Background
Methods
Literature search sources and strategies
Databases | Search strategy | Results | Title screening | Duplicate | Full review |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
PubMed
| ("Public Health"[All] OR "World Health"[All] OR “Health” [tiab]) AND ("Influenza A Virus, H1N1 Subtype"[Mesh] OR h1n1[tiab] OR swine flu[tiab] OR swine influenza[tiab]) AND ("communication"[Mesh] OR "Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice"[Mesh] OR "Access to Information"[Mesh] OR "Communications Media"[Mesh] OR "Internet"[Mesh] OR "J Health Commun" [Journal] OR "Health Commun"[Journal] OR communication*[tiab] OR media[tiab] OR knowledge[tiab] OR information[tiab] OR awareness[tiab]) NOT “therapeutic use*”[All] NOT “reproductive”[All] NOT “records as topic”[Mesh] NOT “exercise*”[ti] NOT “modeling”[All] NOT “modelling”[All] NOT “tobacco”[All] NOT “ethic*”[tiab] NOT “veterinary medicine”[Mesh] NOT “insurance”[ti] NOT “disorders”[tiab] NOT "contracept*"[tiab] NOT "emergency medicine"[Mesh] NOT clinical*[ti] NOT “dental”[All] NOT “stroke”[All] NOT “law”[title] NOT “legal”[ti] NOT “pharmacist*”[tiab] NOT “pharmaceutical*”[tiab] NOT “HIV”[ti] NOT “surveillance” [ti] NOT "emergency department" [tiab] NOT “AIDS”[ti] NOT “provider*”[ti] NOT “worker*”[ti] NOT "departments"[ti] NOT "personnel"[tiab] NOT "nurses"[tiab] NOT "nursing"[tiab] NOT “nurse*”[tiab] NOT "hospital*" [ti] NOT "sales" [ti] | 355 | 148 | 3 | 204 |
Filters: Journal Article; Full text available; Publication date from 2009/01/01 to 2012/08/01; Humans; Chinese; Spanish; English; Portuguese; French; Italian
| |||||
EMBASE
| public health'/exp OR 'public health' OR 'public health':ab,ti OR 'world health':ab,ti AND ('h1n1':ab,ti OR 'swine flu':ab,ti OR 'influenza a(h1n1)':ab,ti OR 'swine influenza':ab,ti) AND ('attitude'/exp OR 'access to information'/exp OR 'awareness' OR 'access to information' OR 'risk perception' OR 'perceived risk' OR 'efficacy' OR 'mass communication'/exp OR 'mass communication' OR 'mass medium'/exp OR 'mass medium' OR 'mass media':ab,ti OR communicat*:ab,ti OR 'information':ti OR 'knowledge':ti) NOT ('therapeutic uses':ab,ti OR 'simulation'/exp OR 'hospital'/exp OR 'hospitalization'/exp OR 'laboratory test'/exp OR 'disease registry'/exp OR 'reproductive':ab,ti OR 'records':ti OR 'tobacco':ab,ti OR ethic*:ab,ti OR 'veterinary medicine'/exp OR 'mental disease'/exp OR 'dental':ab,ti OR 'stroke':ab,ti OR 'law':ti OR 'legal':ti OR 'hiv':ti OR 'aids':ab,ti OR 'diabetes':ab,ti OR 'surveillance':ti OR 'randomized trials':ab,ti OR 'asthma':ti OR 'drug':ti OR 'regulations':ti OR pharma*:ti OR zoonosis*:ti OR [medline]/lim) AND ([chinese]/lim OR [english]/lim OR [french]/lim OR [italian]/lim OR [portuguese]/lim OR [spanish]/lim) AND [1-1-2009]/sd NOT [2-8-2012]/sd AND [humans]/lim AND [embase]/lim AND [2009–2012]/py | 15 | 6 | 3 | 6 |
Filters: Publication date from 2009/01/01 to 2012/08/01; Humans; English; French; Chinese; Italian; Spanish; Portuguese
| |||||
PsycINFO
| ('((DE "Swine Influenza" OR h1n1 OR "swine flu" OR "swine influenza") AND (DE ("Communication" OR "Communication Theory" OR "Communications Media" OR "Audiovisual Communications Media" OR "Mass Media" OR "Multimedia" OR "Social Media" OR "Telecommunications Media" OR "Information" OR "Health Promotion" OR "Health Knowledge" OR "Knowledge Level") OR communication* OR media OR Knowledge OR information OR awareness))) NOT AB workers NOT AB hospital* NOT clinic* | 79 | 58 | 4 | 17 |
Limiters - Published Date: 20090101–20120831; Publication Status: fully published; Publication Type: All Journals, Peer Reviewed Journal, Peer-Reviewed Status-Unknown; Language: Chinese, English, French, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish; Document Type: Journal Article; Exclude Dissertations | |||||
Education Resources Information Center (ERIC)
| ((DE "Swine Influenza" OR h1n1 OR "swine flu" OR "swine influenza") AND (DE ("Communication" OR "Communication Theory" OR "Communications Media" OR "Audiovisual Communications Media" OR "Mass Media" OR "Multimedia" OR "Social Media" OR "Telecommunications Media" OR "Information" OR "Health Promotion" OR "Health Knowledge" OR "Knowledge Level") OR communication* OR media OR Knowledge OR information OR awareness)) NOT databases NOT clinic | 7 | 6 | 1 | 0 |
Limiters - Peer Reviewed; Journal or Document: Journal Articles (EJ); Language: (English OR Chinese OR French OR Italian OR Portuguese OR Spanish)
| |||||
Communication Abstracts
| ((DE "Swine Influenza" OR h1n1 OR "swine flu" OR "swine influenza") AND (DE ("Communication" OR "Communication Theory" OR "Communications Media" OR "Audiovisual Communications Media" OR "Mass Media" OR "Multimedia" OR "Social Media" OR "Telecommunications Media" OR "Information" OR "Health Promotion" OR "Health Knowledge" OR "Knowledge Level") OR communication* OR media OR Knowledge OR information OR awareness)) | 16 | 7 | 3 | 6 |
Limiters - Scholarly (Peer Reviewed) Journals; Publication Date: 20090101–20120831; Publication Type: Academic Journal, Review; Document Type: Article
| |||||
Sociological abstracts
| ((DE "Swine Influenza" OR h1n1 OR "swine flu" OR "swine influenza") AND (DE ("Communication" OR "Communication Theory" OR "Communications Media" OR "Audiovisual Communications Media" OR "Mass Media" OR "Multimedia" OR "Social Media" OR "Telecommunications Media" OR "Information" OR "Health Promotion" OR "Health Knowledge" OR "Knowledge Level") OR communication* OR media OR Knowledge OR information OR awareness)) | 10 | 6 | 3 | 1 |
Limiters - Peer reviewed; Source type: Scholarly Journals Additional limits - Date: From January 01 2009 to August 01 2012;
| |||||
Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts (ASSIA)
| ab(("Swine Influenza" OR h1n1 OR "swine flu" OR "swine influenza")) AND ab((DE ("Communication" OR "Communication Theory" OR "Communications Media" OR "Audiovisual Communications Media" OR "Mass Media" OR "Multimedia" OR "Social Media" OR "Telecommunications Media" OR "Information" OR "Health Promotion" OR "Health Knowledge" OR "Knowledge Level") OR communication* OR media OR Knowledge OR information OR awareness)) NOT pub((test* OR reporting OR surveillance OR nurses OR nursing)) | 40 | 25 | 6 | 9 |
Date: From January 01 2009 to August 01 2012; Language: All; Source type: Scholarly Journals
| |||||
Web of science
| TS = (h1n1 OR "swine flu" OR "swine influenza") | 248 | 219 | 9 | 20 |
AND | |||||
TS = ("communication*" OR "media" OR "knowledge" OR "information" OR "awareness") | |||||
NOT | |||||
TI = (“therapeutic use*” OR “reproductive” OR “records as topic” OR “exercise*” OR “modeling” OR “modelling” OR “tobacco” OR “ethic*” OR “veterinary medicine” OR “insurance” OR “disorders” OR "contracept*" OR "emergency medicine" OR clinical* OR “dental” OR “stroke” OR “law” OR “legal” OR “pharmacist*” OR “pharmaceutical*” OR “HIV” OR “surveillance” OR "emergency department" OR “nurse*” OR “AIDS” OR “provider*” OR “worker*” OR "departments" OR "sales") | |||||
NOT | |||||
TS = (“reproductive” OR “records as topic” OR “exercise*” OR “modeling” OR “modelling” OR “tobacco” OR “ethic*” OR “veterinary medicine” OR “insurance” OR "contracept*" OR "emergency medicine" OR “dental” OR “stroke” OR “law” OR “legal” OR “pharmacist*” OR “HIV” OR “surveillance” OR "emergency department" OR “AIDS” OR "sales") | |||||
Filters: | |||||
LANGUAGE:
(English OR Chinese OR French OR Italian OR Portuguese OR Spanish) AND
| |||||
Timespan = 2009-2012
| |||||
Refined by: DOCUMENT TYPES = (ARTICLE) AND WEB OF SCIENCE CATEGORIES = (INFECTIOUS DISEASES OR EMERGENCY MEDICINE OR SOCIAL SCIENCES BIOMEDICAL OR SOCIAL SCIENCES INTERDISCIPLINARY OR HEALTH CARE SCIENCES SERVICES OR EDUCATION EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH OR NURSING OR PSYCHOLOGY MULTIDISCIPLINARY OR HEALTH POLICY SERVICES OR PSYCHOLOGY SOCIAL OR COMMUNICATION OR SOCIAL ISSUES OR NURSING SCI OR SOCIOLOGY)
| |||||
Total
|
770
|
475
|
32
|
263
|
Data extraction and analysis
Results
Characterization of the literature
Communication theories
Population-based studies
Sociodemographic variables
Interpersonal and psychosocial factors
Communications and preparedness outcomes
Communication outcomes | Definition | Frequency (%) | Examples |
---|---|---|---|
Information sources and exposure | The incidental exposure of information of a public health threat, which is not actively looked for by the audience, but obtained through daily routine or from the surrounding. | (46) 50% | Information about government’s social distancing recommendations learned from routine television watching. |
Information seeking behaviors | The actions people take proactively to search for information about public health threats for self-protection and survival. | (10) 11% | Browsed website and/or call doctors to get info about vaccine against H1N1. |
Trust and credibility | Trust and credibility in the information sources, quality of the information received, fairness of treatment, or government’s ability to respond to a public health emergency. | (29) 32% | Trust in commercial television or health department as information source about H1N1 vaccines. |
Information processing | Ability to understand information about public health threats for self-protection and survival. | (3) 3% | Some subgroups in society were more vulnerable during pandemics because they had difficulty in understanding preventive measures. |
Information utilization | Ability and/or willingness to use information obtained to prepare for and respond to public health threats. | (11) 12% | Compliance with hygienic practices during pandemics. |
Preparedness outcomes
|
Definition
|
Frequency (%)
|
Examples
|
Knowledge/awareness | Knowledge about specific threats and preventive behaviors. | 49 (53%) | Individuals with knowledge of a particular mode of transmission for H1N1. |
Risk perception | Subjective judgment about the characteristics and severity of personal or societal risk. | 64 (70%) | The risk of being infected with the H1N1 virus. |
Preventive behaviors | Any activity undertaken by individuals to prevent a disease or limit contagion to other people. | 64 (70%) | Compliance with the hygienic practices, immunization practices. |
Healthcare behaviors | Any activity undertaken by individuals to seek medical attention after they encounter the threat. | 24 (26%) | Seeking health care, compliance with recommended medications (i.e. antivirals). |
Emotional response | Emotional reactions that occur as a response to a real risk or potential threat to health or environment. | 43 (47%) | Fear, worry, anxiety, hopelessness or anger. |