Urea cycle disorders in India: clinical course, biochemical and genetic investigations, and prenatal testing

Urea Cycle Disorders (UCD) are a group of inborn errors of metabolism seen frequently in tertiary care intensive care units (ICUs) in view of the hyperammonemic encephalopathy which is the most common presenting feature. The overall incidence of UCD varies from 1:8000 to 1:44,000 births [1‐4]. A more recent study from 3 countries in Europe reported an estimated cumulative incidence of 1 in 51,946 for UCDs [5]. Incidence of UCD is not known in India. All types of UCDs have been recognized.

The overall outcome of children with UCD remains poor, even in the developed world where excellent infrastructure and facilities are available [1, 6]. Children with UCD are recognized after symptoms of hyperammonemia such as lethargy and coma occur, thus leading to a significant delay in diagnosis. This may happen in babies who are screened as well, because neonatal hyperammonemic encephalopathy often occur before neonatal screening test results are known. A delay in diagnosis results in either death or neurodisability [7, 8]. This is exacerbated by a lack of awareness amongst families and primary health care physicians, causing a delay in seeking medical attention. Additional factors in developing countries like India are inadequate facilities in most primary and secondary level hospitals that contribute to a poor outcome. For instance, laboratory ammonia assays are usually only available even in tertiary hospitals. Therefore, a majority of babies die without a diagnosis, or are recognized very late, contributing to increased morbidity and mortality. An accurate genetic diagnosis is essential not only for appropriate management of the child, but also for genetic counseling in the context of subsequent pregnancies and carrier testing. So far, only a few mutations have been reported from India [9‐12]. The Indian population is a unique mix of several cultures and sects, with considerable consanguinity. With the distinctness of Indian gene pool, mutations may be different from other populations and perhaps recurrent in some areas in view of closed community marriages, limiting the gene pool to an ethnic group.

We present here our experience in diagnosis, genetic testing and outcome after diagnosis of UCD in these families. The data was collected from two major metabolic centres in India.

A total of 148 patients from the two centres were collected, of whom 123 patients from 123 families fulfilled the criteria and were included in the study. Nine patients from Centre 1, and 16 cases from Centre 2 were excluded because of lack of a confirmed diagnosis. Seventy seven cases from Centre 1 and 48 from Centre 2 fulfilled the criteria and were enrolled. In the cohort of patients whose data was collected, 82% have been after year 2007.

The diagnosis was established in all 123 patients; 61 had citrullinemia type 1, 26 patients had OTC deficiency, 20 were of argininosuccinic aciduria (ASA), 9 had arginase deficiency, 3 had carbamoyl phosphate synthetase (CPS1), 2 had N-acetyl glutamate synthase (NAGS) deficiency and one patient each had lysinuric protein intolerance (LPI) and citrin deficiency (Table 1). All patients were diagnosed biochemically by quantitative amino acid analysis on dried blood spots (MS/MS) or in plasma (U/HPLC), except for LPI where both plasma and urine amino acid quantitation was performed by HPLC (see Additional file 1).

Clinical details were available for all 123 patients. Full clinical, laboratory, and outcome details are available in Additional file 1. Approximately three-fifth of patients (72/123, 58%) presented in the first 30 days of life (neonatal period), 88% of whom presented on or before day 7 of life (classical presentation). Thirteen cases presented in infancy between 1 and 12 months of life, and 38 after the first year of life. Overall male to female ratio was 1.7:1 (2.25:1 in OTC deficiency, 1.65:1 in non-OTC deficiency). Consanguinity and a positive family history were noted in 23% (26/113) and 33% (38/115) of families, respectively. All families were unrelated except one where a non-consanguineous couple visited our clinic after losing their daughter on day 6 of life with encephalopathy and no other investigations. Husband’s niece was detected to have citrullinemia type 1. Based on the history, the couple was tested and detected to be carriers of citrullinemia type 1. Apart from this, there were no related families.

Detailed description of all cases including demography, clinical presentations, family history, biochemical investigations, outcomes and prenatal diagnosis data (for subsequent pregnancies in parents of probands) are shown in Additional file 1: Table S1. A large number of cases presented with encephalopathy with or without seizures (94/123, 76%), either in neonatal period or later (Table 1). Half of the patients in the late onset group presented with developmental delay (22/51, 43%). A significant number of children had features of liver disease (10.5%) and failure to thrive (3%) (Table 1).

Urea cycle disorders occur universally with varying frequencies in different populations [1, 21‐23]. While OTC deficiency has been reported to be the most commonly occurring UCD, citrullinemia type 1 is reported to be less common [3, 5, 24]. In contrast, in our cohort, citrullinemia type 1 contributed to about half (61/123, 49.6%), thus making citrullinemia type 1 the most commonly occurring UCD in this cohort. The data was pooled from two centres, both showing similar results independently. OTC deficiency was observed with lower frequency in the cohort. In fact, the total incidence for OTC deficiency was less than half of that found for citrullinemia type 1. Although suspected in few additional patients (hyperammonemia with high urinary orotic acid expected in OTC deficiency), there was insufficient evidence to prove OTC deficiency in some patients because of the difficulty in performing enzyme based diagnosis (which would have required a liver biopsy) or due to lack of mutations in the OTC gene despite full gene study (sequencing as well as testing for larger deletions and duplications by MLPA). These difficulties are however well known and described earlier in large studies [25]. Many factors contributed to the failure to achieve a definitive diagnosis in all patients: the lack of availability of enzyme diagnostics at any centre in India, the invasiveness of the test (liver biopsy) along with difficulty in shipment of liver biopsy specimens in frozen state to another centre abroad, and the overall cost involved. It is therefore likely that cases of OTC deficiency are being missed in India, as known from literature [25].

The situation is different in the case of citrullinemia type 1, where a very high citrulline level on dried blood spot MS/MS can be reliably detected leading to further gene studies confirming the diagnosis. Presence of ASA in blood or urine is indicative of ASL deficiency, and for elevated plasma arginine of arginase deficiency.

Urea cycle disorder commoner than OTC deficiency has also been noted in Saudi Arabian population, where ASL deficiency has been described as the most common UCD. Consanguinity in this particular population seems to be one leading explanation [26]. Parallels can be drawn with the Indian population where both consanguinity and closed community marriages are the norm, leading to genetic isolates. This may be a part explanation to citrullinemia type 1 being more common in India. In our cohort, consanguinity was noted in 23% families. Consanguinity and close community marriages are important factors leading to increased occurrence of recessive disorders, at least in India [27].

The presentation in most Indian children was similar to what is known in literature, with both neonatal classic form and late onset presentations. In our cohort, the neonatal classic presentation was more common in all UCDs except arginase and citrin deficiency. This finding is somewhat different from other studies where majority of presentations are beyond first 30 days of life [1, 28, 29]. The more common early presentation in our cohort may have been a bias because neonatal cases are recognized more easily in view of a careful medical supervision in the neonatal period. A recent study from Europe reported 50 patients of UCD detected both symptomatically (39/50) and NBS/presymptomatically (11/50). In this cohort, 28 of 39 symptomatically detected patients presented with neonatal encephalopathy, thus corroborating with our observation of a neonatal presentation being more common [5]. The high mortality among the neonatal encephalopathy group in our cohort was similar to the cohort reported from Europe [5].

A family history of previous sibling deaths was present in approximately 33% of families. This highlights the immense burden of the disease on the families, and the ignorance as well as lack of facilities denying these families of an opportunity for early diagnosis and prompt treatment. This would have prevented the suffering, either by successful treatment of the index child or by prenatal diagnosis. Molecular diagnosis thus helped the families in prevention of recurrence of this difficult group of disorders.

Molecular analysis revealed several interesting findings besides being immensely helpful in family counseling. For ASS1 gene, there were two common mutations, p.Gly390Arg and p.Arg157His which constituted 65.5% of cases. These two are previously reported mutations and are present globally [30]. Most common mutation seen in multiple ethnic group is p.Gly390Arg except in the east Asian population where another mutation, c.421-2A > G is the commonest [31]. Another mutation, p.Arg265Cys seen in our population was common to the Japanese population [31]. There seemed to be a good genotype-phenotype correlation, which is in agreement with reported literature [24]. Two recurring mutations, p.Arg213Ter and p.Ser170Asn, were found in ASL gene.

In a significant number of OTC deficiency patients, a whole gene deletion was detected. In this disorder, whole gene deletions as well as nonsense mutations were noted either in neonatally presenting severely affected males or in manifesting females, while missense mutations were noted in mildly affected boys. This finding is also in agreement with literature [21, 32, 33]. The mutation p.Arg129His, showing a mild phenotype with excellent prognosis, has previously been described [34]. Similarly, p.Arg277Trp is known to be a mild mutation, reported even in male transmission [35].

Molecular analysis enabled successful prenatal diagnosis in 30 pregnancies with no false negative results. This is an effective way of reducing the disease-related morbidity and mortality, until appropriate facilities are made available for early diagnosis and treatment.

This is the first comprehensive report of mutations in UCDs from the Indian subcontinent. Increasing availability of gene sequencing has enabled higher numbers of prenatal diagnosis for UCDs. Establishing a precise molecular diagnosis by mutation analysis is helpful not only for accurate genetic counseling but also for accurate carrier testing, which is an efficient way for reducing the morbidity and mortality associated with the disease through prenatal diagnosis.