Introduction
Lung cancer, of which the major subtype is non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), is one of the leading causes of cancer-related deaths worldwide [
1]. The large scales of patients with NSCLC are diagnosed with metastatic disease, which is generally fatal and experiences a low 5-year survival rate (≤ 5%) when diagnosed with stage IIIB or IV [
2]. More than 80% of NSCLC cases are adenocarcinoma subtype, whose incidence rate has steadily increased over the past decades [
3]. Platinum-based chemotherapy was recommended as first-line chemotherapy regimen for advanced NSCLC in National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) guideline, especially, those without epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) mutations or anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) rearrangement and proto-oncogene tyrosine-protein kinase ROS (ROS1) translocations [
4]. However, clinical outcomes is varying from individuals, and no widely applicable biomarkers have been successfully applied to daily clinical practice. Due to the little information about biomarkers to evaluate the chemotherapy response, it is clinically important to find out novel predictive markers for treatment response and survival after platinum-based chemotherapy in patients with NSCLC. Currently, development of next-generation sequencing (NGS) technology and genotyping has offered promising prospects on the molecular pathology of NSCLC.
The repeat tissue biopsy can potentially provide prognostic information on chemotherapy efficacy but is limited to longitudinal monitoring for its invasive manipulation [
5]. Furthermore, it may fail to reflect the intra- and inter-tumor genetic heterogeneity [
6,
7]. Compared with tissue biopsy, blood is easier to obtain and less expensive. Besides, it can deliver a more comprehensive genomic profiling because tumor either in first-site or metastases can shed genomic DNA information to the bloodstream [
8,
9]. Liquid biopsy via circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) in blood provides an attractive alternative for long terms evaluation and prediction for lung cancer patients and ctDNA level may provide a more comprehensive picture of the lung cancer, because markers spreading in the blood may contain cancer-associated materials from many diseases site in the body organs.
An increased understanding about ctDNA as predictor and biomarker for disease response and survival in NSCLC patients has come forth in recent years. Some studies showed the ctDNA concentration is associated with poor prognostic results [
10,
11], while other studies assessed the predictive and prognostic value of cfDNA concentration or EGFR mutation in NSCLC patients treated with chemotherapy [
12], but these studies are limited to obtain a few genes, not reflecting the full spectrum of mutations emerging during the treatment. In addition, there is a lack of clinical information on prediction of efficacy for advanced NSCLC patients after chemotherapy, especially through dynamic monitoring.
Here we assessed the genetic dynamics changes in ctDNA before and during chemotherapy treatment, a targeted sequencing panel Oseq-ctDNA based on the Illumina platform was used with a customized bioinformatics pipeline to identify novel responsiveness associated biomarkers and potential actionable targets in advanced lung adenocarcinoma.
Discussion
This study was designed to explore the dynamic genetic alterations during first line platinum-based doublet chemotherapy in advanced NSCLC patients, and investigate the potential genomic variations associated with clinical response based on 508 cancer-related gene assessments. We explored the great potential of ctDNA in cancer prognostic prediction and depicted the genetic spectrum under chemotherapy. Mutation burden and some key mutations were found decreased following chemotherapy. Several critical pathways and potential drug targets were identified, which might provide guidance of individualized lung cancer therapy.
In fact, ctDNA is convenient to obtain and less risk to patients compared with tissue biopsy. Theoretically, ctDNA may carry more information on the entire tumor regardless of tumor heterogeneity caused by sampling of a single site [
31]. CtDNA has been demonstrated to be a potential material for tumor early detection and efficacy monitoring, consequently, FDA has approved several companion diagnostic devices based on blood testing. This study provides that ctDNA assessments could be used to reliably monitor and correlated with clinical outcome to explore a potential technique of cancer treatment. Since analytical validity is critical to the assessment of clinical significance [
32], we validated the potential mutations detected in both blood and matched tissues of two patient before treatment. We found that the concordance rates of mutation between blood and tissue were 32.3% and 20%, respectively, which was within a range of 15%-94% in previous report [
33].
We noticed that mutation burden was decreased following cycles of chemotherapy, and patients harboring more non-silent mutations showed better response Tumor mutation burden (TMB) was known as related to the efficacy of immune checkpoint inhibitors [
34], however, one recent report suggested that TMB may be a predictive marker of chemotherapy response [
35]. Our results gave a clue that chemotherapy has an impact on mutation burden, and mutation burden could be a potential marker of clinical response, which increased our understanding of mechanism of chemotherapy and the association between genomic alteration with chemotherapy. Among mutations altered following chemotherapy, C>G substitutions were significantly decreased, and C>A point-mutation was also associated with chemotherapy efficacy (Additional file
11: Table S6).
Furthermore, some common driver genes, including
TP53 (p.K159X) and
EGFR (p.E709 K and p.G719A) were no longer detected after therapy, indicating these mutations may contribute to sensitivity to chemotherapy, although the biological behavior of these mutations was not fully understood, our study demonstrates their potential effects on chemotherapy and improved our knowledge to lung adenocarcinoma mutation landscape.
TP53 mutation can elicit oncogenic activities besides the loss of tumor suppression function [
36], previous studies have explored the predictive role of
TP53 in NSCLC with chemotherapy treatment, but the results were inconsistent. In a 253-patient study, the presence of
TP53 mutation showed as an approval factor in response from chemotherapy [
37], while a study with 35 patients indicated that mutant
TP53 associated with resistance to chemotherapy [
38], another report involving 524 patients found that no correlation of
TP53 mutation with clinical chemotherapy responses [
39]. Further investigations are needed to improve assessment of the prognostic value of
TP53 in chemotherapy treatment.
ROBO2 gene was considered as a tumor-suppressor gene in multiple cancers [
24,
40,
41], but this effect could be weakened by mutation [
26]. Another study found that mutation in the fibronectin and intracellular region of ROBO may significantly affect the function, and further facilitate disease progression and confer a worse clinical outcome.
ROBO2 mutation may disrupt ROBO signaling, and cause cell growth imbalance and apoptosis, which further lead to progression and poorer prognosis. Our results indicate that
ROBO2 may be a potential target in the treatment of NSCLC patients.
Moreover, besides gene mutation, several pathways were associated with chemotherapy treatment, and might be a potential drug target of lung cancer treatment. MAPK pathway comprised of the MAPK/ERK family, Big MAP kinase-1(BMK-1), c-jun N-terminal kinase (JNK), and p38 signal families [
42]. It is reported to be a critical pathway to human cancer survival, differentiation and drug resistance, its importance can be differentiated according to the origin of tissue [
43]. Driver mutations (such as
EGFR,
KRAS and
BRAF) have been identified in genes downstream of MAPK/ERK pathway. Our results demonstrated that more than half of the tumors harbored MAPK activating mutation in adenocarcinoma, suggesting that MAPK signal pathway is also involved in the regulation of NSCLC chemotherapy. The PI3K/AKT/MTOR signaling pathway also plays a key role in cancer biology, first generation MTOR inhibitors were approved for treatment of multiple cancer types, including renal, breast and some brain cancers [
44]. Potential of this pathway target has been identified for NSCLC chemotherapy [
45]. Our present study showed no much genomic alteration changes following chemotherapy treatment in PI3K/MTOR pathway, indicating that the combination of MTOR inhibitor and chemotherapy may be an effective therapeutic strategy for NSCLC. These findings underscore the need for further research into the mechanisms and targeted therapy of MAPK and PI3K/MTOR signal pathway in NSCLC. Somatic alterations including
EGFR, ALK, CDK12 were successfully identified, two of which are targetable by currently available drugs, these findings approved the usage of ctDNA for mutation detection and the potential targeted therapy in NSCLC patients receiving chemotherapy.
In addition, we analyzed the role of smoking in lung cancer. Smoking has been accounted for the development of cancer for a long time and correlated with 87% of lung cancer deaths [
46]. Our study showed non-smokers are more likely to benefit from Pemetrexed and cisplatin treatment than smokers, but not for Pemetrexed & carboplatin group, moreover, patients treated with Pemetrexed & cisplatin got a minimal survival benefit than Pemetrexed & carboplatin. In multiple analysis, TKI therapy was significant with overall survival, all these impact on survival caused by smoking status/chemotherapy regimen/TKI therapy should be cognizant by the oncologists.
In conclusion, we explored the dynamic genomic changes in ctDNA in advanced NSCLC patients received chemotherapy, the results demonstrated the potential predictive role of mutation burden and a subset of genes, and underscored the need for additional studies to further assess the biological mechanisms of MAPK and PI3K/MTOR pathway in chemotherapy. Moreover, this study gave a clue that non-smokers can better benefit from Pemetrexed and cisplatin treatment than smokers.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.