Serum cytokines in second trimester pregnancy and their relationship with spontaneous preterm births in the Ribeirão Preto and São Luiz cohorts

Preterm birth (PTB) is defined as birth before 37 weeks of gestation, which may or may not be preceded by labor, and is independent of the newborn’s weight [1]. Its incidence varies widely between developed and developing countries and has shown a significant global increase in recent years [2]. Preterm births are responsible for about 75% of neonatal deaths and the surviving newborns are susceptible to numerous complications, including respiratory disorders, delayed neuropsychomotor development, cerebral palsy. and other neurological sequelae such as vision, hearing and motor deficits [3, 4].

The physiopathology of PTB is not fully understood but appears to be the result of a multifactorial process in which the interaction of numerous factors transforms the quiescent uterus into an effectively contracting uterus [5]. Preterm labor can be caused by activation of the normal labor process or be the consequence of risk conditions and pathological processes [6]. The isolated or simultaneous occurrence of some of these pathological processes will lead to a common pathway that is characterized by degradation of the extracellular matrix of the cervix and fetal membranes and by myometrial stimulation, accompanied by uterine contractions, cervical dilatation and membrane rupture [7]. Studies have suggested the involvement of some cytokines in the onset of labor and in the pathological processes [8].

Several studies have reported a strong association of high concentrations of inflammatory biomarkers with a short cervix [9] and consequently with PTB, which may be caused by increased levels of the cytokines that triggers rupture of the cervical connective tissue [10]. Interleukin 1 beta (IL-1β) and tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α) stimulates the production of prostaglandins in the myometrium. Interleukin 6 (IL-6) stimulates the production of acute-phase proteins and enzymes necessary for prostaglandin production, while IL-8 is important for modification and preparation of the uterine cervix [11].

Cytokines are hydrosoluble glycoproteins or polypeptides that are synthesized and released by different cell types in the organism in response to different stimuli. They can be divided into interleukins (IL-1 to IL-35), chemotactic cytokines (chemokines), tumor necrosis factors, mesenchymal growth factors, and interferons [12]. During pregnancy, cytokines trigger contractions and are involved in the onset of labor, in addition to balancing the inflammatory response during the period. Cytokines are also responsible for the maintenance of pregnancy and for the fact that the fetus is not recognized as a foreign body by the maternal immune system [8].

The well-established relationship between inflammation and myometrial contraction that underlies the mechanism of contractions and subsequent progression to labor (preterm or term) allows us to question whether the early emergence of inflammatory markers in maternal venous blood an indicator of PTB may be and whether these markers may be used for population screening because of the easy application of this method and noninvasive sample collection. In view of this association, studies have attempted to determine the role of cytokines in the diagnosis of labor by measuring their levels in vaginal secretions, amniotic fluid, and/or maternal blood. However, these studies are conflicting since their results are variable and inconsistent [13].

The aim of this study was to establish the relationship between serum cytokine levels in asymptomatic women in the second trimester of gestation and PTB, and to identify cytokines that could be used as risk indicators of prematurity in asymptomatic patients in the second trimester.

A total of 2,864 pregnant women from Ribeirão Preto and São Luís were included in the study. There were 242 women with PTB (8.7% of all patients, n = 2,757). Forty-five PTB were excluded from the study because of insufficient data or the impossibility of analyzing inflammatory markers (not collected, inadequate sample). Spontaneous PTB group was n = 115 of cases. The control group (pregnant women who delivered at term, ≥ 37 weeks) was selected by simple random drawing without replacement at a proportion of 2:1 in their respective cities (426 patients). Thus, the total sample of the study consisted of 623 patients. In the group that included only spontaneous PTB (spontaneous PTB group), the mean age at birth was 239.8 days.

Exclusive comparison between the spontaneous PTB group (n = 115) and the control group revealed no expressive changes in relation to those observed in the PTB group as a whole. A significant difference was only observed for maternal smoking and a history of preterm delivery in previous pregnancies. Maternal age, parity or infections did not differ between the two groups (Table 1).

A significant difference between the two groups was also observed for cytokines GRO, with lower levels in patients with spontaneous PTB. On the other hand, this analysis revealed a significant difference in MCP-1 (monocyte chemoattractant protein 1), whose levels were also lower in the spontaneous PTB group (Table 2).

Logarithmic transformation was performed for cytokines with very discrepant values from the mean (outliers) and the results were compared with those obtained by tests without transformation to identify the possible influence of these outliers. Among the reevaluated cytokines, a significant difference was observed for Log IL-2 in the group involving only spontaneous PTB (p = 0.03) (Table 2).

In multivariate analysis, only a history of preterm delivery and GRO were associated with PTB. Patients with a history of preterm delivery had an almost 7 times higher risk of PTB (RR: 7.63; 95%CI: 5.20, – 11.23). As the measurement unit of GRO increased, the risk of PTB decreased. Since the marker-related variables are continuous, the estimates were very close to 1 (Table 3).

The present study evaluated characteristics throughout the prenatal period that could be associated with PTB, more specifically spontaneous PTB, i.e., that resulting from preterm labor or rupture of the chorioamniotic membranes. For this purpose, maternal characteristics and serum cytokine concentrations were analyzed in two groups of patients for subsequent calculation of the relative risk in univariate and multivariate analyses.

Studies have investigated risk factors of prematurity and the most important maternal risk factors include extreme ages [15, 16], smoking [15, 17, 18], genitourinary infections [19], and a history of preterm delivery [15, 20]. The last is the main risk factor associated with prematurity; the larger the number of previous PTB, the greater the risk of prematurity [15, 21].

Our results only identified a history of at least one preterm delivery as a risk factor for spontaneous PTB, while no association was observed with maternal age, parity, smoking or genitourinary infection. These discrepant findings might be related to the small sample size, the choice of the control group, and the fact that a convenience cohort was studied.

It is important to characterize that PTB has an increase in inflammatory mediators such as IL-1, IL-6, IL-8, TNFα, as well as a decrease in other inflammatory mediators such as IL-10 and IL-4, and this balance is essential to maintain delivery with normal weight or PTB [22]. In this sense, the cytokines studied in this study had their evaluations and among those that were significant are the cytokines GRO and MCP1. In the study by Sullivan et al. 2002, the cutoff value for serum cytokine in preterm infants was defined as around 250 pg/ml. In another study from 2021 but on the serum cytokine MCP1 the cut-off values of normal children are around 150 ng/ml and in this work several cytokines were compared with children with sepsis [23] it is also worth remembering that we are talking about very specific cytokines that there are not many articles in the literature, especially when it comes to spontaneous preterm births. Immune modulation systematically expressed throughout a pregnancy result in less complicated deliveries than spontaneous preterm deliveries, including data from women who smoke confirm this trend of complications in childbirth [24, 25].

The use of antibiotics during pregnancy can be a treatment for bacterial infections, but there are indications that these patients with the use of antibiotics may be more likely to have direct or indirect preterm delivery and also inflammatory reactions [26].

In addition to maternal characteristics, we examined the serum concentrations of inflammatory markers (cytokines, chemokines, and growth factors) in asymptomatic pregnant women in the second trimester and compared them between patients with PTB and a group of patients who delivered at term. Among the 41 cytokines analyzed, only GRO was a risk factor for spontaneous prematurity. The mean level of this cytokine was lower in the PTB group, although the literature shows an association between increased serum proinflammatory cytokines and PTB [27].

GRO is a chemokine that consists of three subunits: GROα/CXCL1, GROβ/CXCL2, and GROγ/CXCL3. This chemokine is produced by different cell types such as synovial cells, monocytes, fibroblasts, and endothelial cells. Its production is directly influenced by 7 IL-8, which is responsible for neutrophil activation and chemotaxis of inflammatory cells [28]. Some studies have shown that an increase in chemokines [29] of the CXC family in maternal serum [30] and in amniotic fluid of patients with chorioamnionitis [29] was associated with PTB.

Our findings are biologically plausible. Laudanski et al. [31] also found significantly lower serum GRO concentrations in pregnant women with preterm labor compared to women who delivered at term (> 37 weeks of gestation), but did not establish a causal relationship between the serum concentration of this cytokine and progression to prematurity. On the other hand, Hsu et al. [32] detected higher concentrations of the alpha subunit of this cytokine in patients who progressed to PTB. Low serum GRO levels may reflect a deficient inflammatory response and increased susceptibility to infections, increasing the risk of triggering a myometrial contractile response and PTB. Some studies have demonstrated that lower serum or cervical concentrations of proinflammatory cytokines can predispose to infection and chorioamnionitis, which can cause PTB [33], in agreement with the findings of the present study.

The analysis of this study may be compromised by the fact that it was not possible to assess changes in the plasma concentrations of the inflammatory markers throughout pregnancy, which would allow to identify critical periods during which cytokine levels would reflect the real increase in the risk of prematurity. Another limitation of the study is the impossibility of evaluating cervical characteristics and their association with serum levels of the inflammatory markers since the patients from São Luís did not undergo specific ultrasound examination to measure cervical length in the prenatal cohort, and another limitation is the use of corticosteroids during pregnancy, which can cause lung or neurological damage in the neonate, future randomized clinical trials will bring more evidence for this indication. Normal cut-off values for the cytokines are not available in the literature for direct comparison with the outcome (prematurity). The results of different studies are still insufficient to indicate the serum concentration of inflammatory markers in asymptomatic patients in the second trimester as a parameter to predict PTB or to identify at-risk populations.