Botulinum A toxins: units versus units

Abstract

We investigated the efficacies and potencies of two commercial preparations of botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNt/A) reputed to differ in potency. Tests were conducted in vitro using the mouse phrenic nerve-hemidiaphragm which is an approved tool for measuring clostridial toxicity. In addition, in a double-blind trial on volunteers, varying amounts of one product were injected into the Musculus extensor digitorum brevis of the left foot, while equal amounts, i.e. units, of the other preparation were injected into the same muscle of the right foot. Compound muscle action potentials (CMAPs) were recorded before and at various points in time after the injections. As opposed to wide-spread anecdotal reports, no difference in effectiveness was found. The dose-response curves obtained from the mouse organ preparation with both commercial products equalled one another in potency (number of units) and corresponded to previous toxicity tests in mice conducted elsewhere. Dose-response curves from volunteers were also identical for both commercial preparations. The time course of paralysis and recovery of muscle function did not differ either. At lower concentrations of toxin, however, restoration of muscle function was more rapid than at higher concentrations. Since the results obtained from man and the animal organ preparation are in excellent accord, we conclude that 1 unit of Botox corresponds to 1unit of Dysport.