Background
Methods
Search strategy and data sources
Inclusion/ exclusion criteria
Data extraction
Reference | Study design | Population (includes comparator group/s) | Intervention | Place (bold font indicates country) | Comparator | Timing of measures | Outcome Measures | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Epel et al., 2016 [1] | RCT | Healthy women (n = 94); Experienced meditator (n = 30), Novice meditator (n = 33), Vacation (n = 31) | 5-day Meditation Retreat: Meditaton and yoga. | Chopra Center for Wellbeing, La Costa Resort, Carlsbad, California, United States | Vacation at the same venue without meditation retreat activities | Pre-retreat, post-retreat, 1 and 10 months post-retreat. | Gene expression changes (transcriptome-wide expression patterns), aging-related biomarkers (telomerase activity, Aβ peptide levels), depressive symptoms, perceived stress, vitality and mindfulness. | Highly sig. Gene expression changes observed across all groups post-retreat (the ‘vacation effect’) characterized by improved regulation of stress response, immune function and amyloid beta (Aβ) metabolism. Sig. improvement in all groups in depressive symptoms, perceived stress, mindful awareness and vitality immediately after and 1-month post-retreat. The novice group improved sig more on mindfulness than the other two groups at day 5 and at 1-month and 10-months post-retreat. |
Mills et al., 2016 [2] | Quasi-randomised trial | Healthy men and women (n = 119); Intervention (n = 65), Vacation ((n = 54) | 6-day Panchakarma Ayurvedic Retreat ‘Perfect Health (PH) Program’: Physical cleansing through ingestion of herbs, fiber, and oils. Twice-daily Ayurvedic light plant-based meals. Daily Ayurvedic oil massage, heating treatments (sauna and/or steam, lectures on Ayurvedic principles, lifestyle, meditation and yoga philosophy. Twice-daily group meditation, daily yoga and breathing exercises (pranayama), emotional expression through journaling and emotional support. Integrative medical consultation (1-h) with a physician and follow-up with Ayurvedic health educator. | Chopra Center for Wellbeing, La Costa Resort, Carlsbad, California, United States | Vacation at the same venue without meditation retreat activities | Pre-retreat, post-retreat and 1 and 10 months post-retreat. | The Spirituality Scale, Gratitude questionnaire, Self-Compassion Scale, Ryff Scale of Psychological Wellbeing, Center for Epidemiology Studies-Depression (CES-D) tool, Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement System (PROMIS) Anxiety Scale. Other outcomes obtained were BP, height, weight (reported in Peterson 2016) | Sig. increases in spirituality (p < 0.01) and gratitude (p < 0.05) in the retreat group and no change in control group. Sustained increases in spirituality (p < 0.01), gratitude. and self-compassion (p < 0.01) and reduced anxiety (p < 0.05) at 1-month follow-up. |
Peterson et al., 2016 [3] | RCT | Healthy men and women (n = 119); Intervention (n = 65), Vacation (n = 54) | 6-day Panchakarma Ayurvedic Retreat ‘Perfect Health (PH) Program’: Ayurvedic herbs using the Zrii purify herbal program, vegetarian diet, meditation, yoga, Ayurvedic oil massage, heat therapies and lectures on self-care and wellbeing. | Chopra Centre for Wellbeing, La Costa Resort, Carlsbad, California, United States | Vacation at the same venue without meditation retreat activities | Pre and post-retreat | BMI, systolic and diastolic BP, heart rate, saliva, stool, fasting blood sample, alcohol use, caffeine use, biological markers of cell biology, genome, metabolome and microbiome. Psychological indices of wellbeing (reported in Mills 2016) | Statistically sig. Changes (decrease) in plasma levels of phosphatidylcholines, sphingomyelins and others after 6 days. |
Taren et al., 2015 [4] | Single-blind RCT | Stressed unemployed job-seeking community adults ((n = 35); Intervention (n = 18), Vacation (n = 17) | 3-day Enhancement Through Mindfulness (HEM) Retreat: Mindfulness training through body scan awareness exercises, sitting and walking meditations, mindful eating and mindful movement (gentle hatha yoga postures), discussion of individual observations and practices. | Residential Retreat, Pittburgh, Pennsylvania, United States | Vacation at the same venue without meditation retreat activities | Pre-retreat (up to 4 weeks before), post-retreat (up to 2 weeks after) and 4 months post-retreat | Neuroimaging assessment (resting state functional connectivity (rsFC) scan), hair sample (cumulative hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis activation), Perceived Stress Scale (PSS). | Sig. changes in resting state functional connectivity (rsFC) in the right amygdala-subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC) of intervention group (time-treatment interaction p < 0.05). |
Gilbert et al., 2014 [5] | RCT | Women, aged 31 to 60, with no meditation experience (n = 66) randomised to intervention or vacation ((n = not reported) control (n = not reported) | 5-day resort stay to attend meditation, yoga, awareness and self-reflection training (intervention) or to relax at the resort and receive health lectures (control). Both groups received the same diet. | Chopra Center for Wellbeing, La Costa Resort, Carlsbad, California, United States | Vacation at the same venue without meditation retreat activities | Pre- and post-retreat | Stress, affect, reactivity and rumination (end-of day diaries). | Sig. increase in positive affect and decrease in negative affect post-retreat in the retreat but not the control group. Both groups felt less ‘stressed’ post-retreat (p’s < .001).Only retreat women reported sig. Greater control over stressors (p = .01). All participants reported decreased rumination post-retreat, with more pronounced changes in the retreat group (p’s < .001). |
Pidgeon et al., 2014 [6] | RCT | Human services professionals (n = 44); Intervention (n = 22), Nil intervention ((n = 22) | 2.5-day Mindfulness with Metta Training (MMTP) Retreat and 2 × 4-Hour Follow-up over 12-weeks: Periods of silence, training in mindfulness and metta skills and cognitive therapy strategies to increase mindfulness and self-compassion. Follow-up included review and practice of mindfulness, metta and cognitive strategies. | Residential Facility, Southern Queensland, Australia | No intervention | Pre-retreat, post-retreat, 1 and 4 months post-retreat | Resilience (The Resilience Scale), Mindfulness (The Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire) and Self-compassion (The Self-Compassion Scale). | No sig. Differences reported immediately post-retreat with sig. Improvements in mindfulness and self-compassion in the retreat group at 1- and 4-months post-retreat and in resilience at 4-months post-retreat. |
Kwiatkowski et al., 2013 [7] | Randomised multicenter trial | Non-metastatic breast cancer patients in complete remission (n = 232) intervention (n = 117), control (n = 115) | 13-day SPA stay by small groups of patients comprising physical training, dietary education, physiotherapy and SPA cares. | Three SPA centres: Vichy, Le-Mont-Dore, Chaˆtel-Guyon, France | Not reported | Pre-retreat and every 6 months post-retreat for next 3 years | Anthropometric measures; Quality of Life (SF36 questionnaire), Anxiety and Depression (Hospital Anxiety and Depression (HAD) questionnaire) | Sig. increase in SF36 score by 9.5 points (p < 0.001), 4.6 (p < 0.5) and 6.2 (p < 0.05) respectively at 6, 12 and 24 months. Anxiety and depression score were reduced at 6, 12 and 24 months. |
Brazier et al., 2006 [8] | RCT | HIV/ AIDS patients (n = 47); Intervention (n = 20), Standard care (n = 27) | 15-day Art-of-Living with HIV Retreat and Weekly Follow-up for 12 weeks: Breathing techniques, meditation, movement and group process. Three breathing exercises are the essential elements of the program, particularly the Sudarshan Kriya or Healing Breath. At the end of the retreat, participants were given a daily home practice. Follow-up sessions included reviewing procedures from retreat. | Residential AOL facility in Quebec, standard care and follow-up in Vancouver, Canada | Standard care | Pre-retreat and 1, 6 and 12 weeks post retreat | General well-being, Mental Health Index (MHI), Health-related quality of life (MOS-HIV Survey), Stress (Daily Stress Inventory (DSI)). | Sig. positive changes in wellbeing, post-retreat with no change at later time points. |
Reference | Study design | Population (includes comparator group/s) | Intervention | Place (bold font indicates country) | Comparator | Timing of measures | Outcome Measures | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Al-Hussaini et al., 2001 [9] | Observational study with control | Vipassana Meditation Course participants (n = 45); Intervention (n = 14), Nil Intervention (n = 31) | 10-day Vipassana Meditation retreat involving silent sitting and/or walking meditation, avoidance of caffeine and alcohol, specific breathing practices and daily lectures. | Muscat, Oman | No intervention | Pre and post-retreat | General Health (General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-28)) | Sig. improvements in physical and psychological well-being in the Vipassana but not control group. |
Khurana & Dhar, 2000 [10] | Observational study with controls | Male and Female Prison inmates (n = 150); Intervention (n = 75), Nil Intervention (n = 75). | 10-day Vipassana Meditation retreat involving silent sitting and/or walking meditation, avoidance of caffeine and alcohol, specific breathing practices and daily lectures. | Tihar Jail, India | No intervention | Pre and post-retreat | Subjective Well-being, scale), Quality of Life (Life Satisfaction Scale), Criminal Propensity Scale. | Sig. improvements in Criminal Propensity and Subjective Well-being in male inmates of Vipassana group compared with conrol. |
Emavardhana & Tori, 1997 [11] | Observational study with controls | Teenagers, some teachers and other adults (n = 719); Intervention (n = 438), Nil Intervention (n = 281) | 7-day Vipassana Meditation retreat involving silent sitting and/or walking meditation, avoidance of caffeine and alcohol, specific breathing practices and daily lectures. | Young Buddhists Association Retreat Center, Bangkok, Thailand | No intervention | Pre and post-retreat | Self Esteem (Tennessee Self-Concept Scale (TSCS)), Life Style Index, Buddhist Beliefs and Practices Scale | Sig. improvement in self-esteem and self-concept post-retreat |
Chandiramani et al., 1995 [12] | Observational study (study I) Observational study with control (study II) | Prison inmates (n = 270); Study I (n = 120), No comparator. Study II (n = 150), Intervention (n = 85), Nil Intervention (n = 65). | 10-day Vipassana Meditation retreat involving silent sitting and/or walking meditation, avoidance of caffeine and alcohol, specific breathing practices and daily lectures. | Tihar Jail, India | No intervention | Pre-retreat, post-retreat, 3 and 6 months post-retreat (study II only) | Well-being (Psychological General Well-being Index (PGI) scale), Hope (Miller and Power hope scale), hostility questionnaire | Sig. improvement in physical and psychological health in the intervention group (Study II). Both studies showed sig. Reductions in anxiety and depression scores post-retreat (p < 0.001) in the Vipassana group but not in the control group. |
Longitudinal cohort study with control | Advanced breast, prostate or colon cancer patients (n = 15), their partners (n = 15), natural history group of patients (n = 20) and their partners (n = 20) | 5-day Tapestry Psychosocial Retreat: Intensive psychosocial intervention for palliative care patients and their partners based on the Commonweal Cancer Help Program. | Retreat and Renewal Centre outside of Calgary, Canada | No intervention | Pre-retreat, post-retreat, 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months post-retreat | Quality of Life (Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy – General Form (FACT-G), McGill Quality of Life Questionnaire (MQOL), Quality of Life in Life Thretreating Illness – Family (QOLLTI-F) questionnaire, Fatigue (Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy – Fatigue (FACT-F)), Spirituality and Purpose (Functional Assessment of Chronic Ilness and Treatment-Spirtuality Subscale FACIT-Sp)) Depression (Beck Depression Inventory-II, Hopelessness Scale, Brief Symptom Inventory-18), Index of marital satisfaction (IMS). | Patients in the tapestry group demonstrated Sig. improvement in marital satisfaction (p = .011) with less psychological wellbeing (p = 0.029), support (p = 0.021) and poorer social wellbeing (p = 0.01)than patients in the natural history group. Partners of patients in the Tapestry group reported more financial worries p = 0.05, and less marital satisfaction p = 0.05 than partners of patients not attending the retreat. Both the Tapestry and natural history groups reported more fatigue as time progressed regardless of groups. | |
Descriptive study with control | Men with biopsy-proven low-risk prostate cancer (n = 35); Intervention (n = 10), Standard care (n = 25) | 3-day Lifestyle Modification Retreat and Outpatient phase as part of 3-month Comprehensive Lifestyle Modification Program: Low-fat, wholefoods, plant-based diet with supplements. Stress management (gentle yoga-based stretching, breathing, meditation, imagery, and progressive relaxation), moderate aerobic exercise and weekly group support sessions. Education and counselling by registered dietitian, exercise physiologist, clinical psychologist, nurse, and stress management instructor. Outpatient phase included weekly telephone contact with a study nurse. | Retreat location not reported, United States | Standard care | Pre-retreat, post-retreat and 5 years post-retreat | BMI, blood pressure, relative telomere length of peripheral blood mononuclear cells and telomerase activity, Lifestyle adherence (Lifestyle-index scores). | Sig. improvements in weight, abdominal obesity, blood pressure, and lipid profile were observed (all P < 0.05). Sig. increase in relative telomere length after 5 years in retreat group compared to decrease in control. Adherence to lifestyle changes associated with sig. Increase in telomere length compared with control. |
Reference | Study design | Population (includes comparator group/s) | Intervention | Place (bold font indicates country) | Timing of measures | Outcome Measures | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Newberg et al., 2017 [18] | Observational study | Christian faith (n = 14), No comparator | 7-day Ignatian Spiritual Retreat: Morning mass, personal reflection, contemplation, prayer, daily meeting with Spiritual Director. Meals eaten in common dining area with other retreatants but typically maintain overall silence of the retreat. | Jesuit Center, Wernersville, Pennsylvania, United States | Pre-retreat (up to 1 month before) and post-retreat (up to 2 weeks after) | Dopamine and seratonin transporter binding in midbrain (DaTscan single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT)), Speilberger State Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI-Y), Profile of Moods Scale (POMS), Beck Depression Inventory (BDI), Short Form Health Survey (SF-12), Cloninger Self Transcendence Scale, Spirituality (Index of Core Spiritual Experiences (INSPIRIT)) | Sig. decreases in dopamine transporter binding in the basal ganglia and in serotonin transporter binding in the midbrain post-retreat. Sig. changes in a variety of psychological and spiritual measures including improvement in perceived physical health, decreases in tension and fatigue, more intense religious and spiritual beliefs, feeling more religious and more spiritual and increase in feelings of self-transcendence. |
Cohen et al., 2017 [19] | Observational study | Gwinganna Lifestyle retreat guests (n = 37), No comparator | 7-day Gwinganna Lifestyle Retreat: Choice of nature walks, boxing, dance, spin classes, qi gong, yoga, Pilates, meditation, educational talks, spa treatments, massage, body treatments, counseling sessions, and other healing modalities. Organic diet with mainly plant-based foods, some fish and egg protein, no added sugar or salt, no gluten, dairy, caffeine, alcohol, red meat, or canned or packaged food. | Gwinganna Lifestyle Retreat, Tallebudgera Valley, Queensland, Australia | Pre-retreat, post-retreat, 6 weeks post-retreat. | Height, weight, abdominal girth, blood pressure, urinary pesticide metabolites; food and health symptom questionnaire, Five Factor Wellness Inventory (FFW), Pittsburgh Insomnia Rating Scale (PIRS), Depression, Anxiety Stress Scales (DASS), Profile of Mood States (POMS), Generalized Self-Efficacy Scale (GSE), Health Symptom Questionnaire (HSQ), and Cogstate cognitive function test battery. | Sig. improvements in all anthropometric measures (p < 0.001) and psychological and health measures (p < 0.05) post-retreat with a trend for improved health symptom frequency and severity. Health symptom frequency and severity continued to improve and became statistically sig. 6-weeks post-retreat, other measures reduced somewhat and were no longer statistically sig., even though they remained below pre-retreat levels. |
Steinhubl et al., 2015 [20] | Observational study | Experienced and novice meditators (n = 40); Experienced (n = 20), Novice (n = 20) | 7-day Wellness retreat: Silent mantra meditation, talks, guided deep breathing exercise (pranayama), yoga and other activities supporting inner calm in individual and group settings. | Retreat location not reported, United States | Pre and post-retreat | Heart rate and heart rate variability (HRV), mean arterial pressure, electroencephalograph ((EEG); 14 sensors plus 2 references) | Sig., measureable EEG changes in experienced and novice meditators. Meditation was associated with a small, but statistically sig. Decrease in blood pressure in a normotensive population. |
Longitudinal cohort study | Multiple Sclerosis patients (n = 274); No comparator | 5-day Lifestyle Modification Retreat: Low-fat, plant-based diet, exercise, sunlight exposure, vitamin D and omega-3 supplementation. Educational program, meditation and stress reduction techniques, counselling, yoga and qigong. | The Gawler Foundation, Victoria, Australia | Pre-retreat and 1, 2.5 and 5 years post retreat (2.5 years phased out) | Health-related quality of life (HRQOL), Multiple Sclerosis Quality Of Life Questionnaire (MSQOL-54) | Sig. improvements in HRQOL including overall quality of life domain (p < 0.001); physical health composite (p < 0.001); and mental health composite (p < 0.001). Further improvements at 5 years for overall quality of life; physical health composite and mental health composite | |
Vella & Budd et al., 2011 [23] | Observational study | Female reast cancer patients (n = 28); No comparator | 7-day Photographic Art Therapy Retreat: Photographic art therapy in concert with psychoanalytically oriented group therapy, mind-body practices (optional yoga and meditation), lectures, discussion and support groups and very low-fat diet and exercise. | F. Holland Day Center for Creativity and Healing, Georgetown, Maine, United States | Pre-retreat, post-retreat and 6 weeks post-retreat | Anxiety, depression, and somatic symptoms (Brief Symptom Inventory-18 (BSI)), Quality of life (Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-General (FACT-G)), Spiritual well-being (Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Spiritual Well-being (FACIT-sp) subscale). | Sig. reductions in depression, anxiety and somatic stress and sig. Improvements in QoL and spiritual wellbeing that were sustained after 6 weeks. |
Conboy et al., 2009 [24] | Observational study | Women (n = 20); No comparator | 5-day Panchakarma Ayurvedic Retreat and 3-weeks (Min.) Pre-Retreat and 2-weeks Post-Retreat: Individual assessments, massage treatments, cleansing diet, yoga session, cooking class and group discussion. Pre-intervention includes guidance to modify diet and begin taking common herbal supplements. Post-intervention continues the cleansing process with lifestyle recommendations to maintain balance long term. | Kripalu Centre for Yoga and Health, United States | Pre-retreat, post-retreat and 3 months post-retreat | Health-Promoting Lifestyle Profile, Quality of life (SF-12), Self efficacy (single measure), Anxiety (Beck Anxiety Inventory), Social support (Interpersonal Support Evaluation List and Sarason Scoial Support Questionnaire), Perceived Stress Scale). | Sig. improvements in self-efficacy towards using Ayurveda to improve health with sig. Improvements in perceived social support and depression 3 months post-retreat |
Kennedy et al., 2003 [25] | Observational study | Rice Diet Program Participants (n = 101); No comparator | 10-day (Min.) Rice Diet Retreat: Very low-fat diet and exercise. Optional participation in yoga and meditation classes. Lectures, discussion and support groups, including a discussion group on spirituality. | Durham, North Carolina, United States | Pre and post-retreat | Spirituality (3 item questionnaire), well-being (12 item questionnaire), meaning in life (1 item questionnaire) and anger (4 item questionnaire). | Increased spirituality positively associated with increased well-being, increased sense of meaning and purpose in life, and decreased tendency to become angry. |
Beatus et al., 2002 [26] | Observational study | People with Multiple Sclerosis (n = 41) | 6-day summer retreat offered annually by The Multiple Sclerosis Society to individuals with MS. The retreat encourages physical activity, art, and social interaction. | Specific location not stated, United States | Pre- and post-retreat | Rosenburg Self-Esteem Scale (Self-E), Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQOL-54), Activities of Daily Living (Activities of Daily Living Self Care Scale for persons with multiple sclorisis (ADL-MS). | Sig. increase in the mental component of quality of life. |
Kennedy et al., 2002 [27] | Observational study | Patients with coronary disease and their partners (n = 72); Patients (n = 51), Partners (n = 21) | 2.5-day Educational Retreat ‘Choice to Review’: Open discussions with healthcare professionals, activities such as stress-reduction techniques, (progressive relaxation, yoga, breathing exercises, visualization, and imagery), exercise options, nutritional counseling and vegetarian food, group exercises that encourage self-efficacy, enhance social support, build self-esteem and improve communication skills, and spiritual principles and techniques for healing (meditation, prayer and forgivesness) | Remote location, United States | Pre-retreat, post-retreat and 4–6 months post-retreat | Spirituality (3 item questionnaire), well-being (12 item questionnaire), meaning in life (1 item questionnaire) and anger (4 item questionnaire). | Changes in spirituality were positively associated with increased well-being, meaning in life, and confidence in handling problems, and with decreased tendency to become angry. No sig. Differences 4 and 6 months post-retreat. |
Risk of bias assessment
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) | Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) Self-reported outcomes | Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) | Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Other bias | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Epel et al., 2016 [1] | Low | Unclear | High | High | Low | Unclear | Low |
Mills et al., 2016 [2] | High | High | High | High | High | Unclear | Low |
Peterson et al., 2016 [3] | High | High | High | Low | Low | Unclear | Low |
Taren et al., 2015 [4] | Low | High | High | High | Low | Unclear | Low |
Gilbert et al., 2014 [5] | Low | Unclear | Unclear | High | Unclear | Unclear | Low |
Pidgeon et al., 2014 [6] | Low | Unclear | Unclear | High | High | Unclear | Low |
Kwiatkowski et al., 2013 [7] | Low | Unclear | Unclear | High | Low | Unclear | Low |
Low | Unclear | Unclear | High | Unclear | Unclear | Low |
Bias due to confounding | Bias in selection of participants into the study | Bias in classification of interventions | Bias due to deviations from intended interventions | Bias due to missing data | Bias in measurement of outcomes | Bias in selection of the reported result | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Al-Hussaini et al., 2001 [9] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Khurana & Dhar, 2000 [10] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Emavardhana & Tori, 1997 [11] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Chandiramani et al., 1995 [12] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low | |
Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low |
Bias due to confounding | Bias in selection of participants into the study | Bias in classification of interventions | Bias due to deviations from intended interventions | Bias due to missing data | Bias in measurement of outcomes | Bias in selection of the reported result | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Newberg et al., 2017 [18] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Cohen et al., 2017 [19] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Steinhubl et al., 2015 [20] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low | |
Vella & Budd et al., 2011 [23] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Conboy et al., 2009 [24] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Kennedy et al., 2003 [25] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Beatus et al., 2002 [26] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
Kennedy et al., 2002 [27] | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |