Pertussis detection in children with cough of any duration

The diagnosis of pertussis, or whooping cough, in clinical practice continues to be a challenge worldwide as the symptoms are variable [1]. Pragmatically, it is an overlooked cause of cough in children after several decades of universal immunization [2]. The symptoms and its subsequent clinical diagnosis are influenced by age and presence of underlying co-morbidities such as rhinovirus, respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), adenovirus, Streptococcus pneumoniae, Mycoplasma pneumoniae and Staphylococcus aureus, etc. [3, 4]. In addition, immunization status or history of natural infection, presence of passively acquired antibody, and antibiotic treatment may also have a role [3].

Pertussis is caused by the fastidious Gram-negative bacterium Bordetella pertussis [5]. It is estimated that there are 30 to 50 million cases of pertussis worldwide every year, leading to more than 300,000 deaths [6]. Pertussis is a class B reportable infectious disease in China (according to the epidemiological characteristics and damage degree, the law of the People’s Republic of China on the prevention and treatment of infectious diseases divides infectious diseases into three categories: A, B and C). According to data from the Chinese infectious disease reporting system, the incidence of pertussis has been less than 1 per 100 000 since the 1990s with only 2183 and 2517 pertussis cases being reported in 2011 and 2012, respectively [7]. In China, pertussis is mainly diagnosed by the physicians based on the typical clinical symptoms, as most of the Chinese hospitals do not have dedicated specific tests for pertussis(e.g. bacterial culture, serology test and molecular methods). Thus the reported low incidence may be related to the clinical and laboratory methods used for diagnosis, suggesting an underestimation of the disease prevalence.

In studies that have examined the prevalence of pertussis, most focused on children with a persistent cough for ≥2 weeks [8‐10]. There is little data on the prevalence of pertussis in children with an unselected cough duration. Thus, in our prospective study, we sought to determine the prevalence of pertussis in Chinese children irrespective of the cough duration. Furthermore, as data examining the association between clinical features and cough duration of pertussis are still not available, we also explored the clinical characteristics of children with pertussis with different cough durations. Our study’s primary aim was to compare the similarities and differences in the clinical features, microbiology, CRP and peripheral white blood cell count indices among 312 children with acute, sub-acute or chronic cough, with and without pertussis. Our secondary aim was to examine the antimicrobial susceptibility of all the B. pertussis isolates. We hypothesize that pertussis can be found in cough of any duration and that there are distinguishing features among the groups.

Among 320 patients initially approached, eight were excluded because their parents either declined to participate or their specimens were inappropriate. Therefore, a total of 312 patients were finally included in this study. The median age of the 312 children enrolled was 3 months (IQR 3–34), ranging from 1 month to 11 years; 210 (67.3%) were male, and 142 (45.5%) were vaccinated against pertussis in the previous 12 months. Nasopharyngeal swabs were collected from 309 (99%) enrolled children for pertussis culture and PCR analysis. For peripheral blood samples, 298 (95.5%) were obtained for the examination of IgG for anti-pertussis toxin, 217 (69.6%) for anti-pertactin; 289 (92.6%) were obtained for the examination of IgM for Mycoplasma pneumoniae (MP), Chlamydia pneumoniae (CP),Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) and Legionella pneumophilia (LP); and 296 (94.9%) were obtained for full blood count and CRP test. Two hundred and fifty-four (81.4%) sputum samples were obtained for immunofluorescence.

Table 1 presents the prevalence of B. pertussis infection in children presenting with cough. Laboratory confirmed pertussis was most common in the sub-acute group compared to the acute group and chronic group. Anti-PT IgG ≥ 62.5 IU/ml presence was most common in the sub-acute compared to the acute group and chronic group.

The difference in clinical characteristics, microbiology, CRP and peripheral white cell count indices between children presenting with acute cough diagnosed with laboratory confirmed pertussis or not are presented in Table 2. Among the 119 children with acute cough, only two features were significantly different between the groups: apnea and cyanosis. Notably paroxysmal cough was very common in both groups (> 75%) and wet/productive cough was as likely found in the pertussis group as in those without pertussis. The proportion of other pathogens (any virus and Mycoplasma pneumoniae, Chlamydia pneumoniae, Respiratory syncytial virus and Legionella pneumophilia) detected between laboratory confirmed pertussis or not did not show significant differences. There was no significant difference of CRP and peripheral white cell count indices between children with and without laboratory confirmed pertussis.

Table 3 shows the differences of clinical characteristics, microbiology, CRP and peripheral white cell count indices between children presenting with sub-acute cough diagnosed with laboratory confirmed pertussis or not. Among 80 enrolled children with sub-acute cough, whoop was the only featured symptom reported by children who had laboratory evidence of pertussis. Remarkably, paroxysmal cough was also very common in children with sub-acute cough either with or without laboratory evidence of pertussis (> 74%). The proportion of other pathogens (any virus and Mycoplasma pneumoniae, Chlamydia pneumoniae, Respiratory syncytial virus and Legionella pneumophilia) detected between children with laboratory confirmed pertussis or not did not show significant differences. There was no significant difference of CRP and peripheral white cell count indices between laboratory confirmed pertussis or not.

The differences of clinical characteristics, microbiology, CRP and peripheral white cell count indices between children presenting with chronic cough diagnosed with laboratory confirmed pertussis or not are presented in Table 4. No statistical significance in “classic” clinical pertussis symptoms was observed between children with and without laboratory evidence of pertussis. The proportion of other pathogens (any virus and Mycoplasma pneumoniae, Chlamydia pneumoniae, Respiratory syncytial virus and Legionella pneumophilia) detected between laboratory confirmed pertussis or not did not show significant difference. There was no significant difference of CRP and peripheral white cell count indices between laboratory confirmed pertussis or not.

The MIC50, MIC90 and MIC range values of all the 36 B.pertussis isolates to 6 antimicrobials were shown in Table 5. In the test, 72.2% (26/36) of the 36 isolates could not be inhibited by erythromycin and azithromycin at all, and the remaining 10 isolates (27.8%) demonstrated low MICs, and were susceptible to erythromycin and azithromycin interpreted by the breakpoints for H.influenzae. No MIC of B.pertussis isolates to sulphamethoxazole/trimethoprim was more than 1.5 mg/L in the test. The MIC to levofloxacin was no more than 1.5 mg/L in the test. The MIC50 and MIC90 to amoxicillin were 0.75 mg/L and 1 mg/L respectively, and the tested isolates were sensitive to amoxicillin by the EUCAST points. Doxycycline did not show potent action on these isolates in in-vitro test.

We investigated the prevalence and clinical characteristics, CRP and peripheral white cell count indices of pertussis in children irrespective of the cough duration. In 312 children with cough presenting to the in- and out-patient departments of one large Chinese hospital, 97 (31.1%) children had laboratory evidence of pertussis. Although confirmed pertussis was found in all cough duration groups (acute, sub-acute and chronic), it was significantly higher in those with sub-acute cough. Among those acute cough, apnea and cyanosis were significantly more common in those with pertussis; whilst in children with sub-acute cough, whoop was the sole statistically significant factor. In the chronic cough group, none of these factors were significant between groups.

There is little data on the prevalence of pertussis in children based on cough duration. We found laboratory confirmed pertussis in all the different cough duration groups, but significantly higher in the sub-acute group than in the acute or chronic groups. Although the classic symptoms of pertussis were more common in the lab-confirmed pertussis group, most of these features were also present in the children without pertussis. A multicenter study of epidemiological data of pertussis infection among adolescents and adults with a cough of a duration≤30 days reported 6.9% of enrolled patients had pertussis infection. The classic symptoms of pertussis were present in confirmed cases or not [18], but the investigation of the incidence rate of pertussis was based on age groups, and the cases with persistent and chronic cough were not included in this study. A New Zealand prospective study of school-age children (aged 5–16 years) and adults (17–49 years) with cough of 2 weeks duration or greater reported 10% (23/225) had pertussis infection and neither cough duration nor any individual presenting symptom discriminated those with pertussis from those due to other causes [19]. The prevalence of pertussis was based on age groups and cases with cough of less than 2 weeks were not included in this study.

There is little published data that has described the clinical characteristics in children with pertussis of various cough duration. We found that apnea and cyanosis were more common in the acute cough group, whilst whoop was more common in the sub-acute cough group. However, we did not find any specific characteristic in the chronic cough group. This highlights that a “one-size-fits-all” clinical case definition is not appropriate as also described by several others [16]. Indeed, a growing body of evidence suggests that the existing WHO clinical case definitions of pertussis(a case diagnosed as pertussis by a physician, or a person with a cough lasting ≥2 weeks with ≥1 of the following symptoms: paroxysms (ie, fits) of coughing, inspiratory “whooping”, and posttussive vomiting (ie, vomiting immediately after coughing) without other apparent cause [16]) may be not appropriate anymore.

The spectrum of illness for pertussis can vary widely with atypical pertussis commonly found in adolescents, adults, and in infants under 1 year of age [20, 21]. A small study of 76 adult patients with cough of more than 2 weeks found 14 patients (18.4%) had laboratory evidence of pertussis infection, and classic symptoms of pertussis were not significantly common in confirmed patients [22]. A case-control study in children0 to 18 years of age found only 42% of confirmed cases met a clinical definition of pertussis and typical symptoms were not common in confirmed cases, and the atypical symptoms were likely moderated by high immunization rates or may have been caused by other respiratory pathogens [23]. A small study of 7 neonates with confirmed pertussis by bacterial culture reported cyanosis and apnea were the characteristic symptoms displayed after 4–7 days of the onset [24].These findings may reflect that ‘classic’ symptoms of pertussis may not necessarily be evident, and that clinical symptomatology is influenced by patient age, immunization status and underlying co-morbidities, but the clinical characteristics of patients with pertussis of different cough durations were unreported in these studies. With consideration of patient age, immunization status and underlying co-morbidities, our study found clinical symptomatology of pertussis was associated with cough duration. Our results raise questions regarding the possible need to reexamine the existing diagnostic criteria for pertussis, and possibly identify new sets of criteria specific to particular subgroups based on cough duration.

In our study, other than culture and PCR, we detected IgG for both anti-PT and anti-PRN. Pertussis toxin is secreted exclusively by B. pertussis, whereas it is now clear that antibody response to pertactin also occurs following other Bordetella infections, so that isolated increases in titers of antibody against pertactin are not specific for B. pertussis infection. For this reason, the measurement of anti-PT antibodies is recommended [5]. In our study, a child was considered to have probable B. pertussis infection when an anti-PT IgG ≥ 62·5 IU/ml if the patient had not had the vaccination against pertussis in the previous 12 months [17].

In the 36 B.pertussisisolates detected, macrolide resistance with MIC > 256 mg/L was high, consistent with a previous study in China [12].Currently, marolides are recommended as first line antibiotics for the treatment of pertussis [25, 26] and sulphamethoxazole/trimethoprim as the second choice [27‐29]. Our results suggest that amoxicillin maybe an alternative for children with marolide-resistant B.pertussis infection and that local sensitivities are required to inform clinical practice.

A strength of our study is the detailed co-detection of other pathogens that may exist with pertussis. Our study has many limitations. Firstly, we did not analyze how co-infection of other pathogens influence the cough symptoms. Secondly, we limited children enrolled under 14 years old, and we did not recruit children with alternative etiologies (e.g. cystic fibrosis, immune deficiencies), because these children might also get pertussis. Thirdly, we did not do chest X-ray interpretation/comparisons and not conduct a specific age breakdown for apnea and cyanosis because of small sample size. Fourthly, we did not have data from asymptomatic healthy controls. Further our study was limited to a single-center study and may also not be representative of all children.

Several findings of the current study were important for clinical practice: (a) laboratory confirmed pertussis can be present in children irrespective of cough duration; (b) children with pertussis with different cough durations have clinical features that are influenced by the child’s age and immunization state; and(c) those with chronic cough have nonspecific cough, lacking characteristic symptoms. This may suggest that in the context of the likely underestimation of the burden of pertussis, the “one-size-fits-all” clinical pertussis case definition is no longer optimal to recognize this disease in a population and large comprehensive studies of children with all types of cough is required to confirm or refute our findings. This may make substantial inroads into increasing both the sensitivity and specificity in pertussis diagnosis, will impact public health.