Background
Malaria is one of the leading causes of childhood morbidity and mortality, and
Plasmodium falciparum infection is responsible for nearly all malaria deaths. The World Health Organization estimated that in 2017 there were 435,000 deaths due to malaria of which around 61% were in children below 5 years of age [
1]. Children in malaria-endemic areas become most vulnerable to malarial infection at 4 to 6 months of age as maternally transferred antibodies wane [
2] and they then begin to acquire their own antibodies in response to repeated infection. Naturally acquired immunity to malaria develops over time with continuous exposure to infection [
3].
Antibodies play a crucial role in mediating acquired immunity to malaria. Blood stage merozoite antigens and variant surface antigens (VSA) expressed on infected erythrocytes (IE) are important targets of this protective immunity. Antibodies to merozoite antigens inhibit invasion of red blood cells (RBCs), prevent intra-erythrocytic growth [
4], and promote opsonization for phagocytic clearance [
5] and complement fixation [
6]. Antibodies to merozoite antigens of sufficient magnitude and function appear to contribute to immunity [
7]. In young children or those with limited malaria exposure, they may instead act as biomarkers of malaria exposure [
8,
9], with potential to inform surveillance and control activities [
10]. Among the tested antigens, merozoite surface protein 1 (MSP1) is the most copious protein found on the surface of the merozoite [
11]. Crucial for the primary interaction between merozoites and RBCs in parasite invasion [
12], MSP1 is a major target of opsonizing following natural exposure [
13]. MSP2 is another abundant, GPI-anchored surface protein necessary for merozoite invasion. Increased IgG level against MSP2 was associated with increasing age, higher haemoglobin level and reduced parasitaemia suggesting its protective effect [
14]. Erythrocyte binding antigen 175 (EBA175) is released from micronemes [
15] and aggregates at the apical region of the merozoite surface. Antibodies to the RIII-V region of EBA175 have also been associated with protection from malaria [
16‐
18]. Rhoptry-derived Rh2A9 help binding to the RBC receptors after the primary interaction between the RBC and merozoite surface proteins is completed. The level of IgG against Rh2A9 in children (5–14 years) was associated with lower risk of malaria [
19].
Antibodies to VSA diminish malaria risk by obstructing cytoadhesion to different host receptors [
20,
21] and initiating phagocytic clearance of IE [
22]. Several studies have reported associations between levels of anti-VSA antibodies and protection against symptomatic malaria [
23‐
26] but few studies have examined the dynamics of naturally occurring anti-VSA IgG in infants in a malaria-endemic setting [
27,
28]. In one study [
27], children up to 24 months of age did not acquire antibodies to VSA but in a high-transmission area of Tanzania [
29], children had dramatic increases in antibodies to VSA from 1 to 2 years of age. Recent studies in Papua New Guinea suggest that acquired antibodies to VSA play an earlier role in immunity to malaria than antibodies to merozoite antigens [
30]. These contradictory findings indicate the need for further studies to investigate the dynamics of naturally acquired immunity targeting both merozoite antigens and VSA in very young children.
This study examines the dynamics of antibody acquisition to multiple merozoite antigens, schizont extract and VSA in young children in response to ongoing exposure to malaria. The study was part of the International Lipid-based Nutrient Supplement (iLiNS) Project DYAD-Malawi randomized controlled trial (clinicaltrials.gov registration number NCT01239693). The original study reported that nutrient supplementation did not have any significant impact on anthropometric indices in 18 months old children [
31]. Another sub-study from the same cohort [
32] reported that malaria antibody acquisition (against the same antigens reported here) in early infancy was not improved by additional lipid-based nutrient supplementation. For this report, malaria antibody measurement at 18 months of age was related to concurrent malaria infection and to documented episodes of clinical malaria during early childhood to understand the impact of exposure on antibody acquisition.
Methods
Study location and participants
The study participants were 601 infants of 18 months of age from rural Malawi, participants in the iLiNS Project DYAD-Malawi trial. Detailed description of the trial design and supplements has been published elsewhere [
33]. Briefly, pregnant women were randomly allocated to supplementation groups that received either iron and folic acid (IFA), multiple micronutrients (MMN) or 20 g of lipid based nutrient supplements (LNS) daily. After delivery, women in the IFA group received placebo, whereas MMN and LNS supplementation was sustained for 6 months post-partum. From 6 to 18 months of age, children in the LNS group received 10 g LNS twice daily.
Detection of malaria
Children were followed up weekly at home and febrile episodes were investigated for malaria. Clinical malaria was defined as fever with axillary temperature above 37.5 °C and parasitaemia was confirmed by microscopy or rapid diagnostic test (RDT). For microscopy, slides were examined under 100× magnification and parasites were counted against 200 leucocytes. The RDT was the Clearview® Malaria Combo (British Biocell International Ltd, Dundee, UK) which detects the proteins P. falciparum lactate dehydrogenase and histidine-rich protein 2.
Preparation of plasma samples
Blood from participants was collected at the 18-month study visit. Plasma was separated by centrifugation and stored at − 80 °C prior to shipping on dry ice to Australia. Samples were thawed, heat inactivated at 57 °C for 45 min, and were stored at − 80 °C until assayed.
Maintenance of parasite culture
Three
P. falciparum lines were cultured as previously described [
34]. The E8B-ICAM line binds to ICAM-1 and CD36 [
35], and expresses group B/C
var genes [
36]. Rosetting line R29 expresses
var genes from group A [
37]. A 3D7-derived line had a group A
var gene as its dominant transcript, but its binding phenotype was not defined [
30]. Cultures were synchronized by hypotonic lysis using 5% sorbitol, and by regular gelatin flotation [
38]. To select R29 for high levels of rosetting, it was subject to two rounds of gelatin flotation. After the first round, the pellet was collected and resuspended in gelatin with heparin lithium salt, (0.05 mg/ml Sigma Aldrich), added to disrupt rosettes, and the supernatant was collected.
Measurement of IgG to merozoite antigens and schizont extract
Merozoite antigens MSP119kD, MSP2 (FC27 clone), EBA 175, and
P. falciparum reticulocyte binding protein homologue 2 (Rh2A9) were expressed and purified as previously described [
16,
19,
32,
39,
40], and schizont extract was prepared as previously described [
41]. ELISAs were performed as previously described [
32].
Measurement of IgG levels against VSA
IgG antibody levels against VSA were measured by flow cytometry as previously described [
32], and flow cytometry data were analysed as described [
42].
Data analysis
Data were analysed using Stata version 13.0 (StataCorp, Texas, USA) and graphed using GraphPad Prism version 5 (La Jolla, CA, USA). Antibody levels were measured as optical density (OD) for schizont and merozoite antigens, or as geometric mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) for VSA. They were expressed relative to the positive control which was a pooled plasma sample from malaria exposed individuals from Africa.
Seroprevalence was specified as the percentage of children whose relative antibody level was greater than the mean plus three standard deviations of the negative controls’ antibody levels. Negative controls were a panel of malaria-naïve Melbourne blood donors. Socio-economic status (SES) was derived from an inventory of key household assets (HHA) adapted from [
43]. Chi squared tests were performed to test the differences in seropositivity. Mann–Whitney tests were performed for comparing antibody levels between two groups and Kruskal–Wallis tests were performed to compare the antibody levels among more than two groups.
The association between malaria episodes and antibody seroprevalence in 18 months old children was investigated using logistic regression, and linear regression was performed to study the association of malaria episodes with antibody levels. Linear regression was done by transforming antibody levels to their natural logarithm; these were back transformed for reporting descriptive results. Multivariate regression adjusted for the covariates duration of gestation, HIV infection, gender of the child and maternal anaemia.
Discussion
Naturally acquired immunity to malaria is achieved with ongoing exposure to infections and subsequent acquisition of anti-malarial antibodies. Antibodies against merozoite antigens and VSA are thought to play key roles in conferring immunity against malaria [
26,
44]. The aim of this study was to examine how asymptomatic parasitaemia at the time of blood sampling and episodes of clinical malaria in young children affect the early development of antibodies against merozoite antigens and VSA. This study investigated whether the number of episodes in early life, or the age at which they occurred, influenced the development of antibody. The study found that at 18 months of age children who were parasitaemic had significantly higher levels of antibodies and seroprevalence to all the tested VSA and merozoite antigens than the aparasitaemic children, with the exception of antibody to Rh2A9. Children who had experienced clinical malaria episodes before 18 months of age had higher antibody levels and seroprevalence for the tested antigens than children who did not have any episode, and the levels and seroprevalence of antibodies at 18 months of age did not differ depending on the age of the child at the time of malaria episodes. This knowledge is relevant to informing vaccine development and strategies for sero-surveillance of malaria [
10].
Previous studies have shown that newborn babies and young infants are relatively protected from symptomatic malaria [
45,
46], and this has been attributed mainly to maternally transferred antibodies present in the first few months of life [
2,
47]. Young children become most susceptible to infection as maternally derived antibodies wane, and then gradually begin to acquire antibody in response to infections, thus developing naturally acquired immunity to malaria [
2,
3].
The present study examined the effect of clinical malaria episodes and parasitaemia on acquisition of antibodies by 18 months of age. At this time, little or no placentally transferred antibody remains, so antibodies elicited are likely to reflect naturally acquired immunity [
47]. Antibody levels against all the tested antigens were relatively low, in agreement with earlier studies showing the age dependent acquisition of antibody [
48,
49]. The proportion of children with detectable antibodies was highest for MSP1 (54.4%) and schizont extract (54.1%) perhaps because schizont extract acts as a crude marker of blood stage malaria infection whereas MSP1 is the most abundant merozoite surface protein [
11]. Antibodies to VSA expressed by IE predominantly consist of antibodies to PfEMP1, the main antigen on the IE surface [
50]. Antibodies to VSA are largely strain-specific and repeated exposure leads to the acquisition of a repertoire of antibodies to different variants [
51]. Slow acquisition of variant-specific antibody, and possible lack of infection with variants similar to those tested, could explain the very low prevalence of detected antibodies to VSA.
Children who were parasitaemic at the time of sample collection at 18 months had significantly higher levels of antibodies and seroprevalence to all the tested VSA and merozoite antigens (except Rh2A9) than the aparasitaemic children. This finding is consistent with studies from Kenya in which antibodies to VSA [
52] and to merozoite antigens [
53] were higher in currently parasitaemic individuals. In the latter study, there were more dramatic differences in IgG levels between parasitaemic and aparasitaemic children, than between parasitaemic and aparasitaemic adults. Over two time periods of higher and lower transmission, parasitaemia was strongly associated with higher antibody levels for MSP2 and Rh2A9 (and to other antigens including AMA1 and MSP4), and weakly with antibody to MSP1, EBA175 and schizont extract [
53]. In Malawi, by contrast, antibodies to all tested antigens except Rh2A9 were strongly associated with parasitaemia. However, it is possible that some infected children may have been missed because parasitaemia was detected using RDT, which may miss low density infections. Selecting antibody targets for surveillance of malaria exposure [
10] will require evaluation in multiple populations and age groups.
The relationship between antibody levels or seroprevalence and history of clinical malaria infections was also investigated. Both measures were higher in children who had experienced clinical malaria episodes before 18 months of age than children who did not, and the differences were significant for MSP1 19 kd, MSP2, schizont extract, and (for antibody levels, but not seroprevalence) for IgG against all tested parasite lines. This is in accordance with other studies that report antibody boosting following exposure to clinical malaria [
9,
27,
53‐
55], and suggests that merozoite (and VSA) antibodies act primarily as biomarkers of exposure in very young children [
8,
9]. Some children with no malaria episodes detected did have antibodies; this likely reflects the occurrence of low-density asymptomatic infections that were not detected during follow up and were sufficient to generate antibodies to some antigens.
When the cohort was divided into children with single or multiple malaria episodes, those with single malaria episodes had significantly higher levels of antibody against MSP1, MSP2, schizont extract (≤ 0.0015) and IgG against VSA for all three tested parasite lines (≤ 0.028) compared to those without episodes. Fewer children had multiple episodes, limiting statistical power, but these children also had significantly higher antibody levels against MSP1, MSP2 and schizont extract (≤ 0.0418) than those who did not have malaria. There was no relationship between the number of clinical episodes and either antibody levels or prevalence. These findings suggested that antibodies to MSP1, MSP2 or schizont extract were useful markers of history of clinical malaria, but antibodies to EBA175 and Rh2A9 were not. In Kenyan children 1–8 years old, MSP1, MSP2, Rh2A9 and schizont extract also showed moderate induction following malaria episodes in the previous year, while EBA175 did not [
53]. In sum, antibodies to MSP1, MSP2 and schizont protein extract may serve as good biomarkers for sero-surveillance of malaria [
10,
56], although other antigens such as AMA1 and MSP4 [
53] warrant further evaluation.
Infants’ immune systems are rapidly developing, and responses to infection may differ between younger and older children in magnitude or longevity. To investigate this, antibody levels and prevalence at 18 months were compared between children having malaria before 6 months of age, or from 6 to 18 months. Symptomatic malaria is uncommon in very young infants [
3], and only 31 participants (5.15%) had clinical malaria before 6 months of age, whereas 113 (18.8%) had malaria from 6 to 18 months of age. The levels and seroprevalence of antibodies at 18 months of age did not differ between these two groups, and both children with malaria before 6 months of age and children with malaria from 6 to 18 months had higher levels of antibody (except to EBA175) than children with no malaria. This is in keeping with observations suggesting that the time of first exposure to malaria or previous malaria episodes have no effect on the acquisition of antibodies to MSP1, EBA175 and VSA [
27,
28], although an earlier longitudinal study of antibody to MSP1 in infants showed highly dynamic antibody responses, with generally short-lived IgG peaks that correlated with symptomatic or asymptomatic infection [
47]. Development and persistence of malaria antibody responses in infancy require further exploration.
The strengths of this study include the longitudinal design, with home-based monitoring of children with weekly home visits to 18 months of age and prompt detection and diagnosis of clinical malaria, and the number of antibody assays performed in a large group of over 600 well-characterized infants. The study provides unique insight into the development of antibody responses to VSA in relation to clinical malaria in infancy. Possible study weaknesses include the infrequent blood sampling of asymptomatic children, which gave only limited insights into the relationship between asymptomatic infection and antibody acquisition.
Authors’ contributions
SJR and PA designed the laboratory studies. PA and KM designed the intervention trial. PB performed laboratory work. PB, SJR, PA and JGB analysed the data. PB and SJR drafted the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.