Introduction
Region | Characteristicsa | Summary of regional changes |
---|---|---|
North East (Cavan, Meath, Louth and Monaghan) | Population: 440,211 Area (km2): 6395 | • Region-specific reconfiguration plan partly implemented from 2006 to 2010. • Two emergency departments reconfigured to local injury units. • Some centralisation of trauma, acute stroke and coronary care (to Cavan and Louth) with rehab support in other hospitals. • Mater [Dublin North] is the percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) centre with supporting ambulance protocols. • Roll-out of general practitioner (GP) out of hours care. • Limited regional clinical governance. |
Dublin North East (Fingal, Dublin North City) | Population: 578,317 Area (km2): 532 | • No major changes. • Three large emergency departments with limited governance integration and differentiation of services (PCI centre at Mater [Dublin North]). • Out of hours GP co-operative established. |
Dublin South (Dublin South City, Dun Laoghaire Rathdown, Wicklow) | Population: 563,560 Area (km2): 2168 | • One emergency department reconfigured to local injury unit in 2013, with reduced hours in another. • Centralisation of acute stroke, coronary and trauma care to two hospitals (both in Dublin South City) but limited differentiation and integration between both. • Multiple out of hours GP co-operatives. |
Dublin Midlands (Dublin South, Longford, Westmeath, Laois, Offaly, Kildare) | Population: 761,324 Area (km2): 8442 | • Centralisation of acute stroke (Kildare, Westmeath, and Dublin South) coronary care (Dublin South) and trauma (Offaly and Dublin South) at several hospitals, supported by ambulance bypass protocols. • Limited integration of clinical governance. • Several out of hours GP co-operatives operating. |
South East (Carlow, Kilkenny, Wexford, Waterford and Tipperary South) | Population: 497,305 Area (km2): 9451 | • Designated hub for major trauma, and acute coronary care (Waterford – PCI centre supported out of hours by Cork) with ambulance bypass protocols. • Acute stroke care available at all 4 hospitals. • Informal clinical network with shared regional rota for emergency medicine consultants. • Single GP out of hours co-operative. |
South (Cork and Kerry) | Population: 663,176 Area (km2): 12,161 | • Region-specific reconfiguration plan largely implemented, beginning 2012–2013. • Two emergency departments reconfigured to local injury units, with another closing. • Acute stroke, coronary and major trauma care provided at hub CUH [Cork] with support of ambulance protocols and outlying centres (Kerry can thrombolyse and deal with most trauma and myocardial infarctions (MIs), Bantry [Cork] does thrombolysis). • Region-wide clinical governance structures established. • Single GP out of hours co-operative. |
Mid-West (Limerick, Clare and Tipperary North) | Population: 378,210 Area (km2): 8252 | • Region-specific reconfiguration plan largely implemented, 2009–2013. • All emergency care centralised to one hospital (Limerick), former emergency departments reconfigured to local injury units. • Ambulance bypass protocols and region-wide clinical directorates established. • Single GP out of hours co-operative. |
West (Galway, Roscommon, Mayo, Leitrim, Sligo, Donegal) | Population: 702,966 Area (km2): 22,649 | • Reconfiguration of one emergency department to a local injury unit in 2011. • Single hub for acute coronary (Galway is the PCI centre but Sligo and Roscommon have a mobile cath. Lab 1 day a week) and major trauma care with support services provided at other centres (Mayo, Donegal and Sligo take most trauma cases). • Acute stroke care available at all centres, excluding Roscommon. • Clinical directorates established across the region. • Several out of hours GP co-operatives. |
Methods
Service | Details of data collected |
---|---|
Pre-hospital Expenditure | |
General Practice: Activity, Funding and Staffing | • Claims through the Primary Care Reimbursement Service (PCRS) categorised as ‘Emergency’ and ‘Out of Hours’ were taken to represent urgent and emergency cases [15]. Expenditure related to these claims is also reported by the PCRS. • GP and practice nursing workforce figures were reported in a recent study [16]. • Data on workforce employed by GP co-operatives were gathered through surveys sent to the General Manager of each practice (response rate = 90%). • Additional data on healthcare service utilisation taken from the Quarterly National Household Survey [17] were used to estimate GP and practice nurse staffing and non-medical card activity and expenditure |
Ambulance Services: Activity, Funding and Staffing | |
In-Hospital Expenditure | |
Public ED and LIU: Activity, Funding and Staffing | • Public ED and LIU expenditure data were provided by the Health Service Executive’s (HSE) Healthcare Pricing Office (HPO). • Overall Hospital expenditure data were extracted from the HSE Management Data report [21]. • Surveys designed to collect additional data on ED and LIU consultant, non-consultant hospital doctor and nursing staffing levels were posted to all hospitals (Response rate = 33%). Secondary sources were used to supplement the survey data [22, 23]. • Presentations at each public ED and LIU were extracted from the HSE Data Management report [21]. |
Private ED and LIU: Activity, Funding and Staffing | • Data on consultant staffing and activity in private EDs were estimated by the HSE, based on contractual agreements with consultants around the split between public and private work. • Data on the number of presentations at private LIUs were used to estimate resources used in private clinics [22]. |
County of Residence: Utilisation | • The patient’s county of residence in relation to each ED and LIU presentation was extracted from the Hospital In-Patient Enquiry Scheme, held by the HPO. |
Population Estimates | |
County and Regional | • All population data were taken from the 2011 Census [13]. |
Pre-hospital expenditure
In-hospital expenditure
Analysis
Results
Are urgent and emergency care resources distributed evenly across counties and regions?
Region/County | GPs | Ambulance | Public EDs and LIUs | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|
North East | ||||
Cavan | 1.94 | 39.97 | 123.89 | 165.80 |
Louth | 7.35 | 47.96 | 152.37 | 207.68 |
Meath | 16.85 | 17.99 | 33.32 | 68.16 |
Monaghan | 1.95 | 55.27 | 13.37 | 70.59 |
Dublin North East | ||||
Dublin | 13.26 | 22.45 | 109.93 | 145.64 |
Dublin South | ||||
Dublin | 13.26 | 22.45 | 109.93 | 145.64 |
Wicklow | 9.65 | 37.00 | 0.00 | 46.65 |
Dublin Midlands | ||||
Dublin | 13.26 | 22.45 | 109.93 | 145.64 |
Kildare | 14.54 | 21.85 | 32.92 | 69.32 |
Laois | 13.19 | 33.25 | 87.71 | 134.14 |
Longford | 18.26 | 59.35 | 0.00 | 77.62 |
Offaly | 13.19 | 61.75 | 100.30 | 175.24 |
Westmeath | 18.27 | 55.96 | 65.15 | 139.38 |
South East | ||||
Carlow | 39.17 | 38.25 | 0.00 | 77.42 |
Kilkenny | 39.17 | 29.19 | 52.65 | 121.01 |
Tipperary | 13.53 | 59.05 | 60.83 | 133.93 |
Waterford | 10.62 | 41.61 | 96.70 | 148.93 |
Wexford | 12.08 | 32.59 | 55.05 | 99.71 |
South | ||||
Cork | 22.62 | 32.86 | 74.24 | 129.72 |
Kerry | 26.82 | 58.66 | 55.32 | 140.80 |
Mid-West | ||||
Clare | 12.63 | 58.85 | 14.31 | 85.79 |
Limerick | 21.19 | 26.14 | 100.83 | 148.16 |
Tipperary | 13.53 | 59.05 | 60.83 | 133.93 |
West | ||||
Donegal | 14.31 | 54.94 | 52.87 | 122.11 |
Galway | 14.29 | 36.91 | 90.24 | 141.43 |
Leitrim | 10.10 | 64.82 | 0.00 | 74.93 |
Mayo | 16.76 | 49.68 | 40.17 | 105.65 |
Roscommon | 10.44 | 71.52 | 28.24 | 110.21 |
Sligo | 10.10 | 25.34 | 129.52 | 164.97 |
National Average |
15.66
|
31.47
|
81.28
|
131.06
|
Are those areas with lower population density or deprivation associated with higher per capita funding levels?
Do those regions which have reconfigured have higher non-hospital spending to compensate for the centralisation of services?
Pre-hospital Expenditure | Public ED and LIU Expenditure | Private ED and LIU Expenditure | Overall Expenditure | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Dublin South | 46 | 79 | 14 | 139 |
Dublin North East | 33 | 98 | 7 | 138 |
South | 62 | 61 | 9 | 132 |
West | 61 | 61 | 6 | 127 |
North East | 45 | 79 | 0 | 124 |
South East | 59 | 64 | 0 | 123 |
Mid West | 60 | 60 | 0 | 120 |
Dublin Midlands | 42 | 63 | 0 | 105 |