Background
Aphids are important insect pests of plants and vectors for plant-infecting viruses [
1,
2]. Aphids are themselves infected by viruses, which may cause disease in the insects [
1,
3]. For this reason, aphid-infecting viruses have been investigated with respect to their potential use in biological control or as agents that might interfere with aphid-mediated transmission of phytopathogenic viruses [
4,
5]. However, viruses can sometimes act as mutualists, as demonstrated in at least one case for aphid-infecting viruses by a DNA virus, the
Densovirus Dysaphis plantaginea virus, which promotes production of winged forms of its host, the rosy apple aphid, which enhances dissemination of both the host and virus [
6].
The
Dicistroviridae, which are
Picorna-like positive-sense RNA viruses, are among the best-studied pathogenic viruses of aphids [
3].
Aphid lethal paralysis virus (ALPV) and
Rhopalosiphum padi virus (RhPV) are members of the family
Dicistroviridae and the genus
Cripaviridae (type species,
Cricket paralysis virus: CrPV) [
7]. Studies of CrPV revealed two internal ribosome entry sites preceding each of the two non-overlapping open reading frames (ORFs) of the dicistronic RNA genome [
8]. ORF1 encodes non-structural proteins: a suppressor of RNA silencing; a helicase; a protease; the viral genome linked protein (VPg), and the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). ORF2 encodes four structural proteins, VP1–4 [
3]. ORFs 1 and 2 are translated from the genomic RNA, producing polyproteins that are cleaved to yield the mature viral proteins [
9]. RhPV, first isolated from
R. padi in 1981, decreases aphid longevity and fecundity [
10,
11]. ALPV was isolated from
R. padi in South Africa and shares many biophysical properties with RhPV [
12,
13]. RhPV has a genome that is slightly larger (10Kb) than that of ALPV (9.8Kb) [
14,
15]. Both RhPV and ALPV can be transmitted between insects (horizontal transmission) and transovarially (vertical transmission) [
3]. Remarkably, these aphid-infecting viruses are also transmitted horizontally through plants, which serve as infection reservoirs but are not considered to be hosts, since they do not support virus replication [
3].
Big Sioux River virus (BSRV) was first isolated from honeybees (
Apis mellifera) following a study of the bee microbiome to identify potential causes of bee colony collapse disorder in the United States [
16]. BSRV has also been isolated from mosquitoes (
Culex tritaeniorhynchus) and in the soybean aphid (
Aphis glycines) in China [
17,
18]. Neither the diversity of aphids nor the range of viruses infecting them has been examined in East Africa. We carried out viral metagenomic studies on aphid and plant samples collected on smallholder farms in from different agroecological zones in Kenya, focusing on farms where common bean and/or maize were grown.
Discussion
In this article, we describe DNA-based species identification of winged aphids collected from farms in Kenya and the detection, using viral metagenomics, of dicistrovirus sequences in these aphids and in maize leaf samples. We found that
A. fabae was the only aphid species present in the bean plots sampled, despite these being located on small farms that had mixed cropping systems. The lack of aphid diversity was surprising, given the diversity of plants present on the farms. For example, at the Ndeiya sampling site, beans were intercropped with maize and potato, and a wide variety of fruit trees and seasonal vegetable crops such as cabbage and amaranth were present in adjoining plots. The absence of aphids other than
A. fabae could be due to two reasons. Firstly, the sampled plots may have had crop combinations that contained plant hosts unfavourable for other aphid species. Secondly, there may have been a seasonal effect on aphid diversity. Literature on the seasonal variation of aphids, in East Africa and Kenya specifically, is scant but past surveys conducted in Kenyan bean farms found that
A. fabae and
A. gossypii were the most prevalent aphids over the April to June long rainy season [
37,
38] but no information was previously available for the October to November short rainy season.
Viral metagenomic analysis of aphids and maize leaf samples detected three dicistroviruses: ALPV, RhPV, and a novel BSRV-like virus. ALPV and RhPV have been detected in
R. padi,
A. fabae and maize in South Africa [
11,
12], but not previously in East or Central Africa. The discovery of BSRV-like viruses in
A. fabae is, to our knowledge, the first report from Africa. Phylogenetic comparison of the ALPV isolates from our study with those identified by others and deposited in GenBank revealed two main clades. These results are consistent with the analysis of Liu and colleagues [
39], who also found two main clades for ALPV and suggested classification of ALPV isolates into two new species. Viral species demarcation is normally contingent on three criteria: evidence of different natural hosts; serological differences, and amino acid sequence identity between the capsid proteins being less than 90% [
40]. The Spanish and US isolates that are phylogenetically in a separate clade from other ALPV isolates are the best candidates for reclassification but they fulfill only the third criterion. In our study, isolates obtained in Kenya from maize and
A. fabae showed genetic variation, indicating that there could be more than one lineage of ALPV. However, the Kenyan isolates did not meet the divergence thresholds for reclassification as separate species.
Recombination is a powerful driver of viral speciation, especially in viruses with monopartite genomes [
41,
42]. For viruses with multipartite genomes, recombination can occur more in one of the genomic RNA components though the overall rate of recombination is infrequent [
43,
44]. Our sequence analyses have revealed the first evidence of recombination among for ALPV. The results point to the likelihood that the three isolates (KE Aphid P7, KE Aphid P9 and Israel) are separate strains from isolate KE Maize and this difference was caused by a recombination event.
There is currently no full genome for BSRV in GenBank and, therefore, our isolates may be BSRV or could be a BSRV-like, novel dicistrovirus species infecting
A. fabae. The BSRV-like sequences from Kenya cluster phylogenetically with viruses of the genus
Cripavirus. From previous reports, BSRV appears to be a multi-host pathogen; having been previously detected in honeybees, mosquitoes and soybean aphids [
16‐
18]. All discoveries of BSRV have been through metagenomic studies and hence BSRV is yet to be formally classified by the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses (ICTV), which until recently has required evidence of biological properties such as pathogenicity, host range and epidemiology. However, due to the increasing rate of discovery of novel viruses by metagenomics, the ICTV is waiving these requirements in favor of phenotypes inferred from genome analysis and sequence relatedness inferred from phylogeny, homology detection and divergence metrics [
45].
Dicistroviruses, such as ALPV and RhPV, utilize plants (in which they do not replicate) as reservoirs (‘vectors’) to infect new insect hosts in which these viruses can replicate [
3]. There is no evidence (from experiments done using RhPV) that dicistroviruses replicate in plant tissue [
10,
46]. However, experiments in barley show that RhPV travels through the plant vasculature to all parts of the plant including the roots within 7 days of inoculation [
23]. On barley,
R. padi individuals infected with RhPV have decreased fecundity and diminished behavioral responses to semiochemicals, most notably for methyl salicylate, a semiochemical that denotes host plant suitability for aphid colonization [
47]. It was also noted that RhPV-infected aphids were more sensitive to the aphid alarm pheromone (
E)-β-farnesene [
47]. This semiochemical promotes dispersal, which translates to decreased aphid populations on plants. These authors also noted that aphids infected with RhPV were more frequently attacked by the predatory lady beetle
Coccinella septempunctata, and the parasitoid wasp
Aphidius ervi [
47].
The permissiveness of plants to dicistroviruses is suggestive that plants may have evolved to enable them to benefit from the insect-lethal properties of these viruses. Aphid populations increase on common bean when the plants flower and their aggregation around flowers and developing pods causes direct feeding damage as well as virus transmission [
48]. We speculate that dicistroviruses could potentially play a natural role in protecting plants through the control of aphid populations. The payback to the dicistroviruses would likely be access to new insect hosts. This conjectured mutualistic plant-virus relationship raises the possibility that plants exploit dicistroviruses as natural biopesticides.
Is there a role for beneficial insects such as pollinators in the spread of aphid-lethal dicistroviruses? ALPV has been detected in honeybees but its presence was not associated either with colony collapse disorder or any other pathology, suggesting that bees are latent hosts [
16,
49]. It has been demonstrated that the honeybee-infecting dicistrovirus
Israeli acute paralysis virus can be transmitted to non-infected individuals or colonies via virus-contaminated pollen collected during foraging on flowers [
50]. Bee-infecting viruses such as
Black queen cell virus,
Deformed wing virus and
Chronic bee paralysis virus have been detected in honeybee feces [
51,
52]. Thus, one might speculate that pollinators may also disseminate aphid-lethal dicistroviruses.
Acknowledgements
We thank all the teams at BecA-ILRI Hub for technical and institutional support for the Illumina MiSeq sequencing. We would like to thank the staff of the Segolip Unit at the BecA-ILRI Hub in Nairobi for help with Sanger sequencing. We thank David Karanja, the National Bean Programme coordinator at Kenya Agricultural and Livestock Research Organization, for his help and support in accessing smallholder farms in Katumani and Kaiti. We are grateful to Mr. Moses Njiriri and Mrs. Jacinta Nthenya Muia for allowing us to collect aphid samples from their farms at Ndeiya and Oloirien in Kiambu and Kajiado counties, respectively. We thank Dr. Andrew Firth, Dr. Nina Lukhovitskaya, and Professor Sir David C. Baulcombe for useful discussions.