Resting and feeding preferences of Anopheles stephensi in an urban setting, perennial for malaria
verfasst von:
Shalu Thomas, Sangamithra Ravishankaran, N. A. Johnson Amala Justin, Aswin Asokan, Manu Thomas Mathai, Neena Valecha, Jacqui Montgomery, Matthew B. Thomas, Alex Eapen
The Indian city of Chennai is endemic for malaria and the known local malaria vector is Anopheles stephensi. Plasmodium vivax is the predominant malaria parasite species, though Plasmodium falciparum is present at low levels. The urban ecotype of malaria prevails in Chennai with perennial transmission despite vector surveillance by the Urban Malaria Scheme (UMS) of the National Vector Borne Disease Control Programme (NVBDCP). Understanding the feeding and resting preferences, together with the transmission potential of adult vectors in the area is essential in effective planning and execution of improved vector control measures.
Methods
A yearlong survey was carried out in cattle sheds and human dwellings to check the resting, feeding preferences and transmission potential of An. stephensi. The gonotrophic status, age structure, resting and host seeking preferences were studied. The infection rate in An. stephensi and Anopheles subpictus were analysed by circumsporozoite ELISA (CS-ELISA).
Results
Adult vectors were found more frequently and at higher densities in cattle sheds than human dwellings. The overall Human Blood Index (HBI) was 0.009 indicating the vectors to be strongly zoophilic. Among the vectors collected from human dwellings, 94.2% were from thatched structures and the remaining 5.8% from tiled and asbestos structures. 57.75% of the dissected vectors were nulliparous whereas, 35.83% were monoparous and the rest 6.42% biparous. Sporozoite positivity rate was 0.55% (4/720) and 1.92% (1/52) for An. stephensi collected from cattle sheds and human dwellings, respectively. One adult An. subpictus (1/155) was also found to be infected with P. falciparum.
Conclusions
Control of the adult vector populations can be successful only by understanding the resting and feeding preferences. The present study indicates that adult vectors predominantly feed on cattle and cattle sheds are the preferred resting place, possibly due to easy availability of blood meal source and lack of any insecticide or repellent pressure. Hence targeting these resting sites with cost effective, socially acceptable intervention tools, together with effective larval source management to reduce vector breeding, could provide an improved integrated vector management strategy to help drive down malaria transmission and assist in India’s plan to eliminate malaria by 2030.
Hinweise
Shalu Thomas and Sangamithra Ravishankaran contributed equally to this work
Various factors like host preference, resting and feeding behaviour, adult longevity and density, human biting rate and host location strategy influence the role of mosquitoes in malaria transmission [1]. The state of Tamil Nadu had 8714 malaria cases in 2014, of which 337 (3.86%) were Plasmodium falciparum and the remaining 8377 (96.13%) P. vivax [2]. Almost 70% of the malaria cases recorded in Tamil Nadu occur in Chennai [3]. Malaria is endemic in Chennai, transmitted by the urban vector, Anopheles stephensi, which breeds predominantly in overhead tanks besides, other water storage habitats [4], and lesser examined rain fed clear water habitats. The transmission is unstable, but perennial with seasonal peaks mainly in July to August and then from October to November [5]. The present study was done as a part of the project on ‘Center for the Study of Complex Malaria in India’ (CSCMi) where transmission dynamics (micro environmental profile, immature and adult vector density, host, resting and breeding preferences of the vector mosquitoes) and eco-epidemiology of malaria (clinic study to investigate the impact of complex malaria on disease outcome in symptomatic individuals and community study to determine the incidence and prevalence rate of complex malaria including asymptomatic malaria) in urban transmission settings [6]. The main objective of this study was to find the feeding and resting preferences of An. stephensi and its transmission potential in a malaria endemic area of Chennai with perennial transmission.
Methods
Adult vector collections
The study site, Besant Nagar (13.0002°N, 80.2668°E) is a residential area with slums adjacent to the seashore in the southeastern part of Chennai; it is distinctly characterized by its meso-endemic perennial transmission of malaria, predominantly P. vivax, by the Asiatic urban malaria vector, An. stephensi. Human dwellings (tiled, asbestos and thatched houses) and cattle sheds were surveyed from January to December 2014 in order to find the resting and feeding preferences besides, infectivity rate of the primary vector, An. stephensi. The study site indicating cattle sheds were georeferenced and human dwelling collection sites along with malaria incidence of 2014 is represented in Fig. 1. Cattle sheds were classified according to type of roof structures such as asbestos, thatched and concrete, visited on two consecutive days in a fortnight in the dusk during the study period using flashlight and a mouth aspirator (Table 1). A total of 17 cattle sheds were selected for yearlong survey. However, six were surveyed on regular basis (66.1% of total surveys), while other sheds were surveyed randomly (33.9% of total surveys) depending on the availability and accessibility to survey. In each cattle shed, 15–30 min were spent depending on the size/area of the cattle shed and presence or absence of mosquitoes at the time of collection. The fortnightly man hour density (MHD) is plotted against malaria incidence data of 2014, obtained from the Regional Office for Health and Family Welfare (ROH & FW), Besant Nagar, Chennai and corresponding temperature and relative humidity (using Onset HOBO data logger–U10-003) from a longitudinal temperature study carried out in parallel (Fig. 2).
Fig. 1
Study site with GPS plots of cattle sheds, human dwellings and malaria incidence of 2013–2014
Table 1
Anopheles stephensi collections from varied structure types of cattle sheds (by IRC) and human dwellings (by PSC)
Resting habitats
Roof types
No. of times surveyed
No. of times positive for resting habitats with Anopheles stephensi
n (%)
No. of Anopheles stephensi collected
Abdominal conditions
Unfed
Freshly fed
Late stage fed
Semi gravid
Gravid
Cattle sheds (n = 17)b
Asbestos (n = 6)
79
46 (58.2)
474
34
30
371
24
15
Concrete (n = 7)
46
14 (30.4)
75
3
3
68
1
0
Thatched (n = 3)
38
14 (36.8)
96
2
5
66
20
3
Rooflessa (n = 1)
20
10 (50.0)
98
3
7
61
22
5
Human dwellings (n = 245)c
Tiled (n = 6)
6
1 (16.7)
2
0
0
0
0
2
Thatched (n = 188)
188
28 (14.9)
49
5
0
23
9
12
Asbestos (n = 51)
51
1 (2.0)
1
1
0
0
0
0
aOpen with concrete wall
bSampling repeated
cOne time survey
Fig. 2
Man hour density of Anopheles stephensi with temperature, relative humidity and malaria incidence in Besant Nagar, Chennai for 2014
×
×
Anzeige
In addition, Pyrethrum spray sheet collections (PSC) were done in human dwellings with different roof types such as thatched, asbestos, and tiled, randomly selected in and around the malaria endemic area of about 3.5 km north–south and 2.5 km east–west direction [4]. They were surveyed on weekly basis to check the presence of resting adult vector mosquitoes, if any. Attempts were made to collect vector mosquitoes in concrete structures too. Since Anopheles mosquitoes were not observed, collections were focused on thatched, asbestos and tiled structures only. The collections were done during dawn (6.00–7.30 a.m.) in five to seven houses, spending 20–30 min for each house on every occasion. Indoor resting collections (IRC) were also performed with the help of mouth aspirator and flashlight, though it was not successful due to sparse sample count (Table 1). A few Anopheles subpictus specimens, caught during the fortnight collections were also screened to determine the presence of malaria parasites.
Abdominal condition, age structure, host seeking preferences and infectivity
The collected mosquitoes were identified to the species level following standard identification keys [7, 8], females enumerated and graded based on their abdominal conditions. The late stage fed, gravid and/or semi-gravid appearance of the abdomen were considered as resting stages, while the unfed guts and/or freshly fed as feeding stages [9]. The fortnight man-hour density (MHD) of An. stephensi was calculated by dividing the total number of female mosquitoes collected by total time spent for a particular fortnight for 1 h period i.e., (Total female An. stephensi collected/Total time spent) ×60. Out of 634 (late stage fed and freshly fed mosquitoes together), 548 i.e., 86.4% (Table 1) were processed for blood meal analysis. After smearing the blood from the abdomen of female mosquitoes on Whatman filter paper (No. 1), the head and thorax of the mosquitoes were processed for circumsporozoite sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) following the Malaria Research and Reference Reagent Resource Center (MR4) protocol [10]. The dried blood spots were analysed by counter-current immunoelectrophoresis method [11]. A proportion of unfed and gravid females were immediately screened for the presence of sporozoite by dissecting the salivary glands and midguts for oocysts and the age structure or parity (gonotrophic status) of the vector population was ascertained by dissecting the ovaries and examining the tracheoles. All the dissections were done following the standard MR4 protocols [12]. The remaining unfed and gravid females were also processed for CS-ELISA.
Results
The adult vectors (An. stephensi) were predominantly found resting in cattle sheds that were in close proximity (<5 metres distance and often with shared walls) to human dwellings. Fewer mosquitoes (both in terms of absolute numbers and frequency of structure types found positive) were collected from human dwellings. The adult vector density was relatively stable across the year, though with a maximum count observed during the first fortnight of June.
Mosquitoes were found in all types of cattle sheds (i.e., whether they were asbestos structures, concrete, thatched, or roofless sites with concrete walls). On the other hand, in 245 surveys of human dwellings, anopheline mosquitoes were rarely found and these tended to be encountered in thatched structures as opposed to tiled or asbestos structures. Among 882 Anopheles specimens collected from cattle sheds, 743 (84.2%) were An. stephensi (all female) and the remaining 139 (15.8%) were An. subpictus and Anopheles vagus. Out of 94 Anopheles species collected from human dwellings, 52 (55.3%) were An. stephensi, 41 (43.6%) An. subpictus and 1 (1.1%) An. vagus. 49 (94.23%) of the An. stephensi collected were from thatched structures followed by 2 (3.85%) from tiled structures and the remaining 1 (1.92%) from asbestos roofed house. When the abdominal conditions of the vector mosquitoes collected were examined, it was found that, among the mosquitoes collected from cattle sheds, 5.7% were unfed, 6% freshly fed, 76.2% of late-fed stage, 9% semi-gravid and the rest 3.1% gravid. Interestingly, 88.3% of the vectors found to be resting were late stage fed, semi gravid and gravid stages, while 11.7% were feeding stages (unfed and freshly fed). Similarly in human dwellings, 88.5% were late stage fed, semi gravid and gravid, while 11.5% were feeding stages. The freshly fed females were collected while they were feeding on cattle. The resting stage of vector mosquitoes were 7.5 times more than the feeding stages.
Anzeige
Host-seeking preference of vector mosquitoes
Blood meal analysis was done using counter-current immunoelectrophoresis technique and the results are depicted in Table 2. Among the vector mosquitoes collected during 2014, 530 mosquitoes from cattle sheds and 18 from human dwellings were analysed for origin of their blood meal. Of 548 samples, 518 (94.5%) had bovine blood meal while only five were positive for human blood (four from human dwellings). Blood meal origin of 25 samples was unknown and the Human Blood Index (HBI) was 0.009. In contrast, Bovine Blood Index (BBI) was 0.95.
Table 2
Host seeking preference, Plasmodium vivax and Plasmodium falciparum infectivity of Anopheles stephensi
Resting habitats
Host seeking preference
Proportion of infectivity
No. of samples analysed
Bovine
Human
Mixed
Unknown
No. of samples analysed
Pv 210 n (%)
Pv 247 n (%)
Pf
n (%)
Cattle sheds
530
518
1
0
11
720
3 (0.4)
0 (0.0)
1 (0.1)
Human dwellings
18
0
4
0
14
52
1 (1.9)
0 (0.0)
0 (0.0)
Total
548
518
5
0
25
772
4 (0.5)
0 (0.0)
1 (0.1)
Age structure and malaria parasite infection in vector mosquitoes
About 200 females were dissected to check the presence of oocysts and sporozoites besides, age structure. None of them were found to harbor oocysts and sporozoite infections. Further, when the parity was checked, 57.75% of the dissected vectors were nulliparous, whereas, 35.83% were monoparous and 6.42% biparous. Cattle shed and household mosquito samples were processed for sporozoite detection by CS-ELISA and the results are shown in Table 2. A total of 772 samples collected during 2014 (720 from cattle sheds and 52 from households) were analysed for vector incrimination. Of these, five were found to be infected with the malaria parasites (four P. vivax 210 infected—three from cattle sheds and one from human dwelling) and one P. falciparum infected (collected from cattle shed). Sporozoite positivity rate was 0.648 and 1.92% of An. stephensi collected from human dwellings were infected. The P. falciparum infected mosquito sample was collected during February 2014 whereas, P. vivax infected samples were obtained during October, November and December. However, P. vivax infected sample from human dwelling was collected during March 2014. Furthermore, 135 An. subpictus samples collected during the study period were subjected to vector incrimination using CS-ELISA and one P. falciparum infection was detected.
Discussion
In the present study, vectors were more abundant in outdoor structures (cattle sheds) than human dwellings. Wherever mosquitoes were found indoors, there appeared to be a preference for thatched structures, possibly due to the availability of eaves and crevices, which provide suitable/preferential hideouts and conducive humidity [13, 14]. Previous studies in Sri Lanka, Tanzania and Gambia, revealed poor housing similar to thatched structures to be associated with increased entry and resting of mosquitoes with high malaria incidences [13]. In addition, thatched structures mainly belong to households with low socio-economic status and these households tend to use fewer repellents against nuisance mosquitoes. Use of repellents has been associated with less malaria in a clinic study carried out in Chennai [15].
Abundance of vectors in cattle sheds confirms the previous finding of An. stephensi that, it prefers animal sheds for feeding besides, resting in Chennai [16‐18]. It was observed that 96.77% of the cattle sheds were with shared walls (<5 metres distance) from the nearest human dwelling. The proximity of the cattle sheds to human dwellings indicates, even though the human host was so close, the mosquitoes perhaps were lured to cattle/animals for their blood meal as there was no repellent or any mosquito prevention method and therefore, the animals were easily bitten by vector mosquitoes. This was reflected in the blood meal analysis, which showed the vector mosquitoes preferring animal blood. The results of the blood meal analysis indicated the selective preference of vectors on animal blood as the mosquitoes preferred the cattle population, even though human hosts were abundant when compared to the former [19]. However, studies carried out in Iran reported endophagic and endophilic behaviour of An. stephensi [20].
Further, the human blood meal samples collected from cattle sheds, support the previous reports that, after feeding on human blood, An. stephensi used animal sheds for resting which would help in completing its gonotrophic cycle [17]. Four of the five infected mosquitoes were collected from cattle sheds/outdoors. In the present study, it is assumed that An. stephensi selected cattle sheds as foraging and as an ideal resting habitat. The density of resting adults was low, which is the same elsewhere in many urban cities/towns in India [4, 21, 22].
The sporozoite positivity rate observed was very low despite perennial transmission of malaria over a period of time. This might be due to the incomplete knowledge of resting preferences [23, 24], which means the current study probably underestimates the density of infectious mosquitoes. However, the relatively low infectivity rate in the mosquitoes could also be due to the fact that this area has a moderate to low transmission rate, or the infected mosquitoes undergo enhanced mortality [25‐28]. The parity analysis supported the fact that, survival of the adult mosquitoes in the study area was limited. This was in line with studies carried out elsewhere that only 10% of the adult population survives to the epidemiologically relevant age [29, 30]. In Solomon Islands, P. falciparum was detected from 15.2% of 1-parous Anopheles farauti mosquitoes, using PCR detection method [31]. Another study in Benin showed that, the infected females were at least of biparous stage of physiological age [32].
The results of ELISA (Table 2) showed that, P. falciparum infection was observed in mosquitoes collected during February, and P. vivax infection in mosquitoes collected during October, November and December. Being a malignant parasite, presence of P. falciparum in mosquitoes during relatively low transmission season (Fig. 2) underlines the importance of having intense active surveillance irrespective of seasons. However, with such low sample sizes it is difficult to draw any conclusions regarding seasonality or potential links to microclimate data [23].
Anopheles subpictus infected with malaria parasite is yet another interesting finding as this is the first report of vector incrimination of An. subpictus from Chennai. In India, sporozoite positive specimens were collected from a coastal village in the state of Tamil Nadu [33]. Anopheles subpictus was previously believed to be a benign species because of its zoophilic nature, though it was reported to be a vector in Sri Lanka and a secondary vector in Indonesia [34‐39] and elsewhere, in Madhya Pradesh [40], Odisha [41] and urban area of Goa [42]. P. falciparum infection in An. subpictus indicates that it is a competent vector when favourable condition arises. Considering urban malaria, this finding is important as this can pose a real problem in future along with the primary/major vector, An. stephensi in Chennai.
Anzeige
Limitations
The present study was centered on human dwellings and cattle sheds and the latter was found to be preferred resting place of the local vector. As the current understanding of the other resting preferences are obscure as far as the local vector is concerned, there are chances that the present estimates of vector density and sporozoite rate may underestimate the true picture in Chennai.
Conclusion
The study revealed that adult vectors feed predominantly on cattle and also rest in cattle sheds. The UMS of the national programme focuses on larval source management, by carrying out anti-larval operations in breeding habitats of the urban malaria vectors. This strategy has additional benefits of contributing to Dengue and Chikungunya control as some of these habitats, like cisterns, are co-inhabited by An. stephensi and Aedes aegypti [4]. In rural areas, adult vector surveillance and control with indoor residual spray (IRS) or long lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) often focus on indoor domestic dwellings. The present study indicated that human dwellings (other than thatched structures) are not the preferred resting sites of the urban malaria vector. Rather, mosquitoes appear to be most readily found resting in cattle sheds and feeding on cattle. A recent theoretical study identified that in areas where residual malaria transmission is sustained by zoophilic vectors, even modest amounts of control that explicitly target these vectors may dramatically reduce transmission [43]. Therefore, targeting these resting sites with appropriate, cost effective intervention tools that are socio-behaviourally acceptable, coupled with effective larval source management to reduce vector breeding, could create opportunities for improved integrated vector management strategies that will help drive down malaria transmission and assist in India’s plan to eliminate malaria by 2030.
Authors’ contributions
AE designed the experiment with inputs from MBT, JM, MTM and support from NV. ST participated in study design and wrote the manuscript with AE. JAJ and AA performed the vector sampling in the field and ST, SR, AA and JAJ performed laboratory works and contributed to data analysis. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Acknowledgements
We thank NIMR and ICMR for providing the necessary facilities and support. We gratefully acknowledge the staff of the NIMR field unit, Chennai; the communities of Adyar, Besant Nagar, Thiruvanmiyur for permitting us to carry out the adult as well as immature vector collections in their premises. We gratefully acknowledge the Regional Office for Health and Family Welfare (ROH & FW), Besant Nagar, Chennai for providing us the Malaria incidence data for the study period. We thank Dr. Jane Carlton for her valuable suggestions and support. This work was supported by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health (NIH) Grant U19AI089676, an International Center of Excellence for Malaria Research. The content of this manuscript is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the NIH. The financial assistance of CSIR (Junior Research fellowship), New Delhi to Ms. Shalu Thomas for this study is thankfully recalled.
Anzeige
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
The dataset generated during and/or analysed during the current study available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The manuscript does not involve the use of any animal or human data or tissue. However, institutional ethical clearance of the project was obtained from National Institute of Malaria Research of Indian Council of Medical Research, New Delhi (ECR/NIMR/EC/2010/100).
Funding
The work was supported by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health (NIH) Grant U19AI089676. The content of this manuscript is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the NIH. The financial assistance as Junior Research fellowship was provided to ST from Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, New Delhi.
Anzeige
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
Resting and feeding preferences of Anopheles stephensi in an urban setting, perennial for malaria
verfasst von
Shalu Thomas Sangamithra Ravishankaran N. A. Johnson Amala Justin Aswin Asokan Manu Thomas Mathai Neena Valecha Jacqui Montgomery Matthew B. Thomas Alex Eapen
