Skip to main content
main-content

01.12.2011 | Research article | Ausgabe 1/2011 Open Access

BMC Public Health 1/2011

Multi-center feasibility study evaluating recruitment, variability in risk factors and biomarkers for a diet and cancer cohort in India

Zeitschrift:
BMC Public Health > Ausgabe 1/2011
Autoren:
Rashmi Sinha, Carrie R Daniel, Niveditha Devasenapathy, Hemali Shetty, Susan Yurgalevitch, Leah M Ferrucci, Preethi S George, Kerry Grace Morrissey, Lakshmy Ramakrishnan, Barry I Graubard, Kavita Kapur, K Srinath Reddy, Mary J McAdams, Tanuja Rastogi, Nilanjan Chatterjee, Prakash C Gupta, Sholom Wacholder, Dorairaj Prabhakaran, Aleyamma A Mathew
Wichtige Hinweise

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.​1186/​1471-2458-11-405) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors' contributions

The author responsibilities were as follows - RS designed, initiated, and secured study funding, developed analytic strategy, interpreted the results, and drafted the manuscript; CRD, LMF contributed to the development of the analytic strategy, interpretation of results, and drafting of the manuscript; SW, KSR, NC, TR participated in the study design and drafting of the manuscript; ND, HS, PSG implemented the overall site-specific study protocol, such as recruitment, field-work, data collection; BIG provided statistical support; SY, KGM, MJM developed protocols and oversaw data management and analyses; LR oversaw the biological collection protocol and measured biomarkers; KK developed the dietary assessment instrument; PCG, DP, AAM were principal investigators of the three centers and involved in the concept and design of the India Health Study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Abbreviations
AI
Asian Indians
BMI
body mass index
CEB
community enumeration block
DH
diet history
HT
hypertension, HIS: India Health Study
IPAQ
International Physical Activity Questionnaire
PA
physical activity
WHR
waist-to-hip ratio
WTR
waist-to-thigh ratio

Background

According to the World Health Organization, cancer deaths in India are expected to increase 158% by the year 2020. Although overall actual cancer incidence rates are lower in India than in North America and Europe, the rise in cancer-related deaths is likely to present a significant burden to the already overwhelmed health systems. Unique environmental exposures, as well as the genetic variation among people in India, can provide valuable new information on factors that contribute to cancer risk or protect against it [13]. Population heterogeneity by region, socio-economic status, and religion provide the opportunity to evaluate a wide range and variety of dietary exposures not easily studied elsewhere, including unique oils, grains, vegetables, and legumes [3, 4]. Additionally, spices and chilies in Indian foods contain numerous potential chemopreventive agents yet to be comprehensively examined in epidemiologic studies [510].
Epidemiologic studies of diet and cancer in India are primarily of cross-sectional or case-control design and subject to biases, including differential recall of past diet [1117]. Seminal observations in Japanese migrants and other Asian-Americans have motivated epidemiologic research on unique dietary components related to cancer risk, such as soya products [3, 18]. Similarly a prospective cohort study in India could provide insight into the complex relationships between dietary exposures and cancer, as well as provide clues for possible mechanisms [1921]. Thus, establishing a cohort in India could have a major public health impact for global recommendations by shedding light on cancer risk factors, such as obesity, physical activity, reproductive health, and environmental and occupational exposures [1, 2225]. Early findings would be immediately useful to develop preventive strategies in the at-risk Asian-Indian (AI) and South-Asian populations living throughout the world, where diet and cancer incidence patterns remain unique [3, 2632].
Before establishing a population-based prospective cohort of diet and cancer risk in India, evaluation of specific aspects of the study population, infrastructure, and environment are required. We believe a successful "state-of-the-art" cohort in India would include the following constructs: a wide-range or variability in diet and lifestyle exposures to evaluate associations with cancer risk; the ability to assess exposures using the most current and population-specific methodologies; the capacity to collect biological samples prior to cancer onset and treatment (a particularly important issue in India where many cancer cases present at late stages); and a cost-effective and sustainable, long-term design. Furthermore, although India is a rapidly developing country, the infrastructure necessary for such a study may not be adequate and needs to be evaluated. We also saw a need to assess the potential limitations inhibiting both follow-up and the collection of accurate and unbiased endpoints for a prospective cohort in India [described in [33]].
To evaluate the feasibility of a future diet and cancer cohort, we conducted a multi-center pilot study across three diverse regions of India with population-based cancer registries: New Delhi, Mumbai, and Trivandrum. As opposed to seeking a "random sample", we aimed to capture India's unique heterogeneity in diet and lifestyle exposures to facilitate future epidemiologic investigations of cancer risk. Thus, to further maximize the variability in exposures of interest, namely diet, we recruited diverse religious groups known to follow varied patterns of diet and lifestyle practices; and targeted both urban and rural areas in Trivandrum. In New Delhi and Trivandrum, we also evaluated the feasibility and acceptance of biological sample collection. Similar to established prospective cohorts in developed countries [3437], we targeted India's large "middle class" population, which was believed to be more stable and accessible than other class extremes; thus, insuring the longevity and long-term follow-up potential of the cohort. The rapidly growing and evolving middle class in India encompasses a wide-range of ethnicities, education-levels and occupations, as well as varied access to resources, such as nutrition and healthcare. In this population, we evaluated different recruitment techniques; collected detailed information on diet, physical activity, and medical history; conducted anthropometric measurements and medical examinations; and collected biospecimens. Herein, we outline the study design and recruitment procedures, provide the response rates for study assessments, and present initial findings of the regional variation in diet, physical activity, anthropometry, and metabolic markers from the India Health Study (IHS).

Methods

The IHS was conducted between December 2006 and July 2008 in three regions of India: New Delhi in the north (All India Institute of Medical Sciences and Centre for Chronic Disease Control); Mumbai in the west (Healis-Sekhsaria Institute for Public Health); and Trivandrum in the south (Regional Cancer Center). These centers were selected to capture regional variability in diet and lifestyle and to utilize cancer registries meeting the International Agency for Research on Cancer standards [38].
Sampling in the IHS was stratified by gender, religion, and type of residence (urban/rural) (Figure 1) and designed to estimate the mean and range of various foods and nutrients within each strata with the following precision: mean intake of nutrients would lie within 5% of the true intake value with 95% confidence and mean intake of foods would lie within 10 percent of the true value with 95% confidence [39, 40]. To obtain our desired precision for dietary data and satisfy requirements for estimating the participation rate, approximately 200 households per stratum were required.
Participants were eligible if they were aged 35-69 years old, resided in the study area for a minimum period of one year (to minimize participant migration), had no prior history of cancer or cardiovascular event, could speak English or the primary regional language, had no physical ailments that prevented them from fully participating in the study, and were willing to provide biological samples. Females could not be pregnant. We recruited an approximately equal numbers of subjects for each five-year age category, and one male and one female per household for equal gender distribution and cost efficiency.
Human ethics committees from each study center and the Special Studies Institutional Review Board of the United States National Cancer Institute reviewed and approved the study protocol prior to study commencement. Due to the nature of the international collaboration, the Indian Health Ministry Screening Committee for projects involving foreign assistance and/or collaboration, which is part of the Indian Council of Medical Research reporting to the Government of India, also reviewed and approved the study. We obtained written informed consent from all participants.
New Delhi, India's capital, is a metropolitan city spread over 1,483 km2. The IHS was conducted in the South District, the second largest district with 2.3 million residents (16% of New Delhi's total population), covering 16.7% of the city's total area [41]. Of the three subdivisions in this district, Hauz Khas was randomly selected and of the 19 wards, Wards 13 and 11 were randomly chosen. Within these wards, a total of 23 census enumeration blocks were randomly selected for sampling households (Figure2).
We initially attempted to identify households using the 2001 census information, but the houses listed in the census did not match with the existing properties; therefore, we selected an equal number of houses from each lane of a census enumeration block (contains three to five lanes). Of the 1,298 households identified, we successfully interviewed 626 households.
Mumbai (formerly Bombay), the densely populated capital of the state of Maharashtra is divided into suburban districts and the island city, which comprises 15.9% of the greater metropolitan area (76.8 km2) with 3.3 million people [41].
IHS participants were recruited from an ongoing study of mortality, the Mumbai Cohort Study (39, 40) in three representative areas (Parel, Naigaum, Sewri) from Ward F-South (Figure 3). If the cohort member from a selected household had died, moved outside the study area, or was not eligible for the IHS, then a new eligible person, who may or may not have been a cohort member, was recruited from the same or neighboring household. Of the 851 households identified, 687 households were successfully interviewed.
Trivandrum district (or Thiruvananthapuram), the capital of the state of Kerala, is located on the south-west coast of India, and spans 2,192 km2. Trivandrum's 3.4 million people live in four taluks or sub-divisions, which are split into urban areas (34%) and rural panchayats, village councils (76%) [41]. We recruited participants from six urban and 49 rural wards in two taluks (Figure 4).
The wards were selected to maximize the number of Hindu, Christian, and Muslim participants as a proxy for dietary practices. Wards are divided into three or four polling stations and households were identified with voter lists from 2006 that contained the name of the head of household, address, and the number of adult individuals in the household. Of the 4,915 households identified, 1,720 households were successfully interviewed (925 urban, 795 rural).
Before the study recruitment began, the three centers used multiple approaches to introduce the study aims and objectives to the communities. Trained field staff, along with the principal investigators, talked to community and religious leaders, and/or held public meetings in communal areas. In order to standardize the study protocol and implementation, as well as develop a highly-trained and professional staff, we conducted two intensive, week-long protocol development and training sessions. We also instituted a quality control component where principal investigators of the study sites would pay unannounced visits to the field. The community-based mobile clinics or camps, where participants underwent medical examinations and provided biological samples, were staffed by medical doctors and nurses. This was useful to bring attention and credibility to the study's recruitment efforts, as well as to achieve compliance for the different components.

Study visits

Once households were identified, field interviewers visited the homes to determine eligibility, provide information, and schedule a visit. During the first in-home morning visit, the interviewer administered demographic, residential history, physical activity, tobacco and alcohol use, and occupational history questionnaires, as well as a computerized diet history questionnaire (Table 1). Participants usually completed all questionnaires within one hour. In Mumbai, anthropometric measurements were also completed during the first visit. Interviewers in New Delhi and Trivandrum scheduled a second visit and left biospecimen containers with directions for collecting a first morning urine sample and toenail clipping. Biological samples were not collected in Mumbai as the study center did not have laboratory or storage facilities.
Table 1
Field visits and details on questionnaires
Visit
Forms
Details
Pre-visit
Screening
Household Form
Dwelling type, household members
 
Eligibility Screener
Date of birth, gender, language, religion, eligibility information (pregnant, heart attack < 12 months, cancer, hemophilia, willingness to provide blood sample), contact information
 
Non-response Form
Reasons for refusal
Visit 1
Questionnaires after signing consent form
Demographic
Education, mother tongue, marital status, cooking fuel, household appliances, income
 
Food Preparer
Household information on use of 19 spices, chilies (dried and green), coconut, garlic, onions, 13 cooking oils
 
Residential History
Time at current residence, reason for moving to current residence, contact information in case the participant moves
 
Physical Activity
Vigorous activity, moderate activity, walking, sitting during the past 7 days
 
Tobacco Use
Type of tobacco smoked/chewed, length of time using product, quantity used
 
Alcohol Use
Type of alcohol consumed, the length of time using the product, quantity consumed
 
Occupational History
Current occupation, five most recent occupations lasting 6 months or longer, time at each job.
Visit 2
Medical history Physical examination
Medical History
Information on health care provider, medical conditions, medication, family history
 
Reproductive History
Female - menses, sexual activity, pregnancies, contraceptives, hormone therapy
Male - sexual activity, contraceptives
 
Biospecimen Collection
15 ml fasting blood, first morning urine sample, toe nail clippings
 
Anthropometric Measures
Standing and sitting height, weight, blood pressure, waist, hip and thigh circumference, triceps and scapula skinfold
Diet was assessed using a computer-based, interviewer-administered, meal-based comprehensive diet assessment tool known as the New Interactive Nutrition Assistant-Diet in India Study of Health (NINA-DISH) [42, 43]. This software was developed for the IHS by modifying software developed by Novo Nordisk Pharma India (Bangalore, India). The diet history (DH) component included three sections: a set of defined questions similar to a food-frequency questionnaire [44], an open-ended section for each mealtime to collect additional unique regional foods, and a food preparer questionnaire (amount and type of oils, spices, onion, garlic, chilies, and coconuts purchased per household). A subset of participants completed four 24-hour dietary recalls providing information on all foods consumed during the day.
All participants completed the validated, short-form of the International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) about total time spent in physical activity for recreation, occupation, household work, and transportation in the last 7 days [4547]. Total weekly physical activity (metabolic equivalents of task (MET-hr/wk) was calculated as the weighted sum of the reported time spent at each intensity using a MET value specific to each category (walking: 3.3 METs; moderate: 4 METs; vigorous: 7 METs).

Biological sample collection and processing

The second visit was conducted either in mobile clinics within the participant's neighborhood or at the individual's home between six and eight in the morning. The participants completed medical history and reproductive questionnaires, and provided 15 ml of blood, 100 ml of first morning urine sample, and toenail clippings from all toes. As an incentive, we offered to provide the participants with the results from the blood analyses. Blood pressure and anthropometric (weight, standing and sitting height; waist, hip, and thigh circumference; and triceps, sub-scapula and supra-patella skin fold) measurements were also taken. Biological samples were transported to the laboratory in coolers within three-hours of collection. Laboratory technicians processed the samples into fractions as soon as they reached the laboratory (i.e., plasma, serum, blood clot, buffy coat, red blood cells) and stored them in equal aliquots at -80° Celsius. Toenail clippings and Guthrie cards with blood spots were stored in a dry environment at ambient temperature.
Fasting glucose levels were determined with the glucose oxidase/peroxidase method [48] (New Delhi: Randox Laboratories Ltd., Antrim, UK; Trivandrum: Span Diagnostics Ltd., Surat, India). In New Delhi only (all reagents from Randox Laboratories Ltd., Antrim, UK), lipid profiles were analyzed using the following methods: total cholesterol by cholesterol oxidase/p-aminophenazone method, triglyceride by glycerolphosphatase oxidase-peroxidase aminophenazone method, and HDL by precipitation method using phosphotungstate/magnesium-precipitation of apolipoprotein B containing lipoproteins followed by estimation of cholesterol in supernatant by enzymatic method. LDL was estimated using the Friedwald formula [49].

Follow up projections

We calculated the expected numbers of cancer cases over five years per 100,000 people for the eight most common cancers at each of the four IHS location (i.e., Mumbai, New Delhi, Trivandrum rural and urban) by gender (i.e., total cohort of 800,000). For incidence, we used truncated crude rates (35-69 years) and age-specific rates (35-39, 40-44, 45-49, 50-54, 55-59, 60-64 and 65-69) from the Trivandrum Cancer Registry (2005-2006) [50] and the National Cancer Registry Program (2001-2004) for Mumbai and New Delhi [51].

Results

Of the 6,355 adults between ages 35-69 identified, 4,671 met the eligibility criteria. Of the eligible participants, 89% (4,177/4,671) agreed to participate in the studies by signing the consent form. We calculated the response rates using two denominators: all eligible participants (n = 4,671) and participants who provided informed consent (n = 4,177; Figure 5). Of the 4,671 eligible participants, 88% (4,099/4,671) completed all questionnaires, 70% (3,272/4,671) provided anthropometric measurements, and 67% (2,586/3,845) provided all biological samples (New Delhi and Trivandrum only). Of the 4,177 individuals that agreed to participate in the study, 98% (4,099/4,177) provided all questionnaire information, 78% (3,272/4,177) provided anthropometric measurements, and 77% (2,586/3,373) provided all biological samples (New Delhi and Trivandrum only).
Of the study participants, 78% (739/942) in New Delhi and 76% (1,847/2,431) in Trivandrum, provided both blood and urine. Both types of biological samples were provided by a higher proportion of females (83%), as compared to males (71%) and adherence also differed somewhat by religious group (71% of Christians; 81% of Hindus; and 76% of Muslims; data presented in text only). The proportion of individuals who complied with anthropometric measurements also differed by region (New Delhi, 86%; Mumbai, 95%; and Trivandrum, 77%), gender (87% of females and 78% of males), and religion (73% of Christians; 87% of Hindus; and 76% of Muslims; data presented in text only).
The mean age of the 3,908 IHS participants who completed the demographic and diet history questionnaires was 47, 50, and 49 years in New Delhi, Mumbai, and Trivandrum, respectively (Table 2). Approximately 48% of the total study population was male. New Delhi had the highest proportion of participants with a college degree. Across all regions, men had higher levels of education than women. The majority of the population (> 80%) was married; thus, household income did not differ greatly by gender. History of tobacco use varied by region and gender; 36%, 15%, and 50% of men in New Delhi, Mumbai, and Trivandrum, respectively, reported ever having smoked. Smokeless tobacco was primarily used in Mumbai (36% of men, 52% of women), as compared to New Delhi (6% of men, 1% of women) and Trivandrum (7% of men, 4% of women). The majority of households owned televisions and telephones, while hot water heaters, computers, cars, and washing machines were primarily reported in New Delhi. In 83% of the women, menarche began between the ages of 12 to 15, while 14% were aged 16 years or older (described in text only). Less than 2% of the women had never been pregnant, while 32% had more than 4 pregnancies. Parity did not differ substantially by religion, but women with less than a primary school education were more likely to have 4 or more pregnancies (42%), as compared to women with at least a primary school education (16%; described in text only).
Table 2
Selected characteristics of study population by center
Characteristic
New Delhi
Mumbai
Trivandrum
Total (n = 3908)*
n = 839*
n = 768*
n = 2,301*
Age distribution (years), %
   
   Under 40
32
16
21
   40-49
31
31
33
   50-59
23
31
29
   Over 60
14
22
17
Male, %
46
48
50
Religion, %
   
   Hindu
77
58
34
   Muslim
3
< 1
34
   Christian
< 1
6
32
   Sikh
18
< 1
0
   Buddist
0
35
0
   Other
2
< 1
0
Urban
100
100
48
Household monthly income (Indian rupees), %
  
   < 5,000
6
36
69
   5,000-10,000
18
45
27
   > 10,000
76
19
4
Highest education attained, %
  
   Illiterate
6
7
3
   Literate, No formal education
6
1
1
   Primary school
7
6
13
   Middle school
15
24
28
   Secondary school
27
56
46
   Graduate/University
31
5
7
   Post-graduate
8
< 1
3
Married, %
94
81
93
Family members in household
   
   (median, 10% and 90%)
5 (3, 6)
5 (3, 8)
4 (2, 6)
Ever smoked, %
   
   Male
36
15
50
   Female
2
< 1
1
Ever other tobacco, %
   
   Male
6
36
7
   Female
1
52
4
Types of cooking fuel used, %
  
   Firewood
1
0
80
   Gas
100
96
78
   Kerosene
< 1
39
23
Household items, %
   
   Bicycle
28
6
27
   Cable
92
89
61
   Car
24
1
8
   Computer
18
11
8
   Hot water geyser
55
3
1
   Phone
95
87
73
   Refrigerator
87
78
54
   Scooter
63
15
36
   Indoor toilet
90
35
55
   Television
99
96
89
   Washing machine
78
34
12
*3,908 participants had complete demographic and diet history questionnaire information
Missing data excluded from estimates
Food group intake varied widely across the three regions (Table 3). Cereals were widely consumed, but the type varied by region. Participants in Trivandrum frequently consumed fermented rice and rarely consumed wheat products. Compared to relatively low intakes in other regions, unique dietary components by region were fish in Trivandrum, dairy in New Delhi, and pulses (legumes) in Mumbai. Consumption of meat, alcohol, fast food, and soft drinks was scarce in all regions. Fruit and sweet snack intake was also sparse relative to high vegetable consumption. There was also substantial variation in food additives, such as, spices, allium vegetables (e.g., onions, garlic), and cooking oils across the three regions [data not shown; described in [42]]
Table 3
Regional distribution of selected food group intake collected in the Diet History Questionnaire
 
New Delhi (n = 839)
Mumbai (n = 768)
Trivandrum (n = 2301)
 
%
Median**
%
Median**
%
Median**
Food
≥ 1/month*
(10%, 90%)
≥ 1/month
(10%, 90%)
≥1/month
(10%, 90%)
Total Cereals
      
   Total rice products
97.8
3.5 (1.0, 9.0)
98.2
14.8 (7.2, 18.0)
100.0
19.0 (13.0, 22.5)
Fermented rice
< 1
0 (0, 0)
41.9
0 (0, 2.0)
96.9
4.0 (2.0, 7.0)
   Total wheat products
100.0
21.0 (14.5, 28.0)
99.5
21.0 (12.0, 30.0)
80.3
2.0 (0, 8.5)
Refined wheat
64.7
1.00 (0, 6.0)
77.3
3.50 (0, 11.0)
16.2
0 (0, 2.0)
Vegetables
99.7
16.3 (6.0, 28.5)
99.9
20.0 (12.0, 44.0)
99.7
15.3 (7.5, 27.0)
Cruciferous
61.1
0.5 (0, 2.2)
84.5
2.0 (0, 4.0)
78.0
1.0 (0, 3.0)
Potato/starchy
98.8
4.5 (1.2, 10.4)
94.9
3.5 (1.0, 8.0)
92.2
1.5 (0.2, 5.0)
Fruits
83.5
1.8 (0, 8.0.0)
77.6
3.2 (0, 9.2)
83.8
2.0 (0, 8.0)
Banana
38.7
0 (0, 2.0)
68.8
1.6 (0, 4.0)
82.5
2.0 (0, 7.0)
Total Pulses
99.4
6.5 (2.0, 12.0)
99.6
16.0 (9.0, 22.5)
97.7
4.0 (1.8, 7.2)
   Pulses with skin
89.0
2.0 (0, 6.2)
97.3
8.0 (3.8, 12.0)
87.0
1.0 (0, 3.0)
Total Meat
48.4
0 (0, 3.0)
85.8
2.0 (0, 4.0)
80.5
1.0 (0, 3.5)
   Red meat
45.6
0 (0, 1.5)
69.1
0.5 (0, 2.0)
69.4
0.5 (0, 2.0)
Fish
20.8
0 (0, 0.5)
84.8
5.0 (0, 9.0)
98.4
14.0 (6.1, 21.0)
   Dried fish
< 1
0 (0, 0)
56.0
0.5 (0, 2.0)
36.6
0 (0, 1.0)
Total Dairy
98.0
8.0 (1.8, 18.5)
57.9
0.8 (0, 7.0)
72.7
1.0 (0, 7.0)
   Curd/Yogurt
96.4
5.0 (1.2, 14.2)
51.2
0.3 (0, 3.0)
70.4
1.0 (0, 4.0)
Sweet snacks
83.8
1.0 (0, 2.5)
61.2
0.5 (0, 2.5)
61.8
0.4 (0, 2.6)
Savory snacks
78.9
1.2 (0, 4.8)
52.9
0.5 (0, 8.8)
86.3
2.5 (0, 7.8)
Pickled food
68.7
1.0 (0, 7.0)
51.6
0.9 (0, 2.0)
72.6
1.3 (0, 7.0)
Chutneys
65.6
1.0 (0, 5.0)
65.9
1.0 (0, 4.0)
93.5
2.0 (0.8, 3.0)
*Percent of foods consumed more than once a month.
** Median frequency of intake/week (10th and 90th percentile).
Women had a higher mean body mass index (BMI) than men across all regions (Table 4), but the overall anthropometric distribution did not differ substantially by region or religion (data not shown). When defined by a lower cut-point specific to Asian populations (BMI≥25 kg/m2) [52] the prevalence of obesity was close to 50%, while 80% were centrally obese based on the waist-to-hip ratio (WHR). New Delhi participants had the highest BMI and waist circumference and the lowest total physical activity. Across all regions, higher educational attainment was associated with lower levels of physical activity and higher BMI (data not shown). Trivandrum had the highest prevalence (61% in urban areas and 46% in rural areas) of impaired fasting glucose (≥100 mg/dl) [53, 54] and over 25% of the participants in the urban areas could be classified as diabetic (≥ 126 mg/dl), while only 18% self-reported a medical history of diabetes. In New Delhi men and women, respectively, 53% and 48% had total cholesterol levels over 200 mg/dL, and 40% and 30% had LDL to HDL ratios above 4.5.
Table 4
Anthropometric measures, physical activity, and blood markers by study center and gender
 
New Delhi
Mumbai
Trivandrum
     
Rural
Urban
 
Female
Male
Female
Male
Female
Male
Female
Male
 
(n = 451)
(n = 388)
(n = 399)
(n = 369)
(n = 595)
(n = 596)
(n = 550)
(n = 560)
Weight (kg)
62.8 (49, 79)
69.9 (54, 88)
58.2 (44, 73)
63.0 (50, 81)
60.5 (46, 73)
66.2 (50, 77)
62.8 (47, 78)
65.9 (50, 80)
Height (cm)
155 (147, 161)
167 (160, 176)
150 (143, 158)
164 (156, 173)
152 (143, 161)
164 (155, 172)
153 (145, 163)
164 (155, 172)
Physical Activity (MET-hr/wk)
30 (12, 100)
26 (8, 102)
175 (15, 342)
139 (12, 400)
127 (51, 263)
135 (34, 331)
154 (36, 263)
118 (17, 330)
BMI (kg/m2)
26.4 (21, 33)
25.0 (20, 30)
25.3 (20, 32)
23.3 (19, 28)
25.0 (20, 31)
23.8 (19, 27)
26.2 (21, 33)
24.5 (19, 29)
Waist (cm)
92.3 (79, 110)
95.1 (82, 108)
86.7 (72, 103)
88.4 (75, 103)
83.9 (73, 98)
85.0 (74, 98)
88 (74, 102)
86.0 (75, 99)
WHR
0.96 (0.83, 1.03)
0.98 (0.92, 1.05)
0.90 (0.81, 0.98)
0.97 (0.89, 1.05)
0.93 (0.83, 1.02)
0.97 (0.89, 1.05)
0.93 (0.84, 1.03)
0.98 (0.92, 1.06)
WHR High*, %
85
95
80
88
87
88
87
92
WTR High**, %
82
79
-
-
55
62
57
68
FPG, mg/dL
103.0 (86, 140)
103.0 (87, 157)
-
-
92.0 (62, 168)
96.0 (62, 171)
100.0 (71,175)
100.0 (70, 171)
   ≥100 mg/dL, %
61
60
-
-
44
46
63
59
   ≥126 mg/dL, %
15
16
  
17
17
28
25
Diabetes, self-report, %
11
13
10
12
21
25
17
18
Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index; WHR, waist-to-hip ratio; WTR, waist-to-thigh ratio; FPG, fasting plasma glucose; Median (10%, 90%) unless otherwise specified as percent.
*WHR ≥ 0.9 (m) ≥ 0.85 (f); **WTR ≥ 2
Based on existing cancer registry data in India [50, 51] a cohort of 800,000 with 5-years of follow-up would accrue a total of approximately 5,000 cases of the 8 most common cancers (Table 5).
Table 5
Expected number of cases of the most frequent cancers (based on cancer registry data) in a potential cohort of 800,000 people (100,000 per gender and region)
   
Trivandrum
 
Site
New Delhi
Mumbai
Rural
Urban
Total
Male
     
   Oral cavity/pharynx
155
165
255
165
740
   Esophagus
40
45
50
35
170
   Stomach
25
30
85
65
205
   Colorectal
40
40
50
120
250
   Lung
110
60
225
185
580
   Prostate
35
25
35
80
175
 
405
365
700
650
2,120
No. of cancers in males (shown above) by age categories:
    
   Under 40
27
16
15
20
78
   40-49
86
76
120
140
422
   50-59
140
126
340
195
801
   Above 60
152
147
225
295
819
Female
     
   Oral cavity/pharynx
50
75
120
45
290
   Esophagus
30
35
10
5
80
   Stomach
15
15
15
10
55
   Colorectal
30
35
55
50
170
   Lung
30
30
40
35
135
   Breast
315
295
460
370
1440
   Cervix uteri
190
145
140
85
560
 
660
630
840
600
2,730
No. of cancers in females (shown above) by age categories:
   
   Under 40
72
57
100
40
269
   40-49
210
192
260
185
847
   50-59
209
203
275
205
892
   Above 60
169
178
205
170
722

Discussion

We conducted the IHS to evaluate whether a complex multi-center, population-based diet and cancer cohort with multiple questionnaires and biological samples could be implemented in India. The IHS demonstrated that it is feasible to recruit a large number of adults from different regions of India with an ample response rate. Questionnaires, physical examinations, and biological samples (in New Delhi and Trivandrum) were successfully obtained. However, our study also identified areas that require attention before a cohort study could be established in these populations.
We discovered that a large percentage of participants agreeing to take part in an epidemiologic study would complete all components of the study. These findings are noteworthy, as the conventional wisdom at the time the IHS was initiated held that many of the participants would not agree to provide blood or urine samples or to undergo physical examinations. Our results should encourage future researchers in India to collect biological samples, so that results are comparable to other international studies. However, it is important to note that the recruitment was restricted to individuals who agreed to provide biological samples, which could be an important strategy for future studies. Even though this method could lead to recruitment bias, the internal validity of the study results would not be compromised if there is minimal differential loss to follow-up.
The reputation of the local institutes and the professional attitude of the interviewers were critical to obtaining a high participation rate, as individuals often changed their minds regarding enrollment once staff mentioned the name of the affiliated organization. We also used extensive community outreach (talking to village leaders, open meetings in communities) to provide study information. We observed that having uniformed doctors and nurses on the field team engendered trust from participants, especially for biological sample collection and physical examination; and we found that receiving test results (blood pressure, glucose, cholesterol, and hemoglobin) was a cost-effective incentive for enrollment and participation.
We did, however, encounter challenges with collection, transport, and storage of biological samples. In Mumbai, we could not collect biological samples as adequate laboratory and storage facilities were not available. We found that weather was an important factor in the other regions where we collected biological samples. During the summer, it was difficult to keep samples cold, and in Trivandrum, dry ice necessary for shipping samples was not available. In New Delhi, home visits during the winter months presented logistical difficulties for field staff. During monsoon season, visits often could not be completed. Transferring the biological samples for analysis within three hours was achievable in our study, as most of the collection sites were relatively close to the processing laboratory. A similar strategy may be possible in a full-scale study by establishing temporary processing centers and/or mobile clinics. For the purposes of this study, we also found that we needed to set up reliable short- and long-term biological sample storage. We encountered various problems such as the availability of dry ice for shipment of samples to the central repository, electrical outages, diesel fuel shortages for backup generators, and technical support delays during freezer breakdowns. Some of these problems could be ameliorated with the use of liquid nitrogen freezers. Other large cohorts have had to address many of these issues and may provide creative solutions [55].
The diet history data revealed substantial differences in regional food consumption [43]. For the full study population, the diets encompass a wide variety of foods not consumed regularly in other populations (e.g., fermented rice, pulses or lentils, and vegetables). Variability in dietary components added during cooking also provided novel information that may help evaluate some preventive or adverse aspects of the Indian diet [42]. For example, while coconut oil and ghee contain high levels of saturated fat that could be detrimental, mustard seed oils may have beneficial properties [56]. Future studies that assess these food items could provide valuable information on the chemopreventive properties of spices (e.g., curcumin), allium vegetables, and chilies in relation to chronic disease etiology [5, 7, 57, 58].
We also observed variation in lifestyle factors, such as tobacco use and physical activity. Tobacco use varied greatly between the genders, as in India smoking is not considered a socially acceptable behavior for women. In the limited number of women that reported tobacco use, we found that they were more likely to use smokeless products. The regional differences in tobacco use, such as the preference for smokeless tobacco in Mumbai compared to smoking in Trivandrum (namely in men), may be a reflection of the varied distribution of education and/or socioeconomic status across the regions. Physical activity levels were lowest in New Delhi and throughout the regions physical activity appeared to be inversely related to education and income level, perhaps reflecting occupation-related activity and/or use of labor-saving devices.
The IHS population appears to fit the "AI-phenotype" [59], a model of metabolically obese, normal-weight individuals [60]. To account for differences in body composition across different ethnicities, the World Health Organization provides modified cut points for BMI that may be more applicable to Indian and other Asian populations [52]. When using these criteria, just under half of participants in the IHS participants were obese. Compared with Caucasian populations, AIs typically develop metabolic syndromes at lower BMIs, and for any given waist circumference, have increased visceral fat and insulin resistance, but thinner extremities [6163]. Measures approximating the proportion of visceral versus subcutaneous fat deposition (WHR and WTR) may be particularly useful in this population. Using these measures, we found that compared to Western populations more individuals in the IHS were centrally obese, a predictor of type 2 diabetes [64, 65]. In New Delhi and Trivandrum, fasting blood analysis revealed that many IHS participants were pre-diabetic and dyslipidemic; and thus, at high risk for diabetes and cardiovascular disease [62, 66].
It is important to note that our sampling scheme and recruitment methods may have decreased the external validity of our study population, as we encountered several challenges during recruitment. Study personnel had limited access to individuals of higher socioeconomic status [67, 68], as they tended to live in gated communities. Furthermore, we did not include individuals in temporary housing or of very low socioeconomic status from urban areas, due to potential issues with very limited dietary variability (i.e., only cereal) and major challenges with follow-up, particularly for medical outcomes. Since younger, healthier males were more likely to work outside of their homes during the study visit time-frame we may also have higher proportions of women and older individuals. We recognize that an alternative sampling method for selecting individuals from households [69] may be useful in the future to capture a more representative sample. We also realize that while the generalizability or external validity may be an issue, the internal validity of study results would not be compromised if the loss to follow-up was non-differential.

Conclusions

From this feasibility study, we conclude that there is epidemiologic expertise and sufficient infrastructure at these three sites in India to successfully carry out a population-based study of a modest size. However, our current cancer incidence projections suggest that a prospective cohort study investigating the relationship of diet to cancer outcomes would need to recruit close to one million participants to accrue approximately 5,000 cases over 5-years of follow-up, requiring a greater level of manpower and expertise. Epidemiologists, statisticians, study and field managers, computer programmers, dieticians/nutritionists, medical staff, trained interviewers, and laboratory technicians would be needed in greater numbers to expand this feasibility study in its current form. In addition to fully utilizing local expertise, it may also be necessary to expand public health training programs in these areas. Based on our experiences, it would also be crucial to have personnel who understand the cultural and administrative issues at each study site. Biospecimen storage presents a greater logistic challenge. Field stations for processing samples close to the collection sites or mobile clinics may alleviate some of the immediate issues. However, stable biospecimen storage at the study centers, as well as long-term storage at a central repository would also need to be established. Finally, developing a validated computerized system for all study questionnaires should be considered to ease data collection and management, as we found that dietary information could be collected on laptops even in rural settings.

Acknowledgements and Funding

We are indebted to the participants in the IHS for their patience and outstanding cooperation even during the busy times of their day.
This research was supported by the Intramural Research Program of the NIH, National Cancer Institute. The authors would like to thank all the field, laboratory, data-entry, and office staff at the three centers for their dedicated work to make this study possible. Our special thanks go to Sriram Hariharan of Atribs for developing the NINA-DISH software and Puneet Chadda for taking charge of the New Delhi dietary component, and Mangesh Pednekar and Binukumar for their continued support. The network support provided by the team at the Capital Technology Information Services, Inc., Raj Shah, Anil Srivastava, Chirag Shah, Sachin Parikh, and Keyur Shah, was invaluable for the success of the IHS. We would also like to expresses our gratitude to Eric Berger of the Information Management Systems, Inc., and Judy Walsh, Sujata Dixit-Joshi and Viji Narayana of Westat for data management.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://​creativecommons.​org/​licenses/​by/​2.​0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors' contributions

The author responsibilities were as follows - RS designed, initiated, and secured study funding, developed analytic strategy, interpreted the results, and drafted the manuscript; CRD, LMF contributed to the development of the analytic strategy, interpretation of results, and drafting of the manuscript; SW, KSR, NC, TR participated in the study design and drafting of the manuscript; ND, HS, PSG implemented the overall site-specific study protocol, such as recruitment, field-work, data collection; BIG provided statistical support; SY, KGM, MJM developed protocols and oversaw data management and analyses; LR oversaw the biological collection protocol and measured biomarkers; KK developed the dietary assessment instrument; PCG, DP, AAM were principal investigators of the three centers and involved in the concept and design of the India Health Study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Zusatzmaterial
Authors’ original file for figure 1
12889_2011_3217_MOESM1_ESM.jpeg
Authors’ original file for figure 2
12889_2011_3217_MOESM2_ESM.jpeg
Authors’ original file for figure 3
12889_2011_3217_MOESM3_ESM.jpeg
Authors’ original file for figure 4
12889_2011_3217_MOESM4_ESM.jpeg
Authors’ original file for figure 5
12889_2011_3217_MOESM5_ESM.jpeg
Literatur
Über diesen Artikel

Weitere Artikel der Ausgabe 1/2011

BMC Public Health 1/2011 Zur Ausgabe