Lutein is a carotenoid that may play a role in eye health. Human milk typically contains higher concentrations of lutein than infant formula. Preliminary data suggest there are differences in serum lutein concentrations between breastfed and formula-fed infants.
Aim of the study
To measure the serum lutein concentrations among infants fed human milk or formulas with and without added lutein.
Methods
A prospective, double-masked trial was conducted in healthy term formula-fed infants (n = 26) randomized between 9 and 16 days of age to study formulas containing 20 (unfortified), 45, 120, and 225 mcg/l of lutein. A breastfed reference group was studied (n = 14) and milk samples were collected from their mothers. Primary outcome was serum lutein concentration at week 12.
Results
Geometric mean lutein concentration of human milk was 21.1 mcg/l (95% CI 14.9–30.0). At week 12, the human milk group had a sixfold higher geometric mean serum lutein (69.3 mcg/l; 95% CI 40.3–119) than the unfortified formula group (11.3 mcg/l; 95% CI 8.1–15.8). Mean serum lutein increased from baseline in each formula group except the unfortified group. Linear regression equation indicated breastfed infants had a greater increase in serum lutein (slope 3.7; P < 0.001) per unit increase in milk lutein than formula-fed infants (slope 0.9; P < 0.001).
Conclusions
Breastfed infants have higher mean serum lutein concentrations than infants who consume formula unfortified with lutein. These data suggest approximately 4 times more lutein is needed in infant formula than in human milk to achieve similar serum lutein concentrations among breastfed and formula fed infants.
Introduction
Lutein is a carotenoid that selectively accumulates in the macular region of the retina and protects retinal cells required for vision [16]. Humans cannot synthesize lutein and thus all lutein in the human body comes from dietary sources. Studies in adults have revealed that dietary or supplemental lutein leads to variable increase both in serum lutein and in macular pigment [8, 13]. Some epidemiological evidence suggests lutein may reduce the risk of age-related macular degeneration [22, 24].
Lutein may be important well before adulthood. Lutein is present in cord blood at the time of newborn delivery indicating placental transfer to the fetus, and cord blood concentrations are highly correlated to maternal serum concentrations [28]. Lutein is present in human donor eyes as early as 17–22 weeks gestation [1, 9]. After birth, breastfed infants receive lutein from mother’s milk [2]. At 1 month of age there are differences in serum lutein concentrations between breastfed and formula-fed infants [14]. This finding is plausible because there are higher concentrations of lutein in human milk than in infant formulas. Infant formulas contain a small amount of innate lutein contributed by ingredients in the formula.
Anzeige
A next step in understanding lutein nutrition in early life is to determine serum lutein concentrations of exclusively breastfed and formula-fed infants. The aim of this study was to examine serum lutein concentrations in infants fed human milk or formulas unfortified and fortified with lutein. This study is unique because it is the first prospective study of serum lutein concentrations in healthy full-term infants consuming different concentrations of lutein in formula in comparison to serum lutein concentrations in human milk fed infants.
Methods
Subjects
This 3½ month double-masked, parallel, prospective 12 week feeding study enrolled exclusively formula-fed and breastfed infants. Infants were recruited from hospitals and pediatric practices in the Portland, Oregon area. Oregon Health and Science University Institutional Review Board approved the study protocol and the informed consent form. Infant inclusion criteria included: healthy singleton term infants (37–42 weeks gestation) between 9 and 16 days of age, parent or guardian of formula-fed infants agreed to feed assigned study formula ad libitum, and breastfeeding mother’s agreed to exclusively breastfeed for duration of study. An inclusion criterion for a breastfeeding mother was a self-reported consumption of 6 or more ½-cup servings per week of dark green vegetables, which are a rich source of lutein [11]. To verify consumption, each breastfeeding mother at study entry completed a validated, semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaire [4]. Questionnaires were analyzed at the Harvard School of Public Health and lutein intake was calculated from the Harvard University food composition database derived from the USDA Survey Nutrient database plus other sources.
Study formulas
The lutein fortification concentrations targeted for this study were 25, 100, and 200 mcg lutein per liter of formula. These concentrations were chosen because they are within the range of lutein concentrations observed in the largest, multinational study of breast milk carotenoids [2]. Study formulas were analyzed several times during the trial to monitor actual lutein content in the formulas over time. Lutein was present in the raw material and the innate amount of lutein was ~20 mcg/l, which contributed to the final lutein concentration in the formula. Thus, the four study formulas contained the following average concentrations of lutein as confirmed by analysis: 20 (unfortified), 45, 120, and 225 mcg/l. At enrollment, formula-fed infants were randomized to one of these four study formulas, all of which were based on Wyeth S-26 Gold (Askeaton, Ireland). The source of lutein for the fortified formulas was FloraGLO® lutein 20% liquid in safflower oil (Kemin Industries, Inc., Des Moines, Iowa). The lutein in this material was supplied as purified oleoresin obtained from the extraction, purification, and crystallization of oleoresin from the marigold flower. A saponification step in the processing created free lutein from lutein esters. Study formulas were supplied as ready-to-feed liquid in 250 ml tetrabriks with (per l): 14.3 g protein, 73 g carbohydrate, 36 g fat, and 672 calories. All formulas contained approximately 135 mcg/l of beta-carotene, and other micronutrients did not differ among the formulas.
Human milk and serum samples
Human milk was collected using an Avent ISISTM breast pump (Philips Avent, London, UK) [5] at mid-afternoon from each breastfeeding mother the day before study visit weeks 4, 8, and 12. A single, mid-afternoon sample of breast milk represents the average 24-h concentration of lutein [6]. The mother expressed the sample into clean bottles and stored it in the home freezer until the study visit the following day.
Anzeige
Serum lutein concentrations were determined from infant blood samples collected at baseline and week 12. Whole blood (1–2 ml) was obtained from each infant by venipuncture by a registered pediatric phlebotomist or by heel stick by a pediatric registered nurse.
Human milk and serum samples were stored at −80 °C at the study site in a cryobox for light sensitive specimens, shipped on dry ice to a contract bioanalytical laboratory (Craft Technologies, Inc., Wilson, North Carolina), and verified frozen on arrival. Samples were stored at −70 °C before being analyzed. All laboratory lights were covered with ultraviolet filters to protect samples from degradation. Human milk was analyzed for milk lipid concentration determined by creamatocrit [17] and carotenoid composition.
Lutein and beta-carotene analyses
Serum concentrations of lutein and beta-carotene were measured by Craft Technologies using high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with multiwavelength photodiode-array absorbance detection as previously described [19]. A 150 μl volume of serum was mixed with an equal volume of buffer and then mixed with two volumes of ethanol containing the internal standard (tocol). Lutein and beta-carotene were extracted from the aqueous phase into hexane. The combined hexane extracts were dried under vacuum. The extract was redissolved in ethyl acetate and diluted in mobile phase. An aliquot was injected onto a C18 reversed phase column and eluted isocratically. The analytes possess absorbance that is proportional to their concentration in solution and therefore these properties were used for quantitative analysis. Lutein and beta-carotene were measured by absorbance at 450 nm. Chromatograms were recorded using a computer data system. Analytes were quantified by external standard quantitation using neat standards to calculate response factors based on the peak area of the analyte. The quantities of analytes were corrected for recovery post-run based on the internal standard. Coefficient of variation was less than 7%.
Concentrations of these analytes in human milk were determined after saponification of the samples. An aliquot of milk sample was mixed with potassium hydroxide in methanol (with pyrogallol added as antioxidant) and allowed to stand overnight in a refrigerator to hydrolyze lipids. Each sample was then extracted by use of tetrahydrofuran and hexane; the combined extracts of each sample were evaporated under vacuum and the residue was dissolved and analyzed by reversed-phase HPLC as described above.
Statistical methods
Human milk and serum lutein concentrations were not normally distributed and data are presented as geometric means and 95% two-sided confidence intervals. Linear regression was performed to analyze the relationship between lutein in the milks and lutein in serum at week 12. Linear regression analyses were performed with and without baseline serum lutein concentrations in the model. Final regression lines do not include baseline serum lutein concentrations as a covariate.
Results
The mean (SD) age at study entry was 13 (±2.0) days. A total of 40 infants were enrolled, including 14 human milk-fed and 26 formula-fed infants (Table 1). Eighty-five percent (34/40) of enrolled infants completed the study. Six infants did not complete the study due to the following reasons: 2 infants were lost to follow-up; 2 families moved out of the area; 1 infant was no longer exclusively human milk-fed, and 1 formula-fed infant withdrew due to an adverse event that was not related to the formula according to the study pediatrician.
Table 1
Infant demographic information at enrollment
Randomized formula-fed group Formula lutein concentration (mcg/l)
Breastfed group
20 [Control] (n = 6)
45 (n = 6)
120 (n = 7)
225 (n = 7)
Human milk (n = 14)
Age at enrollment (days)
Mean ± SD
13 ± 1.3
12 ± 2.7
13 ± 2.1
14 ± 1.1
13 ± 2.1
Median
13
12
14
14
13
Range
11–15
9–15
10–16
12–15
9–15
Female sex [n (%)]
4 (67)
3 (50)
5 (71)
5 (71)
7 (50)
Race [n (%)]
White
5 (83)
5 (83)
6 (86)
4 (57)
12 (86)
Black
1 (17)
0 (0)
0 (0)
0 (0)
0 (0)
Other
0 (0)
1 (17)
1 (14)
3 (43)
2 (14)
Anthropometrics
Weight (kg)
3.8 ± 0.4
3.9 ± 0.6
3.3 ± 0.4
3.9 ± 0.4
3.8 ± 0.4
Length (cm)
51.1 ± 1.5
52.5 ± 3.4
50.1 ± 2.8
51.4 ± 1.1
51.8 ± 2.2
Head circumference (cm)
35.9 ± 1.2
36.1 ± 0.8
34.7 ± 1.2
36.2 ± 1.3
36.1 ± 1.2
Lutein concentrations in human milk and lutein in the diet of breastfeeding mothers
Geometric mean lutein concentrations in human milk samples were similar at weeks 4, 8, and 12 (Table 2). The mean lipid content of the human milk samples was 41.5 g/l (95% CI 37.4–46.0). The average lutein concentration from the three collections of all breastfeeding mothers was 21.1 mcg/l (95% CI 14.9–30.0) and the average amount of lutein per gram of milk fat was 0.492 mcg (95% CI 0.319–0.761). Analysis of the Food Frequency Questionnaire, which was designed to report dietary intakes of both lutein and its structural isomer, zeaxanthin, indicated that the median lutein plus zeaxanthin in the maternal diet was 3363 mg/day [mean 4286 mg/day (95% CI 2679–5892)].
Table 2
Lutein concentrations in human milk at different study times
Week 4
n = 13
Week 8
n = 13
Week 12
n = 12
Average
n = 13
Lutein (mcg/l)
Geometric mean
20.5
20.1
19.7
21.1
95% CI
12.8–32.9
15.5–26.1
12.3–31.5
14.9–30.0
Median
21
20
21.5
23
Range
6–61
9–37
3–50
7–48
Limit of detection of lutein in human milk was 0.4 mcg/l
Lutein concentrations in infant serum
Human milk-fed infants had higher mean serum lutein concentrations (81 mcg/l) than all formula-fed infants (13 mcg/l) at baseline. Serum lutein concentration increased from baseline in each of the formula groups except in the unfortified group (Table 3). Linear regression model with and without baseline serum lutein indicated baseline serum concentrations did not have a significant effect on final serum concentrations in either the formula (P < 0.001) or human milk fed groups (P = 0.001). After 12 weeks of feeding, the human milk group had a sixfold higher mean serum lutein concentration than the unfortified formula group. Fortification of formula with lutein resulted in a dose-dependent increase in serum lutein concentrations after 12 weeks.
Table 3
Lutein concentrations in infant serum at study entry and week 12
Randomized formula-fed group Formula lutein concentration (mcg/l)
Breastfed group
20 [Control]
45
120
225
Human milk
Study entry
n
6
6
7
7
14
Geometric mean
11.9
12.9
22.4
8.5
81
95% CI
6–23.9
6.9–24
11.2–45
6.3–11.6
51–128.6
Median
10
13.5
26
8
95
Range
7–40
5–25
8–46
6–17
19–236
Week 12
n
4
5
7
5
13
Geometric mean
11.3
35.9
107.5
192.1
69.3
95% CI
8.1–15.8
30.1–42.8
88–131.4
141.7–260.6
40.3–119
Median
11.5
37
109
180
66
Range
9–14
31–42
82–148
148–278
7–168
Limit of detection of lutein in the serum was 2 mcg/l
Anzeige
Relationship between dietary lutein and infant serum lutein concentrations
A positive linear dose-dependent relationship (Fig. 1) was observed between lutein in the formula and lutein in the serum. The slope of the regression equation was steeper for human milk lutein than lutein in formula. For infants fed human milk, serum lutein concentration increased approximately 3.7 mcg/l for every 1 mcg/l increase in human milk lutein concentration, whereas for infants fed formula, serum lutein concentration increased only 0.9 mcg/l for every 1 mcg/l increase in formula lutein concentration.
Fig. 1
Scatterplot of serum lutein concentrations (mcg/l) at week 12 in infants fed different concentrations (mcg/l) of lutein containing formula or human milk. Solid circles represent infant formula groups and open triangles represent human milk group. Linear regression equation for formula-fed groups was Yi = −4.4 + 0.9 (formula lutein) (r2 = 0.87, P < 0.001) and for the human milk group was Yi = 1.8 + 3.7 (human milk lutein) (r2 = 0.67, P < 0.001). Baseline serum concentrations did not have a significant effect on final serum concentrations (P = 0.001 for human milk; P < 0.001 for formula) and the slopes shown are based on unadjusted data
×
Lutein fortification and serum beta-carotene concentrations
The mean average serum beta-carotene concentration at baseline across all formula-fed groups was 24.4 mcg/l. In the infants fed the 20 (control), 45, 120, and 225 mcg/l lutein containing formulas, the corresponding serum beta-carotene concentrations at week 12 were 128.0 (95% CI 47.3–346.6), 201.2 (95% CI 98.4–411.2), 173.2 (95% CI 125.5–238.8), and 202.3 mcg/l (95% CI 139.5–293.3), respectively.
Safety evaluation
Infant growth was within normal limits as assessed by mean weight gain in grams per day as well as by means for Z-scores in weight, length, and head circumference (data not shown). There were no adverse events related to the formula and no serious adverse events reported.
Discussion
This is the first randomized, prospective study comparing serum lutein concentrations in healthy term infants consuming different concentrations of lutein in formula. An important finding from this study is that the breastfed infant reference group had approximately 6 times the mean serum lutein concentration of infants consuming unfortified formula during the first several months of life. Fortification of formula with lutein resulted in a dose-dependent increase in serum lutein. Approximately 4 times more lutein is needed in the formula than in human milk to achieve similar serum lutein concentrations among the breastfed and formula fed infants.
Anzeige
It is interesting to note that despite the similarity in the lutein concentration of human milk and the unfortified formula, serum lutein concentrations were markedly different in the two groups of infants at week 12 but also at study entry. Two observations may account for this finding. Although we did not measure cord blood lutein concentrations, cord blood lutein did not differ at birth among infants who were ultimately fed human milk or infant formula (unpublished data, Wyeth, Dr. Minervini, 1993). However, infants who receive breast milk immediately after birth most likely consume substantially more lutein from colostrum than infants who consume infant formula unfortified with lutein [23, 25] and would explain the differences in serum lutein at study entry. In our study, the mothers reported at study enrollment that approximately 86% of the infants in the human milk group were exclusively breastfed from birth and 77% of the infants in the formula fed group received exclusively commercial formula.
Secondly, our data suggest that the bioavailability of lutein from formula is considerably lower than from human milk and could explain the lower mean serum lutein concentration in the unfortified group at week 12 despite similar lutein concentrations in the human milk and unfortified formula. The ratio of the slopes from the linear regression lines indicates that a fourfold higher lutein concentration was needed in formula compared to human milk to achieve similar lutein concentrations between formula-fed and breastfed infants. The reason why lutein availability was different between human milk and lutein-fortified formula remains unclear. Lutein added to the formula is predominantly free lutein and similar to the dominant form of lutein in human milk. Several findings reveal that availability of lutein from foods would be affected by several factors including the food matrix, fat intake, and nutrient–nutrient interactions [3, 7, 10, 20, 21, 27]. In relation to those points, additional studies are needed to explain the difference in bioavailability.
The human milk lutein concentration in this study was similar to the average values in the largest human milk survey published to date [2] reporting human milk lutein data from lactating women in nine countries including the US. Because dietary carotenoid intake influences human milk lutein concentrations, a goal of our study was to enroll breastfeeding mothers who consumed a diet rich in lutein. A study inclusion criterion for breastfeeding mothers was a reported consumption of 6 or more ½-cup servings per week of dark green vegetables, which are a rich source of lutein [11]. The results of the Food Frequency Questionnaire indicated that our goal of recruiting a population of breastfeeding women with a rich dietary intake of lutein was achieved. When compared to a sample of women from the Women’s Health Initiative, the breastfeeding mothers in our study fell between the 60th and 80th percentiles of intakes observed in the much larger study (n = 1698) [18].
There is limited information regarding lutein concentrations in infant formulas. Lutein is currently not added to infant formulas in the US but it has been detected in the ingredients used in infant formula manufacturing. Unpublished data from our laboratory indicate typical skim milk powder and whey protein ingredients contain lutein in amounts from <3.3 to 10.2 mcg/100 g and <3.3 to 15.6 mcg/100 g, respectively. One study [12] reported lutein in formulas and in human milk samples from Northern Ireland mothers and found that most formulas studied had detectable lutein and the range of concentrations in formula was similar to the range of concentrations found in human milk.
Anzeige
Serum beta-carotene concentrations were measured in this study because interactions between lutein and beta-carotene have been reported. Competition between lutein and beta-carotene for absorption was observed in healthy adults consuming supplements [15] and vegetable sources [26]. Lutein reduced beta-carotene concentrations in some subjects and enhanced it in others [15]. In our study, all infants were given formula with the same concentration of beta-carotene but the infants who consumed lutein supplemented formula had higher mean serum beta-carotene concentrations than infants who consumed control formula. These data suggest lutein supplementation enhanced absorption of beta-carotene but additional studies are needed to confirm.
The strengths of this study include the use of a wide range of lutein concentrations in the formula, measurement of lutein concentrations in the human milk, and the length of time exclusively formula or breastfed. The small sample size for each group could be considered a limitation of the study although a linear dose response relationship was apparent. The exclusion criteria of infants less than 9 days old limits our understanding of the amount of lutein in colostrum and how it might have had an early impact on baseline serum lutein concentrations. However, requiring that the infants be older than a week at study entry was necessary to avoid recruiting into a trial during a time when a mother might be deciding between breast and formula feeding.
In summary, infants fed formula unfortified with lutein have serum lutein concentrations approximately one-sixth those of breastfed infants in the first few months of life. An increase in lutein in infant formula leads to an increase in serum lutein in a dose-dependent manner. More lutein is needed in infant formula than human milk to achieve similar serum lutein concentrations among breastfed and formula fed infants. Additional studies are needed to demonstrate whether lutein fortification in infant formula leads to improved eye health or other benefits.
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to Kristina Krabill, the study nurse and coordinator; Dr. Pam Fisher who was the study pediatrician and performed the physical examinations; Dr. Jay Groebel for his statistical assistance; and Susan Troemel for her help with this study. The study was supported by Wyeth Nutrition, Collegeville, PA, USA.
Open Access
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
Open AccessThis is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0), which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
