Abstract
To assess interobserver variability in estimation of brain atrophy based on CT, four neuroradiologists examined CT brain images of 150 consecutive patients without focal lesions. An independent neuroradiologist made the following quantitative measurements: frontal horn index, subarachnoid space area and the ratio between subarachnoid space area and inner skull space area. Level of agreement was fair for the presence (k=0.24), slight for the degree (mild, moderate, severe) (k=0.24) and moderate for the type (cortical, subcortical, mixed) of atrophy (k=0.59). There was a highly significant correlation between the number of observers agreeing and quantitative measurements. We concluded that neuroradiologists' subjective estimation of brain atrophy alone is not reliable. Quantitative measurements would be needed in cases where the presence of brain atrophy might determine clinical decisions.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Moseley I (1986) Diagnostic imaging in neurological disease. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh
LeMay M (1984) Radiologic changes of the aging brain and skull. AJNR 5:269–275
Leonardi M, Martelli A, Costa A, Mauri M, Zanotti B, Zappoli F (1991) Imageric cérébrale: applications neuropathologiques à la maladie d'Alzheimer: le rôle de la TDM et evaluation endocrine. Bull Assoc Anat 75:97–99
Kohlmeyer K, Shamena AR (1983) CT assessment of CSF spaces in the brain in demented and nondemented patients over 60 years of age. AJNR 4:706–707
Laffey PA, Peyster RG, Nathan R, Haskin ME, McGinley JA (1984) Computed tomography and aging: results in a normal elderly population. Neuroradiology 26:273–278
LeMay M (1986) CT changes in dementing diseases: a review. AJNR 147:963–975
Nagata K, Basugi N, Fukushima T, et al (1987) A quantitative study of physiological cerebral atrophy with aging. A statistical analysis of the normal range. Neuroradiology 29:327–332
Gomori JM, Steiner I, Melamed E, Cooper G (1984) The assessment of changes in brain volume using combined linear measurements. A CT-scan study. Neuroradiology 26:21–24
Sabattini L (1982) Evaluation and measurement of the normal ventricular and subarachnoid spaces by CT. Neuroradiology 23: 1–5
Hirashima Y, Shindo K, Endo S (1987) Measurement of the area of the anterior horn of the right lateral ventricle for the diagnosis of brain atrophy by CT. Neuroradiology 25:23–27
Adam P, Fabre N, Guell A, Bessoles G, Roulleau J, Bès A (1983) Cortical atrophy in Parkinson disease: correlation between clinical and CT findings with special emphasis on prefrontal atrophy. AJNR 4:442–445
Yerby MS, Sudsten JW, Larson EB, Wu SA, Sumi SM (1985) A new method of measuring brain atrophy: the effect of aging in its application for diagnosing dementia. Neurology 35:1316–1320
Steiner I, Gomori JM, Melamed E (1985) Features of brain atrophy in Parkinson's disease. ACT scan study. Neuroradiology 27:158–160
Lee D, Fox A, Viñuela F, et al (1987) Interobserver variation in computed tomography of the brain. Arch Neurol 44:30–31
Soininen H, Puranen M, Riekkinen PJ (1982) Computed tomography findings in senile dementia and normal ageing. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 45:50–54
LeMay M, Stafford JL, Sandor T, Albert M, Haykal H, Zamani A (1986) Statistical assessment of percentual CT scan ratings in patients with Alzheimer type dementia. J Comput Assist Tomogr 10:802–809
Inzelberg R, Treves T, Reider I, Gerlenter I, Korczyn AD (1987) Computed tomography brain changes in Parkinsonian dementia. Neuroradiology 29:535–539
De Leon MJ (1989) Alzheimer's Disease: longitudinal CT studies of ventricular change. AJNR 10:371–376
Arai H, Kobayasci K, Ikeda K, Nagao Y, Ogiara R, Kosaka K (1983) A computed tomography study of Alzheimer's disease. J Neurol 229:69–77
Agati R, D'Alessandro R, Fiorani L, Righini A, Leonardi M (1992) Valutazione quantitative dell'atrofia cerebrale in tomografia computerizzata. Rivis Neuroradiol 5:185–193
Fleiss JH (1971) Measuring nominal scale agreement among many raters. Psychol Bull 76:378–382
Landis JR, Koch GG (1977) The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 33:159–174
Fleiss JL (1981) Statistical methods for rates and proportion. Wiley, Louton, pp 212–234
Von Gall M, Artmann H, Lerch G, Nemeth N (1978) Results of computed tomography on chronic alcoholics. Neuroradiology 16:329–331
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Leonardi, M., Ferro, S., Agati, R. et al. Interobserver variability in CT assessment of brain atrophy. Neuroradiology 36, 17–19 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00599186
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00599186