Abstract
This study investigates efficiency and quality of care in nursing homes. By means of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), the efficiency of 40 nursing homes that deliver their services in the north-western area of the Lombardy Region was assessed over a 3-year period (2005–2007). Lombardy is a very peculiar setting, since it is the only Region in Italy where the healthcare industry is organised as a quasi-market, in which the public authority buys health and nursing services from independent providers—establishing a reimbursement system for this purpose. The analysis is conducted by generating bootstrapped DEA efficiency scores for each nursing home (stage one), then regressing those scores on explanatory variables (stage two). Our DEA model employed two input (i.e. costs for health and nursing services and costs for residential services) and three output variables (case mix, extra nursing hours and residential charges). In the second-stage analysis, Tobit regressions and the Kruskall–Wallis tests of hypothesis to the efficiency scores were applied to define what are the factors that affect efficiency: (a) the ownership (private nursing houses outperform their public counterparts); and (b) the capability to implement strategies for labour cost and nursing costs containment, since the efficiency heavily depends upon the alignment of the costs to the public reimbursement system. Lastly, even though the public institutions are less efficient than the private ones, the results suggest that public nursing homes are moving towards their private counterparts, and thus competition is benefiting efficiency.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Goodson J, Wooseung J (2008) Assessing nursing home care quality through Bayesian networks. Health Care Manage Sci 11:382–392
Shimshak DG, Lenard ML, Klimberg RK (2009) Incorporating quality into data envelopment analysis of nursing home performance: a case study. Omega 37:672–685
Lee RH, Bott MJ, Gajewski B, Lee Taunton R (2009) Modeling efficiency at the process level: an examination of the care planning process in nursing homes. Health Serv Res 44(1):15–32
Zhang NJ, Unruh L, Wan TTH (2008) Has the Medicare prospective payment system led to increased nursing home efficiency? Health Serv Res 43(3):1043–1061
Laine J, Harriet Finne-Soveri U, Bjorkgren M, Linna M, Noro A, Hakkinen U (2005) The association between quality of care and technical efficiency in long-term care. Int J Qual Health C 17(3):259–267
Laine J, Linna M, Noro A, Hakkinen U (2005) The cost efficiency and clinical quality of institutional long-term care for the elderly. Health Care Manage Sci 8:149–156
Laine J, Linna M, Hakkinen U, Noro A (2005) Measuring the productive efficiency and clinical quality of institutional long-term care for the elderly. Health Econ 14:245–256
Castle NG, Engberg J, Lave J, Fisher A (2009) Factors associated with increasing nursing home closures. Health Serv Res 44(3):1088–1109
Bjorkgren MA, Hakkinen U, Miika L (2001) Measuring efficiency of long-term care units in Finland. Health Care Manage Sci 4:193–200
Chesteen S, Helgheim B, Randall T, Wardell D (2005) Comparing quality of care in non-profit and for-profit nursing homes: a process perspective. J Oper Manage 23(2):229–242
Tortosa MA, Granell R (2002) Nursing home voucher in Spain: a Valencian experience. Ageing Soc 22(6):669–687
Castle N, Engbert J, Liu D (2007) Have nursing home compare quality measure scores changed over time in response to competition? Qual Saf Health Care 16:185–191
Sainfort F, Ramsay J, Monato H Jr (1995) Conceptual and methodological sources of variation in measurement of nursing home quality: an evaluation of 24 models and an empirical study. Med Care Res Rev 52(1):60–87
Donabedian A (1988) The quality of care: how can it be assessed? J Am Med Assoc 260(12):1743–1748
Center for Health Systems Research and Analysis (2001) QI definitions. Online; accessed 12-April-2005; http://www.chsra.wisc.edu/CHSRA/PIP_ORYX_LTC/QI_Matrix/main.htm].
Nyman JA, Bricker DL (1989) Profit incentives and technical efficiency in the production of nursing home care. Rev Econ Stat 71(4):586–594
Kooreman P (1994) Nursing home care in The Netherlands: a nonparametric analysis. J Health Econ 13:301–316
Anderson RI, Shelton Weeks H, Hobbs BK, Webb JR (2003) Nursing homes quality, chain affiliation, profit status and performance. J Real Estate Res 25(1):43–60
Ozcan Y, Wogen SE, Wen Mau L (1998) Efficiency evaluation of skilled nursing facilities. J Med Syst 22(4):211–224
Cooper WW, Seiford LM, Tone K (2006) Data envelopment analysis. Springer-Verlag, New York
Linn MW, Gurel L, Linn BS (1977) Patient outcome as a measure of quality of nursing home care. Am J Public Health 67(4):337–344
Gertler PJ (1989) Subsidies, quality, and the regulation of nursing homes. J Public Econ 38:33–52
Zinn JS, Aaronson WE, Rosko MD (1994) Strategic groups, performance, and strategic response in the nursing home industry. Health Serv Res 29(2):187–205
Spector WD, Takada HA (1991) Characteristics of nursing homes that affect resident outcome. J Ageing Health 3:427–454
Health Care Financing Administration (2000) Report to Congress: appropriateness of minimum nurse staffing ratios in nursing homes, Summer
Banker RD, Chang H, Cooper WW (1996) Simulation studies of efficiency, return to scale and misspecification with nonlinear functions in DEA. Ann Oper Res 66:233–253
Wilson PW (2008) FEAR: a software package for frontier efficiency analysis with R. Socio-Econ Plann Sci 42:247–254
Simar L, Wilson PW (1999) Of course we can bootstrap DEA scores! But does it mean anything? Logic trumps wishful thinking. J Prod Anal 11:93–97
Simar L, Wilson PW (2000) Statistical inference in nonparametric frontier models: the state of the art. J Prod Anal 13:49–78
Simar L, Wilson PW (2007) Estimation and inference in two-stage, semi-parametric models of production processes. J Econom 136:31–64
Pilyavsky AI, Aaronson WE, Bernet PM, Rosko MD, Valdmanis VG, Golubchikov MV (2006) Health Econ 15:1173–1186
Blank JLT, Valdmanis VG (2009) Environmental factors and productivity on dutch hospitals: a semi-parametric approach. Health Care Management Science, Published online
Borge LE, Harldsvik M (2009) Efficiency potential and determinants of efficiency: an analysis of the care for the elderly sector in Norway. Int Tax Public Financ 16:468–486
Norman M, Stoker B (1991) Data envelopment analysis, the assessment of performance. Wiley, New Jersey
Blank JLT, Eggink E (2009) A quality-adjusted cost function in a regulated industry: the case of Dutch nursing homes. Health Care Manage Sci 4:201–211
Kleinsorge K, Karney D (1992) Management of nursing homes using data envelopment analysis. Socio-Econ Plann Sci 26(1):57–71
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Garavaglia, G., Lettieri, E., Agasisti, T. et al. Efficiency and quality of care in nursing homes: an Italian case study. Health Care Manag Sci 14, 22–35 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10729-010-9139-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10729-010-9139-2