The Need for Integration of Religion and Spirituality into the Mental Health Care of Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Populations in Australia: A Rapid Review
Australia is a multicultural and linguistically diverse country. Despite the vital role of religion/spirituality in the mental health of people from culturally and linguistically diverse (CALD) backgrounds, it is not commonly included in their mental health care. A rapid review was conducted to critically evaluate the studies that identified relevant religious/spiritual aspects regarding mental health care for CALD communities. After a systematic search and screening, sixteen empirical studies were included. The findings of the review suggest that people from CALD backgrounds draw strength and comfort from their religion to support mental health. Religious/spiritual practices were identified as effective mental health strategies by CALD people. Religious leaders were noted to be important sources of mental health support and guidance for individuals from some CALD communities. Collaboration of religious leaders in the mental health care, and integration of religious/spiritual practices into mainstream mental health interventions, may improve mental health care for people with CALD backgrounds.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Introduction
Australia is one of the most culturally and linguistically diverse countries in the world (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2022a). From 2017 to 2021, more than one million people arrived in Australia, contributing to the 51.5% of residents who were either first or second-generation born overseas (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2022a). About 5.5 million people in Australia speak a language other than English at home and a substantial number of people do not speak English at all (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2022b). The term ‘culturally and linguistically diverse’ (CALD) refers to people born overseas, people with limited English proficiency, and children of people born overseas (Khatri & Assefa, 2022). Besides linguistic diversity, in the last 2 decades, there has been a change in religious affiliation in the Australian population. Attributing to recent migration and humanitarian entrants in the past 25 years, the percentage of people reporting an affiliation with other religions (other than Christianity) has increased from 3.5% in 1996 to 10% of the population in 2021 (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2022c). In 2021, the most common religions were: Christianity (43.9%); No religion (38.9%); Islam (3.2%); Hinduism (2.7%); and Buddhism (2.4%) (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2022c).
People from CALD backgrounds have a higher likelihood of mental health concerns due to the trauma experienced before migration, the stressful process of adjustment to the new culture migrants and limited language proficiency (Abbott & Silles, 2016; Minas et al., 2013). Furthermore, stresses such as difficulties in understanding the new system to access essential services in the host country, isolation and disconnection from family and other social support pose additional challenges for people from CALD backgrounds (Bhugra, 2004; Khawaja, 2007). Though there are no clear data on the prevalence of mental disorders (Said et al., 2021), about a quarter of a million first-generation adult Australians from CALD backgrounds are estimated to experience some form of mental disorder in 12 months (Department of Health & Aged Care, 2018).
Anzeige
Despite the struggles of immigration and mental health challenges, people from CALD communities do not access mental health services (Au et al., 2019; Fauk et al., 2022). While there are numerous factors of nonengagement, such as shame and stigma attached to mental illness (Said et al., 2021), lack of bilingual services (Mitchell et al., 1998; Tobin, 2000) and mistrust in the services (Said et al., 2021), people from CALD background deemed mental health services not compatible to their religious and cultural beliefs (Au et al., 2019; Carolan & Cassar, 2010; Tobin, 2000).
Religion/spirituality plays an important role in the lives of people from CALD backgrounds (Bairami et al., 2021). For instance, in a comparative study, Muslim Australians from culturally and linguistically diverse (CALD) backgrounds endorsed religious beliefs more strongly than Muslims from non-CALD, Anglo/Caucasian backgrounds (Bairami et al., 2021). Religion/spirituality is related to greater psychological well-being for people from CALD backgrounds (Chan, 2009; Hashemi et al., 2020), and they often prefer religious/spiritual interventions over mainstream mental health treatments (Bairami et al., 2021; Omar et al., 2017). In a study, participants from CALD backgrounds rated psychological counselling as less effective but rated Quran recitation as significantly more effective than non-CALD participants (Bairami et al., 2021). Similarly, in a qualitative study of Muslim refugees, primarily from Somalia, participants stated that traditional "talking therapies" were ineffective and preferred religious interventions over mainstream mental health interventions (Omar et al., 2017).
In view of the important role religion/spirituality plays in the mental health of people from CALD backgrounds (Ahmad et al., 2022), religious and spiritual aspects need to be an integral part of their mental health care (Beaini & Shepherd, 2022). There is a lack of policies that address the unique mental health needs of CALD populations (Minas et al., 2013). While specialised state transcultural mental health policies provide comprehensive information regarding mental health issues of CALD populations, general Commonwealth and State and Territory mental health policies currently do not have the provision for the inclusion of religion and spirituality in the mental health care for the people from CALD backgrounds.
The Present Study
This study aims to critically review the current evidence regarding the need for the inclusion of religion and spirituality in the mental health care of the CALD population in Australia. Since the review is about mental health care, studies relevant to mental health, including mental health resilience, and mental health outcomes were included in the review. It is anticipated that the findings of the review may highlight the importance of the inclusion of religious and spiritual aspects in mental health care for people from CALD backgrounds. The insight gained from the review may be used for the provision of evidence-based mental health care and relevant policy changes for CALD communities in Australia.
Anzeige
Method
Design and Protocol Registration
This rapid review used systematic methods to search and critically appraise published research conducted in Australia since the year 2000. Rapid reviews employ a systematic and rigorous methodological approach but may compromise the breadth or depth of the process (Khangura et al., 2012). The process of this review was guided by the World Health Organisation's practical guide on rapid reviews (Tricco et al., 2017). The protocol of the review was developed and registered with Open Science Framework (Malviya, 2022). The findings of the review were summarised using narrative synthesis to answer the research question.
Information Sources and Search Strategy
Two databases, CINAHL and PsycINFO, were searched. A systematic and comprehensive search strategy was developed using a combination of key terms and MESH terms. The search strategy was adapted in accordance with the guidelines of individual databases. See Table 1 for an example search strategy for CINAHL. The search strategy for PsycINFO is available in Appendix 1. Searches were limited to the English language and studies published in the year 2000 or later were included in the review. Unpublished studies, case reports and grey literature were not included in the review.
Table 1
Search strategy of CINAHL
DATABASE
CINAHL (from 2000 to 2022)
STRATEGY
#1 AND #2 AND #3 AND #4
1
(MH “Mental Disorders +”) OR (MH “Anxiety +”) OR (MH “Depression +”) OR (MH “Stress +”) OR (MM “Psychological Well-Being”) OR (MM “Quality of Life”) OR Resilience OR Coping
2
(MH “Immigrants +”) OR (MM “Refugees”) OR “culturally diverse” OR “linguistically diverse” OR CALD OR “non-English speaking” OR migrant OR refugee OR ethnic OR "Chinese Australian" OR "Indian Australian" OR "Arabic Australian" OR "African Australian" OR "Culturally and linguistically diverse" OR “multicultural” OR “Indian” OR “Chinese” OR “Malaysian” OR “Vietnamese” OR “Arab” OR “Iraq” OR “Iran” OR “Syrian” OR “Afghan” OR “Middle Eastern” OR “Sudanese” OR “Jordan” OR “Somalian”
3
(MH "Religion and Religions +”) OR (MH "Spirituality") OR (MH "Spiritual Well-Being (Iowa NOC)") OR (MH "Spiritual Healing +”) OR (MH "Spiritual Care") OR Prayer OR Spiritual practices OR Religious practices OR Religi* OR Spirit*
4
Australia OR Australian OR Australians
Limiters applied
English language, peer-reviewed, studies conducted in Australia
Search results on 10/08/2022
66
Study Selection and Eligibility Criteria
Studies of qualitative/quantitative/mixed experimental design that considered mental health, mental health resilience or mental health outcomes of people from CALD backgrounds were included. Only peer-reviewed studies conducted in Australia were considered. Detailed eligibility criteria are presented in Table 2. Screening of studies was conducted in two phases. The author assessed titles and abstracts against eligibility criteria in the first phase. Full-text articles were screened in the second stage.
Table 2
Eligibility criteria
Inclusion
Exclusion
Population/type of participants
Adults from, culturally and linguistically diverse CALD, non-English speaking, from the minority ethnic group, migrants. Clinical or non-clinical population
Studies related to infants/children, studies related to non-CALD populations
Context
Studies that reported the role of religion/spirituality in dealing with mental health issues or identified the need for inclusion of religion/spirituality in mental health assessment and/or intervention
Studies not reporting the role of religion/spirituality in dealing with mental health issues
Outcome
Mental health, mental health resilience, mental health disorders, mental well-being
Physical conditions, any other condition not related to mental health
Study design
Observational and experimental studies—quantitative and qualitative
Peer-reviewed, in English. Studies published in 2000 or later. Studies conducted in Australia
Not peer-reviewed, a language other than English. Studies published before 2000. Studies conducted outside of Australia
Quality Appraisal
The quality of the studies was appraised using the Mixed Method Appraisal Tool (MMAT) (Hong et al., 2018). Developed for the assessment of the methodological quality of empirical studies, the latest version of MMAT includes two screening questions and five criteria for each of the following five study designs (Hong et al., 2018). These study designs are: (a) qualitative; (b) randomised controlled trial; (c) nonrandomised; (d) quantitative descriptive; and (e) mixed methods studies (Hong et al., 2018). An overall score of the quality appraisal of each study and detailed appraisal is presented.
Data Extraction and Analysis
Data were extracted and tabulated under the categories; (a) author/s, year, and place; (b) participants’ characteristics; (c) study design; and (d) relevant findings. Data were synthesised using narrative synthesis. Narrative synthesis is the process of formulation of an integrated interpretation of findings from multiple sources (Popay et al., 2006).
Results
Search Results
Searches of both databases retrieved a total of 106 studies. After removing 14 duplicates, 92 studies were screened in phase one, and 40 full-text studies were screened in phase two. Of these 40 studies, 24 were further excluded. Results of the searches, screening process and reasons for exclusion are outlined in Fig. 1. Sixteen studies were included in the final review.
Fig. 1
PRISMA flow diagram of screening (Page et al., 2021)
×
Result of Quality Appraisal
Results of MMAT quality appraisal of individual studies are outlined in Appendix 2. One study was identified as mixed methods (Chan, 2009); 11 as qualitative studies (Brijnath, 2015; Fauk et al., 2022; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Omar et al., 2017; Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006; Ridgway, 2022; Said et al., 2021; Schweitzer et al., 2007; Youssef & Deane, 2006), and four as quantitative studies (Bairami et al., 2021; du Plooy et al., 2019; Hashemi et al., 2020; Stolk et al., 2015). All included studies addressed both screening questions and stated research aims and justified findings to answer research questions. Overall, all studies met three or more of the five quality appraisal criteria of MMAT except one study (Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006). In this study (Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006), while the qualitative data collection was adequate to address the research question, there was no explanation about the approach used for qualitative data analysis.
Characteristics of Included Studies
All of the included studies were conducted in Australia over the last 16 years in various locations. Two studies (Bairami et al., 2021; Du Plooy et al., 2019) were conducted online, while locations were not reported in the other two (Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Stolk et al., 2015). Locations of the other studies are listed in Table 3. Eleven studies used qualitative methodology (Brijnath, 2015; Fauk et al., 2022; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Omar et al., 2017; Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006; Ridgway, 2022; Said et al., 2021; Schweitzer et al., 2007; Youssef & Deane, 2006), four were quantitative survey studies (Bairami et al., 2021; du Plooy et al., 2019; Hashemi et al., 2020; Stolk et al., 2015), and one study used mixed method (Chan, 2009). Details of individual studies are outlined in Table 3.
Table 3
Characteristics of included studies
Study/year/place of study
Experimental/control or comparison (age range or mean age/sex/number of participants
Diagnosis
Country of birth or linguistic and cultural background/religious background of participants
Anglo/Caucasian (28), Asian (73), European (33), Middle
Eastern (39), Other
(9)/Muslims-Australians
Quantitative survey
In comparison with Anglo-Caucasian Muslim participants, CALD Muslim Australian participants were more likely to employ cultural attribution to mental illness. While Anglo participants more strongly endorsed mainstream professional treatment for mental illness over traditional and religious methods, Middle Eastern participants rated the effectiveness of Quran recitation significantly more than Anglo participants
Indian-Australian/Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Atheist or Agnostic, other
Qualitative
In comparison with Anglo Australian, Indian Australians drew meaning and peace from spirituality and religious activities. While Anglo-Australian participants made little mention of religion and spirituality, Indian-Australians reported using religious practices such as listening to religious songs and attending church/temple as mental health strategies. Religious faith was considered an important source of support and comfort for Indian Australian participants
Cont
40.9/M—10, F—20/30
Depression
Anglo-Australian/Christian, Atheist or Agnostic, Other
Religious practices such as prayer were identified as a mental health strategy. Participants valued the support from the church and temples to support mental health. Religion and spirituality offered participants insight to change their perspective during adversity
Southern Asian (India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka),
Confucian Asian (China, Hong Kong, Singapore, Taiwan)/NR
Quantitative survey
Both the Southern Asian and Confucian Asian groups sought significantly more support from religious/church groups compared to the Anglo cultural group and having greater amounts of this support was linked to higher psychological flourishing. There were no significant associations between distress and support from various groups including church or religious groups
Participants reported that African migrants' understanding of mental illness was influenced by their religious beliefs and not consistent with how mental illness is defined by Australian mental health services. Participants viewed this discrepancy as a barrier to accessing mental health services. Participants stressed involving local church and religious leaders in education and dissemination of information about mental illness. Since religious leaders are the first point of contact for African migrants, participants stressed educating them and involving them in the mental health care of these communities. It was also noted that African migrants would not feel shame to receive mental health information from religious leaders. Participants noted that the integration of some religious values (aspects) in mental health services may increase the acceptability
Hashemi et al. (2020)/Various locations in Queensland
30.41/M—199, F—183/382
NR
Middle Eastern/
Islam (348), Christian (5), Judaism (3), Others (6), No religion (20)
Quantitative, cross-sectional survey
Using structural equation modelling, this study explored associations between socioreligious predictors and the psychological well-being of migrants. Findings suggested that the religious identity of migrants was directly predictive of psychological well-being. Social connectedness with the ethnic community was a mediator in the association between religious identity and psychological well-being
Sri Lanka (49), Pakistan (36), Zimbabwe (21), Iraq (12), Afghanistan (10), Other (3)/NR
Qualitative
Participants identified religion as a protective factor and a buffer against hopelessness and supported mental health. Social support through the religious community helped participants to cope with stress and provided a sense of belonging. Religious practices such as prayers, rituals, reading scriptures and religious counselling were used as mental health strategies to manage stress. Adherence to a religious faith was a salient protective factor against suicide. Religious beliefs (for example, their future was left to the will of Allah) helped participants to adopt a positive outlook and supported mental health
Participants used their religion as a coping strategy to deal with the adversities and stress experienced throughout the migration process. Prayer was used as a mental health strategy and was used to combat stress. The sense of surrender through placing their fate in God’s hands helped in coping with stress and struggles related to migration. Religious community—church provided social, emotional, and material support. Religious beliefs helped participants to reappraise the adversities and contributed to coping with stress
Participants recognised drawing strength from religion through involvement in religious practices. They also found that religious community support was helpful for their mental health. Involving in religious activity provided a sense of belonging and helped in dealing with the feeling of isolation and sadness. Participants reported that the religious community provided a sense of comradery which helped with depression, anxiety, and loneliness. Involvement in religious activities such as khidmat (social service) helped to engage young participants and provided a meaningful role within the community. Religion was reported as a way of deriving meaning in life
Religious practices such as Dhikr (chanting) and bandagi (meditation) and reading of scriptures were used as mental health strategies. Participants reported using religious practices as mental health strategies even outside formal religious places. Attending jamatkhana (religious place) was reported to be vital for the psychosocial well-being of participants and provided solace and comfort through spiritual/religious reflection and developing social support networks
Participants raised the lack of community religious support and connection by not having a muezzin (call to prayer). Religious practices such as reading/recitation of the Quran, and attending congregational prayers in a mosque were identified as effective treatments by participants. Participants reported religious beliefs as an important aspect to develop resilience to support mental health. Some participants suggested that the young generation who might have integrated both Australian and Somalian cultures were more likely to use both religious and mainstream mental health interventions
schizophrenia, bipolar, anxiety and personality disorders
Egypt (2), Iraq (2) and
Lebanon (2), Colombia (1), Guatemala (1), El Salvador (3),
Ecuador (1), Spain (1), Chile (1)
Bosnia (4), Filipinas (6) and Iran (4)/NR
Qualitative
A lack of understanding of consumers’ religious beliefs and practices among mental health professionals was identified. Participants reported the need for mental health literacy among religious readers. Participants noted that religious leaders can be a suitable medium for education and support regarding mental health. Training and education of religious leaders and facilitation of linkage between them and local mental health services were recommended as they are the first call for help for people with CALD backgrounds
Albania (1), Indonesia (1), Hong Kong (1), India (2), Arica (1), America (2), UK (1)/Christian, Hindu, Buddhist, self-defined ‘fatalist’
Qualitative
Participating migrant women coped with the stress of divorce through their religiosity/spirituality. Communication and building/reinforcing the relationship with the divine through religious practices such as prayer helped them to endure adversity and rebuild their lives overseas. Religious beliefs helped to reframe their perspective on marital loss which helped in developing resilience. Through the lens of religion, participants were able to change the narrative of their loss and it provided hope for the continuation of life. Social and emotional support from the religious community and through collective chanting and group discussion of religious beliefs were reported to provide a safe place to the participants which supported their mental health
Participants reported a strong influence of religion (Islam) on their perception of mental illness. Some participants reported their faith as a barrier to seeking help. Mental illness was considered part of God’s plan, and an endurance test with the prospect of a better afterlife. The participants expressed that the older generation Somalis believed that God could cure mental illness through prayer and reading the Quran. Participants advocated seeking medical assistance in conjunction with religious and traditional therapies. The participants noted that clinicians should consider the belief (in both traditional remedies and western/medical treatment) of the Somali-Australian community when providing mental health care
Participants noted their religious beliefs as a source of strength and helped to cope with stress. Their belief in God provided meaning (perspective) in life which then helped to regain some control over their life. Participants reported using religious practices such as praying as a mental health strategy to help with the feeling of loneliness and sadness. A religious community such as a church also provided social, emotional, and material support
The study compared the functioning of Vietnamese-Australian (low English proficiency) and Australian-born patients with psychosis. In the study sample more (84.2%) Vietnamese Australian participants rated spirituality or religion as important than Australian participants (53.3%). About half of Vietnamese Australian participants attributed mental illness to supernatural causes, none consulted traditional healers
Arabic Australian-Egypt (18), Lebanese (16), Jordan (1)/Muslim, Christian
Qualitative
The participants demonstrated knowledge and perception of mental illness guided by religious beliefs. The participant reported that as per their religious law, a bridegroom can withdraw from a marriage contract if there is substantial proof of mental illness. This would affect the likelihood of marriage being proposed to any female member of that family since mental illness is considered a hereditary factor in the prospective bride’s family. Participants reported being more comfortable seeking help from religious leaders than mental health professionals. The role of religious leaders was emphasised as important and influential. Participants reported trust (confidentiality) and belief in the ‘spiritual healing power’ of religious leaders. Religious leaders were reported as the initial point of contact. Participants reported their beliefs on religious healing rituals such as reading verses from the Holy book
Anzeige
Participant Characteristics
The review included 2711 participants from 16 studies, with 1414 (52%) being females. The cultural and linguistic backgrounds of participants were reported differently across all studies with the majority of studies reporting country of birth, while others reported the ethnicity of participants. In the included studies, most participants were of African origin (du Plooy et al., 2019; Fauk et al., 2022; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Omar et al., 2017; Said et al., 2021; Schweitzer et al., 2007) and from Middle Eastern background (Bairami et al., 2021; Hashemi et al., 2020; Hocking, 2021; Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006; Youssef & Deane, 2006). Of 16 included studies, nine studies reported the religious affiliation of participants (Bairami et al., 2021; Brijnath, 2015; Hashemi et al., 2020; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Omar et al., 2017; Ridgway, 2022; Schweitzer et al., 2007; Youssef & Deane, 2006) with Islam being most commonly reported religion (Bairami et al., 2021; Brijnath, 2015; Hashemi et al., 2020; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Omar et al., 2017; Youssef & Deane, 2006).
Key Findings
The narrative synthesis of key findings from 16 included studies is summarised in three themes: the centralised role of religion/spirituality in supporting mental health; the use of religious/spiritual practices as mental health strategies; the role of religious leaders in the collaborative approach of mental health care.
The Centralised Role of Religion/Spirituality in Supporting Mental Health
Religion/spirituality appeared to play a central role in the mental well-being of people from CALD backgrounds. Religious identity was directly predictive of the psychological well-being of participants from Middle Eastern backgrounds in a cross-sectional quantitative survey (Hashemi et al., 2020). Religion/spirituality was reported to be important for Vietnamese Australian participants recovering from psychosis (Stolk et al., 2015) and was a source of comfort for Indian Australians with depression (Brijnath, 2015). Participants of included studies reported using their religion/spirituality as a coping strategy (Khawaja et al., 2008), a protective factor against depression and suicidal ideations (Hocking, 2021), and a source to develop mental resilience (Omar et al., 2017; Ridgway, 2022). Religion/spirituality provided meaning during adversities and distress (Brijnath, 2015; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Schweitzer et al., 2007) and was reported as a source of strength against feelings of isolation and sadness (Mitha & Adatia, 2016).
Participants in some studies reported using their religious beliefs to alter their perspective on a stressful event, which improved their mental health (Chan, 2009; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Ridgway, 2022). For example, in a qualitative study with nine migrant women of various religious faiths, participants noted how their religious beliefs helped to reframe their thoughts about divorce, changed the narrative of their marital loss and provided hope for the continuation of life (Ridgway, 2022). Religious beliefs helped participants reappraise adversities and contributed to stress coping in another qualitative study with Sudanese refugees who were primarily of Christian faith (Khawaja et al., 2008).
Social support through the religious community was reported to be an important mediator of psychological well-being in several studies (Chan, 2009; du Plooy et al., 2019; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Omar et al., 2017; Ridgway, 2022; Schweitzer et al., 2007). Participants in some studies reported that the sense of camaraderie and belonging to a religious community helped with depression and anxiety (Mitha & Adatia, 2016) and provided them with a safe place (Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Ridgway, 2022) for spiritual/religious reflection and the development of social support networks.
Participants in various studies viewed mental illness through religious and cultural lenses (Bairami et al., 2021; Fauk et al., 2022; Said et al., 2021; Stolk et al., 2015; Youssef & Deane, 2006). In a quantitative survey of 182 participants, CALD Muslim Australian participants were more likely to use their religious and cultural beliefs to explain the aetiology of mental illness than non-CALD Anglo-Caucasian Muslim participants (Bairami et al., 2021). In a qualitative study, African migrants' understanding of mental illness was reported to be influenced by their religious beliefs and not consistent with how mental illness is defined by Australian mental health services (Fauk et al., 2022). This disparity in understanding of mental illness was identified as a barrier to accessing mental health services in two studies (Fauk et al., 2022; Said et al., 2021).
The Use of Religious/Spiritual Practices as Mental Health Strategies
In this review, participants in several studies identified religious/spiritual practices as mental health strategies (Bairami et al., 2021; Brijnath, 2015; Chan, 2009; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Omar et al., 2017; Ridgway, 2022; Said et al., 2021; Schweitzer et al., 2007; Youssef & Deane, 2006). CALD Muslim Australian participants rated the effectiveness of religious practices such as Quran recitation significantly higher than non-CALD Anglo/Caucasian Muslim participants in a quantitative survey (Bairami et al., 2021). Similarly, while Anglo Australian participants made little mention of religion and spirituality in another qualitative survey, Indian Australians reported using religious practices such as listening to religious songs and attending church/temple as mental health strategies (Brijnath, 2015). Religious/spiritual practices such as reading scriptures, prayers, chanting, (Dhikr—Mitha & Adatia, 2016) and meditation (Bandagi—Mitha & Adatia, 2016) were reported as effective mental health strategies in the majority of studies (Bairami et al., 2021; Brijnath, 2015; Chan, 2009; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Omar et al., 2017; Ridgway, 2022; Said et al., 2021; Schweitzer et al., 2007; Youssef & Deane, 2006). The participants of one study reported using religious practices as mental health strategies even outside of religious settings (Mitha & Adatia, 2016).
The Role of Religious Leaders in the Collaborative Approach of Mental Health Care
The role of religious leaders in mental health care was emphasised in several studies (Fauk et al., 2022; Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006; Youssef & Deane, 2006). In a study with African migrants and service providers, participants emphasised the importance of involving local church and religious leaders in the education and dissemination of information about mental illness (Fauk et al., 2022). Participants in a few studies (Fauk et al., 2022; Youssef & Deane, 2006) highlighted the need for religious leaders' education and training because they were the first point of contact for some CALD communities.
The importance of involving religious leaders in the mental health care of the CALD population was also highlighted by the participants in several studies (Fauk et al., 2022; Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006; Youssef & Deane, 2006). According to one study, African migrants were reported to be open to receiving mental health care and information from religious leaders (Fauk et al., 2022). Similarly, in another study with Arabic Australians, participants reported being more comfortable in seeking help from religious leaders than mental health professionals and the role of religious leaders was emphasised as important and influential (Youssef & Deane, 2006).
Participants in some studies emphasised the significance of incorporating religious/spiritual components into mainstream mental health interventions, as well as the involvement of religious leaders in the collaborative approach to mental health care (Fauk et al., 2022; Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006; Said et al., 2021). A lack of understanding of consumers’ religious beliefs and practices among mental health professionals was identified in one study (Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez).
Discussion
This study aimed to critically review the current evidence regarding the need for the inclusion of religion and spirituality in the mental health care for the CALD population in Australia. The findings of the review highlighted the integral role of religion and spirituality in the mental well-being of CALD communities. Evidence from the included studies suggested that religion/spirituality was related to better mental health resilience and coping among people from CALD backgrounds. Consistent with this finding, in several other Australian studies, participants from CALD backgrounds used religion/spirituality to cope with stress related to physical illness (Ahmad et al., 2022; Kirby et al., 2018; Sellappah et al., 2001) and caregiving (Benedetti et al., 2013). Though not included in the review (due to the age range of the participants), in another Australian qualitative study, young people from CALD backgrounds noted religion/spirituality as a source of strength and resilience in dealing with mental health issues (Gorman et al., 2003).
There were several ways people from CALD backgrounds utilised religion/spirituality to support their mental health. Religious/spiritual beliefs appeared to provide them with an alternative perspective on stressful situations, which might have contributed to their mental well-being. Participants in some of the included studies used religious beliefs to reframe their stressful thoughts through the lens of their religious beliefs, which then supported mental health (Chan, 2009; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Ridgway, 2022). Supporting mental health through changing unhelpful thought patterns is the basic strategy of the most commonly used psychological intervention (DeRubeis et al., 1990). Since religious beliefs were reported to help change the outlook, faith-adapted psychological interventions (Abdul-Hamid & Hughes, 2015; Anderson et al., 2015), that incorporate religious beliefs into conventional psychological therapies may be an acceptable choice of intervention for CALD communities.
Anzeige
Although religion/spirituality was noted to be largely beneficial for the mental health of the CALD population, participants in some studies reported viewing mental illness from their religious perspective, which potentially posed a barrier to accessing mental health care. For example, participants primarily from African and Middle Eastern backgrounds and identified as Muslims, perceived mental illness through the lens of their religious and cultural beliefs (Bairami et al., 2021; Fauk et al., 2022; Said et al., 2021; Youssef & Deane, 2006) and preferred religious interventions over mainstream mental health care (Bairami et al., 2021). Consistent with this finding, in a previous review, mental health literacy issues were prominent in Muslim communities irrespective of their country of origin and despite their formal education (Gurr & Meiser, 1996).
While religious beliefs about mental illness were reported as a barrier to accessing mental health services in one study (Said et al., 2021) of this review, participants from CALD communities were open to using religious practices as mental health strategies. Of 16 included studies in the review, participants from 11 studies (Bairami et al., 2021; Brijnath, 2015; Chan, 2009; Hocking, 2021; Khawaja et al., 2008; Mitha & Adatia, 2016; Omar et al., 2017; Ridgway, 2022; Said et al., 2021; Schweitzer et al., 2007; Youssef & Deane, 2006) were either already using religious practices to support mental health or endorsed them as viable mental health strategies. This aligns with the finding of a study with young Somalians, who were reluctant to use mental health services but were willing to receive religious interventions (Johnsdotter et al., 2011). While mental health education and awareness remain important, incorporating well-evidenced religious/spiritual intervention into mental health care may increase service uptake among CALD communities.
The language barrier is another reason why people with CALD backgrounds are less likely to access healthcare services (Au et al., 2019; Henderson et al., 2011; Minas et al., 2013; Samuel et al., 2018). The body-based mental health interventions, which require little to no language skills, can be used as a supplement or alternative interventions for CALD populations with limited language skills. Some of the body-based religious/spiritual practices have substantial empirical evidence of mental health benefits, such as yoga, chanting, and breathwork (e.g. Brinsley et al., 2020; Lynch et al., 2018; Malviya et al., 2022a). As noted earlier, participants of several studies in this review emphasised the need for integrating religious/spiritual interventions into mainstream mental health care (Fauk et al., 2022; Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006; Said et al., 2021). Given the language barrier and preference for religious interventions, body focussed religious/spiritual practice (also termed sensorimotor religious/spiritual practice (Malviya et al., 2022b) can be a viable alternative for some CALD communities.
Sensorimotor religious/spiritual practice such as recitation of scriptures is well evidenced to support mental health (Babamohamadi et al., 2015; Mahmood et al., 2007; Rafique et al., 2019) of people from the Islamic background. As such, sensorimotor religious/spiritual practices such as recitation may be used as an alternative and/or supportive intervention for Arab Australians of Islamic faith who are hesitant to use counselling and other conversational therapies (Al-Issa et al., 2000; Omar et al., 2017). Additionally, three sensorimotor religious/spiritual practices (yoga, chanting, and breathwork) were identified as potentially viable interventions to be used in clinical services in a recent survey of Australian mental health professionals (Malviya et al., 2022c). Given the reported preference for religious/spiritual interventions and reluctance to use conventional interventions among people from CALD backgrounds, sensorimotor religious/spiritual practices may be integrated into mainstream mental health care for CALD populations.
Anzeige
Participants of several included studies in the review emphasised the importance of involving religious leaders in the mental health care (Fauk et al., 2022; Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006; Youssef & Deane, 2006) for CALD communities. Possibly due to religious beliefs associated with mental illness, participants primarily from African and Middle Eastern backgrounds felt more comfortable receiving care from religious leaders than mental health professionals (Fauk et al., 2022; Youssef & Deane, 2006). Training and education of religious leaders, as recommended by some scholars (e.g. Koenig, 2008), and linking them with mental health services to provide collaborative care may benefit people of CALD background.
Participants in one study of this review identified the need for rigorous and in-depth training for mental health professionals regarding different religions (Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006). Though participants of this study were people with mental health concerns (Prasad-Ildes & Ramirez, 2006), a similar requirement of nuanced and in-depth training regarding diverse religions and cultures was also identified in a qualitative survey with Australian health workers (Lindegaard Moensted & Day, 2022). Since one of the reasons CALD people may not access mental health care is that health professionals do not understand their religious and cultural beliefs (Mitchell et al., 1998; Tobin, 2000), training and education of health professionals are essential.
Recommendations for Clinical Practice
The following recommendations can be drawn from the rapid review. Exploration of religious/spiritual orientation is noted to be critical for CALD community mental health assessment and care. Faith-adapted psychological interventions may be an alternative for CALD people willing to receive psychological therapies. Sensorimotor religious/spiritual practices (e.g. breathwork, chanting/recitation, and yoga) may be offered as a supportive and/or alternative intervention to the CALD people. Religious leaders' education and training, as well as their involvement in the provision of mental health care for the CALD population, particularly those from Africa and the Middle East, may be considered. Mental health professionals who provide care to the CALD population may be required to receive in-depth training on various religions and cultures.
Limitations
The review considered the CALD population including voluntary migrants, refugees, and other humanitarian entrants. It is important to note that there is diversity at many levels within the CALD group. For example, mental health care for a refugee displaced from a war-affected country would differ from that of a voluntary migrant who came through skilled migration. Also, people from different religious and/or ethnic backgrounds may have unique mental health needs. As a result, while the review's findings may be relevant to some extent for the overall CALD population, they should only be regarded as indicative. More focussed research is needed to identify the religious/spiritual needs of mental health care for specific groups within CALD communities. Only studies on religion and spirituality were included in this review. Because there was no clear distinction in the literature between cultural and religious aspects, some relevant research that reported religious or spiritual components as cultural traits may have been overlooked.
Conclusion
This rapid review provides some insight into the importance of the inclusion of religious/spiritual aspects in the mental health care of CALD communities in Australia. Available evidence suggests that people from CALD backgrounds draw strength and comfort from their religion to support mental health. Religious/spiritual practices were identified as effective mental health strategies by CALD people. Religious leaders may play an important role in mental health education and care for CALD communities. Involvement of religious leaders in mental health services, and integration of religious/spiritual practices in mainstream mental health interventions may improve mental health care for people with CALD backgrounds. Mental health professionals who provide care to CALD communities, should receive training and education about various religions and cultures.
Declarations
Competing interests
The author has no relevant financial or non-financial interests to disclose.
Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
The Need for Integration of Religion and Spirituality into the Mental Health Care of Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Populations in Australia: A Rapid Review
