Background
Methods
Data sources and searches
Inclusion/exclusion criteria
Selection of studies
Data extraction
Outcomes
Risk of bias assessment
Data analysis
Results
Study selection
Study characteristics, results of individual studies and synthesis of results
Author | Year | Journal | Setting | Population (number and type) | Age – mean (sd) unless stated | Sex | Type of study | Measurement of wrist pain/time period | Prevalence |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Carnes et al [41] | 2008 | Family Practice | Community | 2493 of general population | 52 (range 18–102) | 44% M 56% F | Cross sectional postal questionnaire | Chronic wrist pain, at least half the days in last year | Right wrist 5% Left wrist 4% |
Celik et al [24] | 2018 | Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing | Hospital | 111 critical care nurses | 31.2 (5.8) | 97 F 14 M | Cross sectional survey and interviews | Wrist pain using CMDQ (Cornell Musculoskeletal Disorder Questionnaire), over last year | 40.5% right wrist 40.5% left wrist |
Chang et al [26] | 1995 | Radiology | Opera school | 326 students | 14.2 (2.2) | 137 M 189 F | Cross sectional questionnaire and radiographs | Questioned as to presence of wrist pain, not specified | 52.5% |
Das et al [17] | 2014 | International Journal of Occupational Medcine and Environmental Health | Workplace (office and brick fields) | 220 brick field workers and 130 controls | 35.5 (6.2) brick field 34.2 (6.7) controls | 100% M | Cross sectional in 2 groups | Modified NMDQ (Nordic Musculoskeletal Disorder Questionnaire), not specified | 85% (brick field workers) 3% (office workers) |
Davatchi et al [15] | 2008 | The Journal of Rheumatology | Community | 10,291 general population | 30 (estimate from data provided) | 51.1% M 48.9% F | Cross sectional | COPCORD Core Questionnaire (CCQ) wrist pain, in last 7 days | 10% |
Davatchi et al [42] | 2015 | Internal Journal of Rheumatic Diseases | Community | 19,786 general population | 30 (estimate from data provided) | 0.9:1 M:F | Cross sectional | COPCORD Core Questionnaire (CCQ) wrist pain in last 7 days | 10.4% |
DiFiori et al [13] | 2002 | Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine | Gymnastics club | 47 gymnasts | 9.6 (range 5 to 16 | 26 M 21F | Cross sectional study | Wrist pain within last six months | 57% |
DiFiori et al [12] | 2002 | American Journal of Sports Medicine | Gymnastics club | 59 gymnasts | 9.3 | 31 M 28F | Cross sectional study | Wrist pain within last six months | 56% |
DiFiori et al [14] | 1996 | American Journal of Sports Medicine | Gymnastics club | 54 gymnasts | 11.8 (5.2) | 21 M 33F | Cross sectional study | Wrist pain within last six months | 73% |
Gangopadhyay et al [18] | 2007 | Industrial Health | Workplace (brass metal workers and office) | 50 brass metal workers 50 office | 40.4 (6.4) brass 39.3 (4.1) office | 100% M | Cross sectional in 2 groups | Wrist discomfort as modified NMDQ over last 12 months | 62% brass metal workers 4% office |
Harutunian et al [16] | 2011 | Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal | Dental school | 74 (54 students and 20 faculty) | 28.9 (range 23–52) | 47% M 53% F | Cross sectional | Questionnaire, wrist pain with last 6 months | 27.1% |
Hawkes et al [43] | 2013 | British Journal of Sports Medicine | Golf club | 128 professional golfers | 33.3 (6.3) | 100% M | Cross sectional | Questionnaire, wrist problems currently | 11.1% |
Hou et al [44] | 2006 | Journal of Nursing Research | Hospitals | 5169 nurses | 30 approximately | 100% F | Cross sectional | Modified NMDQ, wrist pain, over last year | 10.5% |
Inaba et al [45] | 2011 | Industrial Health | Workplace (goods sorting) | 47 sorting cold goods 86 sorting dry goods | 50.8 | 100% F | Cross sectional | Questionnaire, presence of wrist pain, over 4 month period | 68% (cold goods) 41% (dry goods) |
Jonasson et al [19] | 2011 | Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc | Athletes and University staff | 75 athletes 12 staff | Athletes 21.5 (range 10–40) Staff 28 (range 22–38) | 100% M | Cross sectional in 2 groups | Questionnaire re presence of wrist pain, over last week and last year | 9% athletes and 0% staff over last week 23% athletes and 9% staff over last year |
Kihlberg et al [11] | 2007 | Int Arch Occup Environ Health | Workplace | 680 workers who use power tools | Not stated | Not stated | Cross sectional | Questionnaire as regards current wrist pain | 20% |
Kirby et al [20] | 2001 | American Journal of Sports Medicine | Gymnasts and age matched controls | 60 gymnasts 35 non gymnasts | 11.8 (2.3) | 100% F | Cross sectional in 2 groups | Questionnaire, time period not clear | 33% gymnasts 2% non gymnasts |
Kuwabara et al [21] | 2011 | World Journal of Gastroenterology | Hospital | 190 endoscopists 120 non-endoscopists | 41.4 (6.7) 40.1 (7.6) | 261 M 49F | Cross sectional in 2 groups | Questionnaire, current presence of wrist pain | Right wrist – 2% endoscopists and 1% non endoscopists Left wrist – 7% endoscopists and 3% non endoscopists |
MacDonald et al [46] | 2014 | Journal of Veterinary Cardiology | Veterinary echocardiographers | 198 veterinary echocardiographers | 40 approximately | 50% M 50% F | Cross sectional | Questionnaire, wrist pain and time not stated | 5.3% |
McCue et al [47] | 2004 | Wilderness and Environmental Medicine | Fly-casting instructors | 292 fly-casting instructors | Not stated | Cross sectional | Questionnaire, wrist pain for hours/weeks of the year or whole year | 36.1% | |
Menzel et al [48] | 2004 | International Journal of Nursing Studies | Veteran’s hospital | 113 nursing staff | 42 (10.7) | 13 M 100F | Cross sectional | Wrist pain using CMDQ (Cornell Musculoskeletal Disorder Questionnaire), over last week | Author contacted but data was not obtainable |
O’Kane et al [49] | 2011 | Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine | Gyms in Seattle | 96 competitive gymnasts | 11 approximately | 100% F | Cross sectional | Questionnaire regarding overuse injuries | 9.2% |
Punnett et al [22] | 1985 | Scand J Work Environ Health | Boston garment shop and hospital | 162 garment workers 76 hospital employees | 42 (12) 41 (12) | 100% F | Cross sectional in 2 groups | Questionnaire on wrist pain, most days for one month over last year | 16.8% garment workers 4.3% hospital employees |
Purnell et al [50] | 2010 | Physical Therapy in Sport | Acrobatic gymnastics clubs | 73 acrobatic gymnasts | 13.8 (3.6) | 4 M 69F | Cross sectional | Questionnaire on wrist problem, currently affects performance and has for 3 months or more | 12.7% |
Saxena et al [51] | 2014 | Asia-Pacific Journal of Public Health | Dentist practices | 213 dentists | 31.2 (7.34) | 55.%M 44.6%F | Cross sectional | Questionnaire, wrist pain within last 12 months | 17.8% |
Smith et al [52] | 2004 | Australian Journal of Rural Health | Nursing school | 260 nursing students | 25.5 (8.7) | 28 M 232F | Cross sectional | Questionnaire, wrist pain within last 12 months | 12.7% |
Sokas et al [23] | 1989 | American Journal of Industrial Medicine | Garment workers union | 144 sewing machine operators 2822 controls | 53.8 (range 31–68) | 13 M 177F | Cross sectional in 2 groups | Questionnaire, wrist pain lasting at least a month | 8.5% sewing machine operators 4.16% controls |
Viljamaa et al [53] | 2017 | Medical Problems of Performing Artists | Finnish Musicians’ Union | 920 musicians | 45 (10) | 179 M 182F | Cross sectional | Questionnaire, wrist pain in last 30 days and pain exceeding 30 days in last year | 30% F 19%M (in last 30 days) 8%F 5%M (more than 30 days in last year) |
Waikakul et al [54] | 1999 | The Pain Clinic | Rubber tree plantattions | 2609 plantation workers | Not stated | 1603 M 1006 F | Cross sectional | Interview, with chronic pain defined as more than 3 weeks with VAS 3 of more in a year | 5.5% ulnar sided wrist pain |
White [55] | 2013 | Animals | The Spay Neuter Industry Professionals (SNIP) in USA | 219 veterinarians | 41 (range 26 to 76) | 22 M 196F (1 not stated) | Cross sectional | Wrist pain using modified CMDQ (Cornell Musculoskeletal Disorder Questionnaire), over last week | 37.9% right wrist 17% left wrist |
Woldendorp et al [56] | 2018 | Int Arch Occup Environ Health | Dutch professional orchestra | 141 bassists (73 mono-instrument, 68 multiple) | 34.7 (14.2) 35.3 (15.8) | 86.3% M 13.7%F 91.2%M 8.8%F | Cross sectional | Wrist pain, within 3 months and > 3 months/VAS severity | 19.1% right wrist always/often within 3 months 24.1% left wrist always/often within 3 months |
Yu et al [25] | 2013 | Industrial Health | Chinese factories and companies | 5339 employees | 35 approximately | 3632 M 1706F | Cross sectional | Wrist pain as defined as more than 24 h in last year | 33.5% |
Author | Year | Extra information | Risk factors – non-modifiable | Risk factors - modifiable |
---|---|---|---|---|
Celik et al [24] | 2018 | Minor vs slight vs major impact on work with right wrist pain 48.9% vs 33.3% vs 17.8% and with left wrist pain 48.9% vs 33.3% vs17.8% | Nurses who often lifted/carried heavy materials felt significantly more pain in the wrist (37.8%; OR, 0.17; 95% CI, 0.05–0.49; P = .003) | |
Chang et al [26] | 1995 | No increased risk of wrist pain with increased ulnar variance | 24.6% of the 171 painful wrists had abnormal growth plate morphology compared to 19 (10.5%) of the 181 asymptomatic wrists (p < 0.005 X2 test, RR – 2.3) | |
Das et al [17] | 2014 | Higher risk of wrist pain in brick field workers (85%) versus office workers (3%) (p < 0.001, X2 test) | ||
Davatchi et al [15] | 2008 | Wrist pain more common in women 14.7% (CI 13.6–15.8) than in men 5.6 (4.9–6.3) | ||
DiFiori et al [13] | 2002 | Wrist pain was dorsal (56%), palmar (22%), radial (7%) and ulnar (7%). Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed this age range to be significantly associated with wrist pain, independent of training intensity, age of initiation of training, years of training, gender, height, and weight (p = 0.03). The 1-year changes in height and training intensity were not associated with wrist pain (p = 0.15 and p = 0.2, respectively). | Wrist pain was significantly more common in the older and taller groups. Pain free group mean age was 9.6 versus 11.3 in the painful group, p = 0.01. Pain free group mean height was 131.6 versus 139.6 in the painful group, p = 0.04). Of those between 10 and 14 years of age at 1 year, 73% had wrist pain at the study onset and at 1 year, compared with 29% of those who were either less than 10 or more than 14 years of age. (p = 0.004). | |
DiFiori et al [12] | 2002 | By using multivariate regression analysis, we found that training hours per week (P = 0.03) and wrist pain (P = 0.02) were independently associated with radiograph findings of grade 2 or 3. Sixty-seven percent of the gymnasts (22 of the 33) with wrist pain had findings of grade 2 or 3, compared with 31% (8 of 26) of those without wrist pain (P = 0.008). | Age was the only independent risk factor for wrist pain after adjusting for confounders using multivariate regression modelling. Ulnar variance was not associated with wrist pain or radiographic injury of the distal radial physis | Wrist pain prevalence was associated with the radiographic grading of the distal radial physis (P = 0.007). |
DiFiori et al [14] | 1996 | Wrist pain was dorsal (61.5%), palmar (7.7%), radial (6.2%) and ulnar (12.3%). | Two non-modifiable factors were independently associated with wrist pain (age > 10 years, p = 0.018;; age > 14 years, p = 0.016).ars (P = 0.016), | One modifiable factor was independently associated with wrist pain (training intensity, p = 0.036). |
Gangopadhyay et al [18] | 2007 | Higher rate of wrist pain in brass metal workers (62%) versus office workers (4%) (p < 0.001 Chi squared test) | ||
Harutunian et al [19] | 2011 | Of 27.1% with wrist pain, 20.3% were classified as mild, 4.1% moderate and 2.7% severe | Wrist pain was more common in females (p < 0.05) | Wrist pain was more common in those specialising in oral surgery (p < 0.05). |
Hawkes et al [43] | 2013 | The majority of injuries (67%) occurred in the leading wrist at the most common location, the ulnar side of the wrist (35%). 87% of all ulnar-sided and 100% of radial-sided problems were in the leading wrist. | N/A | |
Hou et al [44] | 2006 | Total of 3.4% had a limitation of movement due to the wrist pain reported. Wrist pain increased risk of sick leave OR 2.96 (95% CI 2.06–4.20) adjusted OR 2.36 (95% CI 1.60–3.42). | N/A | |
Jonasson et al [19] | 2011 | Note inconsistency between figures in text and tables. | . Significant associations noted between presence of wrist pain versus thoracic spine pain p = 0.0188 OR 17.60 (95% CI 1.73–178.76) and wrists versus hips p = 0.0437 OR 12.00 (95% CI 1.63–88.29). Also significant associations noted over last year of symptoms related to elbows versus wrists p = 0.0026 OR 16.50 (95% CI2.51–108.64) and wrists versus thoracic spine p = 0.0508 OR 6.56 (95% CI1.17–36.84). | Higher rate of wrist pain in athletes versus staff |
Kihlberget al [11] | 2007 | Higher risk of wrist pain with age (OR 1.4 (95% CI 1.1–1.7)). | Higher risk of wrist pain with high frequency impact tool use (OR 1.5 (95% CI 1.0–2.3)). | |
Kirby et al [20] | 2001 | Higher rate of wrist pain in gymnasts (33%) versus non gymnasts (2%) | ||
Kuwabara et al [21] | 2011 | Higher rate of wrist pain in endoscopists versus non endoscopists | ||
MacDonald et al [46] | 2014 | 41.9% incidence of wrist pain reported whilst carrying out echocardiograms | N/A | |
McCue et al [47] | 2004 | Of those reporting wrist pain, 51% indicated it lasted for hours, 29% indicated it lasted for days, 6% indicated it lasted for weeks, and 4% indicated it lasted all year. | Chi-square tests revealed significant differences in wrist pain prevalence between the overhead and the sidearm styles (32% vs 49%, P = 0.01), between the overhead and the elliptical styles (32% vs 58%, P = 0.03), between the sidearm and the multiple styles (49% vs 20%, P = 0.05), and between the elliptical and the multiple styles (59% vs 20%, P = 0.03). | |
Menzel et al [48] | 2004 | The frequency of wrist discomfort was predicted by number of highest risk tasks per hour and number of patients ≥212 pounds . | N/A | |
Punnett et al [22] | 1985 | Wrist pain more common in garment workers versus hospital employees RR 3.9 p = 0.005 (95% CI 1.4–10.9). Specific types of garment workers were extremely likely to experience wrist pain (Finishers, RR 8.5) | ||
Saxena et al [51] | 2014 | There was no significant association between wrist pain and age. | There was no significant association between wrist pain and use of assistant, use of fitness regime and breaks. | |
Sokas et al [23] | 1989 | Wrist pain was significantly more common in sewing machine operators than controls (p = 0.00001). | ||
Woldendorp et al [56] | 2018 | There was no statistically significant difference in the rate of wrist pain within the last 3 months when comparing mono-instrumentalists with multi-instrumentalists (p = 0.831 right wrist, p = 0.845 left wrist) | ||
Yu et al [25] | 2013 | Wrist pain was more common in men and women with high job strain (psychological demands) (men OR 1.4 (95%CI 1.02–1.91) and women OR 2.20 (95%CI 1.31–3.69)) and high job strain (physical demands) (men OR 1.37 (95%CI 1.05–1.80) and women OR 1.56 (95%CI 1.02–2.40)). Wrist pain was more common in men and women with a effort reward imbalance (ERI) (men OR 1.29 (95% CI 1.02–1.23) and women OR 1.56 (95% CI 1.00–2.42). Wrist pain was more common in women in relation to job control OR 1.37 (95% CI 1.07–1.75). Wrist pain was more common in men related to effort OR 1.25 (95% CI 1.05–1.47). |