Preface to Guidelines: Laparoscopic treatment of ventral and incisional hernias by the International Endohernia Society (IEHS)

Several months ago Dr. R. Bittner, as the European Editor, approached me with the request that Surgical Endoscopy publish the “Guidelines on the Laparoscopic Treatment of Ventral and Incisional Hernia” that was prepared by the International Endohernia Society (IEHS). I was quite receptive to this request for several cogent reasons: (1) the authorship represents the best known and respected international experts on hernia surgery, (2) the methodology used was solid, soliciting two experts who were assigned a specific topic with related search questions for each of the systematic reviews, and (3) the process had been transparent, culminating in confirmation by a consensus conference held at an international meeting of the IEHS involving all participants together with the international audience. There was a problem, however. The document was far too detailed and lengthy for journal publication. Therefore, after consultation with his coauthors, Dr. Bittner agreed to reduce the document by half, agreeing to publication of some of the material only in the online version of Surgical Endoscopy. The abridged version was completed in a few weeks. As editor and objective reviewer, I consider the result to be excellent as now the guidelines document is more focused without loss of substance and with minimal repetition, which is inevitable in a multi-author document containing several systematic review chapters. …