Background
Indicator | Research questions | Metrics |
---|---|---|
Quality | • What percentage of drinking water is contaminated with bacteria by the time it reaches the point of consumption? | • Total coliform bacteria and E. coli levels measured in numerous water samples |
• Given the complexity of the informal distribution system, where along the chain of access does water get contaminated with bacteria, if at all? Specifically, does most contamination occur at the level of the motorized pumps (the point-of-source), the hoses (the distribution network), or the household drinking water storage containers (the point-of-use)? | ||
• What are the key predictors of bacterial contamination of drinking water? Specifically, what are the roles of season, frequency of refilling water, quantity of water consumed, etc., on contamination? | • Gross appearance of water, water treatment method used, gross appearance of storage container, composition of storage container, and days since container was last filled and cleaned for every water sample collected | |
Quantity | • What percentage of households fail to achieve the WHO minimum recommendation of 50 liters per capita per day (l/c/d) for quantity of water consumption? | • Quantity of water used in the last week by each household represented in liters per capita per day (l/c/d) |
• What percentage of households fail to achieve a consumption threshold of 20 l/c/d, which is associated with high risk to health? | ||
• What are the key predictors of use of an inadequate quantity of water? Specifically, what are the roles of season, cost of water, and total money spent on purchasing water? | ||
Cost | • What is the average cost that residents pay per 1000 liters of water? | • Money spent by each household on purchasing water in the last month and week |
• How does the cost of water obtained through the informal distribution system compare to the cost paid by residents of other notified (government-recognized) slums who obtain water through the formal municipal system? | ||
• What percentage of monthly household income is spent on purchasing water? | • Mean household income in the community obtained from a separate survey of 521 randomly selected households | |
Reliability | • What are the health and economic consequences of an unreliable water distribution system? Specifically, how does periodic “system failure” of the informal distribution system impact key indicators such as quality, quantity, and cost? | • Data on major water indicators specifically collected from study households during an episode of “system failure” |
Methods
Study site
The informal water distribution system in KB
Study design for the 2008 Baseline Needs Assessment (BNA)
Study design for the 2011 Seasonal Water Assessment (SWA)
Analysis of predictors of coliform or E. colicontamination of drinking water | Analysis of predictors of quantity of water used in the household |
---|---|
Season | Season |
Quantity of water consumed (in l/c/d) | Total money spent purchasing water in the last week (in INR) |
Water treatment method used | Cost of water (in INR per 1000 liters) |
Gross appearance of water sample (i.e., clear or cloudy) | |
Gross appearance of container cleanliness (i.e., clean or dirty) | |
Container material (i.e., metal, plastic, or clay) | |
Days since the container was last filled | |
Days since the container was last cleaned |
Results
Water costs and hardships
Water indicator | Study period | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Winter | Summer | Monsoon | System failure4
| |
Water costs
| ||||
Monthly spending on water in INR1,2
| 379.8 (139.8) | 1022.0 (676.6) | 378.6 (114.1) | -- |
Mean (SD)
| ||||
Monthly spending on water in USD2,3
| 6.91 (2.54) | 18.58 (12.30) | 6.88 (2.07) | -- |
Mean (SD)
| ||||
Monthly spending on water as a percentage of the mean household income in KB2
| 5.9% | 15.9% | 5.9% | -- |
Estimated cost in INR per 1000 liters of water2
| 145.4 (87.0) | 327.9 (258.9) | 117.9 (56.6) | 463.1 (297.2) |
Mean (SD)
| ||||
Estimated cost in USD per 1000 liters of water2
| 2.64 (1.58) | 5.96 (4.71) | 2.14 (1.03) | 8.42 (5.40) |
Mean (SD)
| ||||
Comparison to government rate of INR 2.25 per 1000 liters of water2
| 65 | 146 | 52 | 206 |
Number of times more expensive
| ||||
Quantity of household water use
| ||||
Liters per capita per day of water use | 22.6 (12.6) | 31.2 (23.6) | 25.6 (13.2) | 23.8 (14.2) |
Mean (SD)
| ||||
Households using <50 liters per capita per day | 20 (95.2) | 17 (80.95) | 19 (90.4) | 20 (95.2) |
n (%)
| ||||
Households using <20 liters per capita per day | 9 (42.9) | 8 (38.1) | 8 (38.1) | 10 (47.6) |
n (%)
|
n (%) | |
---|---|
Frequency of water access | |
Does not purchase water | 7 (0.7) |
Daily | 144 (15) |
Every two days | 279 (29.1) |
Every three days | 231 (24.1) |
Every four days | 236 (24.6) |
Weekly | 62 (6.5) |
Time spent obtaining water | |
<½ hour | 584 (60.9) |
½ hour to 1 hour | 291 (30.3) |
1 hour to 1 ½ hours | 65 (6.8) |
More than 1 ½ hours | 14 (1.4) |
Mode of obtaining water | |
Delivery via water vendors’ hoses | 817 (85.2) |
Fetch water from outside their lanes | 125 (13.1) |
Other | 17 (1.7) |
Does lack of water affect you or your family members’: | |
Health? | 860 (89.7) |
Ability to go to work? | 371 (38.7) |
Ability to go to school? | 87 (9.1) |
Ability to study? | 38 (4.0) |
Ability to start a new business? | 13 (1.4) |
Ability to increase productivity in your current business? | 14 (1.5) |
Water purification methods used1
| |
Filter-based water purifier set | 5 (0.5) |
Cloth filter used during collection | 274 (25.8) |
Boiling | 165 (17.2) |
Alum | 8 (0.8) |
Other purifying agents (i.e., chlorine) | 18 (1.9) |
No purification method used | 568 (59.2) |
Why do you think that the community lacks running water?1
| |
Land belongs to an external agency, so that municipal government cannot provide water | 426 (44.4) |
The community is unauthorized | 111 (11.6) |
No one cares about the community | 182 (19.0) |
Don’t know | 289 (30.1) |
Other | 18 (1.9) |
Who has the primary responsibility for providing water to the community?1
| |
The local politician | 390 (40.7) |
The municipal system | 320 (33.4) |
Residents themselves | 44 (4.6) |
Other (i.e., local water vendors) | 263 (27.4) |
Quantity of water consumed at the household level
Water quality and storage
Water contamination indicator | Study period | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Winter | Summer | Monsoon | System failure | |
Tap water samples (“point-of-source” water)
| ||||
Chawl taps1 (n = 4) | ||||
Samples with coliforms | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 1 (25) | -- |
n (%)
| ||||
Samples with E. coli
| 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 1 (25) | -- |
n (%)
| ||||
Dharavi taps2 (n = 4) | ||||
Samples with coliforms | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | -- |
n (%)
| ||||
Samples with E. coli
| 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | -- |
n (%)
| ||||
Kaula Bandar motors and tap (n = 4) | ||||
Samples with coliforms | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 2 (50) | -- |
n (%)
| ||||
Samples with E. coli
| 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | -- |
n (%)
| ||||
Reay Road tap3 (n = 1) | ||||
Samples with coliforms | -- | -- | -- | 0 (0) |
n (%)
| ||||
Samples with E. coli
| -- | -- | -- | 0 (0) |
n (%)
| ||||
Kaula Bandar hose samples (“distribution network” water, n = 6)
| ||||
Samples with coliforms | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 3 (50) | -- |
n (%)
| ||||
Samples with E. coli
| 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 1 (16.7) | -- |
n (%)
| ||||
Kaula Bandar household level samples (“point-of-use” water)
| ||||
Drinking Water (n = 21) | ||||
Samples with coliforms | 3 (14.3) | 11 (52.4) | 16 (76.2) | 5 (23.8) |
n (%)
| ||||
Coliform counts for contaminated samples in cfu/100 mL4
| 74.3 (36.5) | 16.9 (8.2) | 43.1 (8.5) | 20.8 (9.8) |
Mean (SD)
| ||||
Samples with E. coli
| 1 (4.8) | 9 (42.9) | 6 (28.6) | 5 (23.8) |
n (%)
| ||||
Storage water (n = 21) | ||||
Samples with coliforms | 7 (33.3) | 10 (47.6) | 15 (71.4) | 8 (38.1) |
n (%)
| ||||
Coliform counts for contaminated samples in cfu/100 mL4
| 45.7 (34.8) | 19.5 (10.1) | 40.6 (6.7) | 21.1 (7.1) |
Mean (SD)
| ||||
Samples with E. coli
| 3 (21.4) | 7 (33.3) | 4 (19.0) | 8 (38.1) |
n (%)
|
Coliforms |
E. coli
| |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Odds ratio | 95% Confidence interval | p-value | Odds ratio | 95% Confidence interval | p-value | |
Study period
| 0.002 | 0.086 | ||||
Winter | 1.0 | - | - | 1.0 | - | - |
Summer | 4.3 | 1.1 - 16.1 | 0.032 | 15.0 | 1.7 – 133.6 | 0.015 |
Monsoon | 10.2 | 2.5 - 42.4 | 0.001 | 6.3 | 0.7 – 59.0 | 0.110 |
System failure | 1.0 | 0.2 - 4.1 | 1.000 | 6.3 | 0.7 – 59.0 | 0.110 |