Background
Malaria is caused by the
Plasmodium parasite, which is transmitted to human beings via the bites of infected female
Anopheles mosquitoes. It is prevalent in the tropics and subtropics, particularly sub-Saharan Africa, as well as in Southeast Asia (SEA) and South America. In 2018, there were an estimated 228 million new cases of malaria, which was responsible for approximately 405,000 deaths [
1]. Among them, pregnant women and children under 5 years old in Africa are thought to be the primary victims.
In the 1980s, sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP) replaced chloroquine (CQ) as the front-line anti-malaria treatment when large-scale CQ resistance developed in sub-Saharan African countries. However, SP soon had to be replaced by artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) due to drug resistance. However, SP is still used for intermittent preventive treatment in infants (IPTi) and pregnant women (IPTp) during malaria-endemic regions, following the guidance of the World Health Organization (WHO) [
2]. Furthermore, the administration of SP plus amodiaquine is applied for seasonal malaria chemoprevention (SMC) [
3]. Currently, the emergence, development, and continuous dissemination of
Plasmodium falciparum resistance to the anti-malarial drug is considered a significant global threat for malaria control and elimination strategies [
4]. The development of drug resistance could be influenced by multiple factors, including mutation frequency, treatment costs, drug selection pressure, patient compliance, and host immunity [
5,
6]. It is necessary to conduct molecular epidemiological surveillance and monitoring of drug-resistant
P. falciparum parasites from disease-endemic to nonendemic areas. Molecular markers are a useful tool for confirming that parasites are drug-resistant.
For
Plasmodium spp
., enzymes involved in folate metabolism are interfered with by the antifolate anti-malarial drugs. Pyrimethamine acts as an inhibitor in
P. falciparum dihydrofolate reductase (
Pfdhfr) and sulfadoxine, targets the
P. falciparum enzyme dihydropteroate synthase (
Pfdhps) [
7]. In vitro and in vivo studies have demonstrated resistance to SP is mainly mediated by mutations at codons
Pfdhfr N51
I, C59
R, S108
N, and I164
L, and
Pfdhps S436
A, A437
G, K540
E, A581
G, and A613
S [
8,
9]. SP resistance, with is very common, is accompanied by the accumulation of these mutations [
10‐
12]. In particular, combinations of multiple mutations in both genes, such as the quadruple mutant carrying four partially resistant mutation in combination, are mainly comprised of the
Pfdhfr triple mutant (N51
I/C59
R/S108
N) and
Pfdhps (A437
G). The quintuple mutant genotype includes the
Pfdhfr (N51
I/C59
R/S108
N) and
Pfdhps (A437
G/K540
E). The sextuple mutant consists of a triple mutant (N51
I/C59
R/S108
N) in
Pfdhfr and a triple mutant (A437
G/ K540
E/A581
G) in
Pfdhps, a combination that was called super resistant [
13‐
15]. Multiple combinations of mutations can affect IPTi and IPTp treatment outcomes. Therefore, it is necessary not only to monitor the increase of mutations at a single site, but also to prevent the potential combination of more other multiple mutations.
This study investigated the prevalence of the mutant and wild-type alleles isolated from P. falciparum infecting migrant workers who have returned to Wuhan, central China, who all came from perennial transmission regions from 2011–2019. Such molecular surveillance will provide health authorities with valuable information for adopting efficient anti-malarial drugs in malaria-endemic regions in Africa and malaria nonendemic areas with imported malaria in China particularly Wuhan.
Discussion
Globally, strategies for malaria control have substantially reduced the disease burden in the last few decades. Soon afterward, several nations in Asia (particularly China), Africa, and Latin America began advancing towards malaria elimination [
21‐
23]. However, imported malaria from Africa and SEA has affected and delayed the progress of malaria elimination in China. Furthermore, drug-resistant
P. falciparum parasites will become a significant challeng influencing the process of malaria control, elimination, and eradication. The SNPs in the
Pfdhfr and
Pfdhps genes are linked to the failure of SP treatment against uncomplicated
P. falciparum malaria and have been documented in Africa and SEA for several decades [
10,
11]. However, there are no such data to support drug policies in nonendemic areas with imported malaria in China particularly Wuhan [
24]. To determine whether parasites carrying these polymorphisms exist in Wuhan, molecular surveillance were conducted targeting
Pfdhfr and
Pfdhps gene polymorphisms in imported clinical isolates.
For
Pfdhfr, the critical event in the development of pyrimethamine resistance is a mutation in codon 108 that changes serine (S) to asparagine (N), resulting in partial pyrimethamine resistance. Further mutations at N51
I and/or C59
R increase the level of pyrimethamine resistance [
25]. Under continuous pyrimethamine selective drug pressure, the SNP adaptations in our data have also followed this rule. The current survey demonstrated an extremely high prevalence (> 84%) of three mutations (N51
I, C59
R, and S108
N) in
P. falciparum clinical isolates imported from Africa and SEA. In Africa,
Pfdhfr nonsynonymous polymorphisms have also been reported at high frequencies in isolates from Uganda [
26], Angola [
27], the Democratic Republic of the Congo [
12], Nigeria [
28], and Sierra Leone [
29]. Parasitic infections carrying the
Pfdhfr triple mutant (
IRNI) are significantly more likely to be resistant to SP treatment than infections with fewer
Pfdhfr mutations [
30]. Most of the isolates in our dataset had the triple mutant allele
IRNI (84.4%, 238/282), indicating that pyrimethamine resistance remains at a relatively high level in Africa. However, no mutations in codons 50 and 164 of
Pfdhfr were detected in samples collected on the African continent. An additional mutation, I164
L, confers an elevated level of pyrimethamine resistance that could render SP invalid [
27]. Although the
Pfdhfr I164
L mutation was first reported from Kenya [
31] and then was found in Madagascar [
32] and the Central African Republic [
33], it was not detected in Africa in the present study. Furthermore, only one sample (0.3%, 1/300) with the I164
L mutation was found in 2011 from SEA (Myanmar).
For
Pfdhps, as the key mutation associated with sulfadoxine resistance, a single amino acid residue changes from alanine (A) to glycine (G) at codon 437 of
Pfdhps [
34]. The A437
G selection by SP has been previously described during IPTi [
35]. As the most frequent mutation of
Pfdhps, our findings illustrate the high prevalence of A437
G at 79.0% (229/290), which has also been reported to be nearly at a saturation level in most African countries [
27]. Furthermore, a higher proportion of A437
G has been detected at 75.6% in Gabon [
36], 87.9% in Kenya [
37], 97.6% (1416/1451) in Congo [
12], and 96.4% (27/28) in Nigeria [
28]. Thus, it needs to be kept in mind that a high prevalence of SP-resistant parasites is present in these regions. More attention should be given to SP drug resistance surveillance, both in these countries and in nonedemic areas, particularly Wuhan, which is influenced by imported malaria from endemic areas. Compared to the high prevalence of
Pfdhfr mutations, a low prevalence (< 30%) of four mutant alleles (S436
A, K540
E, A581
G, and A613
S) in
Pfdhps was detected. It has been reported that
Pfdhps K540
E has a low prevalence in Central and West Africa [
9,
14,
28,
33]. In contrast, the K540
E mutation is common in East Africa [
38,
39], similar to our findings. The
Pfdhps A581
G and A613
S/T mutations have been detected at a low prevalence in WA and EA, but a rapid emergence of these mutations has been described in Kenya and Uganda [
25,
33,
40]. Apart from Nigeria and Cameroon, these mutations have not been found in CA [
41]. In Cameroon, there is an increasing trend in the prevalence of the
Pfdhps A581
G and A613
S mutations [
33]. In the current study, the prevalence of A581
G and A613
S were generally consistent with these observations in Africa.
Parasites carrying all five mutations, the
Pfdhfr triple mutant (N51
I + C59
R + S108
N) and the
Pfdhps double mutant (A437
G and K540
E), commonly called the quintuple mutation (
IRNI-S
GEAA), have been strongly associated with SP treatment failure in sub-Saharan Africa [
42‐
45]. Alarmingly, the present study found 18.54% of tested isolates harboured fully resistant (
IRNI-S
GEAA), which is common in EA [
34,
46]. Additional mutations in
Pfdhfr I164
L and
Pfdhps A581
G have been associated with a high level of SP resistance and failure [
47]. However, a quintuple mutant named “super-resistant genotypes” is linked with a more than triple enhancement of therapeutic failure [
47]. The
IRNI-S
GEGA forming the sextuple haplotype has been connected with an optimal resistance effect, referred to as the “super-resistant genotype” [
37]. Three isolates of such genotype are found in our data, which is of concern. In addition, it is noteworthy that the other combined haplotypes, including the quintuple mutant (
IRNI-
AGKAA,
IRNI-S
GKA
S,
IC
NI-S
GEGA), the sextuple mutant (
IRNI
-AGKA
S, N
RNI-
AGK
GS,
IRNI-
AGEAA), and the septuple mutant (
IRNI-
AGK
GS,
IRNL-S
GEGA) were also detected in the current data. Previous studies revealed that
IRNI-S
GEGA,
IRNI-
AGEAA has been highly associated with a lack of IPTp-SP efficacy [
48]. It was illustrated that such genotypes were widely distributed in Tanzania, in line with our study, where one isolate harboured the sextuple haplotype (
IRNI-S
GEGA), which happened to come from Tanzania [
48]. Interestingly, the septuple mutant haplotype (
IRNI-
AGK
GS) accounts for a certain proportion of our findings, which is similar to a previous study reported in Nigeria [
3]. This demonstrates that SP resistance remains at a moderate level in Africa. Although SP is recommended as an effective anti-malarial drug used for the vulnerable population [
35], more attention needs to be paid to these mutations profiles.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.