Spondylodiscitis in a healthy 12-year-old girl with Extraintestinal pathogenic Escherichia coli (ExPEC) bacteraemia

Bone and joint infections are common in children, and spine is affected in 1–4% of cases [1]. Native vertebral osteomyelitis is often the result of hematogenous seeding of the adjacent disc space from a distant focus, as the disc is avascular. Pyogenic spondylodiscitis usually occur in young children, and the main pathogen is Staphylococcus aureus [2]; Gram-negative bacteria are rarely implicated in children as in adults. Among Gram-negative bacteria, E. coli is the most frequent in spondylodiscitis in adults [3]; the main risk factors are a pre-existing or synchronous genitourinary tract infection or an intra-abdominal infection [3, 4].

A 12-year-old caucasian girl presented with a 1-day history of fever (39 °C) with right lumbar pain. She had no medical history and had never travelled outside Western Europe. There was no report of dysuria, frequent daytime urination, abdominal pain or diarrhoea. Physical examination was normal apart from a right lumbar punch. White blood cell (WBC) count was 9400/mm³, neutrophils 7600/mm³ and CRP 16 mg/L. Blood and urines were collected for culture and ceftriaxone was started for suspicion of pyelonephritis. Urinalysis was negative for leukocyte, nitrite and pyuria. Urinary culture was sterile but one blood culture was positive for an Escherichia coli strain susceptible to all antibiotics. Abdominal ultrasound and abdominal tomodensitometry with intravenous injection of an iodised contrast product were normal. The patient was afebrile after 48 h of ceftriaxone. C-Reactive Protein (CRP) culminated at 78 mg/L on day 2 and lowered at 12 mg/L on day 5.

However, lumbar pain persisted despite paracetamol and required morphine. A second renal ultrasound was performed and showed no sign of urinary lithiasis. A magnetic resonance imaging of the spine on day 7 revealed a T11-T12 spondylodiscitis without adjacent epidural or soft tissue inflammation (Fig. 1). No bone biopsy was attempted. It would have been considered if the clinical evolution had been unfavourable despite antibiotic treatment. A corset was prescribed and ciprofloxacin was added on day 6 to complete a 14-day course of intravenous antibiotherapy. She had minimal back pain on day 14 and was discharged with oral ciprofloxacin for another 4 weeks. She complained of arthralgia of both wrists on day 35. Physical examination was normal. Ciprofloxacin was stopped on day 42 and arthralgia resolved spontaneously.

Polymerase chain reactions (PCR) were performed to analyze E. coli strain, as described previously [5‐7]. It harbored serogroup O1:K1 and belonged to the major phylogenetic group B2₁. Among 23 genetic determinants encoding virulence factors (VFs) investigated [5‐7]. 14 were present, including genes coding for siderophores (yersiniabactin - fyuA, aerobactin - iucC, sit system - sitA, salmochelin – iroN), adhesins P fimbriae (papGII but not papGIII), pilin (papC), vacuolating toxin (vat) and cytolethal distending toxin (cdt). Moreover, strain had other genetic determinants: colicin V (cvaA), colicin Ia (cia), a pore-forming toxin gene that increases serum survival (iss), a type I secretion system operon (ets), a putative outer membrane protease (ompT) and a hemolysin (hlyF) which combined with the aerobactin and salmochelin genes are characteristic of a conserved virulence plasmidic region identified in the highly virulent extra intestinal pathogenic E. coli strain S88 [6]. Finally, PCR were negative for other adhesin/invasin genes (sfa/foc and ibeA), alpha-hemolysin (hlyA), cytotoxic necrotizing factor (nf1), secreted autotransporter toxin (sat) and colibactin (clbB).

Immunological explorations including WBC count and smear, the determination of plasma IgA, G, M and E and IgG subclasses levels and classic complement pathway analysis were normal. The absence of previous unusual infection in our patient didn’t lead us further explores her immunity to rule out an immunodeficiency.

Extraintestinal pathogenic Escherichia coli (ExPEC) bloodstream infections represent a growing public health concern [8, 9]. ExPEC strains have acquired genes encoding virulence factors that allow them to cause infections outside the gastrointestinal tract. The B2 phylogenetic group is the main one implicated in various extra intestinal infections [10] and in 63% of E. coli bacteraemia in French children [11]. This proportion is similar whether the identified portal of entry is the urinary tract or the digestive tract. The most frequent extra-intestinal virulence genes identified in this nation-wide study were fyuA, irp2, iraT, ompT, iucC, iron, papC and papGII. Our strain belonged to the B2₁ subgroup, one of the most virulent subgroup, and harbored 6 of these 8 virulence factors, namely fyuA, ompT, iucC, iron, papC and papGII: those could explain the predisposition of this strain to be bacteraemic. Virulence factors of our strain included adhesins (e.g. P fimbriae), factors to avoid or subvert host defense systems (e.g. capsule K1) and nutrient acquisition factors (e.g. siderophores). However, to our knowledge, no publication has established a link between some virulence factors and bone/joint infections.

Recently, Lemaitre et al. and others showed that the conserved virulence plasmidic region identified in our strain contributed to the high level of bacteremia in neonates [6‐12]. The serotype O1:K1 could also contribute to the virulence of our strain. Beside K1 capsule antigen that provides a survival advantage in serum [13], O1-antigen serotype might also confer protection against complement killing [14]. However, our strain didn’t have genes hlyA (alpha-hemolysin) nor cnf1 (cytotoxic necrotic factor), two virulence factors identified as highly cytotoxic toward human osteoblastic cells in vitro [15].

Escherichia coli is an uncommon cause of spondylodiscitis, particularly in children. The strain harbored serogroup O1:K1 and virulence factors common to highly virulent extra intestinal pathogenic E. coli that could explain this rare clinical presentation. The identification of E. coli in a spondylodiscitis should lead to the search for immunosuppression of the host and virulence factors of the strain, particularly those of ExPEC.