Background
Inherited retinal dystrophies, which include retinitis pigmentosa (RP), are a group of genetic diseases caused by mutations in over 300 genes and loci (
http://www.sph.uth.tmc.edu/Retnet/disease.htm). RP is a retinal neurodegenerative condition characterized by primary dysfunction and death of photoreceptor cells, resulting in vision loss and, ultimately, blindness [
1]. Although several experimental therapies have advanced to clinical trials (
https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/results?term=retinitis+pigmentosa&Search=Search), neither approved treatments nor preventive therapies for RP are currently available. Its status as a rare disease and its diverse genetic etiology emphasize the importance of identifying shared pathological mechanisms independent of the causative mutation. Targeting common cellular and molecular retinal responses to mutations could benefit a significant number of RP patients, as well as those with other retinal dystrophies without an exclusively genetic etiology (e.g., glaucoma, age-related macular degeneration, diabetic retinopathy). Recent studies suggest that retinal neurodegeneration is associated with a broad inflammatory response in the retina. This response appears to be mutation-independent and involves microglial activation, reactive macrogliosis, and the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines [
2‐
5].
GSK-3 is a serine/threonine kinase that exists as 2 highly homologous isoforms, GSK-3α and GSK-3β, each encoded by a distinct gene. GSK-3β is predominantly expressed in the central nervous system (CNS) [
6]. Although initially identified as a glycogen synthesis enzyme (the role for which it was named), GSK-3 is currently considered a multitask enzyme involved in the regulation of diverse cellular functions owing to its broad substrate spectrum [
7,
8]. In particular, GSK-3 plays a pivotal role in regulating the balance between pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory cellular responses. Consequently, GSK-3 is considered a potential therapeutic target for diseases with an inflammatory component. The therapeutic potential of GSK-3 modulators is currently being studied in a variety of neuroinflammatory diseases. These include psychiatric and neurodegenerative disorders, as well as retinal dystrophies; as part of the CNS, the retina shares many physiological and pathological traits with the brain [
9].
Employing a chemical genetic approach, we recently investigated the neuroprotective effects of 3 chemically diverse GSK-3 modulators in photoreceptor cells [
10]. In the present study we selected one of these compounds, VP3.15, based on its favorable pharmacokinetic and IC
50 properties. This molecule is a 5-imino-thiadiazole that has been described not only as substrate-competitive GSK-3 inhibitor [
11], but also as allosteric inhibitor of PDE7 [
12].
We sought to validate in vivo the potential of GSK-3 as a therapeutic target for the treatment of RP, and to demonstrate the therapeutic potential of VP3.15 in this neurodegenerative condition. We characterized the expression of GSK-3β and its inactive serine-9-phosphorylated form in the dystrophic retina of the rd10 mouse, a model of RP. Moreover, we demonstrated that chronic systemic in vivo VP3.15 treatment preserved visual function by delaying neurodegeneration. Our results indicate that VP3.15 is an innovative drug candidate for the treatment of RP.
Discussion
This study describes GSK-3β expression and activation of the Akt-GSK-3β pathway during the early stages of retinal neurodegeneration in the
rd10 mouse model of RP. Our findings support the involvement of GSK-3 in retinal decay and provide proof of concept of the neuroprotective effect of GSK-3 inhibition on photoreceptor cells [
10]. In vivo administration of VP3.15, a small-molecule GSK-3 inhibitor, reduced photoreceptor cell loss and extended visual function. This neuroprotective effect was accompanied by a decrease in the expression of neuroinflammatory genes in the retina, indicating the potential of VP3.15 as a candidate RP therapy.
GSK-3 is a constitutively activated multitask enzyme, the activity of which is regulated by several inhibitory signaling pathways [
7]. Inhibitory phosphorylation of GSK-3 at Ser9 is one of the main regulatory mechanisms. Our analysis of GSK-3β RNA and protein levels during the degenerative period in
rd10 retinas revealed no differences with respect to WT counterparts. However, at both P19 and P21, by when photoreceptor degeneration is well established, inhibitory phosphorylation of GSK-3β at Ser9, and phosphorylation of its Akt regulator, were increased in
rd10 retinas. This endogenous activation of the prosurvival Akt-GSK-3β pathway in the
rd10 retina is in agreement with previous observations in a photoreceptor cell line subjected to a variety of insults, and in the dystrophic retina [
16,
17]. We speculate that the activation of endogenous prosurvival pathways in the dystrophic retina constitutes an attempt to control the degenerative process, a response that, however, results insufficient to counteract the permanent genetic damage underlying the degeneration. In our experiments, administration of the GSK-3 inhibitor VP3.15 may have exogenously potentiated the prosurvival pathway, thus delaying photoreceptor cell death and preserving visual function. Indeed, several agents with neuroprotective effects in the retina exert common stimulatory effects on the Akt-GSK-3β pathway [
18‐
20]. GSK-3 is a downstream substrate of the insulin receptor [
15,
21] and is thus inhibited upon insulin receptor stimulation. We have previously demonstrated that proinsulin, which binds with high affinity to the A isoform of the insulin receptor in the retina and activates Akt [
22,
23], similarly prolongs rod survival and preserves visual function [
14,
22,
24].
Neuroinflammation is a key component of neurodegenerative processes affecting the brain and retina, and thus constitutes a promising non-cell-autonomous target for treatments of CNS diseases in general, and of the retina in particular [
2‐
5,
25]. GSK-3 plays a pivotal role in the regulation of peripheral and central pro-inflammatory cytokine production [
26,
27], and its inhibition reduces both systemic and brain inflammation [
26,
27]. The specific molecular events that occur in the
rd10 retina upon GSK-3 inhibition remain to be established. This is a complicated task since GSK-3 is implicated in the regulation of multiple cellular processes including metabolism, cell structure, cell death, proliferation, and gene expression, with over 100 confirmed and 500 predicted substrates [
7]. Exploratory studies employing
rd10 retinal explants showed that VP3.15 attenuated NF-kB activation (Additional file
7: Figure S7). NF-kB is a key regulator of the inflammatory response by enabling the transcription of the genes encoding many pro-inflammatory cytokines. Indeed, our results suggest that levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines (
Il1β and
Tnfα) are reduced in VP3.15-treated
rd10 retinas. This could explain, at least in part, the attenuation of photoreceptor degeneration and loss, and the preservation of vision. Moreover, the reduced inflammatory response observed in VP3.15-treated retinas was accompanied by decreases in the reactive gliosis marker GFAP as well as in
α2M expression, for which a role in retinal neurodegeneration has been recently described [
28‐
30].
In addition to its inhibitory effect on GSK-3, VP3.15 also acts as an allosteric inhibitor of PDE7, an effect that contributes to its neuroprotective activity in other CNS pathologies [
13]. However, PDE7 inhibition, via increasing cAMP levels and PKA activation, also converges on GSK-3 inhibition [
31]. PKA is able to phosphorylate GSK-3β at Ser9 and, subsequently, to inactivate it [
20,
31]. Besides, previous findings by our group support that the prosurvival effect of VP3.15 in photoreceptors may be primarily due to GSK-3 inhibition, since the specific GSK-3 inhibitor tideglusib exerted an even more potent neuroprotective effect in photoreceptors [
10].
Most forms of RP involve primary death of rod photoreceptors, in which the mutated gene exerts its function, followed by secondary loss of cone photoreceptors. VP3.15 treatment prolonged photoreceptor survival, as evidenced by the preservation of ONL thickness and rod outer segment length. Furthermore, VP3.15 preserved the integrity of the cone outer segment, the first site of morphological alterations during cone degeneration. Human vision primarily relies on cones, which mediate daylight, color, and high-acuity vision. Accordingly, a mutation-independent treatment for RP that specifically prolongs cone survival would be highly beneficial. VP3.15 had a marked effect on cone cytoarchitecture and visual function, as indicated by an increase in the amplitude of the photopic b-wave compared with the untreated
rd10 animals. It remains unclear whether VP3.15 exerts a direct effect on cone integrity, or whether this effect is secondary to the prosurvival effect on rods (present study and [
10]). Regardless, VP3.15 resulted in a marked attenuation of the loss of both daylight and dim-light vision.
Acknowledgements
We thank Cayetana Murillo, Laura Ramírez and the staff of the CIB animal house and microscopy facilities for technical support. We thank Violeta Gómez-Vicente for advice on GSK-3 immunostaining. We thank Dr. García-Pardo and Dr. Labandeira-García for providing the pNF-κBser536 antibody and the N9 cell line, respectively. ASC and JZD are recipients of UCM and MECD (FPU13-00362) predoctoral fellowships, respectively.