Introduction
Materials and methods
Program development
Target Population Survey
Institutions involved
Candidate selection
-
At least B1 level proficiency in French and English (the languages of health care in the United Nations) according to the European Language Framework;
-
Willingness to participate in international humanitarian field projects, including in armed conflict areas or following natural or man-made disasters;
-
Flexibility and a positive attitude to working in multicultural contexts.
Curriculum
Competency domain | General learning objectives | Examples of performance objectives |
---|---|---|
1. Disaster medicine | • Understand the definition and different phases of disasters. • Define the nature of injury or illness in relation to different types of disasters. • Describe objectives and features of disaster medicine. • Understand the international disaster response mechanism with involved bodies and organizations. | • List the four phases of disaster management • Name the office of the United Nations responsible for the international coordination in case of disaster or humanitarian emergency |
2. Incident Management System (IMS) | • Describe the general principles and different phases of the IMS. • Demonstrate ability to work within an IMS. • Describe the concept and different methods of Mass Casualty Triage. • Define the concept of surge capacity and its role in unforeseen emergencies and disasters. | • Correctly carry out the initial reporting from a simulated disaster site using the METHANE (Major accident, Exact location, Type of accident, Hazards, Access, Number of victims, Emergency services) method. • Assign simulated victims with the correct priority code according to the Simple Triage And Rapid Treatment (START) triage. |
3. Communication | • Recognize a disaster in progress, assess and report the situation. • Define and apply the principles of successful communication with local and expatriate staff, within and among organizations and with the media during emergencies. • Describe the radio communication procedures and protocols. • Recognize the importance of post-event reports. | • Implement the basic principles of communication in a public release statement with the media regarding the attack of a health facility by one belligerent party. • Write and present a post-event report after a simulated mass casualty event summarizing the facts occurred and the actions taken. • Successfully collaborate with a member of local staff with very limited English speaking skills during the clinical management of a simulated critically -ill patient. |
4. Resource management | • Manage supplies, drugs and equipment and other resources for an effective response. • Manage, supervise, and appropriately use local staff and expatriate aid workers during emergencies. | • Consider early blood compatibility testing for relatives of patients in an hemorrhagic shock scenario when whole blood is scarce or not available. • Demonstrate competence in the use of outdated equipment (e.g ventilators) to provide safe anesthesia in a low-resource-setting. |
5. Public health | • Recognize the top priorities for public health interventions during complex emergencies. • Describe indicators used to assess and monitor public health during complex emergencies. • Understand key epidemiological principles and terminology. • Define the minimum levels to be attained in humanitarian interventions regarding the provision of water, sanitation and hygiene. • Define the minimum levels to be attained in humanitarian interventions regarding the provision of food and nutrition. • Identify which infectious diseases can constitute a major threat following a disaster according to the geographical location and the type of emergency occurring. | • Describe the information to be gathered during a Initial Rapid Assessment and elaborate an intervention plan according to the identified public health needs. • Name the minimum quantity of safe drinking water (liters/ person/ day) to be provided in an humanitarian intervention. • List the main anthropometric indices used to assess malnutrition. • Demonstrate knowledge about the age groups to be covered by a measles vaccination campaign |
6. Safety and security | • Understand the need for a safe and secure approach in humanitarian environments. • Analyze the security environment on the basis of the seven pillars of security. • Apply the preventive measures and/or individual or collective responsibilities adapted to each form of stress. • Identify sources of risk, describe risk scenarios and identify risk mitigation measures. | • Demonstrate successful negotiation skills when approaching a simulated check point. • Demonstrate ability to prevent incidents during road travels (e.g carrying ID card, being able to clearly explane the mission of his/her organization etc). • Identify landmine markings during outdoors exercises |
7. Ethics and international humanitarian law | • Apply basic principles of medical ethics to disaster situations. • Recognize and react accordingly to the difficulties entailed by humanitarian scenarios where different cultural backgrounds are represented. • Define the concept and understand the origins of International Humanitarian Law • List the main International Human Rights • Describe the role of International Humanitarian Law in in protecting the dignity and rights of the most vulnerable populations during armed conflicts | • Demonstrate tolerance when dealing with local staff and patients with different cultural background (e.g covered with burqa). • Describe the origin of the Geneva Convention |
8. Situational awareness | • Respond appropriately to an ever-changing environment and stress-induced situations. • Adapt to pressure and change to operate effectively within humanitarian contexts. | • Demonstrate avoiding fixation errors during the management of critically-ll patients in simulated low-resource scenarios. • Demonstrate ability to anticipate likely events in crisis situations (e.g a huge number of victims to come after a single patient presents with acute organophosphorus pesticide poisoning in a war context). |
9. Psychological support | • Describe the main psychological needs in emergency contexts. • Describe the essential criteria to organize actions in psychological support. • Apply the principles of psychological first aid in emergency situations | • Identify and list the basic principles of Disaster Mental Health. Demonstrate ability to provide the principles of Psychological First Aid • Demonstrate ability to develop good practices to manage personal stress in order to mitigate potential adverse effects of stress |
10. Leadership | • Understand the definition of leadership and recognize the importance in an emergency context. • Describe the different management styles. • Understand conflict management and modify one’s own management style. • Apply the principles of Non-Violent communication. | • Demonstrate ability to implement a Non-Violent communication when giving a member of the local staff a negative feedback regarding his performance during a recent emergency. • Demonstrate ability to make firm decisions during a critical event: e.g. priority of transport for severely injured patients in an hostile environment. |
11. Clinical considerations in the specific field of Anesthesia, Pediatrics and Emergency Medicine in Low Resource Settings | • Understand and apply the principles of safe anesthesia, emergency medicine or pediatrics in low-resource settings according to the needs and resource available. | • Demonstrate good knowledge in the use of Halothane, ketamine, suxamethonium and pancuronium • Demonstrate ability to perform a newborn resuscitation in a resource-constrained environment • Promptly recognize and treat signs and symptoms of malaria in high risk areas |
Delivery method
Evaluation
Participants
Method
-
Level 1- Reaction: measures students’ satisfaction with the program;
-
Level 2- Learning: measures improvement in knowledge, attitudes and skills;
-
Level 3- Behavior: measures the transfer of learning to the workplace;
-
Level 4- Results: measures the objective changes occurred as a result of participation in the training program.
Evaluation plan and evaluation tools
-
We assessed Reaction using a 5-point Likert scale questionnaire with a separate space for commentaries and personal opinions.
-
We evaluated the three dimensions of Learning separately in a pre- and post-test [Fig. 1] as follows:
-
Knowledge with a 30-question-multiple-choice test.
-
Attitude with a 12-question-5-point Likert scale questionnaire. In this study, the term “attitude” was defined as the students’ positive or negative predisposition toward the competency domains at the basis of the course.
-
Skills with simulation-based performance tests, in which each student acted as lead physician in the management of a critically-ill patient in a low-resource emergency room. To decrease the potential impact that reiterative exposure to simulation exercises during the residential phase might have had on post-test performance, students attended standardized simulation tutorials and managed a number of simulated cases before entering the pre-test scenario. Pre- and post-test scenarios progressed on a predefined fashion according to the cue system described by Kim et al. [16] We videotaped resident’s performance and passed the material on to an external independent evaluator, who rated all students according to the validated Italian translation (Translated Italian Global Rating Scale- TIGR) [17] of the Ottawa Global Rating Scale (Ottawa GRS) [16]. This scale uses a 7-point semi-anchored design to evaluate residents’ overall performance and their leadership, problem solving, situational awareness, resource utilization, and communication skills.
-
Pre- and post-test were different tests with the same level of difficulty.
-
-
Every resident was followed during the mission by his immediate MSF field supervisor who qualitatively assessed improvements in behavior using the MSF standard evaluation form for first missioners (form available upon request).
-
MSF field supervisors were blinded to the students’ completion of the training program before deployment. This was necessary to prevent students’ participation from influencing the judgement of supervisors and ensure that evaluations were carried out as usual for any MSF first missioner.
-
All the evaluation tests/forms and case scenarios used to conduct the evaluation are available upon request.
Statistical tests and data analysis
Ethical clearance
Results
Reaction
Learning
Behavior
Student | Strong competences | Competences to develop |
---|---|---|
1 | Good analytical thinking, well-organized, high working capacity, good training skills, compliance with MSF standards and principles, flexibility, empathy, good mass casualty management skills, good technical skills, hard work, good team working skills, good reource management skills. | Human resource management Tropical medicine |
2 | Well-organized, good technical skills, good training skills, hard work, good team working skills, good reource management skills, cross-cultural sensitivity, compliance with MSF standards and principles, good negotiation skills, good comunication skills. | Human resource management |
3 | Cross-cultural sensitivity, good team working skills, good training skills, good people management skills, good leadership skills, well-organized, good analytical thinking, good problem solving skills, good reource management skills, good decision making skills, responsibility, flexibility, good stress management skills, compliance with MSF standards and principles, implement good strategies to ensure security and safety skills in daily work, good comunication skills, hard worker, worked as a person with more experience in MSF. | Participation in monthy reports |
4 | Cross-cultural sensitivity, good team working skills, good training skills, compliance with MSF standards and principles, good at motivating local staff, good reource management skills, flexibility, multitasking, deep commitment, hard work. | Self-health care |
5 | Good mass casualty management skills, compliance with MSF standards and principles, good leadership skills, good communication skills, good team working skills, responsibility, good training skills. | Language skills |
6 | Good analytical thinking, compliance with MSF standards and principles, good team working skills, good at setting priorities, good clinical skills, good team working skills, good comunication skills, flexibility, multitasking, will to improve organization within the project. | Too ambitious with local staff setting sometimes unrealistic goals |
7 | Maximum committment to MSF, compliance with MSF standards and principles, cross-cultural sensitivity, very good attitude towards MSF staff, awareness of the project from a global perspective and not only in own area of competence, committment to promote capacity building, good team working skills, good at motivating local staff, flexibility, implemented an operational research project approved by MSF medical coordination unit. | Self-protection during life saving maneuvers |
8 | Highly adaptable, good skills to work with limited resources, flexibility, responsibility, good at coaching and support of local staff, good reource management skills. |