Background
Methods
Measure selecting criteria
Working group | Chair | Members | Disciplines |
---|---|---|---|
Behavioral Intervention | Paul Spicer (UCD, now at University of Oklahoma-UOk) | Belinda Borrelli (now BU), Barbara Heckman (UCSF), Karen Fehringer (UCD), Margaret Walsh (UCSF), Melissa Riddle (NIDCR), Michelle Henshaw (BU), Nancy Kressin (BU), Ruth Nowjack-Raymer (NIDCR), and Tracy Finlayson (San Diego State University-SDSU). | anthropology, behavioral science, dental hygiene, dentistry, educational research, epidemiology, health services research, pediatric dentistry, public health |
Sociodemographic | Stuart Gansky (UCSF) | Clemencia Vargas (University of Maryland-UMd), Jan Beals (UCD), Jane Weintraub (UCSF, now at University of North Carolina-UNC) | biostatistics, dentistry, demography, public health, social psychology |
Health Service Utilization/Insurance | Tracy Finlayson (SDSU) | Cindy Cadoret (BU), Daniel Brooks (BU), Steve Silverstein (UCSF), Terry Batliner (UCD) | dental hygiene, dentistry, epidemiology, health service research, public health, social psychology |
Oral Health Knowledge and Behavior | Judith Albino (UCD) | Angela Brega (UCD), Clemencia Vargas (UMd), Kristin Hoeft (UCSF), and Margaret Walsh (UCSF) and Jane Weintraub (UNC). | dentistry, dental hygiene, health education, medical sociology, public health, social psychology |
Health Status, Health History, and Development | Gloria Mejia (UCSF, now at University of South Australia) | Karen Fehringer (UCD), Paul Geltman (BU), Rosalia Mendoza (UCSF, now at Kaiser Permanente) | dentistry, epidemiology, pediatrics, public health |
Community Level-Social Environment, Culture | Paul Spicer (UCD, now at UOk) | Judith Barker (UCSF), Kristin Hoeft (UCSF), Maria Rosa Watson (private consultant) | anthropology, health education, pediatric dentistry, public health |
Psychosocial Factors | Angela Brega (UCD) | Judith Albino (UCD), Nancy Kressin (BU), Steve Gregorich (UCSF), Tracy Finlayson (SDSU) | biostatistics,, epidemiology medical sociology, social psychology, public health |
Cost Measures | Joan O’Connell (UCD) | Brenda Heaton (BU), Jane Weintraub (UCSF, now at UNC), Margaret Walsh (UCSF), Ruth Nowjack-Raymer (NIDCR), Sally Stearns (UNC), and Susan Griffin (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention). | educational research, epidemiology, dental hygiene, general dentistry, health economics. |
Domain (number of items) | Description | Scoring | Levels |
---|---|---|---|
Parental Oral Health Behaviors (12) | Items related to parental oral health behavior assess oral hygiene routines and feeding practices. The overall behavior score represents the percentage of oral health behavior items that were answered with an “adherent” response. Adherent means the participant reported following the recommended oral health behavior. | 0-100% | Parent/Family |
Insurance/Utilization & Cost (29) | These items assess access to dental care and utilization of dental health care for prevention and treatment for dental caries. | N/A | Child/Parent/Family |
Parental Oral Health Knowledge (15) | This measure assesses parental knowledge related to oral hygiene routines and feeding practices. The overall knowledge score represents the percentage of oral health knowledge items answered correctly. | 0–100% | Parent/Family |
Parent/Caregiver Dental Self-Efficacy (11) | The overall self-efficacy score represents how sure participants are that they can engage in recommended behavior to take care of their children’s teeth. The overall self-efficacy score is the mean of responses to all items. | 1–5 1 = Strongly disagree 5 = Strongly agree | Parent/Family |
Pediatric Oral Health Quality of Life (12) | This measure assesses the extent to which a child’s functioning is affected by negative oral health experiences. | 1–4 1 = all the time 4 = Did not happen | Child |
Parent/Caregiver and Family Sociodemographics (6) | Age, education, employment status, income, parent/caregiver relationship to the child and number of household members | N/A | Parent/Family |
Child Sociodemographics (3) | Race, ethnicity, and age | N/A | Child |
Domains (number of items) | Center using the variable | Description (number of items) | Range | Levels |
---|---|---|---|---|
Health Literacy (1) | BU and UCSF | Single Item Literacy Screener (SILS) of Chew et al. (2004) and Morris et al. (2006) | 1–5 1 = always 5 = never | Parent/Caregiver |
Health Literacy (2) | UCD | 3 items adapted from screening items developed by Chew et al. (2004) and Morris et al (2006) | 1–5 1 = always 5 = never | Parent/Caregiver |
Tribal Identity (2) | UCD | Tribal identity measures items assessing facility with tribal language and tribal values | 1–5 1 = always 5 = never | Child |
Acculturation (13) | BU and UCSF | The revised Acculturation Rating Scale for Mexican-Americans (ARSMA-II) | 1–5 1 = Not at all 5 = All the time | Parent/Family |
Oral Health Locus of Control (9) Subscales - Internal locus of control (3) External locus of control - powerful others (3) External locus of control - chance (3) | UCD | Attitudes about who or what has control over their child’s oral health outcomes (i.e., the parents themselves, the dentist, or chance) | 1–5 1 = Strongly disagree 5 = Strongly agree | Parent/Family |
Official Tribal Affiliation (3) | UCD | This measure includes items related to enrollment in the tribe | 1 = yes 0 = no 2 = pending | Parent/Family |
Insurance (7) | UCD | This measure included items related to Indian Health Services | 1 = yes 0 = no | Parent/Family |
Perceived Discrimination (9) | UCD | The perceived discrimination measure represents the amount of discrimination participants feel they are subject to, on account of being American Indian | 1–4 1 = Never 4 = Often | Parent/Family |
Sense of Coherence (13) Comprehensibility (5) Meaningfulness (4) Manageability (4) | UCD | Degree to which participants feel the world makes sense and has meaning | 1–7 Higher numbers indicate stronger coherence | Parent/Family |
Social Support (4) | UCD | Degree to which participants believe they have others available to help them when needed | 0–1 0 = No available support 1 = Support available | Parent/Family |
Chronic Stress (17 Subscales - Expectations (3) Location hassles (5) Community family dysfunction (2) Community risky behaviors (5) Community economic distress (2) | UCD | Ongoing stress related to personal expectations, hassles associated with the local community, and community dysfunction | 1–4 1 = Strongly disagree 4 = Strongly agree | Parent/Family |
Parent Stress Index (8) | UCSF | 8 parent stress items adapted from Detroit Dental Health Project’s adaption of the short version of Abidin | 1–5 1 = never 5 = almost always | Parent/Family |
Alcohol Use (3) | UCD | A shortened version of the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT). Referred to as the AUDIT-C. The alcohol score provides an indication of the degree to which a participant drinks excessively. | 0–12 Large numbers represent greater alcohol use | Parent/Family |
Distress (6) | UCD | Amount of distress experienced in the last 30 days. | 1–5 1 = none of the time 5 = all the time | Community Parent/Family |
Motivation (12) | BU | Items are summed to indicate how motivated participants are to engage in a variety of behaviors concerning their child’s oral health | 1–5 scale 1 = not at all 3 = somewhat want to 5 = very much | Parent/Family |
Caregiver Stress (9) | BU | The measured represents caregiver stress using the Hassles Scale | 1 = yes 0 = no | Parent/Family |
Oral Health Knowledge (17) | BU and UCSF | The overall knowledge score represents the percentage of oral health knowledge items answered correctly. | Four items are true/false;13 items have these response options: Good for your child’s teeth, does not affect your child’s teeth, bad for your child’s teeth, don’t know, and prefer not to answer. | Parent/Family |
Cavity Prevention Information Source (1) | UCSF | Where does the parent/caregiver get information about cavity prevention | TV, radio, dentist, family member, friends, magazine, doctor, WIC program | Parent/Family |
Sealant History, Knowledge, and Acceptability (6) | UCSF | Past sealant history, knowledge and acceptability | 1 = yes 0 = no Don’t know | Child |
Child country of birth (3) | UCSF | This measure collects information about the country of birth | N/A | Child |
Child birth order (1) | UCSF | Birth order | N/A | Child |
Importance of engaging in behaviors to support child’s oral health (12) | BU and UCD | Items are summed to indicate participants’ perceived importance of engaging in a variety of behaviors concerning their child’s oral health. | 1–5 scale 1 = not at all 3 = somewhat want to 5 = very much | Parent/Family |
Physical Living Conditions (4) | BU and UCD | This measure assess the living conditions of the caregiver (having enough food, decent place to live, sufficient clothing and access to health care) | 1 = yes 0 = no Don’t know and prefer not to answer are also options | Parent/Family |
Health Belief Model (16) Subscales -Perceived susceptibility (3) Perceived severity (3) Perceived barriers (5) Perceived benefits (5) | UCSF, BU and UCD | The measure represents the parent/caregiver agreement level with items related to each domain. | 1–5 1 = Strongly disagree 5 = Strongly agree | Parent/Family |
Measures working groups
1. How Tooth Decay Happens Cavities are caused by germs in the mouth. |
2. Baby Teeth Are Important Because they do not stay in your child’s mouth very long, baby teeth are not that important. |
3. Lift the Lip Parents checking their child’s teeth every month for changes or spots. |
4. Take Your Child to the Dentist There’s no need to go to the dentist unless children have a problem with their teeth. |
5. Protect Your Child’s Teeth With Fluoride It is best to use toothpaste with fluoride when brushing a child’s teeth. Getting fluoride varnish put on your child’s teeth. |
6. Brush Daily How many times a day should a child’s teeth be brushed? |
7. Limit Food and Drinks with Sugar How sure are you that you can: keep your child from eating frequent sweets (cake, candy)? How sure are you that you can: keep your child from drinking sugary drinks like soda, pop, or Kool-Aid? |
8. No Bottles or Sippy Cups in Bed Good/Bad - Drinking milk from a sippy cup at bedtime. |
10. Don’t Share Germs Using the same spoon to taste the food and feed the child. Sharing a toothbrush with your child. |
11. Help Children Brush Up to Age Six At what age can a child brush his/her teeth by himself/herself? |
Results
Centers | Sample size | Caregiver relation to the child (%) | Caregiver education (%) | Caregiver Poverty Status (%) | Caregiver race/ethnicity | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
UCD (Study I + Study II) | 1603 | Mother | 84.0 | <HS | 24.9 | Below FPL | 78.6 | American Indian (several different tribal affiliations) |
Father | 10.4 | HS or GED | 32.5 | Above FPL | 21.4 | |||
Other | 5.5 | >HS | 32.5 | |||||
College grad+ | 10.1 | Missing | 0 | |||||
BU study | 1036 | Mother | 94.7 | <HS | 22.3 | Below FPL | 88.9 | White Hispanic, White Non-Hispanic, Black Hispanic, and Black Non-Hispanic |
Father | 1.6 | HS/GED | 26.5 | Above FPL | 11.1 | |||
Other | 3.7 | >HS | 22.3 | |||||
College grad + | 28.9 | Missing | 7.0 | |||||
UCSF study | 597 | Mother | 88.1 | <HS | 37.8 | Below FPL | 74.8 | Mostly White Hispanic, but also Asian, White Non-Hispanic, Black Hispanic, and Black Non-Hispanic |
Father | 5.9 | HS/GED | 35.3 | Above FPL | 25.2 | |||
Grandmother | 3.9 | >HS | 17.2 | |||||
Other | 2.1 | College grad + | 9.6 | Missing | 25.0 |