Introduction
Characteristics of subtrochanteric fractures
Epidemiology of subtrochanteric fractures
Subtrochanteric fractures and bisphosphonate exposure
Case reports and case reviews
Reference | Total patients (patients ST/FS/PF fracture) | Age (years) | Location | Radiographic features | Bilateral? | Prodromal symptoms (duration) | Osteoporosis diagnosis? | Prior bisphosphonate | Duration of use (years) | Concomitant therapy | Healing (months of follow-up) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Odvina et al. [31] | 9 (5) | 52 | Femoral shaft | No | No (osteopenia) | ALN | 8 | Ca, D | No (9) | ||
68a
| Femoral shaft | Yes | Yes | ALN | 8 | Ca, D | No (8) | ||||
67 | Femoral shaft | Yes | No (osteopenia) | ALN | 5 | Oestrogen, Ca, D | Yes (5) | ||||
49 | Proximal femur | No | Yes (GIO) | ALN | 3 | Pred, Ca, D | No (8) | ||||
64 | Proximal femur | No | Yes (GIO) | ALN | 4 | Pred, Ca, D | Yes (3) | ||||
Husada et al. [51] | 1 | 72 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening in lateral mid-shaft of contralateral femur | Yes | Severe pain in back and hip (1 month) | Yes | ALN | Not specified | Ca, amlodipine, metaprolol, aspirin | |
Schneider [52] | 1 | 59 | Upper femur | Cortical thickening | No | Moderate pain in thigh (3 months) | No (family history of osteoporosis) | ALN | 7 | Ca, hormone replacement therapy | Yes (>9) |
Armamento-Villareal et al. [53] | 1 | 35a
| Subtrochanteric femur | No | ALN | 6 | Ca | No (36)c
| |||
Cheung et al. [54] | 1 | 82 | Femoral shaft | No | Yes | ALN | 10 | Ca, glucosamine, chondroitin | |||
Demiralp et al. [55] | 1 | 65 | Femoral shaft | Fracture line, callus, cortical thickening, bowing deformity | Yes | Incapacitating bilateral femoral shaft pain (1.5 months) | Yes | ALN | 7 | Ca, D, steroid, thyroxine replacement therapy | |
Lee et al. [56] | 1 | 73 | Femoral diaphysis | No | Bilateral groin pain, difficulty walking (10 months) | Yes | ALN | 1.5 | Yes | ||
Sayed-Noor and Sjoden [57] | 1 | 72 | Subtrochanteric femur | Cortical thickening of lateral femoral cortex, medial beaking at fracture site | No | Diffuse pain in hips and thighs (18 months) | Yes | ALN | 7 | Ca | No (3)/yes (6) |
Visekruna et al. [39] | 3 | 51 | Femoral metadiaphysis | Yes | Bilateral, lateral hip pain | ALN | 5 | Pred | No (3 while on ALN; 12 after stopping ALN) | ||
62 | Femoral metadiaphysis | Yes | Bilateral thigh pain | ALN | 10 | Raloxifene, pred | Yes (12)d
| ||||
75 | Femoral metadiaphysis | No | ALN | 10 | Pred | No (22) | |||||
Odvina et al. [58] | 13 (11) | 57 | Subtrochanteric, contralateral femur shaft (3 years later) | Cortical thickening | Yes | Pain at fracture site (1–6 months) | No (osteopenia) | ALN | 6 | Ca, D | Yes (36) |
74 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | Yes | ALN | 10 | Ca, D | No | |||
67 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | Pain at fracture site (1–6 months) | Yes | RIS | >5 | Ca, D | Yes (6) | ||
58 | Femoral shaft (fractured twice in 3 years) | Cortical thickening | No | Pain at fracture site (1–6 months) | No | ALN | 7 | Ca, D, tamoxifen | Yes (6) | ||
62 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | No (osteopenia) | RIS | 2 | Ca, D, tamoxifen | ||||
63 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | Yes | ALN | 10 | Ca, D, oestrogen | Yes (6) | |||
72 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | Pain at fracture site (1–6 months) | Yes | ALN | 9 | Ca, D, oestrogen | Yes | ||
76 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | Yes (GIO) | ALN | 11 | Ca, D, pred | Yes (12) | |||
72 | Left and right femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | Yes | Pain at fracture site (1–6 months) | Yes (GIO) | ALN | 10 | Ca, D, pred | Yes | ||
77 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | Yes (GIO) | ALN | 9 | Ca, D, pred | Yes | |||
38 | Left and right femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | Yes | Yes (GIO) | ALN | 3 | Ca, D, pred | Yes | |||
Ali and Jay [59] | 1 | 82 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | ALN | 8 | Yes (3) | |||
Goddard et al. [60] | 1 | 67 | Femoral diaphysis | Cortical thickening, unicortical beaking | No | ALN | 16 | Yes (12) | |||
Ibandronate | 1 | ||||||||||
Sayed-Noor and Sjoden [61] | 2 | 78 | Tip of femoral stem | Cortical thickening | No | Yes | ALN | 9 | No (6) | ||
55 | Subtrochanteric femur | Cortical thickening, medial beaking, cortical thickening on contralateral femur | No | Diffuse pain in thighs, walking difficulties (several months) | Yes | ALN | 9 | D | Yes (9) | ||
Cermak et al. [62] | 4 | 64 | Subtrochanteric femur | Cortical thickening | No | Pain in left thigh (3 months) | No | ALN | 5.5 | Yes (6) | |
70 | Femur | Medial cortical beaking | Yes | Pain in thighs | Yes | ALN | 6 | Yes (4) | |||
Other femur (3 months later) | Yes (7) | ||||||||||
77 | Femoral shaft | Cortical thickening | No | Pain in right thigh | Yes | ALN | 12 | Yes (12) | |||
59 | Subtrochanteric femur | Cortical thickening, medial cortical beaking | No | None | Yes | ALN | 10 | Yes (5) | |||
Bush and Chew [63] | 1 | 85 | Subtrochanteric femur | Focal beak of cortical thickening of lateral cortex | No | Limp, persistent pain in anterior thigh (2–3 months) | Yes (GIO) | RIS | >6 | Ca, D, pred | Yes (2) |
Lee [64] | 1 | 82 | Left femoral diaphysis | Horizontal fracture lines at thickest part of femoral cortex extending lateral–medial, followed by short oblique fracture (identical at both sites) | Yes | Yes | ALN | 8 | Ca, D | Yes (5) | |
Right femoral diaphysis (4 years later) | |||||||||||
Edwards et al. [65] | 1 | 60 | Right femoral diaphysis | (Taken after initial, right fracture) Minor lateral cortical thickening on left femur | Yes | Mild pain in right thigh before right fracture, none before left fracture | Yes (GIO) | ALN | 8 | Pred | |
Left femoral diaphysis (2 years later) | |||||||||||
Giusti et al. [50] | 8 | 60 | Right subtrochanteric femur | Yes | Pain in right hip | No | ALN | 4 | Ca, D, pred, inhaled GCs, esomeprazole, repaglinide, metformine, azathioprine, rosuvastatin | No (6) | |
Left subtrochanteric femur (9 months later) | |||||||||||
36 | Femoral shaft | No | Yes | ALN | 8 | D, pred, simvastatine, cyclosporine, amlopidine, atenolol, lisinopril | Yes | ||||
64 | Left and right subtrochanteric femur (1 complete, 1 insufficiency fracture) | Yes | Pain in right thigh | No | ALN | 2.5 | Ca, D, pred, omeprazole, azathioprine, losartan, triamteren, HCT | No (18) | |||
62 | Right and left femoral shaftb
| Yes | Pain in right thigh and hip | Yes | Oral pamidronate | 4 | Ca, D, | Yes | |||
58 | Femoral shaft | No | Pain in left thigh | Yes | Intravenous pamidronate | 3 | Ca, D | No (12) | |||
58 | Subtrochanteric femur | No | Pain in left hip | No | RIS | 5.5 | Ca, D, pred, inhaled GCs, omeprazole, pravastatine, ibuprofen | No (12) | |||
72 | Left subtrochanteric femur | Yes | Pain in left thigh and hip | Yes (GIO) | Oral pamidronate followed by ALN | 7 + 5 | Ca, D, inhaled GCs, esomeprazole, simvastatine, captopril, irbesartan, clopidogrel | Yes (12) | |||
Right subtrochanteric femur (insufficiency fracture 1 year later) | |||||||||||
75 | Femoral shaft (insufficiency fracture) | Severe pain in left thigh and hip | Yes | RIS | 6 | Ca, D, esomeprazole, etoricoxib | |||||
Femoral shaft (insufficiency fracture 1 year later) | Pain in hip |
Reference | Review location/period | Inclusion criteria | Patients eligible (n) | Mean age (years [range]) | Fracture location | Radiographic features (n) | Bilateral? (n) | Prodromal symptoms (duration) | OP diagnosis? (n) | Prior BP (duration of use, years) | Concomitant therapy (n) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Goh et al. [26] | 2 Singapore hospitals/May 2005–February 2006 | ST fracturea due to low-energy trauma | 13 | ||||||||
ALN (9) | 66.9 (55–82) | NA | Cortical thickening (6 = lateral, 3 = contralateral) | NR | 5 pts (2–6 months) | Yes (3) | ALN (4.2 [2.5–5]) | Ca (all); long-term oral steroids (1) | |||
No (4) | |||||||||||
Unknown (2) | |||||||||||
No ALN (4) | 80.3 (64–92) | NA | NR | None | Yes (all) | NA | Ca (2) | ||||
Kwek et al. [28] | Singapore hospital/May 2005–January 2007 | ST fractureb due to low-energy trauma in patients taking ALN | 17 | 66 (53–82) | NA | Lateral cortical thickening, medial cortical beaking (all) | ST stress fracture (2) | Yes, 13 pts (1 week–24 years) | Yes (10) | ALN (4.4 [2–8]) [1 patient taking RIS after 4 years on ALN] | Ca (all); long-term prednisolone (1) |
Femoral shaft stress fracture (1) | No (6) | ||||||||||
Femoral shaft fracture (1) | Unknown (1) | ||||||||||
Neviaser et al. [30] | US trauma centre/January 2002–March 2007 | Low-energy ST and mid-shaft femur fracturesc
| 70 (11 male) | 74.7 | ST femur (50) | Lateral cortical thickening, unicortical beaking (20)d
| NR | NR | Yes (31)e
| ALN (6.2 [1–10]) [25 pts]f
| NR |
Femoral shaft (20) | |||||||||||
Glennon [47] | Australian tertiary hospital, 12 months | ST stress fracture with characteristic radiological/clinical features | 6 | 60–87 | NA | Transverse fracture, unicortical beaking, cortical thickening (all) | 1 patient | Pain in 5 pts (1 week to 6 months) | NR | ALN (1.5–16) [5 pts] | NR |
RIS (>3) [1 pt] | |||||||||||
Ing-Lorenzini et al. [27] | Swiss university hospital/2 years | Low-energy ST fracture, history of BP use | 8 (7 females) | 67.5 | ST femur (7) | Cortical thickening, also in contralateral femur in 4 patients | Yes, in 4 patients 0.5–5 years after first fracture | Pain in 2 pts, 1 lateral side, 1 both sides | Yes (all; 1 pt GIO) | ALN alone (1.5–8) [3 pts] | Ca (all), glucocorticoids (4), proton-pump inhibitors (7) |
Femoral shaft (1) | ALN (3–10) switched to ibandronate (1 NK)g [3 pts] | ||||||||||
RIS (NK) switched to ALN (2) [1 pt] | |||||||||||
Pamidronate (5)h [1 pt] | |||||||||||
Armamento-Villareal et al. [25] | US medical school/November 2004–March 2007 | Low-energy fracture, mainly at cortical sites, 2 years’ BP therapy, bone biopsy | 15 (12 females, 3 males) | ||||||||
43–75 | Femoral shaft (7) [1 male] | Yes (2) | NR | NR | ALN (4–10) [6 pts] | Ca (6); vitamin D (6); infliximab (1); triamcinolone (1); tamoxifen (1); levothyroxine (1); fluticasone (1); HCT (1); mometazone (1) | |||||
Other (9) | RIS (2) [1 pt] | ||||||||||
Capeci and Tejwani [37] | US university hospital/4 years | Bilateral low-energy femoral diaphyseal or ST fracture, long-term ALN | 7 | 61 (53–75) | Simultaneous femoral diaphysis (1) | Cortical thickening, medial beaking (all) | Yes (all) | Thigh pain (4 pts with impending ST stress fractures) | NR | ALN (8.6 [5–13]) | None affecting bone metabolism |
Sequential ST femur (2) | |||||||||||
ST and impending contralateral ST femur (3) | |||||||||||
Femoral diaphysis and impending contralateral ST femur (1) | |||||||||||
Bunning et al. [36] | US rehabilitation hospital/7 years | Atypical low- or no-impact femoral fracture | 4 (1 male) | 49–59 | Diaphyseal femoral (3); left ST/right diaphyseal femoral (1) | Medial cortical thickening (1) | 1 pt | Pain in hip (1–3 months) [all], pain in knee [1 pt] | Yes (all) | None [1 patient] | NR |
Pamidronate (0.5)/zoledronic acid 4 mg (>4.5) [1 pt] | |||||||||||
ALN (5) [1 pt] | |||||||||||
ALN (6) [1 pt] |
Controlled studies
Randomized controlled trials
Study | Age (years) | Study medication | Time from randomization to fracture (days [years]) | Bilateral? | Prodromal symptoms | Compliance | Concomitant therapy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
FIT | 75 | Placebo | 962 (2.6) | >75% | None | ||
FIT | 69 | Alendronate | 1,682 (4.6) | >75% | None | ||
FLEX | 79 | Alendronate (first fracture) | 1,250 (3.4) | Stopped 3 years before first fracture | Alendronate, 6 years (in FIT before FLEX) | ||
Alendronate (second fracture) | 1,369 (3.8) | ||||||
FLEX | 80 | Alendronate/placebo | 1,257 (3.4) | Stopped 3 years before fracture | Alendronate, 6 years (in FIT before FLEX) | ||
FLEX | 83 | Alendronate/alendronate | 1,006 (2.8) | >75% | Alendronate, 5 years (in FIT before FLEX) | ||
HORIZON | 65 | Zoledronic acid | 454 (1.2) | Hip pain | 100% | Raloxifene | |
HORIZON | 78 | Placebo | 1,051 (2.9) | Hip pain | 100% | None | |
HORIZON | 65 | Zoledronic acid | 732 (2.0) | 100% | None | ||
HORIZON | 72 | Placebo | 321 (0.9) | 100% | Calcitonin | ||
HORIZON | 71 | Zoledronic acid (2 fractures) | 934 (2.6) | Yes | Bone pain | 100% | Bisphosphonate and hormone replacement therapy, both before study |