Background
Methods
Search strategy
-
The article had to have been published in English;
-
The study had to have had a cohort or case-control or proportional mortality study design;
-
Lung cancer should have been reported as a major outcome;
-
The article had to have reported original results along with confidence intervals in the form of standardized mortality ratio (SMR) or standardized incidence ratio (SIR) or odds ratio (OR) or proportional mortality ratio (PMR) or mortality odds ratio (MOR) or relative risk (RR) with their corresponding 95 % confidence interval.
Data extraction
Assessing study quality
Statistical analysis
Results
Characteristics of studies and bias assessment
Author, Year | Country | Industry | Covariates adjusted for | Number of subjects | Outcome examined | Measure, silicotic status | Effect Estimate (95 % CI) | Observed lung cancer deaths or cases | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cohort studies | |||||||||
1 | Amandus, 1995 [25] | USA | Mixed | Age, sex, race, talc, asbestos | 760 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 2.30 (1.50–3.40) | |
2 | Berry, 2003 [28] | Australia | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period, smoking | 1467 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.90 (1.50–2.30) | 94 |
3 | Carta, 2001 [31] | Sardinia | Mine & quarries | Age, sex, calendar period | 724 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.37 (0.98–1.91) | 34 |
4 | Chan, 2000 [33] | Hong Kong | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 1502 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.94 (1.35–2.70) | 33 |
5 | Chen, 1992 [34] | China | Mixed | Age, sex | 70179 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.22 (0.90–1.60) | |
6 | Chen, 1990 [35] | China | Iron mine | Age, sex | 1226 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 5.30 (2.90–8.80) | 14 |
Mortality | SMR, non-silicotic | 2.90 (1.60–4.70) | 15 | ||||||
7 | Chen, 2006 [37] | China | Mine | Age, sex | 932 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 4.13 (3.15–5.29) | |
Mortality | SMR, non-silicotic | 1.96 (1.50–2.73) | |||||||
8 | Chia, 1991 [39] | China | granite | Age, sex, calendar period | 159 | Incidence | SIR, silicotic | 2.01 (0.92–3.81) | 9 |
9 | Chiyotani, 1990 [40] | Japan | Mixed | Age, sex | 1941 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 6.03 (5.29–6.77) | 44 |
10 | Finkelstein, 1982 [10] | Canada | mine | Age, sex, calendar period | 1190 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 2.30 (1.80–3.00) | 62 |
11 | Finkelstein, 1995 [43] | Canada | Mixed | Age, sex | 328 | Incidence | SIR, silicotic | 2.55 (1.43–8.28) | 15 |
Incidence | SIR, non-silicotic | 0.90 (0.51–1.47) | 16 | ||||||
12 | Goldsmith, 1995 [49] | USA | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 590 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.90 (1.35–2.60) | 39 |
13 | Infante- Rivard, 1989 [54] | Canada | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 1072 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 3.47 (3.11–3.90) | 83 |
14 | Marinaccio, 2006 [63] | Italy | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 14929 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.10 (1.03–1.18) | 798 |
15 | Mehnert, 1990 [64] | Germany | quarry | age, sex | 2475 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.83 (0.84–3.48) | 9 |
Mortality | SMR, non-silicotic | 0.91 (0.54–1.44) | 18 | ||||||
16 | Merlo, 1995 [67] | Italy | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 450 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 3.50 (2.44–4.87) | 35 |
17 | Ng, 1990 [71] | Hong Kong | Mixed | Age, sex, PAH, asbestos | 1419 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 2.03 (1.35–2.93) | 28 |
18 | Partanen, 1994 [73] | Finland | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 811 | Incidence | SIR, silicotic | 2.89 (2.35–3.48) | 190 |
19 | Puntoni, 1988 [105] | Italy | Refractory brick | Age, sex | 231 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.67 (0.61–3.64) | 6 |
Mortality | SMR, non-silicotic | 2.08 (0.67–4.84) | 5 | ||||||
20 | Scarselli, 2011 [81] | Italy | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 2034 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.39 (1.17–1.64) | 139 |
21 | Sherson, 1991 [83] | Denmark | Foundry | Age, sex, calendar period | 6144 | Incidence | SIR, silicotic | 1.71 (0.85–3.06) | 11 |
Incidence | SIR, non-silicotic | 1.30 (1.07–1.47) | 150 | ||||||
22 | Tornling, 1991 [88] | Sweden | Ceramic | Age, sex | 280 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 2.36 (1.07–4.48) | 9 |
23 | Tse, 2014 [90] | Hong Kong | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 3202 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.86 (1.59–2.17) | 157 |
24 | Wang, 1996 [96] | China | Metallurgy | Age, sex, calendar period | 4372 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 2.37 (1.96–2.86) | 104 |
25 | Westerholm, 1980 [9] | Sweden | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 3610 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 3.80 (2.30–5.80) | |
26 | Westerholm, 1986 [99] | Sweden | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 712 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 5.38 (2.20–11.10) | 7 |
27 | Yu, 2008 [102] | Hong Kong | mixed | Age, calendar period, smoking | 2798 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 1.56 (0.98–2.63) | 86 |
28 | Zambon, 1987 [103] | Italy | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 1313 | Mortality | SMR, silicotic | 2.39 (1.86–3.02) | 70 |
Case-control studies | |||||||||
1 | Forastiere, 1989 [45] | Italy | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period | 595 | Mortality | MOR, silicotic | 2.50 (1.20–4.60) | 10 |
2 | Fu, 1994 [46] | China | Tin mine | Age, sex, smoking | 267 | Incidence | OR, silicotic | 2.03 (1.25–3.29) | |
3 | Lagorio, 1990 [61] | Italy | Pottery | Age, calendar period, smoking | 391 | Mortality | OR, silicotic | 3.90 (1.80–8.30) | |
Mortality | OR, non-silicotic | 1.40 (0.70–2.80) | |||||||
4 | Neuberger, 1988 [70] | Austria | Mixed | Age, sex, calendar period, area, smoking | 2212 | Mortality | MOR, silicotic | 1.41 (1.21–1.64) | 182 |
5 | Schuller, 1986 [82] | Switzerland | Mixed | Calendar period | 2399 | Mortality | MOR, silicotic | 2.23 (1.90–2.60) | 180 |
6 | Tsuda, 2002 [91] | Japan | Mixed | Age, sex, smoking | 501 | Mortality | OR, silicotic | 2.77 (1.60–4.77) | 184 |
Data analysis
Study design (effect measure) | Number of studies | Effect estimate |
P value of effect |
P value of heterogeneity, Q | I2
|
P value Egger test |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cohort studies (SMR) | 63 | 1.55 (1.38–1.75) | 5.68E-13 | <0.0001 | 96.18 | 0.02 |
Cohort studies (SIR) | 19 | 1.68 (1.45–1.96) | 1.36E-11 | 4.59E-08 | 74.51 | 0.24 |
Cohort studies (RR) | 1 | 1.65 (1.13–2.40) | 0.01 | 1 | 0.72 | |
Case-control mortality studies (OR) | 5 | 1.82 (1.25–2.66) | 0.0017 | 0.1070 | 51.17 | 0.51 |
Case-control incidence studies (OR) | 9 | 1.34 (1.24–1.46) | <0.0001 | 0.2075 | 0 | 0.46 |
Case-control studies (MOR) | 3 | 1.69 (1.26–2.26) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 86.70 | 1.00 |
Proportional mortality studies (PMR) | 2 | 1.10 (0.89–1.36) | 0.38 | 0.10 | 62.02 | 1.00 |
Silicotic studies (SMR) | 24 | 2.32 (1.91–2.81) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 94.34 | - |
Silicotic studies (SIR) | 4 | 2.49 (1.87–3.33) | <0.0001 | 0.377 | 25.04 | - |
Silicotic studies (OR) | 3 | 2.56 (1.84–3.57) | <0.0001 | 0.345 | 2.65 | - |
Silicotic studies (MOR) | 3 | 1.88 (1.31–2.71) | 0.0006 | <0.0001 | 86.98 | - |
Non-silicotic studies (SMR) | 4 | 1.78 (1.07–2.96) | 0.027 | 0.013 | 74.37 | - |
Non-silicotic studies (SIR) | 2 | 1.18 (0.86–1.62) | 0.292 | 0.192 | 41.21 | - |
Subgroup analysis of SMR studies | ||||||
Year of publication | ||||||
≤ 1990 | 16 | 2.37 (1.76–3.19) | 1.24E-08 | 2.92E-94 | 95.58 | 0.35 |
1991–2000 | 21 | 1.44 (1.21–1.71) | 2.97E-05 | 1.25E-30 | 89.89 | 0.16 |
> 2000 | 26 | 1.30 (1.16–1.46) | 1.05E-05 | 9.98E-49 | 93.50 | 0.60 |
Industry | ||||||
Mine | 18 | 1.48 (1.18–1.86) | 0.00 | 4.73E-59 | 97.17 | 0.18 |
Foundry | 4 | 1.51 (0.99–2.29) | 0.05 | 0.02 | 86.53 | 0.75 |
Pottery | 7 | 1.14 (1.05–1.23) | 0.00 | 0.27 | 0.02 | 1.00 |
Cement | 4 | 0.87 (0.42–1.82) | 0.71 | <0.0001 | 84.87 | 0.75 |
Construction | 2 | 1.55 (1.31–1.82) | 1.94E-07 | 0.66 | 0.00 | 1.00 |
Stone & granite | 8 | 1.32 (1.15–1.50) | 6.24E-05 | 0.01 | 65.17 | 0.72 |
Mixed | 19 | 2.03 (1.61–2.56) | 1.68E-09 | 96.95 | 0.73 | |
Country | ||||||
Europe | 26 | 1.54 (1.25–1.89) | 4.95E-05 | 4.09E-33 | 95.70 | 0.13 |
USA | 15 | 1.24 (1.12–1.38) | 6.24E-05 | 5.32E-07 | 79.80 | 0.06 |
Canada | 5 | 2.14 (1.46–3.13) | 9.27E-05 | 2.34E-32 | 95.70 | 0.82 |
Australia | 2 | 1.73 (1.51–1.98) | 7.65E-15 | 0.26 | 19.61 | 1.00 |
Asia | 14 | 1.74 (1.27–2.39) | <0.0001 | 97.56 | 0.75 | |
Occupational confounders | ||||||
Absent | 13 | 1.32 (1.14–1.54) | <0.0001 | 1.79E-13 | 87.15 | 0.06 |
Present | 30 | 1.35 (1.17–1.57) | 7.28E-05 | 7.37E-55 | 94.47 | 0.55 |
Reported measure adjusted for smoking | ||||||
Not adjusted | 61 | 1.55 (1.37–1.75) | 4.16E-12 | 96.37 | 0.02 | |
Adjusted | 2 | 1.83 (1.51–2.22) | 7.23E-10 | 0.43 | 0.00 | 1.00 |
NOS score | ||||||
1–3 | 6 | 2.56 (1.57–4.19) | 0.00 | 2.35E-65 | 96.18 | 1.00 |
4–6 | 35 | 1.57 (1.36–1.82) | 9.02E-10 | 1.68E-80 | 93.07 | 0.45 |
7–9 | 15 | 1.24 (1.01–1.52) | 0.042025 | 1.56E-44 | 97.23 | 0.17 |
Cumulative Silica Dust Exposure (CSDE) (mg/m3years) | ||||||
0 < CSDE ≤ 0.83 | 5 | 1.19 (1.02–1.39) | 0.02 | 0.02 | 68.92 | 0.23 |
0.83 < CSDE ≤ 3.9 | 5 | 1.27 (0.89–1.82) | 0.19 | 1.04E-24 | 97.57 | 0.48 |
3.9 < CSDE ≤ 8.35 | 4 | 1.33 (0.94–1.87) | 0.10 | 2.97E-10 | 91.94 | 0.75 |
CSDE > 8.35 | 5 | 1.36 (0.87–2.13) | 0.18 | 1.15E-21 | 96.33 | 0.82 |
Subgroup analysis of SIR studies | ||||||
Year of publication | ||||||
≤ 1990 | 4 | 2.32 (1.50–3.58) | <0.0001 | 0.07 | 64.63 | 0.75 |
1991–2000 | 6 | 1.77 (1.17–2.69) | 0.01 | 5.07E-09 | 85.81 | 0.47 |
> 2000 | 9 | 1.54 (1.40–1.70) | 8.29E-18 | 0.41 | 17.30 | 1.00 |
Industry | ||||||
Mine | 2 | 1.67 (1.32–2.13) | 2.55E-05 | 0.07 | 69.32 | 1.00 |
Foundry | 4 | 1.40 (1.23–1.58) | 2.67E-07 | 0.52 | 7.15 | 0.33 |
Pottery | 1 | 2.34 (0.62–8.84) | 0.21 | 1 | 0.33 | |
Cement | 3 | 1.34 (1.01–1.76) | 0.04 | 0.43 | 12.61 | 1.00 |
Construction | 1 | 1.50 (1.26–1.79) | 5.04E-06 | 1 | 1.00 | |
Granite | 3 | 1.94 (1.55–2.44) | 1.33E-08 | 0.93 | 0.00 | 1.00 |
Mixed | 5 | 2.13 (1.18–3.87) | 0.01 | 4.08E-05 | 85.96 | 0.82 |
Country | ||||||
Europe | 13 | 1.78 (1.48–2.14) | 1.16E-09 | 9.18E-08 | 77.40 | 0.13 |
Canada | 2 | 1.42 (0.52–3.93) | 0.49 | 0.05 | 74.77 | 1.00 |
Australia | 1 | 1.89 (1.57–2.28) | 2.26E-11 | 1 | 1.00 | |
Asia | 3 | 1.38 (1.10–1.73) | <0.0001 | 0.28 | 6.72 | 1.00 |
Occupational confounders | ||||||
Absent | 3 | 1.94 (1.55–2.44) | 1.33E-08 | 0.93 | 0.00 | 1.00 |
Present | 12 | 1.57 (1.32–1.87) | 4.14E-07 | 4.45E-08 | 80.28 | 0.64 |
NOS grading | ||||||
1–3 | 3 | 1.99 (1.19–3.30) | 0.01 | 0.95 | 0.00 | 1.00 |
4–6 | 11 | 1.55 (1.28–1.87) | 5.74E-06 | 2.36E-08 | 82.02 | 0.76 |
7–9 | 1 | 1.61 (1.21–2.14) | <0.001 | 1 | 0.76 |
Measure | Parameter | k | Estimate |
P value estimate |
P value of Q | I2
| R2
|
p covariates |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Meta-regression analysis of SMR studies | ||||||||
SMR | No covariate | 63 | 1.55 (1.38–1.75) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 96.18 | ||
Univariate model | Year of publication | 63 | 2.30E + 18 (2.41E + 08–2.19E + 28) | 0.003 | <0.0001 | 95.44 | 15.12 | 0.000 |
Industry | 63 | 1.15 (0.86–1.53) | 0.353 | <0.0001 | 95.71 | 8.15 | 0.027 | |
Person-years of follow-up | 22 | 1.53 (1.25–1.87) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 94.73 | 13.4 | 0.050 | |
NOS score | 63 | 3.53 (2.27–5.49) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 95.11 | 19.18 | 0.000 | |
Number of subjects | 63 | 1.69 (1.48–1.92) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 95.43 | 10.89 | 0.008 | |
Total number of deaths | 54 | 1.69 (1.48–1.94) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 95.31 | 13.94 | 0.006 | |
Multivariate model | Industry, year of publication | 63 | 1.07E + 19 (3.85E + 09-2.97E + 28) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 94.65 | 25.51 | <0.0001 |
Industry, year of publication, geographical location | 63 | 1.04E + 20 (4.90E + 10-2.21E + 29) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 94.3 | 28.85 | <0.0001 | |
Industry, year of publication, geographical location, number of subjects | 63 | 1.80E + 17 (1.67E + 08-1.94E + 26) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 93.18 | 37.41 | <0.0001 | |
Industry, year of publication, geographical location, number of subjects, NOS score | 63 | 1.06E + 16 (5.27E + 06-2.12E + 25) | 0.001 | <0.0001 | 93.05 | 37.04 | <0.0001 | |
Industry, year of publication, geographical location, number of subjects, total deaths | 54 | 5.32E + 18 (1.07E + 08-2.65E + 29) | 0.001 | <0.0001 | 92.72 | 34.76 | <0.0001 | |
Industry, year of publication, geographical location, NOS score | 63 | 1.29E + 17 (3.61E + 07-4.61E + 26) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 93.77 | 32.23 | <0.0001 | |
Person-years of follow-up, industry | 22 | 1.22 (0.76–1.96) | 0.408 | <0.0001 | 94.12 | 13.87 | 0.086 | |
Person-years of follow-up, industry, year of publication | 22 | 2.80E + 14 (2.88E-08-2.73E + 36) | 0.198 | <0.0001 | 92.81 | 17.99 | 0.079 | |
Person-years of follow-up, industry, year of publication, geographical location | 22 | 1.55E + 23 (4.66E-02-5.12E + 47) | 0.064 | <0.0001 | 92.31 | 23.08 | 0.056 | |
Person-years of follow-up, number of subjects | 22 | 1.62 (1.31–2.00) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 92.9 | 17.36 | 0.055 | |
Meta-regression analysis of SIR studies | ||||||||
SIR | No covariate | 19 | 1.68 (1.45–1.96) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 74.51 | ||
Univariate model | Year of publication | 19 | 7.92E + 11 (3.71E-02-1.69E + 25) | 0.080 | <0.0001 | 72.31 | 4.27 | 0.086 |
Industry | 19 | 1.37 (0.97–1.95) | 0.077 | <0.0001 | 70.88 | 11.68 | 0.214 | |
Number of subjects | 19 | 1.88 (1.55–2.28) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 69.94 | 18.16 | 0.086 | |
Total number of deaths | 5 | 1.29 (1.05–1.59) | 0.017 | 0.687 | 0 | 100 | 0.017 | |
Multivariate model | Number of subjects, exposure level | 19 | 2.09 (1.47–2.96) | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | 72.12 | 9.02 | 0.197 |
Number of subjects, NOS score | 19 | 3.01 (1.52–5.95) | 0.002 | <0.0001 | 69.36 | 15.16 | 0.087 | |
Number of subjects, industry | 19 | 1.71 (1.03–2.85) | 0.037 | <0.0001 | 70.28 | 10.84 | 0.229 | |
Meta- regression of silicotic studies | ||||||||
SMR | Year of publication | 24 | 7.03E + 21 (5.05E + 04-9.79E + 38) | 0.013 | <0.0001 | 92.23 | 20.55 | 0.014 |
Year of publication, total number of deaths | 20 | 1.59E + 23 (1.60E + 05-1.57E + 41) | 0.012 | <0.0001 | 86.98 | 42.87 | 0.002 | |
Year of publication, total number of deaths, geographical location, industry | 20 | 4.61E + 22 (2.40E + 03-8.85E + 41) | 0.021 | <0.0001 | 86.9 | 33.84 | 0.022 | |
Year of publication, total number of deaths, industry | 20 | 6.07E + 22 (1.43E + 04-2.58E + 41) | 0.017 | <0.0001 | 87.46 | 38.8 | 0.002 | |
Year of publication, total number of deaths, geographical location | 20 | 9.89E + 22 (2.24E + 04-4.37E + 41) | 0.016 | <0.0001 | 86.65 | 38.3 | 0.007 | |
Year of publication, geographical location | 24 | 1.26E + 22 (3.90E + 04-4.08E + 39) | 0.013 | <0.0001 | 92.05 | 16.98 | 0.050 |