Background
Methods
Search strategy
Population | Internationally trained nurses (nurses), International medical graduates (doctors), International dental graduates (dentists) working in the UK |
Issues | Migration and integration of the above populations in the UK |
Context | Working in the health care sector |
Outcomes | 1. Migration motives of the nurses, doctors and dentists 2. Barrier and facilitators of Integration of the above populations |
Study design | Eligibility criteria was set for selection of qualitative and mixed method papers Information sources selected Search strategy designed Data collected Quality of papers appraised with CCAT Framework analysis used for meta-synthesis of data |
Column A | Column B |
---|---|
Internationally trained nurses, overseas trained nurses, foreign nurses International medical graduates, internationally trained doctors, foreign doctors, overseas doctors International dental graduates, overseas dental graduates, foreign dentists, overseas dentists International healthcare workers, International health care professionals, foreign healthcare workers, overseas trained health care professionals | Migration, migration motives Integration Adaptation Support Career aspiration Job satisfaction Performance Discrimination |
Quality assessment, data extraction and analysis
Results
Study information | Study Methods | Type of participants |
---|---|---|
Year of publications | Data collection methods n = studies | Professional groups n = studies |
1 January 2000 to 31 January 2017 | Interviews n = 24 Questionnaire surveys n = 8 Focus groups n = 6 Field Observations n = 3 | Internationally trained nurses (Nurses) n = 19 International medical graduates (Doctors) n = 8 International dental graduates (Dentists) n = 1 International nurses and doctors n = 3 |
Country | Methodological approach | Total sample size n = participants |
UK n = 27 UK + EU countries n = 1 UK + EU + International n = 2 UK + International (non EU) n = 1 | Explorative qualitative n = 7 Phenomenology n = 6 Mixed method n = 5 Interpretive phenomenology approach n = 4 Case study n = 3 Grounded theory n = 2 Ethnography n = 1 Not clear n = 3 | Nurses n = 2 202 Doctors n = 517 Dentists n = 5 |
Settings | Sampling | Country of primary qualification represented |
NHS hospitals n = 17 Nursing/care homes n = 4 Training programmes n = 3 Mixed setting n = 3 Primary care n = 2 Adaptation/induction programmes n = 2 | Purposive/theoretical n = 16 Random n = 8 Snowballing n = 4 Convenience n = 2 Not clear n = 1 | Outside EU: Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Caribbean islands, China, Cuba, Egypt, Germany, Ghana, India, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Mauritius, Nepal, Nigeria, Pakistan, Philippines, Russia, Sierra Leone, South Africa, Sudan, Syria, United Arab Emirates, USA, Zimbabwe EU: Austria, Estonia, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Netherlands |
Quality rating and risk of bias
Migration motives of nurses and doctors to the UK
Macro-level driver | |||
---|---|---|---|
Themes and descriptions | Codes | References to clarify the source of the codes | |
UK based | Health system factors (these are factors related to the UK health systems including NHS) | Active recruitment Employment opportunities in the NHS Safety and security of NHS Established networks Support offered for relocation/induction Permit free training | |
Economic factors | Ability to remit money Strength of pound in global economy | ||
Political factors | Bilateral agreement UK referendum vote to leave EU Safety for family/self, fleeing violence Ease of obtaining right to remain Ease of British Citizenship Ease of movement to the UK from EU | ||
Source country based | Health system | Unemployment Underemployment Poor salaries Poor working conditions Overproduction of nurses and doctors | Un/underemployment Poor salaries [41] |
Economic factors | Global recession Devaluation of money Changes to remuneration Remittance to home country | Global recession [30] Devaluation of money [25] Changes to remuneration [41] | |
Social factors | Corruption in everyday life | ||
Political factors | Immigration policies Bilateral agreements Colonial connections | Immigration policies | |
Meso-level | Professional-specific factors (e.g. education/training, job conditions) that frame perceived opportunities in a given occupational sector | ||
UK | Training opportunities | Desire to gain postgraduate training Desire to gain postgraduate qualification Desire to learn the state of the art in the profession Status of gaining UK qualifications and training | |
Employment opportunities | Desire to experience working in a different environment | ||
Career progression opportunities | Opportunities to gain clinical experience through short-term employment Opportunity for research Opportunity for networking | ||
Source country | Training and employment opportunities | Shortage of postgraduate training opportunities Shortage of posts in a particular speciality/profession Natural progression of training | |
Career progression opportunities | Lack of promotion | ||
Micro-level | Individual circumstances and attitudes through which macro- and meso-level drivers are viewed by individuals therefore influencing individuals’ migration decision | ||
Personal fulfilment | Desire for life change Adventure Better quality of life | Desire for life change Adventure [52] | |
Financial gain | Financial gain for self Financial gain for family Financial gain for extended family Desire to increase comparative income | ||
Family factors | Better quality of life for family Better education for children Desire to give children the cultural experience Partners decision to work in the UK Travel to the UK to marry Travel to the UK to escape marriage | Better quality of life for family Better education for children Desire to give children the cultural experience [25] | |
Networks | Access to social networks in the UK Access to professional networks in the UK Influenced by family mentor Influenced by professional mentor | Role of mentor or mentoring [28] | |
Language | Knowledge of English language Desire to improve English language | ||
Window of opportunity | One off opportunity | [25] | |
Migrating stepping stone | Working in the UK is seen as a potential stage in onward migration, primarily to the United States, Gulf countries and Australia | [27] |
Macro drivers
Meso drivers
Micro drivers
Barriers to and facilitators of integration
Main theme based on migrants’ journey | Sub-themes [References] | Barriers to integration | Facilitators of integration |
---|---|---|---|
Adaptation | Motivations for migration not met | Motivations for migration met | |
Registration barriers Employment barriers Lack of professional mentors or networks | Recognition and transferability of qualifications and training Less duration of time for registration and employment Support from professional mentor or network | ||
Lack of social and family network Immigration barriers | Pre-existing social and family networks Right to remain or British citizenship | ||
Mismatched expectations between migrants, managers and organisations | Prior knowledge of destination country and systems Ability to communicate and accept diverse views balance of autonomy and scrutiny | ||
Career progression | Non-recognition of training received in source country Gaps in education caused by migration Variation in education between countries | Adaptation or transitional courses improved education Translation of source country training into UK workplace and its acceptance by employers | |
Good verbal and non-verbal communication skills Good English language skills Good technology-related skills Good interpersonal skills | Self-awareness Opportunities for training in listed skill | ||
Lack of access to NHS training and NHS jobs National and regional variation reducing career choice | Equal opportunities based on merit | ||
Experiences of integration | Discrimination from patients, colleagues, managers and organisations Exploitation in care homes across EU Discrimination in pay Discrimination in progression | Equality and diversity training for all Organisational policy and frameworks to promote equal opportunities Self- actualisation, resilience, focus on long-term goal Moving away from ethnocentric views | |
Lack of personal, professional, social and organisational support networks Lack of mentors and ability to mentor Insensitivity to interpersonal dynamics | Access to formal or informal, professional or social, individual or organisational networks for support Ability to mentor and be mentored Positive feedback loops from patients, colleagues, managers Sensitivity to interpersonal dynamics | ||
Social isolation and lack of international exposure Unwillingness to exchange of knowledge and skills Struggle between self, social and professional identity | Knowledge of behaviours and ability to adapt Interactional styles Health literacy related to the country, population and beliefs | ||
Lack of flexibility Low self-esteem Lack of self-awareness Lack of emotional maturity Insensitivity to interpersonal dynamics Lack of insight and reflection Self-blame and negative psychosocial wellbeing | Personal traits of adaptability, resilience, lateral thinking Sensitivity to interpersonal dynamics Entrepreneurship Focus on long-term goals Positive psychosocial well being |