Background
Knowledge about the interactions between tumour cells and the immune system has increased in the last decades. Yet, many basic issues concerning tumour immunology remain unanswered. An intriguing question is why the immune system, capable of eliminating malignant cells under experimental conditions, fails to eliminate tumour cells in patients with progressive cancer disease. Thus, it remains relevant to study functional changes in various immune cells during cancer disease [
1,
2].
Head and Neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) is one example of diseases where functional changes in immune cells have been demonstrated [
3,
4]. Alterations in immune cell functions in HNSCC patients are shown to be both directly disease dependent as well as indirectly related to disease as, e.g., when correlating to impaired general status of patients [
5]. Furthermore, it has been shown that
in vitro-stimulated lymphocyte proliferation, as well as
in vivo expression of lymphocyte activation epitopes, may be associated with prognosis in HNSCC patients [
6,
7].
Mononuclear phagocytes (MNPs) are also determined to be functionally changed in patients with HNSCC [
8]. Monocytes and macrophages may be separated into type-I and type-II cells according to their cytokine repertoire upon activation [
9]. Interleukin (IL)-6 and other pro-inflammatory cytokines are secreted from type-I cells, whereas chemotactic substances such as monocyte chemotactic peptide (MCP)-1 are secreted mainly from type-II cells [
9]. When monocytes are stimulated in co-culture with HNSCC tumour cells, high levels of both IL-6 and MCP-1 can be detected in supernatants [
10].
IL-6 is a pluripotent cytokine with mostly stimulatory functions. IL-6 may, e.g., act as an autocrine or paracrine growth factor, but also as an anti-apoptotic agent on cancer cells, as is the case in oral cancer [
11‐
13]. MCP-1 was originally determined to recruit macrophages into malignant lesions [
14]. MCP-1 receptor expression on tumour cells may be important in the context of tumour cell proliferation and invasion, e.g., in prostate cancer [
15].
An increased influx of tumour-associated macrophages (TAMs) in HNSCC tumours is mirrored by a worsened prognosis, but so far no association between monocyte function and survival of HNSCC patients has been published [
16]. We have in a previous study observed a correlation between monocyte and TAM IL-6 secretion in HNSCC, suggesting that monocyte function indeed reflects TAM function in HNSCC patients [
10]. We therefore suggest that monocyte function may be related to prognosis in HNSCC patients. The aim of the present investigation was to study this hypothesis.
Monocyte function may be assessed by measuring cytokine secretion after in vitro stimulation of purified monocytes with endotoxin. We have studied whether monocyte function in HNSCC patients, as measured by in vitro endotoxin-stimulated monocyte IL-6 and MCP-1 secretion, was different from monocyte function in control patients and dependent on stage of HNSCC disease as well as prognosis.
Discussion
In this study, we have examined monocyte responsiveness, as measured by
in vitro endotoxin responsiveness, by monocyte IL-6 and MCP-1 secretion. Monocyte responsiveness was increased in monocytes from HNSCC patients compared to control conditions. On the other hand, no difference in monocyte responsiveness was found when HNSCC patients with limited versus extended disease were compared. Patients with high monocyte responsiveness as measured by IL-6 secretion at serum-free conditions had lower disease-specific survival than patients with low such monocyte responsiveness. Predictions for survival based on monocyte IL-6 secretion, were still valid after adjusting for gender, age, TNM stage, albumin and ESR levels. Furthermore, we determined to some extent that MCP-1 secretion following endotoxin stimulation was related to prognosis. We have, however, determined a much more thorough correlation to prognosis with IL-6 levels than with MCP-1 levels. We therefore suggest that MCP-1 level survival prediction should be more closely studied before any firm conclusions can be drawn. Our observations are in line with results from a recent study by Clinchy and co-workers showing that increased IL-6 secretion, in short-duration
in vitro cultures of peripheral blood mononuclear cells stimulated with LPS, was associated with impaired prognosis in patients radically operated for colon cancer [
22]. Monocyte IL-6 and MCP-1 secreted from endotoxin- stimulated monocytes may be linked to an altered inflammatory state as previously shown in HNSCC patients. Examples are increased ESR, lowered albumin values in serum, increased levels of acute-phase proteins and pro-inflammatory cytokines [
23,
24]. This has been studied by adding serum albumin and ESR level information to the Cox regression analyses. We determined only minor explanatory power upon adjusting for ESR and albumin in serum. On the contrary, to some extent the IL-6 secretion level, serum albumin levels and ESR independently predicted survival.
We found no association between tumour burden and monocyte function in the present study. This argues against monocyte function being linearly regulated by HNSCC disease-related factors, such as cytokines secreted from tumour-associated cells. The findings in the present study indicate that monocyte changes are generally present in malignant disease and to a lesser extent influenced by tumour burden.
There is evidence to claim that nuclear factor -κB (NF-κB), which regulates expression of multiple genes in cells, may act as a link between infection, inflammation and carcinogens in development of cancer [
25]. The pro-inflammatory cytokine IL-6 may have an important role in this process by serving as an anti-apoptotic agent through activation of NF-κB [
26]. Our present finding, that increased IL-6 secretion from monocytes predicts prognosis of HNSCC disease, further supports the notion that inflammatory responses may cause both initiation and progression of neoplastic growth [
12].
Another effect of IL-6 is its increased promotion of monocyte differentiation towards macrophages at the expense of dendritic cell (DC) differentiation [
27]. Monocytes are recruited by chemokine gradients to migrate from circulation into tumour tissues where a further differentiation to TAMs or DCs takes place under the regulation of environmental signals of such as IL-6 [
27]. There is currently an increasing agreement that TAMs in carcinoma disease may support tumour growth by virtue of their differentiation into type II macrophages [
28]. Compared to TAMs, DCs apparently have a contrary effect within HNSCC tumours, whereby a high number of DCs correlates with better prognosis [
29,
30]. Furthermore, it has previously been demonstrated that monocytes maintain IL-6 secretion throughout their differentiation to macrophages when continuously stimulated with HNSCC tumour spheroids
in vitro [
31]. We therefore suggest that the malignancy potential of HNSCC relies to some extent on IL-6 stimulation by TAMs.
MCP-1 regulates TAM influx into tumours and may also be secreted by TAMs [
10]. It is therefore possible that MCP-1 mediates a self-enhancing effect driven by TAMs within tumours. Increased expression of MCP-1 in squamous cell carcinomas of the oesophagus has been associated with increased influx of TAMs and an impaired prognosis [
32].
In vitro experiments indicate that these findings may be relevant for HNSCC as well [
16]. To what extent the shown lowered monocyte MCP-1 responsiveness association to increased prognosis can be linked to TAM influx in HNSCC tumours needs to be further elucidated.
The observations in the present study add weight to the arguments that activated MNPs may in fact increase rather than reduce tumour cell aggressiveness in HNSCC. Still, TAMs may in some cytokine environments have tumour suppressive potentials, which probably explains observations of improved prognosis associated with high numbers of TAMs in some other types of malignancies [
33,
34]. The observed reductions in HNSCC tumour mass when injected with biological response modifiers such as OK-432, may be in part be explained by such macrophage activation [
35].
Previously, it has been shown that monocytes in HNSCC patients compared to control patients are primed for an increased sensitivity to endotoxin stimulation as measured by cytokine secretion [
8]. The present study confirms these observations and further shows that monocyte function actually may provide information as to prognosis of HNSCC disease. We have previously determined in another patient sample that IL-6 secretion from monocytes did not predict survival. It should, however, be noted that patients with more affected capability, as measured by Karnofsky scores below 75, were included in the present study as opposed to a previous study [
20]. Furthermore, when both of these samples were combined, prediction relying on monocyte IL-6 secretion was similar to this study (manuscript in preparation).
Both alcohol consumption and tobacco smoking are expected to be higher among HNSCC patients than in the general population because consumption of these substances has been linked to an increased risk of HNSCC [
36]. Smoking and alcohol use may influence monocyte function [
18,
19,
37]. In the present investigation, however, differences between HNSCC patients and control patients, as well as differences between the two HNSCC patient groups, and prognosis were present still after adjusting for tobacco and alcohol consumption. The observed changed monocyte function in HNSCC patients can therefore not be explained by alcohol consumption or tobacco smoking.
Monocyte sensitivity to endotoxin reflects prognosis when adjusted for TNM stage. Therefore it may be possible to identify patients having a better prognosis despite extended HNSCC disease. This might justify the use of a more extensive therapy regime in some selected patients with otherwise very extended TNM stage.
Observations from
in vitro studies suggest that IL-6 promotes cell proliferation and prevents apoptosis in HNSCC cell lines via activation of signal-transducers-and-activators-of-transcription-3 (STAT3) via a common β-chain of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) [
38]. STAT3 plays a critical role in the oncogenesis of several malignancies and has been shown to be activated in tumour tissue and in normal mucosa of HNSCC patients [
39]. The activation of STAT3 is, however, shown to be complexly regulated via different kinases and supressors of cytokine signalling genes, which may explain the failure of treatment protocols based on EGFR- tyrosine kinase inhibitors [
40]. Lee and co-workers therefore suggest that multiple pathways to stimulate STAT3 should be targeted in patients with HNSCC in order to achieve maximal clinical efficacy [
40]. Thus, one possible additional therapeutic pathway could be an inhibition of the IL-6 stimulation of the tumour cells through therapeutic use of anti-IL-6 antibodies [
41].
Competing interests
The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
JHH planned and designed the study together with HJA who also performed the statistical analysis, helped draft the manuscript and critically revised the manuscript. JHH included each patient in the study and wrote the manuscript together with KK, who also took a major part when the manuscript was drafted. BK performed most of the laboratory work and carried out the immunoassays. JO revised the manuscript critically. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.