 | 23.5 |
Northern Territory | 2 | 2.9 |
Queensland | 2 | 2.9 |
South Australia | 2 | 2.9 |
Tasmania | 1 | 1.5 |
Victoria | 14 | 20.6 |
Western Australia | 5 | 7.4 |
Total N | 68 | 100 |
Research priorities
Research topic | Topic area | Priority ranking (percentage important ratings) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Consumer | Carer | Consumer/Carer | ||
How to implement internationally recognised models of peer support in Australia |
Peer to Peer
| 1 (94) | 24 (70) | 72.5 (44) |
Over-representation of mental illness in the justice system |
Justice
| 2 (88) | 1.5 (100) | 11 (78) |
How is psychosocial disability defined in the NDIS, and how will it impact consumers and carers in Australia? |
National Disability Insurance Scheme
| 4.5 (88) | 9 (80) | 15.5 (76) |
How does the use of language include/exclude individuals? |
Language and Communication
| 4.5 (88) | 69 (44) | 55.5 (56) |
Consumers’ experiences of peer-to-peer services |
Peer to Peer
| 4.5 (88) | 39 (60) | 64.5 (50) |
Social inclusion |
Other
| 4.5 (88) | 15.5 (78) | 44.5 (60) |
How participation works in practice (tokenism vs. real involvement) |
Consumer and Carer Involvement
| 7.5 (85) | 24 (70) | 11 (78) |
What is helpful in recovery-oriented services? |
Experiences of Care
| 7.5 (85) | 9 (80) | 32 (65) |
Peer-led services – What are the gaps? (e.g. support groups) |
Peer to Peer
| 10 (84) | 46.5 (56) | 55.5 (56) |
How to recruit and train peer workers – What is going on, and where? Where is it embedded? How are they being supported? |
Peer to Peer
| 10 (84) | 39 (60) | 55.5 (56) |
Mental health in LGBTIQ+ populations |
Other
| 10 (84) | 46.5 (56) | 38.5 (63) |
How is the consumer and carer voice integrated into policy and services? How are their contributions valued, and what indicators exist to demonstrate how their voice is used? |
Services
| 12 (84) | 52.5 (55) | 21.5 (71) |
How do we expand who is involved? (e.g. young people) |
Consumer and Carer Involvement
| 13 (82) | 15.5 (78) | 64.5 (50) |
Is medication what we want? Side effects, health impacts, alternatives, efficacy, cost-effectiveness |
Medication
| 14 (79) | 34 (64) | 59 (55) |
Stigma by health providers (mental health and others) – What do they believe and how does it impact? |
Stigma
| 15.5 (79) | 24 (70) | 5 (83) |
Are consumers being consulted about their experiences of care? |
Experiences of Care
| 15.5 (79) | 24 (70) | 21.5 (71) |
Impact of service delivery on consumers and carers – What contributes to recovery? |
Services
| 17 (78) | 58 (50) | 7 (81) |
What programmes/supports can be devised for reaching individuals that are outside of NDIS scope? |
National Disability Insurance Scheme
| 20.5 (78) | 9 (80) | 15.5 (76) |
Peer support in public mental health system |
Peer to Peer
| 20.5 (78) | 46.5 (56) | 24.5 (69) |
Accommodation |
Other
| 20.5 (78) | 46.5 (56) | 25.5 (69) |
Employment |
Other
| 20.5 (78) | 5 (89) | 7 (81) |
Support in education settings |
Other
| 20.5 (78) | 15.5 (78) | 77 (38) |
Culturally and linguistically diverse perspectives within mainstream mental health system |
Other
| 20.5 (78) | 69 (44) | 32 (65) |
How do individuals adapt to changes in medication that impact lifestyle and quality of life? |
Medication
| 24 (77) | 52.5 (55) | 38.5 (63) |
Training of psychologists – How can consumer perspectives be incorporated? |
Health Professionals
| 26.5 (76) | 62.5 (45) | 44 .5 (60) |
Where do physical health concerns fit into health services when you have mental health problems as a main focus? |
Comorbidity and Physical Health
| 26.5 (76) | 39 (60) | 11 (78) |
Discrimination |
Justice
| 26.5 (76) | 15.5 (78) | 27.5 (67) |
How have people who have experienced trauma been cared for? |
Experiences of Care
| 26.5 (76) | 39 (60) | 21.5 (71) |
Trauma informed care – Why is it important, and how is it integrated into service delivery? |
Services
| 29.5 (76) | 39 (60) | 42 (62) |
Reach – Are services reaching the people that need them? |
Services
| 29.5 (76) | 3 (91) | 27.5 (67) |
Capacity for decision-making/change in legislation and its application; consumer and carer experiences of this. What information is provided about legislation? What support is provided, e.g. legal? |
Legislation
| 32.5 (75) | 15.5 (78) | 47.5 (59) |
To what extent do we follow human rights legislation on mental illness? |
Legislation
| 32.5 (75) | 24 (70) | 15.5 (76) |
Recovery and fulfilling potential |
Other
| 32.5 (75) | 15.5 (78) | 64.5 (50) |
Suicide: continuous care and support |
Other
| 32.5 (75) | 5 (89) | 7 (81) |
Is care traumatising? |
Experiences of Care
| 35 (74) | 9 (80) | 15.5 (76) |
Consumer and carer journey through service pathways – What works and what doesn’t? What do clinicians think? |
Services
| 36.5 (73) | 34 (64) | 52 (57) |
Care coordination between mental health and physical health |
Comorbidity and Physical Health
| 36.5 (73) | 58 (50) | 1 (89) |
Consumer perspectives on use of labels – Which terms are useful/helpful, which are not? |
Language and Communication
| 38.5 (72) | 69 (44) | 47.5 (59) |
Mental health in culturally and linguistically diverse populations |
Other
| 38.5 (72) | 58 (50) | 32 (65) |
Children of people with mental illness |
Other
| 40 (71) | 29.5 (67) | 38.5 (63) |
Awareness and role of GPs, e.g. engagement with carers, language and communication skills with consumers and carers |
Services
| 41.5 (70) | 62.5 (46) | 15.5 (76) |
Exhaustion and burnout of mental health professionals – Impact on service support and delivery |
Health Professionals
| 41.5 (70) | 34 (64) | 32 (65) |
How many people with mental illness/disability are eligible for NDIS support? |
National Disability Insurance Scheme
| 44.5 (69) | 46.5 (56) | 60 (53) |
What forms of communication work for consumers and carers? (e.g. older people – less technology familiarity; younger people – social media, smart phones) |
Language and Communication
| 44.5 (69) | 84 (30) | 19 (75) |
Care planning – What makes a good mental health plan? (e.g. individualised, including perspectives of consumers, carers and clinicians) |
Treatment
| 44.5 (69) | 34 (64) | 3.5 (84) |
Transparency of clinical management – How does it respond and interact with consumers and carers? |
Treatment
| 44.5 (69) | 58 (50) | 3.5 (84) |
What are the experiences of and needs of people coming off medication? How are they being supported? |
Medication
| 47 (68) | 62.5 (45) | 9 (80) |
How mental health-aware are GPs? |
Health Professionals
| 49.5 (67) | 34 (64) | 38.5 (63) |
What is the role of a GP (perceived and actual) as part of the therapeutic alliance in care of mental health consumers? |
Health Professionals
| 49.5 (67) | 52.5 (55) | 26 (68) |
Stigma around borderline personality disorder |
Stigma
| 49.5 (67) | 81 (33) | 76 (39) |
Stigma as a barrier to consumer involvement |
Stigma
| 49.5 (67) | 46.5 (56) | 43 (61) |
Alternative treatments – What are they, and how can they contribute to recovery? Holistic approaches, meditation, exercise |
Treatment
| 52.5 (66) | 76.5 (36) | 75 (40) |
Learned helplessness (experience with services) |
Other
| 52.5 (66) | 69 (44) | 55.5 (56) |
Consumers and carers – Who is involved? |
Consumer and Carer Involvement
| 55 (64) | 15.5 (78) | 55.5 (56) |
Does the stigma in the mental health system worsen outcomes? |
Stigma
| 55 (64) | 29.5 (67) | 32 (65) |
What is the effect of caring? |
Carers, Family and Friends
| 55 (64) | 5 (89) | 15.5 (76) |
What sources of information do consumers and carers have faith in? |
Language and Communication
| 57 (63) | 81 (33) | 64.5 (50) |
How can medications be tailored to the individual? |
Medication
| 58.5 (62) | 62.5 (45) | 50.5 (58) |
Criteria for prescribing medications |
Medication
| 58.5 (62) | 52.5 (55) | 38.5 (63) |
What are clinician views on peer support? |
Peer to Peer
| 60.5 (61) | 81 (33) | 72.5 (44) |
Risk factors for mental illness |
Other
| 60.5 (61) | 46.5 (56) | 32 (65) |
How can we get mental health and other health professionals to work together more efficiently? |
Health Professionals
| 63.5 (61) | 20 (73) | 50.5 (58) |
Comorbidities and stigma |
Stigma
| 63.5 (61) | 69 (44) | 64.5 (50) |
What changes do people make in their own lives as a result of stigma? |
Stigma
| 63.5 (61) | 46.5 (56) | 55.5 (56) |
Who are the carers and what are they doing? |
Carers, Family and Friends
| 63.5 (61) | 24 (70) | 47.5 (59) |
Translation of clinical frameworks and guidelines into practice – Why is there a disconnect? |
Treatment
| 66 (60) | 52.5 (55) | 38.5 (63) |
Carers and bereavement – Are we offering enough counselling? Is it timely enough? Should it be offered in prisons? |
Carers, Family and Friends
| 67.5 (59) | 9 (80) | 32 (65) |
What is a peer? |
Peer to Peer
| 67.5 (59) | 81 (33) | 86 (19) |
What support is available when pain is a comorbid condition? How are people experiencing that? |
Comorbidity and Physical Health
| 70.5 (58) | 85 (22) | 64.5 (50) |
What is the evidence base linking mental illness with alcohol and other drugs? |
Comorbidity and Physical Health
| 70.5 (58) | 29.5 (67) | 64.5 (50) |
What kind of support would carers like? |
Carers, Family and Friends
| 70.5 (58) | 1.5 (100) | 21.5 (71) |
Is there such a thing as carer recovery? |
Carers, Family and Friends
| 70.5 (58) | 15.5 (78) | 2 (88) |
How do current protocols support consumer and carer journeys to recovery? |
Treatment
| 73.5 (57) | 24 (70) | 69 (47) |
How are Partners in Recovery, Personal Helpers and Mentors, support and clinical management working together? |
Services
| 73.5 (57) | 76.5 (36) | 74 (43) |
Bullying |
Other
| 75 (56) | 81 (33) | 72.5 (44) |
Trial of primary healthcare nurse within mental health teams – Does it improve physical health outcomes? |
Comorbidity and Physical Health
| 76.5 (55) | 74 (40) | 84 (28) |
Analysis of stigma according to disorder |
Stigma
| 76.5 (55) | 69 (44) | 47.5 (59) |
Bereavement |
Other
| 78 (53) | 69 (44) | 82 (31) |
How is ‘privacy’ interpreted by health professionals, and does it differ from consumer and carer interpretations? |
Health Professionals
| 79.5 (52) | 52.5 (55) | 81 (32) |
Stereotype formation |
Stigma
| 79.5 (52) | 58 (50) | 79.5 (33) |
Insurance |
Other
| 81 (50) | 29.5 (67) | 85 (25) |
Gender-specific effects of medication |
Medication
| 82 (47) | 87 (18) | 78 (35) |
Effects of drug and alcohol use early in life |
Comorbidity and Physical Health
| 83 (39) | 69 (44) | 72.5 (44) |
Electroconvulsive therapy – What information is given, does it follow best practice, what are consumers’ experiences? |
Treatment
| 84.5 (31) | 86 (20) | 83 (30) |
Smoking cessation |
Other
| 85.5 (31) | 69 (44) | 87 (7) |
Do the public and private sectors work together? Consumer and carer experiences |
Services
| 86 (30) | 76.5 (36) | 79.5 (33) |
Pet therapy |
Treatment
| 87 (26) | 76.5 (36) | 64.5 (50) |
“I hate to say this but the list [of research priorities] touches directly on most of our carers and consumers involved in the mental health system. Your list shows just how far we have to go to have a first class mental health system…” (Carer 1)
“Where I live … it is really difficult to get a care plan in either the hospital or community setting as the staff do not see the value and feel like they haven't got enough time to do things including writing and reading case notes.” (Consumer/Carer 1)
“I was also treated in quite a paternalistic and demeaning way by [the crisis response] team, hospital staff and other staff around these issues as I was not a family member. The feeling of seeing someone you care for being treated in a completely degrading manner but also realising that no one cares about your voice is very horrible.” (Carer 2)
“Lived experience will really matter to shaping better services, and making sure it's a good cross section of people from various socio-economic backgrounds, genders, ethnicity etc.” (Carer 2)