Background
Method
Grade I (Strong evidence) RCTs or review of RCTS IA Calculation of sample size and accurate standard definition of appropriate outcome variables IB Accurate and standard definition of appropriate outcome variables IC Neither of the above |
Grade II (Fairly strong evidence) Prospective study with a comparison group (non-randomized controlled trial, good observational study or retrospective study that controls effectively for confounding variables) IIA Calculation of sample size and accurate, standard definition of appropriate outcome variables and adjustment for the effects of important confounding variables IIB One or more of the above |
Grade III (Weaker evidence) Retrospective or observational studies IIIA Comparison group, calculation of sample size, accurate and standard definition of appropriate outcome variables IIIB Two or more of the above IIIC None of these |
Grade IV (Weak evidence) Cross-sectional study, Delphi exercise, consensus of experts |
Data analysis
Results
Included studies
Quality of included studies
Study design
-
Children’s health, in particular their mental health (internalization, externalization, coping, stress, cortisol-levels)
-
Children’s grief symptoms (traumatic grief, problematic grief)
-
Children’s behaviour and school problems
-
Children’s self-esteem
-
Children’s concepts of death and communication about the deceased parent
-
Parenting (communication, caregiver-child relationship, parental warmth, acceptance, consistent discipline)
-
Caregiver’s mental health
Children’s health and behaviour | Child Behaviour Checklist (CBCL) [42] Children’s Depression Inventory (CDI) [43] Youth Self-Report (YSR) [42] Children’s Manifest Anxiety Scale-Revised (R-CMAS) [44] |
Children’s grief | The Extended Grief Inventory (EGI) [51] Intrusive Grief Thoughts Scale (IGTS) [52] Adapted Inventory of Traumatic Grief: Symptoms of prolonged grief disorder (ITG) [45] Traumatic Grief Inventory for Children (TGIC) [46] The Texas Revised Inventory of Grief (TRIG) [47] |
Children’s self-esteem | The Self Perception Profile for Children (SPPC) [53] |
Parenting factors | Children’s Reports of Parental Behaviour Inventory (CRPBI) [48] Parent Perception Inventory (PPI) [54] |
Caregiver’s mental health | Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) [49] Psychiatric Epidemiology Research Interview (PERI) [50] |
Interventions
Study | Intervention description |
---|---|
Schilling et al. 1992 [36] (USA) | Group intervention, “Bereavement groups for inner-city children” Groups consisting of 6–8 children, age 6–12 years 12 sessions divided into 3 phases, each of 4 sessions
Opening phase: rules of confidentiality, conduct, purpose of the group; focus on the children’s relationship to the deceased and the impact of the loss on their family; sharing experiences related to death; supportive environment; normalizing bereavement issues
Working phase: focus on children’s feelings of sadness, anger, ambivalence related to the loss; demystifying irrational thoughts and fears about the death; identifying and expressing painful feelings
Ending phase: the termination of the group as another loss; encourage children to utilize their family as support system; children were reassessed to determine the need for further treatment |
(USA) | Group intervention, camp activities, “Camp MAGIC” Groups consisting of 5–8 children, separate groups for children age 7–11 and 12–17 years
Camp activities: such as ropes course, canoeing, archery, interacting with new friends
Counseling sessions: 6 counseling sessions during a weekend (Friday-Sunday)
Focus on: trauma experience; trauma and loss reminders; post-traumatic adversities; interplay of trauma and grief; resumption of developmental progression Grief-oriented tasks and cognitive behavioural aspects such as exposure, cognitive restructuring, stress inoculation techniques
Activities: related to grief processing such as creation, play, puppetry show, memorial service Psychoeducational workshop for parents about children’s grieving process |
Kalantari et al. 2012 [28] (Iran/UK/Norway) | Group intervention “Writing for recovery” Intervention for children age 12–18 years 6 sessions in school during three consecutive days, each day consists of two 15-min sessions Writing about traumatic experiences to decrease negative thoughts and feelings
Writing sessions: Progress from unstructured expressive writing about innermost feelings and thoughts about the traumatic event/loss, to more structured writing where children reflect on what they would have given as advice to another in the same situation as themselves. In the last writing session children are asked to imagine that 10 years has passed and they look back and think about what they have learned from their experience |
(UK) | Family intervention, family therapy sessions, with children age 0–16 years and their families 6 family therapy sessions spaced at 2–3 weeks intervals, in the families’ homes
Focus on: help with emotional and practical problems arising from bereavement; promote mourning in both children and surviving parent; improve communication between children and parent; improve communication about death; encourage children to talk about the dead parent and their feelings of loss and grief; encourage expression of grief in the family Separate sessions for parents alone to enable him/her to talk about his/her own grief, anger, needs |
Christ et al. 2005 [26] (USA) | Intervention directed to the well parent and the family when a parent has cancer and is terminally ill, “The Parent Guidance Program” Families with children age 7–17 years 6 or more 60–90 min therapeutic sessions during the terminal stage of the parents illness and 6 or more sessions after the parents death, including meetings with parent(s), children and family
Focus on: to affect the children’s adjustment to the loss by enhancing the surviving parents ability to sustain competence in providing support and care or the children; provide an environment in which the children feel able to express painful or conflicting feelings, thoughts, fantasies about the loss; maintain consistency and stability in the children’s environment; support to parents in their own grief work in order to enhance their capacity to function effectively during the family crisis; problem solving around the immediate crisis; communication about illness, loss, grief, reactions; future planning for the family |
Sandler et al. 1992 [32] (USA) | Family intervention “The Family Bereavement Program” Intervention for families with children age 7–17 years Program including a total of 13 sessions, consisting of a family grief workshop and a family adviser program Family grief workshop, with 8 bereaved families per session
Focus on: to fulfil the perceived needs of bereaved families to meet with other families who have similar experiences; to improve warmth in the parent-child relationship; improve communication about grief experiences Family adviser program, 12 sessions, including 6 individual sessions for parents and 6 family sessions
Focus on: parental support; provide emotional support; decrease parental demoralization; increase warmth of the parent-child relationship; increase positive exchanges between family members; increasing quality time between parent and child; communication in the family; planning of stable events; helping improve coping with stressful family events |
Sandler et al. 2003 [33]; Schmiege et al. 2006 [37]; Tein et al. 2006 [39]; Sandler et al. 2010 [34]; Sandler et al. 2010 [35]; Luecken et al. 2010 [29]; Hagan et al. 2012 [27]; Schoenfelder et al. 2013 [38]; Luecken et al. 2014 [30]; Schoenfelder et al. 2015 [41] (USA) | Family intervention “The Family Bereavement Program” Intervention for families with children age 8–16 years Program including a total of 14 sessions, consisting of 12 sessions in separate groups for caregivers, children and adolescents Four of these include conjoint activities for children and caregivers. The program also include 2 individual family meetings Groups consisting of 5–9 children, separate groups for children age 8–12 and 12–16. Sessions for caregivers
Focus on: improving positive caregiver-child relationship; positive parenting; effective discipline strategies; coping with grief; talking to children about grief; increase positive activities; reduce children’s exposure to negative events; family routines; family time; one on one time; communication; listening skills; decrease caregiver mental health problems Sessions for children
Focus on: improving caregiver-child relationship; positive coping; coping efficacy; control-related beliefs; self-esteem; reduce negative appraisals for stressful events; provide opportunities for expression and validation of grief-related feelings; encouraging sharing of feelings with caregivers; individual goals selected by the children |
Study population
Effectiveness of the interventions
Interventions directed to the bereaved children | |||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Intervention | Reference and grade of evidence | Study population | Evaluation design | Measure | Outcome variable | Effect size TG | Effect size CG | Effect size between groups | |||||
sig | dz
| CL % | sig | dz
| CL % | sig | dm (ϕ) | ||||||
“Bereavement groups for inner-city children” | Schilling et al. 1992 [36] | 38 children (age 6–12) | Pre-test/post-test-design | BID | Depr. (Parent) Depr. (Child) | .26 .29 | −.22 .21 | −59 58 | na na | na na | na na | na na | na na |
IIIC | Evaluation: post treatment | ATCD | Attitudes and Concepts of Death | .01 | .52 | 70 | na | na | na | na | na | ||
Grief camp “Camp MAGIC” (CG) delayed treatment | McClatchey et al. 2009 [31] | 100 children (age 6–16) | Quasi experimental design | UCLA PTSD | PTSD-symptoms | .08 | .33 | 63 | .73 | −.05 | 52 | .08 | .27 |
IIB | TG = 46 CG = 54 | Evaluation: post treatment | EGI | Childhood Traumatic Grief | .00 | .73 | 77 | .90 | −.02 | 51 | .01 | .50 | |
“Writing for recovery” (CG) no treatment | Kalantari et al. 2012 [28] IB | 61 children (age 12–18) TG = 29 CG = 32 | RCT Evaluation: 1 week post treatment | TGIC | Traumatic grief | .00 | 1.26 | 90 | .03 | −.39 | 65 | .00 | 1.21 |
Family-intervention (CG) no treatment | IIB | 83 children (age 0–16) TG = 38 CG = 45 45 families TG = 21 CG = 24 | RCT Evaluation: 1 year post treatment | Clinical Interview | Behavior Sleep Depressed parent | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | .05 .09 .01 | (.21) (.21) (.33) |
Talk about dead parent | na | na | na | na | na | na | .04 | (.26) | |||||
Rutter A Rutter A | Restless Nail-biting | na na | na na | na na | na na | na na | na na | .01 .03 | (.34) (.28) | ||||
School problems | na | na | na | na | na | na | .10 | (.19) | |||||
Family-intervention (CG) no treatment | Black & Urbanowicz 1987 [25] IIB | 73 children (age 0–16) TG = 38 CG = 35 39 families TG = 21 CG = 18 | RCT Evaluation: 2 years post treatment | Clinical Interview | Behavior Talk dead parent | na na | na na | na na | na na | na na | na na | .09 .04 | (.28) (.24) |
School Health | na na | na na | na na | na na | na na | na na | .03 .04 | (.28) (.39) | |||||
“Parent Guidance Program” (CG) telephone monitoring intervention | Christ et al. 2005 [26] IA | 104 families with children (age 7–17) TG = 79 CG = 25 | RCT Evaluation: 8 and 14 months after parent’s death | CDI SEI STAI-S STAI-T CBCL-soc | Depression Self-Esteem State anxiety Trait anxiety Social competence | .00 .00 .00 .00 .29 | .56 .64 .89 .61 .17 | 71 74 81 73 57 | .03 .21 .12 .87 .27 | .48 .29 .35 .04 −.31 | 69 61 64 51 62 | .53 .36 .12 .31 .32 | .14 .28 .44 .43 .36 |
CBCL-bprob | Behavior problem | .17 | .16 | 59 | .80 | −.07 | 53 | .69 | .26 | ||||
POPM-tot | Perceived Parenting | .06 | .25 | 60 | .31 | −.22 | 59 | .11 | .37 | ||||
“The Family Bereavement Program” (first version) (CG) delayed treatment | Sandler et al. 1992 [32] IB | 72 families with 72 children (age 7–17) TG = 35 CG = 37 | RCT Evaluation: post treatment | CRPBI PRS PRS | Par. warmth Grief discussion Par. Support | .00 .78 .00 | .97 .07 .88 | 83 53 81 | .25 .00 .11 | .22 −.70 −.31 | 59 76 62 | .03 .03 .01 | .50 .62 .83 |
“The Family Bereavement Program” (revised version) (CG) self-study program | Sandler et al. 2003 [33] IA | 156 families TG = 90 CG = 66 244 children (age 8–16) TG = 135 CG = 109 | RCT Evaluation: Posttest and 11 months post treatment | Posttest | |||||||||
Comp. GLESC Comp. Comp. AIS TAS SPPC MCPCS CBCL CBCL | Pos. parenting Negative events Ment. health Positive coping Inhibition Neg. thoughts Self-esteem Control belieifs Internalizing Externalizing | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | .00 .03 .01 .02 .01 .78 .37 .72 .03 .11 | .58a
.43a
.50a
.30a
.48a
.05a
.19a
.06a
.41a
.28a
| ||||
11-mth | |||||||||||||
Comp. GLESC Comp. Comp. AIS TAS SPPC MCPCS CBCL CBCL | Pos. parenting Negative events Ment.health Positive coping Inhibition Neg. thoughts Self-esteem Control belieifs Internalizing Externalizing | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | na na na na na na na na na na | .03 .11 .10 .20 .06 .18 .16 .00 .61 .19 | .39a
.32a
.32a
.18a
.39a
.29a
.27a
.40a
.10a
.24a
| ||||
“The Family Bereavement Program” (CG) self-study program | Schmiege et al. 2006 [37] IA | 156 families TG = 90 CG = 66 244 children (age 8–16) TG = 135 CG = 109 | RCT Evaluation: 3 and 11 months post treatment | 3-months | |||||||||
CMAS-R | Anxiety Girls Anxiety Boys | .08a
.17a
| .32a
.23a
| 59 57 | .32a
.04a
| .20a
.38a
| 56 61 | .41c
.25c
| .11 −.13 | ||||
CDI | Depression Girls Depression Boys | .10a
.19a
| .30a
.22a
| 58 56 | .28a
.37a
| .21a
.17a
| 56 55 | .58c
.98c
| .11 .06 | ||||
YSR | Externaliz. Girls Externaliz. Boys | .03a
.08a
| .39a
.30a
| 61 58 | .09a
.05a
| .34a
.38a
| 59 61 | .36c
.50c
| .08 −.03 | ||||
CBCL | Intrenaliz. Girls Internaliz. Boys | .00a
.00a
| .74a
.48a
| 70 63 | .01a
.00a
| .53a
.69a
| 65 69 | .88c
.39c
| .19 −.16 | ||||
CBCL | Externaliz. Girls Externaliz. Boys | .00a
.01a
| .56a
.43a
| 65 62 | .07a
.00a
| .37a
.57a
| 60 66 | .43c
.44c
| .23 −.12 | ||||
11-months | |||||||||||||
CMAS-R | Anxiety Girls Anxiety Boys | .02a
.01a
| .43a
.44a
| 62 62 | .80a
.01a
| .05a
.48a
| 51 63 | .06c
.73c
| .36 .02 | ||||
CDI | Depression Girls Depression Boys | .02a
.07a
| .41a
.32a
| 62 59 | .55a
.05a
| .12a
.37 | 53 60 | .16c
.65c
| .28 −.01 | ||||
YSR | Externaliz. Girls Externaliz. Boys | .08a
.27a
| .33a
.19a
| 59 55 | .89a
.13a
| -.03a
.30a
| 51 58 | .03c
.45c
| .36 −.08 | ||||
CBCL | Intrenaliz. Girls Internaliz. Boys | .00a
.01a
| .80a
.47a
| 72 63 | .01a
.00a
| .57a
.63a
| 66 67 | .93c
.58c
| .20 −.10 | ||||
CBCL | Externaliz. Girls Externaliz. Boys | .00a
.02a
| .55a
.42a
| 65 62 | .32a
.00a
| .20a
.69a
| 56 69 | .11c
.86c
| .40 −.22 | ||||
“The Family Bereavement Program” (CG) self-study program | Luecken et al. 2010 [29] IA | 139 children TG = 78 CG = 61 (age 8–16) | RCT Evaluation: 6 years post treatment | Cortisol | Cortisol level before and after a conflict discussion task | na | na | na | na | na | na | .03b
| .39b
|
“The Family Bereavement Program” (CG) self-study program | Sandler et al. 2010 [34] IA | 156 families TG = 90 CG = 66 | RCT Evaluation: Post-test, 11 months and 6 years post treatment | Post (3-months) | |||||||||
TRIG IGTS | Present grief Intrusive grief | .19a
.16a
| -.16a
.17a
| 54 55 | .09a
.50a
| -.23a
.09a
| 57 53 | .72c
.43c
| .05 .09 | ||||
244 children (age 8–16) TG = 135 CG = 109 | 11-months | ||||||||||||
TRIG IGTS | Present grief Intrusive grief | .69a
.00a
| .05a
.47a
| 51 63 | .87a
.12a
| -.02a
.21a
| 51 56 | .88c
.06c
| .08 .27 | ||||
6-years | |||||||||||||
TRIG IGTS | Present grief Intrusive grief | .00a
.00a
| .73a
1.30a
| 70 82 | .00a
.00a
| .63a
1.08a
| 67 78 | .75c
.03c
| .14 .21 | ||||
“The Family Bereavement Program” (CG) self-study program | Sandler et al. 2010 [35] IA | 140 families TG = 78 CG = 62 | RCT Evaluation: 6 years post treatment | DISC Compsite | Mental Disorder Externalizing Internalizing | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | .28b
.02b
.57b
| nab
.31b
nab
|
218 children TG = 116 CG = 102 | RSE PERI BDI | Self-esteem Demoralization Depression | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | na na na | .01b
.03b
.04b
| .40b
.42b
.40b
|