Background
Methods
Participants
DD patients | PTSD patients | HC | Comparison across groups | |
---|---|---|---|---|
N
| 60 | 39 | 40 | |
Gender (f/m) | 45/15 | 33/6 | 34/6 | χ2 = 2.09, p = .35 |
Age (M ± SD) | 42.6 ± 12.31 | 41.3 ± 9.32 | 40.6 ± 11.9 |
H(2) = 0.9, p = .64 |
Years schooling (M ± SD) | 10.8 ± 2.27 | 10.7 ± 1.59 | 11.8 ± 1.49 |
H(2) = 11.69, p = .003 |
Design and procedure
Material
Data analysis
Results
Symptom severity across groups (HC vs. DD vs. PTSD)
HC
n = 40 | DD−
n = 40 | DD+
n = 20 | PTSD patients
n = 39 | |
---|---|---|---|---|
median (range)
| median (range)
| median (range)
| median (range)
| |
Symptom severity | ||||
SDQ-20 | 21 (20 – 26)
n = 40 | 28.5 (20 – 54)
n = 40 | 36.5 (29 – 56)
n = 18 | 36 (20 – 91)
n = 39 |
DES | 6.49 (0 – 25.36)
n = 40 | 12.14 (0 – 48.57)
n = 40 | 19.64 (9.64 – 51.79)
n = 20 | 38.57 (8.57 – 80.71)
n = 39 |
PDS_Sym | 0 (0 – 8)
n = 40 | 4 (0 – 38)
n = 40 | 30 (16 – 46)
n = 20 | 36 (13 – 48)
n = 39 |
Adversity/trauma measures | ||||
KERF_Sum | 35.08 (0 – 235.5)
n = 40 | 90.17 (0 – 533.08)
n = 38 | 219.67 (18.83 – 605)
n = 17 | 369 (60 – 885.75)
n = 39 |
KERF_Phy | 7.33 (0 – 141.67)
n = 40 | 40.33 (0 – 229.3)
n = 38 | 33 (1.67 – 304)
n = 17 | 141 (0 – 462)
n = 39 |
KERF_Emo | 25 (0 – 218)
n = 40 | 52.5 (0 – 329)
n = 38 | 141 (14.5 – 362)
n = 17 | 239.5 (51 – 423.5)
n = 39 |
KERF_Sex | 0 (0 – 1.3)
n = 40 | 0 (0 – 23.8)
n = 38 | 0 (0 – 27.5)
n = 17 | 7.5 (0 – 40)
n = 39 |
PDS_Event | 1.5 (0 – 5)
n = 40 | 3 (0 – 7)
n = 40 | 4 (2 – 7)
n = 20 | 5 (2 – 8)
n = 39 |
Alexithymia | ||||
TAS-26 | 1.94 (1.33 – 3.05)
n = 40 | 2.58 (1.39 – 3.44)
n = 40 | 2.92 (1.83 – 4.33)
n = 20 | 3.44 (1.66 – 4.55)
n = 39 |
Comparison across groups | DD patients vs. HC
n = 100 | PTSD patients vs. HC
n = 79 | DD patients vs. PTSD patients
n = 99 | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Symptom severity | ||||
SDQ-20 |
H(2) = 70.62
p < .001 |
U = 172.5, z = −7.17
p < .001
r = −0.72 |
U = 62, z = −7.07
p < .001
r = −0.80 |
U = 727, z = −2.98
p = .021
r = −0.30 |
DES |
H(2) = 68.77
p < .001 |
U = 585, z = −4.33
p < .001
r = −0.43 |
U = 24.5, z = −7.41
p < .001
r = −0.83 |
U = 348, z = −5.89
p < .001
r = −0.59 |
PDS_Sym |
H(2) = 82.23
p < .001 |
U = 402.5, z = −5.80
p < .001
r = −0.58 |
U = 0, z = −7.8
p < .001
r = −0.88 |
U = 322, z = −6.08
p < .001
r = −0.61 |
Adversity/trauma measures | ||||
KERF_Sum |
H(2) = 57.55
p < .001 |
U = 610, p = −3.70
p < .001
r = −0.37 |
U = 49, z = −7.05
p < .001
r = −0.79 |
U = 364.5, z = −5.20
p < .001
r = −0.52 |
KERF_Phy |
H(2) = 49.07
p < .001 |
U = 647.5, z = −3.43
p = .001
r = −0.34 |
U = 113.5, p = −6.55
p < .001
r = −0.73 |
U = 460, z = −4.70
p < .001
r = −0.47 |
KERF_Emo |
H(2) = 60.12
p < .001 |
U = 606, z = −3.72
p < .001
r = −0.37 |
U = 47.5, z = −7.19
p < .001
r = −0.80 |
U = 377.5, z = −5.33
p < .001
r = −0.53 |
KERF_Sex |
H(2) = 52.83
p < .001 |
U = 943.5, z = −2.22 n.s. |
U = 226, z = −6.29
p < .001
r = −0.70 |
U = 472.5, z = −5.22
p < .001
r = −0.52 |
PDS_Event |
H(2) = 49.32
p < .001 |
U = 536, z = −4.73
p < .001
r = −0.47 |
U = 108.5, z = −6.66
p < .001
r = −0.74 |
U = 708.5, z = −3.36
p = .007
r = −0.34 |
Alexithymia | ||||
TAS-26 |
H(2) = 70.34
p < .001 |
U = 387, z = −5.72
p < .001
r = −0.57 |
U = 67.5, z = −6.99
p < .001
r = −0.78 |
U = 408, z = −5.46
p < .001
r = −0.54 |
Comparison across groups | DD+ vs. PTSD patients
n = 59 | DD− vs. PTSD patients
n = 79 | DD− vs. HC
n = 80 | DD+ vs. DD−
n = 60 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Symptom severity | |||||
SDQ |
H(3) = 77.61
p < .001 |
U = 332.5, z = −3.20
n.s.
|
U = 394.5, z = −3.78
p < .001
r = −0.41 |
U = 172.5, z = −6.08
p < .001
r = −0.68 |
U = 151.5, z = −3.51
p < .001
r = −0.45 |
DES |
H(3) = 78.20
p < .001 |
U = 197.5, z = −3.08
p = .014
r = −0.40 |
U = 150.5, z = −6.17
p < .001
r = −0.61 |
U = 528.5, z = −2.61
n.s.
|
U = 168.5, z = −3.63
p < .001
r = −0.47 |
PDS_Sym |
H(3) = 102.77
p < .001 |
U = 267.5, z = −1.96
n.s.
|
U = 54.5, z = −7.13
p < .001
r = −0.8 |
U = 402.5, z = −4.09
p < .001
r = −0.46 |
U = 37, z = −5.72
p < .001
r = −0.74 |
Adversity/trauma measures | |||||
KERF_Sum |
H(3) = 61.63
p < .001 |
U = 169, z = −2.71
p = .049
r = −0.35 |
U = 195.5, z = −5.38
p < .001
r = −0.61 |
U = 510, z = −2.5 n.s. |
U = 203, z = −2.19 n.s. |
KERF_Phy |
H(3) = 49.98
p < .001 |
U = 183, z = −2.65
n.s.
|
U = 277, z = −4.73
p < .001
r = −0.53 |
U = 481.5, z = −2.8
p = 0.03
r = −0.31 |
U = 271, z = −0.95
n.s.
|
KERF_Emo |
H(3) = 66.10
p < .001 |
U = 194.5, z = −2.44
n.s.
|
U = 183, z = −5.69
p < .001
r = −0.63 |
U = 512.5, z = −2.47
n.s.
|
U = 169.5, z = −2.80
p = .035
r = −0.36 |
Mace_Sex |
H(3) = 53.50
p < .001 |
U = 173, z = −2.94
p = .021
r = −0.38 |
U = 299.5, z = 4.99
p < .001
r = −0.56 |
U = 676.5, z = −1.81
n.s.
|
U = 287.5, z = −1.00
n.s.
|
PDS_Event |
H(3) = 52.07
p < .001 |
U = 301.5, z = −1.45
n.s.
|
U = 407, z = −3.72
p < .001
r = −0.42 |
U = 424.5, z = 3.67
p < .001
r = −0.41 |
U = 291.5, z = −1.73
n.s.
|
Alexithymia | |||||
TAS-26 |
H(3) = 74.97
p < .001 |
U = 211, z = −2.87
p = .028
r = −0.37 |
U = 197, z = −5.72
p < .001
r = −0.64 |
U = 325.0, z = 4.58
p < .001
r = −0.51 |
U = 226, z = −2.73
p = 0.042
r = −0.35 |
Adversity and trauma measures across groups (HC vs. DD vs PTSD)
Relationship between trauma/maltreatment and symptom severity (overall and within subgroups)
Alexithymia across groups (HC vs. DD vs. PTSD)
Discussion
DD−
n = 40 | DD+
n = 20 | PTSD patients
n = 39 | |
---|---|---|---|
Recurrent depressive disorder or depressive episode | 9 (22.5%) | 5 (25%) | 15 (38.5%) |
(Phobic) anxiety disorder | 1 (2.5%) | 4 (20%) | 6 (15.4%) |
Emotionally unstable personality disorder | 1 (2.5%) | 0 (0%) | 17 (43.6%) |
Somatoform disorder | 15 (37.5%) | 5 (25%) | 3 (7.7%) |