Background
Hand, foot and mouth disease (HFMD) is a common infectious disease that occurs mostly in infants and children, but can also occur in adolescents and occasionally in adults. HFMD is mainly caused by coxsackievirus A16 (Cox A16), which usually results in a mild self-limiting disease with few complications, and enterovirus 71 (EV71), which has been associated with serious complications and may be fatal. [
1,
2] Outbreaks of HFMD have occurred in the Western Pacific Region in recent years, and China is one of the Asian countries with the highest number of reported cases [
2,
3]. An EV71 vaccine was first generated and approved in China in 2016. However, several recent HFMD outbreaks have been caused by other pathogens, making it important to develop multivalent vaccines to control HFMD epidemics [
4].
HFMD has been listed as a notifiable Class C infectious disease in the national communicable disease surveillance and reporting system of China since May 2008. Compared with 2008, the number of reported cases in 2010 was approximately four times higher [
5]. In January 2017, there were 77,412 cases of HFMD including 5 deaths reported in mainland China [
6]. The increasing burden of HFMD has become a serious public health problem in China, causing government concern about the risk factors of this disease and greater interest in approaches to effectively prevent and control HFMD.
In China, the epidemiological characteristics, risk factors and spatiotemporal patterns of HFMD have been studied at a national scale [
3,
7‐
10]. Considering the extensive area and diverse demographic, economic and climatic characteristics of China, the distribution and risk factors likely vary in different regions. Previous studies in Guangzhou, Wuhan, Zhengzhou, Shanxi and Hong Kong have explored relationships between meteorological variables and HFMD using time-series analysis, through which the seasonal and temporal characteristics of HFMD have been characterized. Temperature and relative humidity were found to be associated with incidence of this disease [
11‐
16]. In Beijing, Xu et al. [
17] found a non-linear association between temperature and HFMD incidence.
In addition to temporal dynamics, HFMD epidemics demonstrate spatial patterns, which have been characterized in different areas [
18‐
22]. However, few spatio-temporal studies have explored the relationship between HFMD incidence and meteorological factors and simultaneously quantified spatial and temporal patterns. Bayesian approaches could be utilized both to quantify spatio-temporal variation and identify how meteorological factors affect HFMD incidence [
23,
24]. Such studies could help establish the utility of meteorological monitoring as an adjunct for the surveillance and control of HFMD.
This study aims to quantify seasonal patterns, temporal trends and the spatio-temporal distribution of HFMD incidence at a township level in Beijing, and investigate the relationship between meteorological factors and HFMD incidence in this city.
Methods
Study area
Beijing, the capital city of China, is located in the northern tip of the roughly triangular North China Plain, at a latitude of 39″26′ to 41″03’ N. The area of Beijing is 16,410 km2 with 14 urban administrative districts and two rural counties, comprised of 304 townships. The population is 19.6 million, with townships ranging from 2000 to 359,400 people (The Sixth National Population Census, Beijing, 2010). Beijing has a rather dry, monsoon-influenced continental climate with hot, humid summers and cold, dry winters. As townships are the smallest administrative units for monitoring of infectious diseases, they were used as the geographical unit for this spatiotemporal analysis.
HFMD data
Data on HFMD cases that were reported from January 2010 to December 2012 were obtained from the Beijing Center for Disease Prevention and Control (CDC). The data were collected from the China Information System for Disease Control and Prevention (CISDCP) with age, gender, occupation, address and dates of onset and diagnosis. HFMD cases were diagnosed based on the symptoms of fever, vesicular lesions on hands, feet, mouth and occasionally the buttocks, which are defined by the National Guidelines published by Chinese Ministry of Health in 2009 [
25]. Severe cases are HFMD cases associated with meningitis, encephalitis, and severe complications, including neurological, cardiovascular and respiratory problems. All HFMD cases are required to be reported to CISDCP within 24 h after diagnosis.
Meteorological and population data
Meteorological factors investigated included mean temperature, maximum temperature, minimum temperature, relative humidity, atmospheric pressure, precipitation, sunshine hours and wind velocity. Daily data on these variables were collected from the China Meteorological Data Sharing Service System (
http://data.cma.cn/). A weather monitoring station is located in Daxing District (N39°48′, E116°28′) in southeast Beijing, from which the data are usually used to represent the meteorological conditions of the whole of Beijing city [
17]. Thus, the meteorological data were temporally but not spatially variable. We obtained population data from the Beijing Area Statistics Yearbook from 2005 to 2015, which were used to calculate linear monthly growth rates at the township level and to estimate monthly population counts between January 2010 and December 2012.
Statistical analysis
Seasonal trend decomposition with Loess smoothing was used to explore seasonal patterns and temporal trends of HFMD, using the statistical software R version 3.3.2 (R Development Core Team, 2016).
Pairwise Spearman correlation analysis was conducted to detect correlations between the meteorological factors. For pairs of variables with a correlation coefficient > |0.7|, only one member of the pair was included in multivariable models (the member with the lowest p-value in a bivariate regression model).
The standardized morbidity ratios (SMRs) of each town were calculated by dividing the observed number of cases by the expected number, which was calculated as the product of overall incidence of the city and the average population for each township during the study period.
In this study we used a Bayesian conditional auto regressive (CAR) model approach, with parameter estimation done by Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods. This approach allows estimation of spatial variability of disease risk and the effect of covariates [
26,
27], overcoming the issue of spatial autocorrelation violating the assumption of independence [
23,
28]. In recent years, CAR models have been used to analyze the spatial distribution of malaria, filariasis, and schistosomiasis [
26,
29,
30], but there have been fewer applications to other infectious diseases.
Using the Bayesian framework, Poisson regression models were used to quantify spatiotemporal variation of HFMD incidence and associations with selected meteorological factors. The models were implemented using the WinBUGS software, version 1.4.3 (Medical Research Council, Biostatistics Unit, Cambridge, United Kingdom). Three Bayesian models (non-spatial, spatial and spatiotemporal) were constructed. The regression models assumed that the observed HFMD cases followed a Poisson distribution with a mean (
μ):
$$ {Y}_{ij}\sim Poisson\left({\mu}_{ij}\right) $$
$$ L\mathrm{og}\left({\mu}_{ij}\right)= Log\left({E}_{\mathrm{ij}}\right)+{\theta}_{\mathrm{ij}}, $$
where Y
ij
is the observed number of cases in town i, month j; E
ij
is the expected number of cases in town i, month j; and θij is the relative risk (SMR) in town i, month j.
The non-spatial model was defined as:
$$ {\theta}_{ij}=\alpha +\sum \limits_k{\beta}_k{X}_{kij}+{v}_i+{g}_j+{\omega}^{\ast }{month}_j $$
The spatial model was defined as:
$$ {\theta}_{ij}=\alpha +\sum \limits_k{\beta}_k{X}_{kij}+{v}_i+{u}_i+{g}_j+{\omega}^{\ast }{month}_j $$
The spatio-temporal model was defined as:
$$ {\theta}_{ij}=\alpha +\sum \limits_k{\beta}_k{X}_{kij}+{v}_i+{g}_j+{u}_i+{d_i}^{\ast }{month}_{ij}+{\omega}^{\ast }{month}_j, $$
where α is the intercept; β
k
are the k regression coefficients and X
kij
are the covariates (different meteorological factors); v
i
is an unstructured random effect with mean zero and variance \( {\sigma}_v^2 \); u
i
is a spatially structured random effect with mean zero and variance \( {\sigma}_u^2 \); g
j
is the autoregressive time effect with mean zero and variance \( {\sigma}_g^2 \); d
i
are the spatially smoothed town-level temporal trend coefficients; and ω is the provincial average temporal trend coefficient.
For the intercept (α) flat prior distributions was applied. For all the coefficients (β) and the provincial average temporal trend coefficient (ω), normal prior probability distributions were used and assumed with a mean = 0 and a precision (inverse of variance) = 0.0001. The spatial structuring in structured random effect (u
i
) and spatially smoothed town-level temporal trend coefficients (d
i
) was modelled using a CAR prior structure, which is defined by a simple adjacency weights matrix to determine the spatial relationships between townships. If two towns were adjacent, the weight = 1 and if they were not adjacent, the weight = 0. The weights matrix was generated in ArcGIS (version 10.3, ESRI, Redlands, CA). The priors for the precision of v
i
, u
i
, g
j
and d
i
were specified using non-informative gamma distributions with a shape parameter = 0.5 and a scale parameter = 0.0005.
The model with the lowest deviance information criterion (DIC) was chosen as the best-fitting model. The model was run for 300,000 iterations after an initial burn-in of 10,000 iterations, and was assessed for convergence. After model convergence, samples from the posterior distributions of each random variable were stored and analyzed to provide summary estimates.
Discussion
There were 114,777 HFMD cases from 2010 to 2012, with an average incidence of 190.2 cases per 100,000 people, which was higher than some other provinces in China like Sichuan (43.7/100,000, 2008–2013) [
31], Shandong (104.4/100,000, 2008–2012) [
23], Jiangsu (126.3/100,000, 2009–2013) [
24], and Guangdong (167.8/100,000, 2008–2011) [
32], but was lower than Guangxi (298.3/100,000, 2008–2013) [
21]. The total incidence in males was higher than that in females, which was consistent with previous studies [
23,
24], suggesting the susceptibility of males. Most cases were concentrated in children from 1 to 4 years old, which were the main target groups for the surveillance and control of HFMD in Beijing.
From 2010 to 2012, there was an oscillating inter-annual pattern with peaks at the start and towards the end of the study period in HFMD incidence. The peaks of HFMD cases were in May to July every year, which corresponds to early summer in Beijing. There was another lower peak occurring in the autumn of 2011. Previous studies in Singapore and Malaysia have shown seasonal outbreaks of HFMD between March and May [
22], whereas in Japan, outbreaks typically occur during the summer months [
33]. In China, single seasonal peaks have been shown to appear between April and August in Shandong province, as well as Henan province, both also located in North China [
23]. Double peaks have been observed in some southern districts of China, usually in the warm months of spring and autumn [
34,
35].
The areas of Beijing with high HFMD incidence were distributed in districts circumjacent to central Beijing like Mentougou, Fangshan, Changping, Daxing, Tongzhou and north Huairou district (Fig.
2). The spatial random effect (Fig.
4) represented the residual spatial clustering after accounting for the meteorological variables [
36]. Socio-economic levels, medical and health facility access, surveillance and control capacities of HFMD in different districts might be potential factors influencing this residual variation, which are more amenable to control than meteorological factors. Thus, clusters of high residual risk should be the focus of greater attention in the prevention and control of HFMD with measures like reinforcing community health education and improving health care levels of nurseries.
Mean temperature, relative humidity, wind velocity and sunshine hours were positively associated with HFMD incidence. Temperature and relative humidity were found to be associated with HFMD in previous studies [
14,
33,
37]. There are two main ways that meteorological factors can influence HFMD: by affecting the external environment to change the biological activity, propagation and transmission of pathogen; and by impacting on human behavior [
38‐
40]. During warmer months, communal physical activity among children and adolescents increases, which may promote the risk of contact transmission of HFMD [
41‐
43]. A study in Shandong province [
44] revealed a strong association between HFMD incidence and wind speed as shown in our study. They suggested that wind can promote air pollutants like particulate matter carrying enterovirus and thus accelerate the spread of HFMD [
38]. As a major atmospheric pollutant, fine particulate matter (PM
2.5, defined as particle less than 2.5 mm aerodynamic diameter) has a small size and a relatively large surface area, which makes it easy to absorb viruses in the air. Especially considering the high levels of PM
2.5 pollution in Beijing [
45,
46], it is plausible that high wind velocity is a risk factor for the spread of HFMD. On the other hand, children spend more time with indoor activities in confined spaces during windy periods, which would increase the chances of EV transmission, a possible indirect explanation supporting the association of increased transmission with windy conditions. Longer sunshine hours was also found to be a risk factor in our study, which was different from studies in other places [
23,
24]. Sunlight could promote virus replication or inactivate human virus to some extent [
47‐
49]. It is also possible that children engage more in outside activities on sunny days, thus increasing contact among children. Precipitation was not significantly associated with HFMD incidence in this study, which was consistent with the study conducted in Shandong Province [
23]. A study in Hefei [
50] of China found that extreme precipitation (90th percentile of precipitation as the analytical cut-off point) was significantly associated with childhood HFMD. Beijing is a temperate city with lower mean monthly precipitation (54.9 mm) than Hefei (130.8 mm), which has a subtropical monsoon humid climate The threshold effect of precipitation on HFMD might be the reason for inconsistent conclusions [
50].
There were previous studies conducted in Beijing investigating spatio-temporal patterns of HFMD and the effects of meteorological factors on this disease. Additional file
1: Table S1 showed the detailed comparison of these studies with ours. Wang et al. [
18] used spatial filtering combined with scan statistics methods to detect HFMD clusters in Beijing from 2008 to 2012, finding that the most likely space-time cluster was located in the southwest of Beijing. Dong et al. [
38] used geographically weighted regression model to explore the seasonal influence of weather factors on incidents of HFMD from 2008 to 2011 in Beijing. Our study considered spatial and temporal variability of all the variables in Bayesian CAR model, which could quantify spatio-temporal variation and identify the effects of meteorological factors at the same time. Compared with the study conducted by Dong et al., we found that sunshine hours was also positively associated with HFMD incidence. The effects of mean temperature and wind velocity were consistent while relative humidity and precipitation showed different effect estimates. The threshold effect of precipitation on HFMD incidence might be the reason for the discordant conclusions.
Demographic and socio-economic characteristics which include child population density, Gross Domestic Product per capita, number of health agencies, proportion of children in nursery, and proportion of children in primary school might be confounders affecting the incidence of HFMD. Additional file
3: Figure S2, Additional file
4: Figure S3, Additional file
5: Figure S4, Additional file
6: Figure S5, Additional file
7: Figure S6 were the spatial distributions of these factors, which did not show obvious association with HFMD clusters. However, data of the demographic and socio-economic characteristics that we obtained from Beijing Area Statistics Yearbook are in district level for now and further statistical analysis considering these factors in higher resolution should be conducted if available.
In terms of study limitations, the meteorological data were obtained from one monitoring center, which was assumed to represent the meteorological conditions of the whole city. It would be preferable to incorporate spatial variation in the meteorological variables. However, Beijing has a relatively small area, and we do not expect as much spatial variability between townships as temporal variability across months and years. Secondly, the time-series was short (3 years) and to quantify seasonal and interannual variability and associated factors it would be better to analyze data from a much longer time period. Finally, this was an ecological study and it is important to note that measured associations were only valid at the level of the township and cannot be applied to individuals, or different levels of spatial aggregation [
23].