Background
The plant RNA silencing-based defense enlists a complex set of proteins to combat intracellular parasites, including viruses, retrotransposons, and other highly repetitive genome elements [
1]. This defense cascade is commonly triggered by intracellularly formed double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) or partially double-stranded stem-loop RNA. These are processed by Dicer-like (DCL) nucleases into small RNAs of discrete sizes (21–25 nucleotides [nt]), referred to as small interfering RNAs (siRNAs).
siRNAs are not the end product of the cascade. Rather, they are the sequence specificity determinants of RNA-induced silencing complexes (RISC), directing Argonaute (AGO) proteins in RISC to cellular RNA or DNA complementary to the siRNAs. This process silences corresponding genes or genetic elements through targeted cleavage, repression of translation, or DNA methylation [
2,
3]. In some eukaryotes, such as plants and fungi, cellular RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RDR) acts to convert aberrant RNAs to dsRNA, leading to small RNA amplification and more intensive RNA silencing [
4‐
6].
RNA viruses produce dsRNA as a replication intermediate, thus rendering them targets of RNA silencing [
7]. DCL2 and DCL4 are largely responsible for processing viral dsRNAs into small pieces, termed virus-derived siRNAs (vsiRNAs), which can then be incorporated into RISC [
8‐
15]. The resulting “aberrant” viral RNA cleavage products are thought to be substrates for plant RDR proteins, which subsequently generate more dsRNA [
6]. The major contributors to the production of secondary vsiRNAs are RDR1, RDR2, and RDR6 [
16]. Determining which AGO proteins are involved in defenses against RNA viruses has been the subject of a number of studies. In an in vitro assay,
Arabidopsis AGO1, AGO2, AGO3, and AGO5 showed antivirus activity against a member of the genus
Tombusvirus. In addition, specific AGOs (e.g., AGO1, AGO2, AGO3, AGO4, AGO5, and AGO9) were shown to selectively bind small RNAs derived from viroids or viruses [
17‐
20]. These results suggest that multiple AGO proteins have the intrinsic ability to target viruses. Several AGO mutants were shown to increase susceptibility to viruses [
21]; examples include AGO1 mutants and cucumber mosaic virus (CMV), turnip crinkle virus (TCV), and brome mosaic virus [
15,
22‐
24]; AGO4 mutants and tobacco rattle virus [
25,
26]; and an AGO7 mutant and TCV [
15]. Among them, AGO2 appears to be a major player in RNA silencing against viruses and has been implicated in defense against CMV, TCV, tobacco rattle virus, potato virus X (PVX), turnip mosaic virus (TuMV), and tomato bushy stunt virus [
20‐
28]. In addition, AGO5 appears to play a secondary antiviral role in the absence of AGO2 [
10,
14]. Meanwhile, attenuated viruses with mutated virus silencing suppressors have also been used to identify plant factors involved in antiviral silencing, including DCL2, DCL4, AGO1, AGO2, DRB4, RDR1, RDR6, and HEN1 [
6,
12,
16,
20,
27,
28]. The aforementioned studies have been mostly performed with
Arabidopsis and
Nicotiana benthamiana. Whether RNA silencing-related genes have similar functions and roles in crop plants is worthy of investigation.
Potato virus X is a type member of the genus
Potexvirus (Alphaflexiviridae). Potato virus X (PVX) predominantly infects
Solanaceous plants. Plants belonging to the Brassicaceae family are generally not considered to be hosts for PVX. Recent studies employing
Arabidopsis thaliana revealed that RNA silencing is the chief determinant of the non-host immunity against PVX. Indeed, inactivation of DCLs (DCL2 and DCL4) or AGO2 enable PVX to efficiently infect
A. thaliana plants [
9,
23,
29]. Another study demonstrated that the full restriction of PVX requires AGO5 in addition to AGO2 [
30].
Potato virus Y is a type member of the genus
Potyvirus, family Potyviridae [
31]. Potato virus Y (PVY) is a flexuous rod-shaped virus; its genome consists of a single-strand positive sense RNA (length: ~ 9.7 kb), which contains two opening reading frames (ORFs) encoding 12 proteins. One large ORF encodes a polyprotein that is cleaved into 10 functional proteins. A second small ORF, located in the P3 cistron in a different frame, encodes a polypeptide termed PIPO (Pretty Interesting Potyviridae ORF). Two proteins (P3N-PIPO and P3N-ALT) are expressed through the RNA polymerase slippage mechanism in the P3 cistron [
32‐
37].
The tomato (
Solanum lycopersicum) is an important vegetable crop and a model plant for the research of fruit development and plant defenses [
38], including virus-derived/induced RNA silencing and plant systemic gene silencing. There are 7 DCLs (DCL1, 2a, 2b, 2c, 2d, 3 and 4), 15 AGOs (AGO1a, 1b, 2a, 2b, 3, 4a, 4b, 4c, 4d, 5, 6, 7, 10a, 10b and 15), and 6 RDRs (RDR1, 2, 3a, 3b, 6a and 6b) encoded in the tomato genome [
39]. An analysis of tomato DCL1 and DCL3-silencing mutants indicated that DCL1 produces canonical miRNAs and a few 21-nt siRNAs [
40], while DCL3 is involved in the biosynthesis of heterochromatic 24-nt siRNAs and long miRNAs [
41]. DCL4 is required for the production of 21-nt tasiRNAs that in turn target the ARFs to alter tomato leaf development [
42]. Numerous DCL2 genes (i.e., DCL2a, DCL2b, DCL2c, and DCL2d) are encoded in tomato [
39]. Recently, the DCL2b-dependent miRNA pathway in tomato was shown to affect susceptibility to PVX and TMV [
43]. DCL2b is also required for the biosynthesis of 22-nt small RNAs to defend against ToMV [
44].
In this study, we examine the virulence of PVX and PVY in transgenic tomato plants, in which the expression of the DCL2, DCL4, AGO2, AGO3 and RDR6 genes was suppressed. Our aim in this study was to investigate whether these RNA silencing-related genes are involved in tolerance or defense against infection with these viruses in a crop plant.
Discussion
Silencing the DCL and AGO genes altered the reactions of a susceptible tomato plant to infection with PVX and PVY. The symptoms of PVX infection were exacerbated in DCL2, DCL4, AGO2 and AGO3-knockdown transgenic tomato plants. We observed more severe dwarfing and leaf deformation in hpDCL2.4, more severe mosaics in hpDCL2.4 and necrotic systems in hpAGO2.3 plants, compared with those in the PVX-inoculated other transgenic and wild-type plants. On the other hand, infection with PVY caused symptoms only in hpDCL2.4-knockdown plants, but not in the other transgenic or wild-type plants. RT-PCR tests showed that all PVY-inoculated plants were systemically infected with PVY, indicating that the tomato cultivar Moneymaker is susceptible to infection with PVX and PVY. These results suggest that DCL2, DCL4, AGO2 and AGO3 are involved in tolerance to infection with PVX and PVY in a susceptible tomato plant. Note that, considering the significantly increased levels of DCL2b and DCL2d mRNA in PVX-infected hpDCL2.4 plants, more severe symptoms are not necessarily caused by the downregulation of the DCL genes in plants. The higher levels of these DCL mRNAs may be attributed to the activation of their transcription [
52‐
54], as well as the suppression of RNA silencing by PVX infection, and miR6026, which is produced by and targets DCL2s [
43].
DCL2, DCL4, AGO2 and AGO3 are important factors in the RNA silencing-mediated antiviral defense [
12,
15,
20,
27,
33,
55]. Therefore, it is likely that these factors contribute to tolerance through their roles in antiviral RNA silencing. This would be the case for the tolerance to infection of two strains of PVY (i.e., PVY
N and PVY
O), involving DCL2 and DCL4. Western blotting was only able to detect PVY CP in inoculated hpDCL2.4 plants though it detected PVY CP at 40 dpi. RT-PCR consistently detected PVY genomic RNA in lower PCR cycle numbers and time-course experiments in samples from inoculated hpDCL2.4 plants, although all inoculated plants were systemically infected with PVY. There results indicate that the higher accumulation of PVY observed in hpDCL2.4 plants can probably be attributed to the reduced activity of RNA silencing against PVY. DCL proteins possess RNase III activity to generate small RNAs, such as siRNAs and microRNAs (miRNAs) [
55], and silencing or mutations in DCLs would affect siRNA biogenesis. We recently showed a defect in the biogenesis of siRNAs, especially 22 nt siRNAs, derived from viroid RNA in hpDCL2.4 plants infected with the potato spindle tuber viroid [
44]. Studies have reported the increased accumulation of CMV genomic RNAs [
12] and increased susceptibility to PVX and the TuMV helper component-protease mutant in
Arabidopsis DCL double (DCL2 and 4) and triple mutants (DCL2, 3, and 4) [
56]. Increased accumulation of TuMV and CMV genomic RNAs was observed in DCL2- and DCL4-knockdown
N. benthamiana [
56]. Silencing of DCL4 facilitates the systemic movement of
Zucchini yellow mosaic virus in
N. benthamiana [
54]. These studies indicate that DCL2 and DCL4 restrict the multiplication of viruses in susceptible plants. In this study, tomato DCL2 and DCL4 also did not completely prevent infection with PVY. However, they efficiently restricted infection to reduce the occurrence of symptoms in a susceptible cultivar.
Tolerance to infection with PVX does not appear to be attributed to the roles of DCL2, DCL4, and AGO2 in antiviral RNA silencing. This conclusion was based on the absence of obvious difference in CP and genomic RNA levels among hpDCL2.4, hpAGO2.3 transgenic and wild-type tomato plants (Fig.
4a). PVX has a relatively weak RNA silencing suppressor, triple gene block protein 1 (TGBp1) [
57], and may have ability to escape or survive under active conditions of antiviral RNA silencing [
58]. This ability may partly explain the absence of an obvious increase in PVX accumulation in DCL2.4 and AGO2 plants (Fig.
4b). RNA silencing is one of the major antiviral defense mechanisms involved in the regulation of numerous endogenous genes via siRNAs and miRNAs [
59]. Thus, symptom exacerbations may be attributed to differences in the expression of endogenous genes via the knockdown of DCL2, DCL4, AGO2 and AGO3. We recently showed that symptom exacerbations in hpDCL2.4 plants infected with potato spindle tuber viroid could be attributed to the increased expression of miR398a-3p, which increased the production of reactive oxygen species [
44].
Interactions between PVX and AGO2 have previously been studied. Similar symptom exacerbations, including systemic necrosis, have been observed in the AGO2-knockout
N. benthamiana using CRISPR/Cas9 [
60]. The
Arabidopsis Col-0 plant is a non-host for PVX; however, PVX becomes capable of multiplication in inoculated leaves following mutation of AGO2 [
23]. P25, also known as triple gene block protein 1 (TGBp1), suppresses RNA silencing [
61,
62], which can be partly explained by P25 binding to and directing the degradation of AGO1 via the 26S proteasome [
63]. Studies have shown that P25 has an affinity for AGO2 [
23,
63]. On the other hand, necrosis or cell death associated with infection with PVX or closely related viruses that belong to the genus
Potexvirus has been reported. Infection with PVX triggers hypersensitive cell death responses in potato plants carrying the Nb gene, and P25 is the elicitor of these responses [
64]. TGBp3 induces the unfolded protein response during infection with PVX. This effect is important in the regulation of cellular cytotoxicity that could otherwise lead to cell death if the viral proteins reach high levels in the ER [
65,
66]. An isolate of the plantago asiatica mosaic virus causes systemic necrosis in
N. benthamiana, and its RNA-dependent RNA polymerase is a virulence determinant for necrotic symptoms [
67]. Additionally, an isolate of the PVX-OS strain induced systemic necrotic mosaic in
Nicotiana spp, and the 1422 amino acid C-terminal of its RNA-dependent RNA polymerase is a determinant of systemic necrotic mosaic symptoms [
68]. Co-infection with PVX and PVY causes systemic necrosis in tobacco plants, and PVX P25 and PVY helper component-protease have been identified as determinants for necrotic symptoms [
69]. Recently, systemic necrosis was correlated with an enhanced expression of lipoxygenase activity in PVX and PVY co-infected plants [
70]. Lipoxygenase acts on polyunsaturated fatty acid substrates in the first step of the biosynthetic pathway of jasmonic acid, a hormone involved in the execution of hypersensitive response cell death in tobacco [
71]. Downregulation of double-stranded-RNA-Binding Protein (DRB2) by VIGS is able to reduce PVX-triggered systemic necrosis in ago2 mutant
N. benthamiana [
72].
These previous studies may help reveal the mechanism through which AGO2-knockdown alters the expression of endogenous genes and which host and viral genes involved in the development of necrotic symptoms during infection with PVX.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.