Abstract
Exposure to crystalline silica ranks among the most frequent occupational exposures to an established human carcinogen. Health-based occupational exposure limits can only be derived from a reliable dose–response relationship. Although quartz dust seems to be a well-measurable agent, several uncertainties in the quantification of exposure to crystalline silica can bias the risk estimates in epidemiological studies. This review describes the silica-specific methodological issues in the assessment of exposure. The mineralogical forms of silica, the technologies applied to generate dust, protective measures, and co-existing carcinogens are important parameters to characterize the exposure condition of an occupational setting. Another methodological question concerns the measurement of the respirable dust fraction in the worker's breathing zone and the determination of the quartz content in that fraction. Personal devices have been increasingly employed over time, whereas norms for the measurement of respirable dust have been defined only recently. Several methods are available to analyse the content of crystalline silica in dust with limits of quantitation close to environmental exposure levels. For epidemiological studies, the quartz content has frequently not been measured but only calculated. To develop a silica-dust database for epidemiological purposes, historical dust concentrations sampled with different devices and measured as particle numbers have to be converted in a common exposure metric. For the development of a job-exposure matrix (JEM), missing historical data have to be estimated to complete the database over time. Unknown but frequently high-exposure levels of the past contribute largely to the cumulative exposure of a worker. Because the establishment of a JEM is crucial for risk estimates, sufficient information should be made accessible to allow an estimation of the uncertainties in the assessment of exposure to crystalline silica. The impressive number of silica dust measurements and the evaluation of methodological uncertainties allow recommendations for a best practice of exposure assessment for epidemiological studies.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 6 print issues and online access
$259.00 per year
only $43.17 per issue
Buy this article
- Purchase on Springer Link
- Instant access to full article PDF
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Attfield M.D., and Hearl F.J. Application of data on compliance to epidemiological assessment of exposure–response: The case of data on exposure of United States coal miners. Occup Hyg 1996: 3: 177–184.
Bagschik U., Böckler M., Chromy W., Dahmann D., Gabriel S., Guldner K., et al. Quarzexposition am Arbeitsplatz. HVBG, Sankt Augustin, 2006.
Barenblatt G.I., Patzek T.W., Prostokishin V.M., and Silin D.B. Oil deposits in diatomites: a new challenge for subterranean mechanics. Soc Petrol Eng 2002: 75230: 1–9.
Bauer H.D. Staubjahre — Möglichkeiten ihrer Ermittlung unter Einbeziehung unterschiedlicher Meßsysteme und Verfahren der Arbeitseinsatzlenkung — Bearbeitungshinweise. Hauptverband der gewerblichen Berufsgenossenschaften (HVBG), Sankt Augustin, 1995.
Bauer H.D. Studie zur retrospektiven Analyse der Belastungssituation im Uranerzbergbau der ehemaligen SDAG Wismut mit Ausnahme der Strahlenbelastung für die Zeit von 1946 bis 1990. HVBG, Sankt Augustin, 2000.
Bauer H.D., and Bruckmann E. Neues gravimetrisches Staubsammelgerät zur Messung des atembaren Feinstaubes nach den MAK-Werten. Kompass 1974: 84: 96–102.
Bauer H.D., Dahmann D., and Stoyke G. Vergleichsmessungen zwischen Konimetrie und gravimetrischer Feinstaubprobennahme in Uranerzlagerstaetten von Sachsen und Thueringen. Gefahrstoffe-Reinhaltung der Luft 1998: 58: 153–160.
Beadle D.G. The relationship between the amount of dust breathed and the development of radiological signs of silicosis: an epidemiological study of South African gold miners. In: Walton WH (ed.). Inhaled Particels III. Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1971, pp 953–964.
Bochmann F., Blome H., Rödelsperger K., Woitowitz H.J., Morfeld P., and Piekarski C. Umrechnung von Langzeitgrenzwerten auf schichtbezogene Grenzwerte für Stoffe mit langsamen Wirkungseintritt wie z. B. Quarzfeinstaub. Gefahrstoffe-Reinhaltung der Luft 1997: 57: 441–444.
Brown D., Kaplan S., Zumwalde R., Kaplowitz M., and Archer V. Retrospective cohort mortality study of underground gold mine workers. In: Goldsmith D., Winn D., Shy C. (Eds.). Silica, Silicosis, and Lung Cancer. Praeger, New York, 1986, pp 311–336.
Bruch J., Rehn S., Rehn B., Borm P.J.A., and Fubini B. Variation of biological responses to different respirable quartz flours determined by a vector model. Int J Hyg Environ Health 2004: 207: 203–216.
Buechte S.F., Burggraf C., Langefeld O., McClure W., Morfeld P., and Piekarski C. Comparative Dust Sampling Programm of Respirable Coal Mine Dust Concentrations Taken During 2002 at US Coal Mines Applying German and American Dust Sampling Strategies. Tijdschrift voor toegepaste Arbowetenschap, Eindhoven, 2004.
Cakmak G.D., Schins R.P.F., Shi T.M., Fenoglio I., Fubini B., and Borm P.J.A. In vitro genotoxicity assessment of commercial quartz flours in comparison to standard DQ12 quartz. Int J Hyg Environ Health 2004: 207: 105–113.
CEN EN 481. Workplace atmospheres: size fraction definitions for measurement of airborne particles. European Committee for Standardization 1993.
Checkoway H., Heyer N.J., Seixas N.S., Welp E.A.E., Demers P.A., Hughes J.M., et al. Dose–response associations of silica with nonmalignant respiratory disease and lung cancer mortality in the diatomaceous earth industry. Am J Epidemiol 1997: 145: 680–688.
Chen W., Zhuang Z., Attfield M.D., Chen B.T., Gao P., Harrison J.C., et al. Exposure to silica and silicosis among tin miners in China: exposure–response analyses and risk assessment. Occup Environ Med 2001: 58: 31–37.
Dahmann D., and Bauer H.D. Bestand ein “Faserproblem” bei der Gewinnung von Kieselgur? Kompass 2002: 112: 3–5.
Dahmann D., Hartfiel G.D., and Jackisch J. Intercomparison and performance of stationary aerosol samplers. Gefahrstoffe — Reinhaltung der Luft 2001: 61: 201–206.
DIN EN 13205. Workplace Atmospheres — Assessment of Performances of Instruments for Measurement of Airborne Particle Concentrations. Beuth, Berlin, 2002.
Dosemeci M., Chen J.Q., Hearl F., Chen R.-G., McCawley M., Wu Z., et al. Estimating historical exposure to silica among mine and pottery workers in the People's Republic of China. Am J Ind Med 1993: 24: 55–66.
Dosemeci M., McLaughlin J.K., Chen J.-Q., Hearl F., Chen R.-G., McCawley M., et al. Historical total and respirable silica dust exposure levels in mines and pottery factories in China. Scand J Work Environ Health 1995: 21(Suppl 2): 39–43.
du Toit R.S.J. The Shift Mean Respirable Mass Concentration of Eleven Occupations of Witwatersrand Gold Miners 4/91. NCOH, Johannesburg, 1991.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Guidelines for carcinogenic risk assessment. Fed Regist 1986: 51: 33992–34117.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). EPA proposed guidelines for carcinogen risk assessment. Fed Regist 1996: 61: 17960–18011.
Fubini B., Fenoglio I., Ceschino R., Ghiazza M., Martra G., Tomatis M., et al. Relationship between the state of the surface of four commercial quartz flours and their biological activity in vitro and in vivo. Int J Hyg Environ Health 2004: 207: 89–104.
Gao P., Chent B.T., Hearl F.J., McCawley M.A., Schwerha D.J., Odencrantz J., et al. Estimating factors to convert Chinese “Total Dust” measurements to ACGIH respirable concentrations in metal mines and pottery industries. Ann Occup Hyg 2000: 44: 251–257.
Greenland S. Sensitivity analysis, Monte Carlo risk analysis, and Bayesian uncertainty assessment. Risk Anal 2001: 21: 579–583.
Greenland S. Multiple-bias modelling for analysis of observational data. J R Stat Soc Ser A Stat Soc 2005: 168: 267–291.
Greenwood N.N., and Earnshaw A. Chemistry of the Elements. Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1985.
Heederik D., and Attfield M. Characterization of dust exposure for the study of chronic occupational lung disease: a comparison of different exposure assessment strategies. Am J Epidemiol 2000: 151: 982–990.
IARC Monographs on the evaluation of carcinogenic risk to human, vol. 68 Silica, Some Silicates, Coal Dust and Para-Aramid Fibrils. International Agency for Research on Cancer, Lyon, 1997.
IMA. Expert Workshop — Epidemiological Perspectives on Silica and Health, International mineral association, New York City, 2004.
ISO 7708. Air Quality — Particle Size Fraction Definitions for Health-Related Sampling. ISO Standard 7708. International Standards Organisation, Geneva, 1995.
ISO 15767. Workplace Atmospheres — Controlling and Characterizing Errors in Weighing Collected Aerosols (ISO/DIS 15767: 2000). Arbeitsausschuss Gefahrstoffe/Arbeitsschutz (AGSA) im DIN Deutsches Institut für Normung e.V.. Berlin, Beuth, 2001.
Jacobson M., and Tomb T.F. Relationship between gravimetric respirable dust concentration and midget impinger number concentration. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 1967: 28: 554–556.
Kauppinen T., Toikkanen J., Pedersen D., Young R., Ahrens W., Boffetta P., et al. Occupational exposure to carcinogens in the European Union. Occup Environ Med 2000: 57: 10–18.
Kortner M., and Landwehr K. Bericht über Staubmessungen in den Werken der Kieselgur-Industrie im Raum der Lüneburger Heide (A 1802/62). Silikoseforschungsinstitut der Bergbau-Berufsgenossenschaft, Bochum 1962.
Koskela R.S., Klockars M., Laurent H., and Holopainen M. Silica dust exposure and lung-cancer. Scand J Work Environ Health 1994: 20: 407–416.
Kromhout H. Improved exposure assessment for prospective cohort studies and exposure control in the rubber manufacturing industry. Available from URL: http://exasrub.iras.uu.nl/ [accessed January 23, 2007 ].
Lash T.L., and Fink A.K. Semi-automated sensitivity analysis to assess systematic errors in observational data. Epidemiology 2003: 14: 451–458.
Lehmann F., Hambeck F., Linkert K.H., Lutze H., Meyer H., Reiber H., et al. Belastung durch ionisierende Strahlung im Uranerzbergbau der ehemaligen DDR: Abschlussbericht zu einem Forschungsvorhaben. HVBG, Sankt Augustin, 1998.
Loomis D., and Kromhout H. Exposure variability: concepts and applications in occupational epidemiology. Am J Ind Med 2004: 45: 113–122.
Marsh G.M., Youk A.O., and Morfeld P. Mis-specified and non-robust mortality risk models for nasopharyngeal cancer in the national cancer institute formaldehyde worker cohort study. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 2007: 47: 59–67.
Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA). Office of the Federal Register Code of Federal Regulation Title 30 “Mineral Resources” (30 CFR). Washington, 2001.
Morfeld P., Buchte S.F., McCunney R.J., Piekarski C., and International Carbon Black Association Lung cancer mortality and carbon black exposure: uncertainties of SMR analysis in a cohort study at a German carbon black production plant. J Occup Environ Med 2006: 48: 1253–1264.
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Available from URL: http://www.cdc.gov./niosh/topics/silica/default.html [accessed January 23, 2007].
NIOSH. Recommendations for Occupational Safety and Health: Compendium of Policy Documents and Statements. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Cincinnati (OH), 1992.
Orenstein A.J. Proceedings of the 1959 Pneumoconiosis Conference, Johannesburg. Churchill, London, 1960.
Page-Shipp R.J., and Harris E. A study of the dust exposure of South African white gold miners. J South Afri Instit Mining Metal 1972: 73: 10–22.
Pukkala E., Guo J., Kyyrönen P., Lindbohm M.L., Sallmén M., and Kauppinen T. National job-exposure matrix in analyses of census-based occupational cancer risk estimates: methodology and example results on crystalline silica in Finland. Scand J Work Environ Health 2005: 31: 97–107.
RAG. RAG Handbuch der Arbeitssicherheit Nr. 843 302 — Staubmessplan gemäß GesBergV &8. RAG, Essen, 1996.
Rice F.L., Park R., Stayner L., Smith R., Gilbert S., and Checkoway H. Crystalline silica exposure and lung cancer mortality in diatomaceous earth industry workers: a quantitative risk assessment. Occup Environ Med 2001: 58: 38–45.
Roach S.A., Baier E.J., Ayer H.E., and Harris R.L. Testing compliance with threshold limit values for respirable dusts. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 1967: 28: 543–553.
Rothman K., and Greenland S. Modern Epidemiology. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Philadelphia, 1998.
Sanderson W.T., Steenland K., and Deddens J.A. Historical respirable quartz exposures of industrial sand workers: 1946–1996. Am J Ind Med 2000: 38: 389–398.
Schins R.P.F., Duffin R., Hohr D., Knaapen A.M., Shi T.M., Weishaupt C., et al. Surface modification of quartz inhibits toxicity, particle uptake, and oxidative DNA damage in human lung epithelial cells. Chem Res Toxicol 2002: 15: 1166–1173.
Seiler F., Rehn B., Rehn S., and Bruch J. Different toxic, fibrogenic and mutagenic effects of four commercial quartz flours in the rat lung. Int J Hyg Environ Health 2004: 207: 115–124.
Seixas N.S., Heyer N.J., Welp E.A.E., and Checkoway H. Quantification of historical dust exposures in the diatomaceous earth industry. Ann Occup Hyg 1997: 41: 591–604.
Stacey P.R. The performance of different analytical approaches measuring respirable quartz in the workplace analysis scheme for proficiency (WASP) and the precision and limit of detection of the direct on-air-filter analysis methods. J ASTM Int 2005: 2, DOI:10.1520/JAI12213.
Steenland K., and Greenland S. Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis and Bayesian analysis of smoking as an unmeasured confounder in a study of silica and lung cancer. Am J Epidemiol 2004: 160: 384–392.
Steenland K., ‘t Mannetje A., Boffetta P., Stayner L., Attfield M., Chen J., et al. Pooled exposure–response analyses and risk assessment for lung cancer in 10 cohorts of silica-exposed workers: an IARC multicenter study. Cancer Causes Control 2001: 12: 773–784.
‘t Mannetje A., Steenland K., Checkoway H., Koskela R.S., Koponen M., Attfield M., et al. Development of quantitative exposure data for a pooled exposure–response analysis of 10 silica cohorts. Am J Ind Med 2002: 42: 73–86.
Talvitie N.A. Determination of quartz in presence of silicates using phosphoric acid. Anal Chem 1951: 23: 623.
Tomb T.F. Measurement Strategies in US Unterground Coal Mines. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Cincinnati (OH), 1990, pp 1124–1133.
WHO. Man-Made Mineral Fibres. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1988.
Zhuang Z., Hearl F.J., Odencrantz J., Chen W., Chen B.T., Chen J.Q., et al. Estimating historical. Respirable crystalline silica exposures for Chinese pottery workers and iron/copper, tin, and tungsten miners. Ann Occup Hyg 2001: 45: 631–642.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dahmann, D., Taeger, D., Kappler, M. et al. Assessment of exposure in epidemiological studies: the example of silica dust. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol 18, 452–461 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.jes.7500636
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.jes.7500636
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Association of spirometric restriction with mortality in the silicotics: a cohort study
BMC Pulmonary Medicine (2023)
-
The impact of different approaches to exposure assessment on understanding non-malignant respiratory disease risk in taconite miners
International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health (2020)
-
Cyanurchloridbelastung in Produktionsbetrieben
Zentralblatt für Arbeitsmedizin, Arbeitsschutz und Ergonomie (2014)
-
Dosis-Wirkungs-Beziehung von Quarzstaub in Bezug auf den Lungenkrebs
Zentralblatt für Arbeitsmedizin, Arbeitsschutz und Ergonomie (2013)
-
Exposure assessment for nitrogen oxides and carbon monoxide in German hard coal mining
International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health (2009)