Abstract
The expansion of private sectors of higher education has usually been regarded as a factor of diversification in higher education systems. Some of this differentiation has been found to arise from the affiliation of private institutions with organizations outside the field of higher education. This article reports the results of a study of this form of interorganizational relationship in private universities in Chile. Cases include universities founded or sponsored by religious, business and military organizations. A typology of private universities is proposed, on the basis of the forms affiliation (or its absence), was observed to take in the cases examined. Weak and strong forms of affiliation are described, and affiliated universities are compared to “proprietary” universities, i.e., those owned by individuals who govern them from their positions in the board of directors, and “independent” universities, in which governance lies with internal – academic or administrative – constituents. Albeit derived from the case of Chile, the typology could be applied to the analysis of private higher education in other national systems. The second part of the article seeks to ascertain whether affiliation operates as a source of differentiation in Chilean private higher education. Results show that, compared to the other types of private universities, the affiliated ones possess distinctive mission statements and declarations of principles, consistent with the orientations of their sponsor institutions, they tend to be smaller, and to have more full-time and better qualified faculty. Some receive financial support from their sponsor organization or its members. Distinctiveness was not found in indicators of prestige and student selectivity, nor in tuition levels, program offerings, curriculum design, the weight of research and graduate programs in their functions, student socioeconomic profile, and faculty involvement in governance. This is not to say that there are no differences in these dimensions among private universities: much diversity exists, but most of it cuts across all categories of interest for our study. Overall, affiliation does not appear to be a strong factor behind the diversification that exists in the Chilean private university sector.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aldrich, Howard E. and Pfeffer, Jeffrey (1976). ‘Environments of organizations’, Annual Review of Sociology 2.
G. Altbach Philip (Eds) (1999) Private Prometheus: Private Higher Education and Development in the 21st Century Greenwood Press Westport
C. Apablaza Viterbo M. Lavados Hugo (Eds) (1988) La educación superior privada en Chile CPU Santiago
Jorge Balán Ana García Fanelli Particlede (1997) ‘El sector privado de la educación superior’ Rollin Kent (Eds) Los temas críticos de la educación superior en América Latina NumberInSeriesVol. 2 FLACSO Santiago 9–93
Bernasconi Andrés. (2003). Organizational Diversity in Chilean Higher Education: Faculty Regimes in Private and Public Universities. Doctoral dissertation, Boston University
Bernasconi, Andrés. (2004) (forthcoming). ‘Breaking the institutional mold: Faculty in the transformation of Chilean higher education from the state to market’, in Meyer, H.D. and Rowan, B. (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Education: Advancing Research and Policy. Albany, NY: SUNY Press
Bernasconi, Andrés. (forthcoming). ‘University entrepreneurship in a developing country: The case of the P. Universidad Católica de Chile’,Higher Education
Andrés Bernasconi Fernando Rojas (2004) Informe sobre la Educación Superior en Chile: 1980–2003 Editorial Universitaria Santiago
M. Blau Peter (1970) ‘The comparative study of organizations’ Oscar Grusky George A. Miller (Eds) The Sociology of Organizations. Basic Studies The Free Press New York
José Joaquín Brunner (1993) ArticleTitle‘Chile’s higher education: Between market and state’ Higher Education 25 IssueID1 35–44 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF01384040
José Joaquín Brunner et al. (1992) El proceso de desarrollo de las universidades privadas en Chile CPU Santiago
Claudio Castro Juan Carlos Navarro (1999) ‘Will the invisible hand fix latin American private higher education?’ G. Altbach Philip (Eds) Private Prometheus: Private Higher Education and Development in the 21st Century Greenwood Press Westport
Clemencia Cosentino de Cohen (2003) ArticleTitle‘Diversification in Argentine higher education: Dimensions and impact of private sector growth’ Higher Education 46 1–35
Paul J. DiMaggio Walter W. Powell (1983) ArticleTitle‘The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields’ American Sociological Review 48 IssueID2 147–160
Lex Donaldson (2001) The Contingency Theory of Organizations Sage Publications Inc Thousand Oaks, CA
Carmen García Guadilla (1996) Situación y principales dinámicas de transformación de la educación superior en América Latina CRESALC UNESCO Caracas
Roger Geiger (1986) Private Sectors in Higher Education: Structure, Function and Change in Eight Countries University of Michigan Press Ann Arbor
Giesecke, Hans C. (1999). ‘The rise of private higher education in east central Europe’, Society and Economy 21(1).
Susan L. Golicic James H. Foggin John T. Mentzer (2003) ArticleTitle‘Relationship magnitude and its role in interorganizational relationship structure’ Journal of Business Logistics 24 IssueID1 57–75
Andrew Gonzalez (1999) ‘Private higher education in the Philippines Private domination in a developing country’ Philip G. Altbach (Eds) Private Prometheus: Private Higher Education and Development in the 21st Century Greenwood Press Westport
J.T. Hage (1999) ArticleTitle‘Organizational innovation and organizational change’ Annual Review of Sociology 25 597–622 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.soc.25.1.597
Richard H. Hall (2002) Organizations. Structures, Processes, and Outcomes EditionNumber8 Prentice Hall New Jersey
Richard H. Hall John P. Clark Peggy Giordano Paul Johnson Martha Roeckel ParticleVan (1977) ArticleTitle‘Patterns of interorganizational relationships’ Administrative Science Quarterly 22 457–474
Estelle James (1991) ArticleTitle‘Private higher education: The Philippines as a prototype’ Higher Education 21 189–206 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00137073
Rollin Kent Rosalba Ramírez (1999) ‘Private higher education in Mexico in the 1990s: Growth and differentiation’ G. Altbach Philip (Eds) Private Prometheus: Private Higher Education and Development in the 21st Century Greenwood Press Westport
Kinser, Kevin. (2000). ‘Faculty at the University of Phoenix: A study of non-traditional roles’, A paper delivered at the Association for the Study of Higher Education National Conference, Richmond, VA.
Molly N.N. Lee (1999) ‘Corporatization, privatization and internationalization of higher education in Malaysia’ G. Altbach Philip (Eds) Private Prometheus: Private Higher Education and Development in the 21st Century Greenwood Press Westport 1–1
María José Lemaitre (1995) ArticleTitle‘El Consejo Superior de Educación: Una experiencia de regulación de instituciones privadas de educación superior’ Universidad Futura 6 IssueID17 3–19
Daniel C. Levy (1986a) Higher Education and the State in Latin America: Private Challenges to Public Dominance University of Chicago Press Chicago
Daniel C. Levy (1986b) ‘“Private” and “Public”: Analysis amid ambiguity in higher education’ C. Levy Daniel (Eds) Private Education: Studies in Choice and Public Policy Oxford University Press New York
Daniel C. Levy (1987) ‘A comparison of private and public educational organizations’ Walter W. Powell (Eds) The Nonprofit Sector. A Research Handbook Yale University Press New Haven
Daniel C. Levy (1992) ‘Private institutions of higher education’ Burton Clark Guy Neave (Eds) Encyclopedia of Higher Education Pergamon Oxford
Daniel C. Levy (1999) ‘When private higher education does not bring organizational diversity’ Philip G. Altbach (Eds) Private Prometheus: Private Higher Education and Development in the 21st Century Greenwood Press Westport
Levy, Daniel C. (2002). ‘Unanticipated development: Perspectives on private higher education’s emerging roles’, Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE). Working Paper No. 1
Levy, Daniel C. (2003). ‘Profits and practicality: How South Africa epitomizes the global surge in commercial higher education’, Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE). Working Paper No. 2
Levy, Daniel C. (2004). ‘Where the new institutionalism falls short: Implications from higher education’s worldwide privatization’, Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE). Working Paper No. 3
Longest SuffixJr. B. Beaufort (1990) ArticleTitle‘Interorganizational linkages in the health sector’ Health Care Management Review 15 IssueID1 17–28
Mabizela, M., Subotzky, G. and Thaver, B. (2000). ‘The emergence of private higher education in South Africa: Key issues and challenges’, Paper presented for the CHE Annual Consultative Conference, Education Policy Unit, UWC, November 2000
Alma Maldonado et al. (2004) Private Higher Education: An International Bibliography Boston College CIHE and PROPHE Chestnut Hill, MA
Marshall W. Meyer (1979) ArticleTitle‘Organizational structure as signaling’ Pacific Sociological Review 22 IssueID4 481–500
John W. Meyer Brian Rowan (1977) ArticleTitle‘Institutionalized organizations: Formal structures as myth and ceremony’ American Journal of Sociology 83 IssueID2 340–363
Christine Oliver (1990) ArticleTitle‘Determinants of interorganizational relationships: Integration and future directions’ Academy of Management Review 15 IssueID2 241–262
María Cecilia Pérsico Pablo Pérsico (1994) Realidades y mitos de las universidades privadas CPU Santiago
Walter W. Powell Paul J. DiMaggio (Eds) (1991) The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis The University of Chicago Press Chicago
Michael D. Santoro (2002) ArticleTitle‘Success breeds success: The linkage between relationship intensity and tangible outcomes in industry–university collaborative ventures’ The Journal of High Technology Management Research 11 IssueID2 255–273
Stuart M. Schmidt Thomas A. Kohan (1977) ArticleTitle‘Interorganizational relationships: Patterns and motivations’ Administrative Science Quarterly 22 220–234
R.H. Sebring (1977) ArticleTitle‘The five-million dollar misunderstanding: A perspective on state government-university interorganizational conflicts’ Administrative Science Quarterly 22 505–523
Suspitsin, Dmitry (forthcoming). Russian Private Higher Education: The Quest for Legitimacy. Ph.D. dissertation, Pennsylvania State University
Ai Mei Tan (2002) Malaysian Private Higher Education: Globalisation, Privatisation, Transformation and Marketplaces Asean Academic Press London
Pedro Teixeira Alberto Amaral (2001) ArticleTitle‘Private higher education and diversity: An exploratory survey’ Higher Education Quarterly 55 IssueID4 359–395 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1468-2273.00194
Jandhyala B.G. Tilak (1999) ‘Emerging trends and evolving public policies in India’ G. Altbach Philip (Eds) Private Prometheus: Private Higher Education and Development in the 21st Century Greenwood Press Westport
Voldemar Tomusk (2003) ArticleTitle‘The war of institutions, episode I: The rise and the rise of private higher education in eastern Europe’ Higher Education Policy 16 213–238 Occurrence Handle10.1057/palgrave.hep.8300017
David Ulrich Jay B. Barney (1984) ArticleTitle‘Perspectives in organizations: Resource dependence, efficiency and population’ Academy of Management Review 9 IssueID3 471–481
Tong-In Wongsothorn Yibing Wang (Eds) (1995) Private Higher Education in Asia and the Pacific: Final Report, Part I: Seminar Papers UNESCO PROAP and SEAMO RIHED Bangkok
Lynne G. Zucker (1983) ArticleTitle‘Organizations as institutions’ Research in the Sociology of Organizations 2 1–47
Lynne G. Zucker (1987) ArticleTitle‘Institutional theories of organization’ Annual Review of Sociology 13 443–464 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.so.13.080187.002303
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bernasconi, A. Does the Affiliation of Universities to External Organizations Foster Diversity in Private Higher Education? Chile in Comparative Perspective. High Educ 52, 303–342 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-004-5326-8
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-004-5326-8