ALL Metrics
-
Views
-
Downloads
Get PDF
Get XML
Cite
Export
Track
Research Article
Revised

Secretomes of apoptotic mononuclear cells ameliorate neurological damage in rats with focal ischemia

[version 2; peer review: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]
PUBLISHED 28 Oct 2014
Author details Author details
OPEN PEER REVIEW
REVIEWER STATUS

Abstract

The pursuit of targeting multiple pathways in the ischemic cascade of cerebral stroke is a promising treatment option. We examined the regenerative potential of conditioned medium derived from rat and human apoptotic mononuclear cells (MNC), rMNCapo sec and hMNCapo sec, in experimental stroke.
We performed middle cerebral artery occlusion on Wistar rats and administered apoptotic MNC-secretomes intraperitoneally in two experimental settings. Ischemic lesion volumes were determined 48 hours after cerebral ischemia. Neurological evaluations were performed after 6, 24 and 48 hours. Immunoblots were conducted to analyze neuroprotective signal-transduction in human primary glia cells and neurons. Neuronal sprouting assays were performed and neurotrophic factors in both hMNCapo sec and rat plasma were quantified using ELISA.
Administration of rat as well as human apoptotic MNC-secretomes significantly reduced ischemic lesion volumes by 36% and 37%, respectively. Neurological examinations revealed improvement after stroke in both treatment groups. Co-incubation of human astrocytes, Schwann cells and neurons with hMNCapo sec resulted in activation of several signaling cascades associated with the regulation of cytoprotective gene products and enhanced neuronal sprouting in vitro. Analysis of neurotrophic factors in hMNCapo sec and rat plasma revealed high levels of brain derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF).
Our data indicate that apoptotic MNC-secretomes elicit neuroprotective effects on rats that have undergone ischemic stroke.

Revised Amendments from Version 1

We want to thank the invited referees for their valuable comments and suggestions. We feel that the scientific value of our manuscript has increased significantly. This revised version of the manuscript includes the following major adjustments as suggested by the referees:

We performed an additional experiment aiming at further characterizing the state of apoptosis in apoptotic MNC-secretomes. We found that about 85% of rMNC that had been irradiated and cultured for 18 hours are in the state of apoptosis (see Figure 3).
Other revised points include:

  • The rationale for the two setting-approach plus the limitations of this study have been added to the Discussion.
  • Behavioral data are now presented as mean +/- SD (see Figure 5).
  • Figure 8 now shows all ELISA data on neurotrophic factors in hMNCapo sec in vitro + in vivo.
  • Randomization processes for the animal study have been described in greater detail.
  • Materials and Methods have been described more accurately as suggested (neuronal sprouting assay, production of MNC-secretomes, determination of neurotrophic factors, etc.).
  • References for the production of apoptotic MNC-secretomes have been added.
  • Orthographic errors and typos have been corrected.
  • Ample commas in decimal numbers have been replaced by periods.

See the authors' detailed response to the review by Michael Chopp and Hongqi Xin
See the authors' detailed response to the review by Johannes Boltze

Introduction

The search for clinically effective strategies to intercept the deleterious events that follow a stroke is ongoing. This quest has been particularly driven by the limitations that the use of tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) poses in patients with ischemic stroke (Fonarow et al., 2011). For Europe, it is projected that stroke events will increase from 20% in 2002 to 35% in 2050 in the population above 65 years of age (Truelsen et al., 2006). The United States report a yearly incidence of approximately 795,000, killing about 135,000 people each year (Roger et al., 2012). Most patients have to settle for the need of specialized care culminating into a burden to both persons affected and health care systems (Strong et al., 2007). Even though the potential of targeting neuroprotective pathways to treat ischemic stroke has been debated extensively, there seems to be a consensus towards more multilayered strategies (Iadecola & Anrather, 2011).

Several neuroprotective proteins that play a role in the ischemic cascade have been identified and studied, such as cAMP response element-binding protein (CREB), Akt, extracellular-signal regulated kinase (Erk1/2), or heat shock protein 27 (HSP27) (Qi et al., 2012; Roux & Blenis, 2004). The transcription factor CREB, for instance, exerts its neuroprotective role in the ischemic response by activating protective genes and trophic factors such as B-cell lymphoma 2 (Bcl-2) or brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) (Wilson et al., 1996). The protein-chaperone HSP27 inhibits pathways leading to cell death (van der Weerd et al., 2010). Finding a treatment targeting these proteins simultaneously could open a new window of opportunity in acute stroke management and regeneration.

The role of different populations of adult stem cells is being investigated in several fields of regenerative medicine. Distant stem cells track sites of injury and counteract tissue damage (Assmus et al., 2011; Brunner et al., 2008; Lagasse et al., 2000). It is hypothesized that human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) produce cytokines and growth factors that subsequently repair damaged tissues, including the brain (Chen et al., 2001). After homing to the injured areas, where hypoxia, apoptosis, and inflammation occur, hMSCs secrete trophic factors that enable endogenous repair (Joyce et al., 2010). Hence, the scientific community endeavored to either infuse or inject stem cells in multiple organ-specific disease entities with only limited clinical success in myocardial infarction (Jensen & Patterson, 2013; Lemmens & Steinberg, 2013; Wollert & Drexler, 2010).

In 2005, Thum et al. postulated in their “dying stem cell hypothesis” that therapeutic stem cells are already in the state of apoptosis while being processed for treatment, thus causing immune suppression by scaling down the adaptive and innate immune system (Thum et al., 2005). The authors speculated that these “therapeutic apoptotic stem cells” are able to attenuate hypoxia-induced inflammation (Fadok et al., 2001; Saas et al., 2010).

We have extended this concept and utilized suspensions of apoptotic peripheral blood mononuclear cells (MNCs), rather than stem cells themselves, as a therapeutic agent for the treatment of rodent myocardial infarction in a previous study (Ankersmit et al., 2009; Hoetzenecker et al., 2012; Lichtenauer et al., 2011). The almost complete absence of long term myocardial scarring led us to newly validate the suitability of peripheral MNCs and their secreted factors for regenerative medicine. In our previous work we showed that first, human apoptotic MNC-secretomes (hMNCapo sec) circumvented inflammation and caused preferential homing of c-kit+/CD34- endothelial progenitor cells; second, hMNCapo sec caused immune suppression in vitro and, third, paracrine factors derived from human apoptotic MNC-secretomes led to an upregulation of matrix metalloproteinase 9 (MMP-9) and Interleukin 8 (IL-8) in primary cultured human fibroblasts. Both these factors are known to be involved in neoangiogenesis (Nold-Petry et al., 2010). In addition, hMNCapo sec have been shown to cause enhanced wound healing in vivo via the formation of new blood vessels and increased migration of primary cultured fibroblasts and keratinocytes (Mildner et al., 2013). Ultimately, one single intravenous administration of hMNCapo sec in a large animal closed chest reperfusion model of acute myocardial infarction (AMI) prevented myocardial damage (Ankersmit et al., 2009; Hoetzenecker et al., 2012; Lichtenauer et al., 2011).

With these data at hand, we investigated in the present study whether secretomes derived from rat (rMNCapo sec) and human (hMNCapo sec) apoptotic MNCs are also able to reduce ischemic lesion volumes and improve neurological outcome in a rat MCAO (middle cerebral artery occlusion) model.

Materials and methods

Ethics statement

All animal procedures were approved by the Animal Research Committee of the Medical University of Vienna (Protocol No.: 66.009/127-II/3b/2011) in accordance to the guidelines for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals by the National Institutes of Health. Efforts were made to minimize suffering.

For the production of human MNC-secretomes, human MNCs were isolated from whole blood of healthy volunteers. This was approved by the ethics committee of the Medical University of Vienna (approval number: EK 2010/034). Participants provided their written informed consent.

Animals

A total of 84 adult male Wistar Rats (Charles River Laboratories, Sulzfeld, Germany) weighing 280–320 g were used. Animals were kept in cages of three to four and accustomed to a 12 hour light-dark cycle for two weeks. Nutrition and tap water were provided ad libitum. Sixteen animals made up the secretome group for which MNCs were extracted out of whole blood and their secretomes produced. Ten animals were randomly selected for the pilot-phase with the intention of establishing protocol and attaining a consistent surgical technique. The remaining 58 animals were used for the study groups and randomly assigned to either the control or the treatment group. Deaths occurred equally in both study groups (total N=21, n=10 in setting 1 [rMNCapo sec] and n=11 in setting 2 [hMNCapo sec], 7 animals were excluded from the study (n=3 in setting 1 and n=4 in setting 2) and euthanized within 6 hours after MCAO due to severe dyspnea and suffering. For statistical analyses, the remaining 30 animals were used (n=16 in setting 1 and n=14 in setting 2) Data were analyzed in a blinded manner. Animals’ tails were marked with colored ink pens before surgery. From that moment on, investigators registered values using only that color code. Surgery was performed by a surgeon unaware if the animals received treatment or placebo. Neuroscore was evaluated by an investigator not involved in the surgical procedure or application of compounds. Statistical analyses were performed by an external statistician.

Production of apoptotic MNC-secretomes from rats (rMNCapo sec) and control medium for experimental setting 1

This section describes the production of apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from rats (Hoetzenecker et al., 2013). These were used for the treatment group in setting 1 whereas the treatment group in setting 2 received apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from humans (see below). Syngeneic rat-MNCs were harvested from splenocytes of Wistar rats. For this procedure, animals were anesthetized with an intraperitoneal administration of Ketamine (100 mg/kg) and Xylazine (10 mg/kg). Through a midline incision, spleens were harvested and MNCs were separated by passing spleens through 70 µm and 40 µm cell strainers (BD Biosciences, Vienna, Austria). Red blood cells were lyzed for 90 seconds using a red blood cell lysing buffer (Sigma Aldrich, Vienna, Austria). After washing, MNCs were resuspended in 4 mL CellGro serum-free medium (CellGenix GmbH, Freiburg, Germany) and apoptosis was induced by Caesium-137 irradiation (Department of Transfusion Medicine, Vienna General Hospital) with 45 Gy. Cells were cultivated in CellGro serum-free medium at a concentration of 25×106 cells/mL at 37°C and 5% CO2 for 18 hours. Cells were removed by centrifugation at 1300 RPM for 9 minutes (Beckman Coulter Allegra® X-15R, Brea, CA, USA) and cell culture supernatants were then dialyzed against 50 mM ammonium acetate (Sigma Aldrich) using dialysis membranes (cut off: 6–8 kDa; Spectrum laboratories, Breda, The Netherlands) for 24 hours at 4°C on a shaking platter. Subsequently, the dialyzed supernatants were lyophilized over night (Lyophilizator Christ alpha 1–4, Martin Christ Gefriertrocknungsanlagen GmbH, Osterode am Harz, Germany). Lyophilization was performed at -20°C and 0.1 mbar pressure. The final product, rMNCapo sec, was stored at -80°C. For the control group, the same cell culture medium that was used for the production of rMNCapo sec was irradiated, cultivated, dialyzed, and lyophilized accordingly. All cell and tissue samples were handled under sterile conditions. Microbial smears on chocolate agars (BD Biosciences, Vienna, Austria), a non-selective media for cultivation of fastidious microorganisms, were performed before lyophilization to rule out contaminations.

Production of apoptotic MNC-secretomes from humans (hMNCapo sec) and control medium according to GMP protocol for experimental setting 2

Pathogen-reduction methods such as photodynamic treatment with methylene blue (MB) plus visible light and gamma radiation have been developed to inactivate viruses and other pathogens in plasma and platelet concentrates. Regulatory authorities require these two pathogen reduction steps for blood derived products such as IVIg, plasma or coagulation factors (Gauvin & Nims, 2010; Lambrecht et al., 1991; Nims et al., 2011; Wallis & Melnick, 1965) to be performed in a good manufacturing practice (GMP) facility.

Human apoptotic MNC-secretomes were prepared as described previously (Lichtenauer et al., 2011). Briefly, venous blood samples (75 mL) were drawn from healthy volunteers (n=15). Blood cells were separated using Ficoll-Paque (GE Healthcare Bio-Sciences AB, Stockholm, Sweden) density gradient centrifugation. MNCs were resuspended with CellGro serum-free medium. After irradiation with 45 Gy as described above, cells were cultivated with CellGro serum-free medium at a concentration of 25×106 cells/mL under sterile conditions for 18 hours. Supernatants were collected by centrifugation and methylene blue (MB) plus light treatment was performed in the Theraflex MB-Plasma system (MacoPharma, Mouvaux, France) using the Theraflex MB-Plasma bag system (REF SDV 0001XQ) and an LED-based illumination device (MacoTronic B2, MacoPharma). Light energy was monitored and reached 120 J/cm2. Integrated in the bag system was a pill containing 85 mg of MB, yielding a concentration range of 0.8 to 1.2 mM MB per unit. Removal of MB and photoproducts by Blueflex filtration was done consecutively after treatment. Air was removed from the plasma units before illumination. After lyophilization of this viral inactivated cell culture supernatant as indicated above, the lyophilized powder ran through the second step of pathogen removal, gamma irradiation. Gamma irradiation was performed by Mediscan, which operates a gamma irradiation unit (Gammatron 1500, Mediscan, Seibersdorf, Austria). Gamma rays were generated by radioactive decay of Cobalt 60. For this purpose, apoptotic MNC-secretomes were put in metal sterilization totes that pass on a meandering path through the irradiation vault around the emitting center in five layers. The cobalt unit emits photons that are almost isotropic. Regarding the complex path (280 positions in five layers) the dose is distributed consistently. The dose rate recorded by a Polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) dosimeter was determined to be 25000 Gy after 23 hours of irradiation. The lyophilized and two-step pathogen-free supernatant of apoptotic MNCs (hMNCapo sec) was stored at -80°C. For the control group, cell culture medium was put through the same steps (cultivation, two step pathogen reduction, irradiation and lyophilization).

Verification of apoptosis in cultured irradiated apoptotic rMNCs using flow cytometry

Syngeneic rMNCs (MNCs derived from rats) were harvested from splenocytes of Wistar rats (n=5) using the same protocol as described earlier. To investigate apoptosis rates during the production of our compounds, washed MNCs that had been cultured for 18 hours were divided into two groups, one to be irradiated in order to induce apoptosis (as described before by using Caesium-137 irradiation with 45 Gy) the other to remain non-irradiated. Except for irradiation, MNCs in both groups were processed equivalently (cultivation, dialysis, lyophilization). Co-staining with Annexin-V/Propidium Iodide (FITC/PI, Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA) was performed following manufacturer’s instructions. The rate of apoptosis was then evaluated on a flow cytometer (FC500, Coulter, CA, USA).

Animal preparation and induction of focal cerebral ischemia

Fifty eight animals were weighed and anesthetized with an intraperitoneal administration of Ketamine (100 mg/kg) and Xylazine (10 mg/kg). This was followed by a subcutaneous injection of Piritramide (15 mg/kg). Animals were then intubated with an 18G intravenous catheter (BD Biosciences) and anesthesia was maintained throughout surgery with 1.5% isoflurane delivered in 1.5 L air and 0.8 L oxygen per minute. Body temperature was regulated using a heating pad (Trixie 76085 Heizmatte, Trixie, Flensburg, Germany). Permanent middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAO) of the right hemisphere was performed according to the suture model described by Zea Longa et al. using a coated monofilament (Doccol Corporation, CA, USA) (Longa et al., 1989). Briefly, a 3 cm coated monofilament with a thickened tip was inserted into the external carotid artery (ECA) and advanced to the middle cerebral artery (MCA) to induce ischemia in the MCA territory.

Postoperative administration of apoptotic MNC-secretomes

In the first experimental setting, lyophilized rMNCapo sec (produced from 12.5×106 apoptotic rat MNCs) or control medium was resuspended in 0.3 mL saline (Fresenius Kabi, Vienna, Austria) in the laboratory prior to surgery. In order to investigate the potency of apoptotic MNC-secretomes, both the treatment group and the control group (n=29) randomly received 0.3 mL rMNCapo sec or control medium intraperitoneally forty minutes after surgery (Figure 1, blue arrow). In the second setting, lyophilized hMNCapo sec (produced from 12.5×106 apoptotic human MNCs) or lyophilized control medium were each resuspended in the laboratory in 0.3 mL saline prior to surgery. In order to investigate whether a higher dosage and time interval would provide additional benefits, animals from experimental setting 2 (n=29) received two intraperitoneal doses 40 minutes and 24 hours after MCAO induction (Figure 1, red arrows). The rationale for this two-step-approach is given in the discussion. In addition, all animals were given a subcutaneous injection of 3.5 mL/kg saline after surgery and put under a heating lamp until they woke up.

052895f1-b69a-4e67-91c7-58a782fceb0a_figure1.gif

Figure 1. Experimental study setting.

For setting 1, rMNCapo sec (apoptotic MNC-secretomes from rats) were injected 40 minutes after MCAO (blue arrow). In setting 2, hMNCapo sec (apoptotic MNC-secretomes from humans) were administered twice at 40 minutes (0.7 hours) and 24 hours after MCAO (red arrows). In both settings, neurological evaluations were performed at 0 hours (before surgery) as well as 6, 24, and 48 hours after surgery (boxes). Both treatment and control animals were euthanized 48 hours after surgery and brain slices were treated with TTC (2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium chloride) to stain ischemic areas in the brain.

Measurement of infarct volumes

In both experimental settings, animals were euthanized 48 hours after surgery with an intraperitoneal injection of 600 mg/kg Pentobarbital. Brains were harvested and cut into five 2 mm coronal slices using a brain matrix (Zivic Instruments, Pittsburgh, PA, USA) and razor blades (Zivic Instruments). In order to stain ischemic areas, brain slices were then incubated for 30 minutes at 37°C in a 2% solution of 2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium chloride (TTC; CarlRoth, Karlsruhe, Germany) (Bederson et al., 1986). Slices were digitalized using a commercially available photo scanner (Epson Perfection V330 Scanner; Figure 2). Lesion volumes were determined by a blinded investigator using ImageJ planimetry software (Version 1.6.0_10; Rasband, W.S., ImageJ, U.S. National Institutes of Health; Bethesda, MD, USA). Lesion volumes were calculated with respect to edema formation using the following formula: 100×(Volume of the contralateral hemisphere-Volume of the ipsilateral hemisphere)/(Volume of the contralateral hemisphere). Ipsi- and contralateral lesion volumes were calculated by multiplication of area with slice thickness summed for all sections (Swanson et al., 1990).

052895f1-b69a-4e67-91c7-58a782fceb0a_figure2.gif

Figure 2. Representative brain slices of rats subjected to MCAO.

Brains were stained with a 2% solution of TTC forty-eight hours after MCAO. Animals received either treatment (in this representative scan: hMNCapo sec) or control medium, in this case, 40 minutes 24 hours after surgery. White areas indicate ischemic tissue while red areas stain for non-ischemic tissue. Animals treated with control medium (left image) had larger ischemic (=white) areas than animals treated with hMNCapo sec (right image).

Neurological evaluation

Neurological examinations were performed by a blinded investigator in both experimental settings using a neurological score before surgery, and 6, 24, and 48 hours after surgery. The test at each time point consists of seven exercises and animals would receive a score ranging from 0 points (no pathological responses) to 7 points (maximum impairment). A successfully completed exercise would add 0 points to the score. Pathological performance in an exercise would add 1 point. The exercises were: left forepaw extension, instability to lateral push from right, tail hanging, walking on ground, whisker movement on the left, hearing, and vision (Nedelmann et al., 2007). E.g. if the rats could not hold against a hand pushing them from the right, they would get 1 point. If they did push against the examiner’s hand, they would get 0 points. Accordingly, if the rats did extend their left forepaw when hauled up by their tail, they would get 0 points. If they could not extend their left forepaw, they would get 1 point. This adds up to a score ranging from 0 points (=no pathological response at all), to 7 points (=highly impaired animal).

Cell culture

Human primary astrocytes, Schwann cells and neurons were obtained from CellSystems (CellSystems Biotechnologie, St. Katharinen, Germany) and cultured in their respective growth medium (CellSystems) at 37°C and 5% CO2.

Western blot analysis

3×106 astrocytes, Schwann cells and 3×105 neurons were seeded in 6-well plates (Costar, Vienna, Austria) and cultured overnight in their respective growth medium. After removal of the medium, cells were washed twice at room temperature with PBS (Gibco BRL, Gaithersburg, MA, USA) and cultured in their respective basal medium (Astrocyte or Schwann cell growth medium (CellSystems) without growth supplements) for 3 hours. Aliquots of lyophilized human MNC-secretome and control medium were resolved in the different basal media at a 10-fold concentration (lyophilized secretome, derived from 25×106 cells/mL). One tenth of this solution was then directly added to the cell cultures. After 1 hour, the cells were washed at room temperature with PBS and lyzed in 200 µL SDS-PAGE loading buffer (100 mL contain: 1g SDS (Sigma, Vienna, Austria), 3 mg EDTA (Sigma) and 0.75g TRIS (Sigma). pH is adjusted with HCl (Merck, Vienna, Austria) to 6.8 for 10 minutes at room temperature. After sonication (Laborpartner, Vienna, Austria: output = 100%; 20 Cycle for 1 second each) and centrifugation (20000g for 10 minutes) proteins were size-fractionated by SDS-PAGE through an 8 to 18% gradient gel (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech, Uppsala, Sweden) and transferred to nitrocellulose membranes (BioRad, Hercules, CA, USA). Immunodetection was performed with anti-c-Jun (Cell Signaling Technology, Inc. Danvers, MA, USA; 1µg/mL, #9165), anti-phospho-c-Jun (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #9261), anti-CREB (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #9197), anti-phospho-CREB (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #9198), anti-Akt (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #2938), anti-phospho-AKT (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #9271), anti-Erk1/2 (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #4695), anti-phospho-Erk1/2 (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #4376), anti-HSP27 (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #2402), anti-phospho-Hsp27 (Cell Signaling Technology; 1µg/mL, #2404) followed by an HRP-conjugated goat anti-mouse IgG antiserum or a goat anti-rabbit IgG antiserum (GE Healthcare, Freiburg, Germany). Reaction products were detected by chemiluminescence with the ChemiGlow reagent (Biozyme Laboratories Limited, South Wales, U.K.) according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

Neuronal sprouting assay

To investigate neuronal sprouting of human primary neurons, 1×104 cells (CellSystems) were seeded in 24-well plates (Costar) and allowed to adhere for 24 hours. Cells were further cultivated in neuronal medium (see above) without growth factors for five days together with the secretome of hMNC derived from 2.5×106 cells/mL (hMNCapo sec) or control medium. After five days cells were fixed at room temperature in 100% methanol for 10 minutes and stained with methylene blue (Sigma; 0.5% in methanol). Excess methylene blue was washed out with distilled water, and culture wells were evaluated with an inverted microscope (EvosXL, Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA, USA). Cell cultures were digitalized using an Olympus Digital Camera E-520 (3648×2736 pixels). A blinded observer set a random representative area of the photographed cell culture (as seen in Figure 7b) using Adobe Photoshop Lightroom Software (Version 5.2, 2013; Adobe, San José, CA, USA). (i) on a photograph of cells treated with human apoptotic MNC-secretomes and (ii) on a photograph showing cells treated with control medium. The areas in each photograph measured 1420×2456 pixels. Subsequently, they picked and marked visible distinct, full-length and non-overlapping 30–35 neurites using ImageJ software (Bethesda, MD). Another blinded investigator measured these marked neurons using ImageJ software.

Determination of neurotrophic factors in apoptotic MNC-secretomes and control medium

BDNF, nerve growth factor (NGF) and glial derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) in rMNCapo sec, hMNCapo sec, and control medium, were measured using commercially available ELISA-kits (Enzyme linked immunosorbent assay; BDNF: catalog# DY248; beta-NGF catalog# DY256; GDNF catalog# DY212; R&D Systems, Minneapolis, MN, USA). All samples were assayed in triplicates. Manufacturer’s instructions were followed and plates were read at 450 nm on a Wallac Multilabel counter 1420 (PerkinElmer, Boston, MA, USA).

Determination of BDNF in rat plasma

To see whether intraperitoneal administration of apoptotic MNC-secretomes and control medium influence BDNF production, six rats were injected intraperitoneally with hMNCapo sec (n=3), or control medium, (n=3). Rats were euthanized with an intraperitoneal injection of 600 mg/kg Pentobarbital 24 hours after injection with hMNCapo sec (secretomes of 12.5×106 cells) or control medium. Blood was retrieved in heparinized tubes, centrifuged, and plasma was stored at -20°C. Rat BDNF levels were measured using a commercially available BDNF-ELISA (catalog# KA0330, Abnova, Taipei, Taiwan) and plates were read at 450 nm on a Wallac Multilabel counter 1420 (PerkinElmer, Boston, MA, USA).

Statistical analyses

To test for differences in lesion volume between control and treatment groups the Mann-Whitney U-test was applied. Differences were also assessed graphically using box-plots. The calculations were performed separately for each experimental setting. Linear mixed models were calculated to explain neuroscores by time point, treatment and interaction effects between time point and treatment. A random intercept term was included for each individual animal to account for the correlation of observations within an individual. The calculations were done using the MIXED procedure in SAS 9.3. The neuroscores were also assessed graphically by plotting a time curve of mean neuroscore values±SD for each group. Neurite lengths in neuronal cultures were compared applying the student’s t-test. A p-value of 0.05 or below was considered significant.

Results

Apoptosis rates in irradiated apoptotic rMNCs

In order to see the extent of apoptosis in rMNCs that had been cultured for 18 hours, we analyzed apoptosis rates in cultured irradiated and cultured non-irradiated rMNCs from 5 donors using flow cytometry. Analysis of cultured irradiated rMNCs revealed apoptosis rates of 85±5% (mean±SD) while 12±5 did not stain for FITC/PI, thus being viable. In the non-irradiated rMNC control group, 44±7 cells were apoptotic with 55±7 still being viable (Figure 3).

052895f1-b69a-4e67-91c7-58a782fceb0a_figure3.gif

Figure 3. Apoptosis rates in irradiated and non-irradiated cultured rMNCs.

Mean percentage values of viable (white) and apoptotic (red) rMNCs are given in this bar graph. The percentage of cells in either state are shown for non-irradiated rMNCs (control) and irradiated rMNCs after 18 hours in cell culture. Irradiated rMNCs correspond to the compound we used throughout the study.

Apoptotic MNC-secretomes reduce the infarction volume in an experimental MCAO model

In a rat model of MCAO we examined the potential of apoptotic MNC-secretomes to reduce ischemic lesion volumes in an allogeneic (experimental setting 1, rMNCapo sec) and a xenogeneic approach (experimental setting 2, hMNCapo sec) (Figure 1). The results of the allogeneic setting displayed significantly lower lesion volumes in the treatment group compared to the control group as shown by TTC-staining (Figure 4). Treatment with rMNCapo sec led to a mean decrease of 36% in total infarct volume. Hemispheric lesion volumes (mean±SD) in the control group were 59%±8% ranging from 50% to 73% (Mann Whitney U-test; * p=0.0006; Figure 4a). The treatment group had a mean hemispheric lesion volume of 38%±11% ranging from 24% to 51%. In the xenogeneic setting, we injected hMNCapo sec 40 minutes and 24 hours after MCAO. The reduction of the infarction volume in the xenogeneic setting was statistically significant and comparable to that observed in the allogeneic setting (Mann Whitney U-test; * p=0.0041; Figure 4b). The mean decrease in total infarct volume was 37%. Hemispheric lesion volumes (mean±SD) in the control group were 52%±8% ranging from 42% to 67%. The treatment group had a mean hemispheric lesion volume of 33%±11% ranging from 21% to 48%.

052895f1-b69a-4e67-91c7-58a782fceb0a_figure4.gif

Figure 4. Infarct volumes in control animals and animals treated with apoptotic MNC-secretomes.

The percentage of hemispheric lesion volumes (%HLV) are represented as box and whiskers plots, wherein the boxes indicate the 1st and the 2nd quartile and the whiskers the minimum and maximum within 1.5 times the interquartile range from the box. Figure 4a shows lesion volumes as the extend of ischemia in setting 1, where apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from rats were administered 40 minutes after MCAO compared to controls. Figure 4b corresponds to setting 2, where apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from humans were administered 40 minutes and 24 hours after MCAO. In both settings, MNCapo sec (red boxes) caused a significant decrease in infarct volumes (* p=0.0006 for setting 1, Figure 4a, and * p=0.0041 for setting 2, Figure 4b) compared to the control group (white boxes) that received only cell culture medium.

Apoptotic MNC-secretomes improve neurological outcome in an experimental MCAO model

In order to discover the effects of apoptotic MNC-secretomes on the neurological outcome, we performed a neurological exam on each animal at 4 specific time points. The first score was measured prior to surgery (baseline; 0 hours) and was 0 points for all animals. This was followed by 3 postoperative measurements at 6, 24 and 48 hours. All animals expressed neurological stroke-symptoms immediately after anesthesia wore off. The fixed effect coefficient estimates of the mixed models, their standard errors and p-values are shown in Table 1a and Table 1b. The factor Treatment was coded in a way that Treatment=0 corresponds to the control group and Treatment=1 corresponds to the treatment group. The time point 6 h is the reference group for the factor Time.

Table 1. Fixed effect coefficient estimates of the mixed models and their standard errors.

Data include both experimental setting 1 that used apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from rats, “rMNCapo sec”, (Table 1a), and setting 2 that used apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from humans, “hMNCapo sec”, (Table 1b). p-values are calculated from t-tests with the null hypothesis of the true coefficient being equal to 0. The factor Treatment was coded in a way that Treatment=0 corresponds to the control group and Treatment=1 corresponds to the treatment group. The time point 6 h is the reference group for the factor Time.

Table 1a: Linear mixed model analysis for setting 1.
“rMNCapo sec”.
EffectEstimateStandard
Error
p
Intercept50.2502<.0001
Time 24 h00.25661
Time 48 h-0.18750.25660.471
Treatment-0.06250.35380.8611
Treatment*Time 24 h-1.06250.36290.0067
Treatment*Time 48 h-1.56250.36290.0002
Table 1b: Linear mixed model analysis for setting 2.
“hMNCapo sec”.
EffectEstimateStandard
Error
p
Intercept4.57140.2761<.0001
Time 24 h0.14290.34420.6818
Time 48 h-0.50.34420.1593
Treatment00.39051
Treatment*Time 24 h-1.42860.48680.0072
Treatment*Time 48 h-1.64290.48680.0025

The results from both settings are similar. At time point 6 h there is no significant mean difference in the neuroscores between control and treatment, which is suggested by the coefficient for Treatment. The coefficients for Time 24 h and Time 48 h are not significantly different from zero. We can therefore not conclude that the mean neuroscore in the control group changes with time. The interaction terms for Treatment and Time, however, are significant. This indicates a significant decrease in the mean neuroscore over time in the treatment group. These results correspond well to the graphical depictions of the time curves (Figures 5a and 5b).

052895f1-b69a-4e67-91c7-58a782fceb0a_figure5.gif

Figure 5. Neurological outcome score in control animals and animals treated with apoptotic MNC-secretomes.

Mean neuroscores (±SD) are plotted over time. Treated animals (red triangles for setting 1, Figure 5a, and red squares for setting 2, Figure 5b) improved over time compared to controls (black/white triangles for setting 1, Figure 5a, and black/white squares for setting 2, Figure 5b). Error bars correspond to +/- one standard deviation.

Apoptotic MNC-secretomes activate signaling cascades involved in cytoprotection in glia cells

Glia cells are non-neuronal cells that provide support and protection for neurons in the brain and peripheral nervous system (Giaume et al., 2010). We therefore investigated the potency of hMNCapo sec to activate/phosphorylate signaling-molecules that are part of protective pathways in human primary astrocytes as well as in Schwann cells. For Western blot analysis, astrocytes and Schwann cells were treated with hMNCapo sec for 1 hour. Both cell types showed an increased phosphorylation of CREB, Erk1/2, c-Jun, and Akt. Phosphorylation of HSP27 was only detected in astrocytes (Figure 6).

052895f1-b69a-4e67-91c7-58a782fceb0a_figure6.gif

Figure 6. Expression of cytoprotective proteins in human Astrocytes (AC) and Schwann Cells (SCs).

Cell extracts were prepared after stimulation with hMNCapo sec or cell culture Medium as control. Western blot analysis revealed an activation of CREB, ERK1/2, c-Jun, Akt, and HSP27. Proteins were normalized to the respective non-phosphorylated proteins.

Apoptotic MNC-secretomes induce CREB phosphorylation and neuronal sprouting in human primary neurons and contain BDNF

We next investigated whether hMNCapo sec are also effective in human primary neuron cultures. Western blot analysis of neurons and astrocytes revealed a rapid dose dependent activation of CREB phosphorylation (Figure 7a). Incubation of neurons with apoptotic MNC-secretomes led to a significant increase in the length of newly sprouting neurons. Cultured neurons treated with hMNCapo sec had a mean neurite length of 21±1µm (mean±SEM) versus 13±1µm in neurons treated with control medium (t-test; * p<0.0001; Figure 7b–c).

052895f1-b69a-4e67-91c7-58a782fceb0a_figure7.gif

Figure 7. Enhanced CREB phosphorylation and neurite length in neurons treated with apoptotic MNC-secretomes.

(a) Cell extracts were prepared after stimulation with hMNCapo sec or cell culture medium as control. Western blot analysis for phospho-CREB revealed a dose dependent activation of CREB in astrocytes and in neurons. (b) Neuron cultures treated with hMNCapo sec or control medium for five days were stained with methylene-blue. One representative picture of ten is shown. Bar=10 µm (c) Lengths of neurons treated with hMNCapo sec or cell culture medium as control were calculated using ImageJ software. Bars represent the mean of five different cultures.

In order to characterize the composition of neurotrophic factors present in hMNCapo sec, we performed ELISA for BDNF, GDNF and NGF. Interestingly, only high amounts of BDNF (356±14pg/mL) were detected in hMNCapo sec, suggesting an exclusive role for this neurotrophic factor in hMNCapo sec (Figure 8a).

052895f1-b69a-4e67-91c7-58a782fceb0a_figure8.gif

Figure 8. Profile of neurotrophic factors in hMNCapo sec and animals treated with hMNCapo sec.

(a) ELISA for BDNF, GDNF, and NGF detected only levels of BDNF (356±14pg/mL, mean±SEM) in hMNCapo sec. (b) Six animals received an intraperitoneal injection with hMNCapo sec (n=3, red bar) or control medium (n=3, black/white bar) and BDNF plasma levels were determined 24 hours after administration using ELISA.

Effects of apoptotic MNC-secretomes on plasma BDNF-levels in rats

After revealing BDNF as one component in hMNCapo sec, BDNF levels in plasma of rats treated with hMNCapo sec were measured with ELISA 24 hours after i.p. administration. Plasma BDNF-levels were higher in rats treated with hMNCapo sec compared to those treated with control medium (n=3 for each compound). Twenty four hours after treatment with hMNCapo sec, BDNF plasma levels were 72±5ng/mL (mean±SEM) compared to undetectably low BDNF levels in controls (Figure 8b).

Discussion

For over a decade, MSCs have been known to have beneficial effects on the outcome of several disease entities (Assmus et al., 2011; Chen et al., 2001; Crigler et al., 2006; Lagasse et al., 2000). In our previous studies we were able to show that apoptotic MNC-secretomes share some of the regenerative characteristics of stem cells and, based on the data presented in this work, considerably more. We show here that apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from both rats (rMNCapo sec) and humans (hMNCapo sec) caused a reduction of lesion volumes in rats subjected to MCAO. Neurological evaluations revealed an improvement in motor and sensory function, which was not observed in the control group. Furthermore, apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from humans (hMNCapo sec) (i) activate several mechanisms ultimately leading to the expression of protective proteins in cultured primary human glial cells, such as astrocytes, Schwann cells and human neurons, and (ii) induce notable sprouting of neurites in primary neuron cultures. Additionally, hMNCapo sec contain BDNF and lead to increased presence of BDNF in plasma of rats treated with hMNCapo sec. Neurotrophic factors and proteins involved in protective pathways seem to be triggering the therapeutic factors found in our experiments.

Crigler and coworkers described the ability of MSCs to express neuro-regulatory molecules and to promote neuronal cell survival (Crigler et al., 2006). In the literature, MSCs are described to home to injured areas and regenerate damaged tissue by either causing cytoprotection, anti-inflammation or by inducing activation of endogenous stem cells (Gnecchi et al., 2012; Siegel et al., 2012; Williams & Hare, 2011). Recently, it became commonly accepted that possible stem cell effects are derived from the paracrine factors secreted by MSCs (Di Santo et al., 2009; Jayaraman et al., 2013). This theory of paracrine factors aiding in regenerative processes emerges as a possible explanation for the therapeutic potential of apoptotic MNC-secretomes shown previously in myocardial infarction and, given our new data, in ischemic stroke (Ankersmit et al., 2009; Lichtenauer et al., 2011a; Lichtenauer et al., 2011b). The mechanisms of action seem to be a matter of immunomodulation and cytoprotection (Ankersmit et al., 2009; Lichtenauer et al., 2011a; Lichtenauer et al., 2011b). Cultured glial cells incubated with apoptotic MNC-secretomes revealed an upregulation of several proteins involved in conveying cytoprotective signals, such as CREB, HSP27, Erk 1/2, and Akt. These results suggest that apoptotic MNC-secretomes affect different pathways within the ischemic cascade, and most prominently they appear to act via anti-apoptotic pathways. In concert with this it is tempting to speculate that the enhanced cell survival of glial cells is beneficial for neurons since glial cells are known to support and protect neurons (Ferrer et al., 2001). In rats subjected to MCAO the overexpression of HSP27 resulted in a 30% reduction of infarct sizes (van der Weerd et al., 2010). The extracellular signal-regulated kinases Erk 1/2, part of the MAPK-families (mitogen activated protein kinase), are thought to play a role in cell survival and proliferation (Roux & Blenis, 2004). Furthermore, activation of the prosurvival kinase Akt reduces the proapoptotic signaling that is triggered by ischemia. It is suggested that Akt activation protects against ischemic brain injury by suppressing the proapoptotic JNK3 (c-Jun N-terminal kinase-3) pathway (Zhang et al., 2007). The activation of the transcription factor CREB induces BDNF, which plays an important role in neuronal protection (Ferrer et al., 2001). Studying the brain’s ischemic cascade, where repair processes are initiated through the expression of several of these aforementioned survival proteins, an upregulation of protective proteins and pathways by a targeted treatment is obviously a welcome effect (Moskowitz, 2010).

Our data on CREB phosphorylation and neurite sprouting also suggest direct positive effects of apoptotic MNC-secretomes on neurons. We show here that apoptotic MNC-secretomes contain BDNF and enhance systemic, most likely indirect, BDNF secretion in rats after injection with human apoptotic MNC-secretomes. Neurotrophic factors may play a critical role in the treatment of cerebral ischemia (Abe, 2000). It was discussed in the literature that BDNF is among the most important neurotrophic factors due to its capability to promote neurogenesis and angiogenesis, to prevent neuronal cell death, and to modulate local inflammatory processes (Jiang et al., 2011; Ploughman et al., 2009; Schäbitz et al., 2007). In light of these data it seems arguable that apoptotic MNC-secretomes provide, at least in part, indirect protection in this experimental stroke model via BDNF. When we integrate all these recent findings into our suggested mode of action of apoptotic MNC-secretomes in ischemic stroke, we can, step by step, characterize it as a biological, battling the ischemic cascade on several fronts. As mentioned before, the overall mechanism of action of our compound could be linked to the release of paracrine factors (Korf-Klingebiel et al., 2008).

We decided to run two experimental settings in order to investigate (i) whether syngeneic rMNCapo sec are able to attenuate ischemic lesion volumes and (ii) to further define whether xenogenic hMNCapo sec, produced according to GMP criteria and virus-inactivated, are equally potent as rMNCapo sec. This extended two-step experimental approach was chosen because hMNCapo sec are very close to the final product that is intended for later clinical use. hMNCapo sec can be produced effectively and securely using whole blood, similar to blood products such as packed red cells. Also, allogeneic apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from multiple healthy donors could be pooled and lyophilized. In the future, the proposed ability of hMNCapo sec to reduce ischemic injury in the early phases of stroke may even imply its use in combination with established therapeutic concepts such as arterial recanalization. Considering that inflammatory processes are particularly aggressive in ischemia associated with reperfusion, the suppression of inflammation provided by hMNCapo sec would be a fitting addition to reperfusion therapy (Stowe et al., 2009). Experiments investigating the anti-inflammatory action of apoptotic MNC-secretomes in our setting of experimental MCAO are subject to future studies. We agree that rat and human apoptotic MNC-secretomes are hardly comparable, representing a limitation of this study. In this preclinical setting of stroke, however, we were able to find similar effects through both. The intention of this study was to investigate whether there is any beneficial effect of MNC-secretomes in this preclinical setting of stroke. To avoid possible loss of potency in the xenogenic setting (hMNCapo sec in rat MCAO), we decided to use treatment twice instead of only once in the allogeneic experiments (rMNCapo sec in rat MCAO). This approach further allowed us to reduce the required amount of animals according to the principle of the three R´s (replacement, reduction and refinement) (Richard, 2001). This small study with all its agreeable limitations was done to see if the promising data obtained from previous studies might be translatable into experimental ischemic stroke. We realize that larger animal studies with a more thorough observation according to STAIR criteria are needed to further uncover effects of hMNCapo sec in experimental stroke and also to set a time window at which this treatment is feasible (Fisher et al., 2009).

Conclusion

We suggest that apoptotic MNC-secretomes have multifaceted, direct and indirect, neuroprotective characteristics acting through different ways in the ischemic cascade (inflammation, apopotosis, ischemia). Rats treated with apoptotic MNC-secretomes in this experimental stroke study expressed smaller lesion volumes than control animals and showed improvement in neurological function over time. Based on our findings, we believe that apoptotic MNC-secretomes derived from human blood can aid in the development of new treatment strategies in ischemic stroke.

Data availability

figshare: Apoptotic MNC-secretomes in experimental stroke. doi: 10.6084/m9.figshare.1051645 (Altmann et al., 2014).

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 2
VERSION 2 PUBLISHED 19 Jun 2014
Comment
Author details Author details
Competing interests
Grant information
Copyright
Download
 
Export To
metrics
Views Downloads
F1000Research - -
PubMed Central
Data from PMC are received and updated monthly.
- -
Citations
CITE
how to cite this article
Altmann P, Mildner M, Haider T et al. Secretomes of apoptotic mononuclear cells ameliorate neurological damage in rats with focal ischemia [version 2; peer review: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations] F1000Research 2014, 3:131 (https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.4219.2)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
track
receive updates on this article
Track an article to receive email alerts on any updates to this article.

Open Peer Review

Current Reviewer Status: ?
Key to Reviewer Statuses VIEW
ApprovedThe paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approvedFundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions
Version 2
VERSION 2
PUBLISHED 28 Oct 2014
Revised
Views
30
Cite
Reviewer Report 03 Nov 2014
Johannes Boltze, Department of Cell Therapies, Fraunhofer-Institut für Zelltherapie und Immunologie IZI, Leipzig, Germany 
Approved with Reservations
VIEWS 30
I want to thank the authors for their thorough amendments made on their paper. While not every single response is absolutely convincing (at least to me), the overall quality of the paper is clearly above average.
Importantly, all study limitations are ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Boltze J. Reviewer Report For: Secretomes of apoptotic mononuclear cells ameliorate neurological damage in rats with focal ischemia [version 2; peer review: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]. F1000Research 2014, 3:131 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.5935.r6549)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
Views
28
Cite
Reviewer Report 30 Oct 2014
Michael Chopp, Department of Neurology, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, MI, USA 
Hongqi Xin, Department of Neurology, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, MI, USA 
Approved
VIEWS 28
The authors have addressed my ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Chopp M and Xin H. Reviewer Report For: Secretomes of apoptotic mononuclear cells ameliorate neurological damage in rats with focal ischemia [version 2; peer review: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]. F1000Research 2014, 3:131 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.5935.r6551)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
Version 1
VERSION 1
PUBLISHED 19 Jun 2014
Views
39
Cite
Reviewer Report 13 Aug 2014
An Zhou, Neuroscience Institute, Morehouse School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA 
Approved with Reservations
VIEWS 39
In this work, the authors examined the therapeutic potential of secretory proteomes of apoptotic mononuclear cells (MNCapo sec) in treating focal ischemic stroke, modeled on rats with permanent MCAO. They found that intraperitoneal administration of MNCapo sec prepared from either ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Zhou A. Reviewer Report For: Secretomes of apoptotic mononuclear cells ameliorate neurological damage in rats with focal ischemia [version 2; peer review: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]. F1000Research 2014, 3:131 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.4517.r5562)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
Views
43
Cite
Reviewer Report 25 Jul 2014
Michael Chopp, Department of Neurology, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, MI, USA 
Hongqi Xin, Department of Neurology, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, MI, USA 
Approved with Reservations
VIEWS 43
The authors in this report examined the regenerative potential of conditioned medium derived from rat and human apoptotic mononuclear cells (MNC) in experimental stroke. They found that administration of rat as well as human apoptotic MNC-secretomes (rMNCapo sec and hMNCapo ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Chopp M and Xin H. Reviewer Report For: Secretomes of apoptotic mononuclear cells ameliorate neurological damage in rats with focal ischemia [version 2; peer review: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]. F1000Research 2014, 3:131 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.4517.r5568)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
  • Author Response 15 Oct 2014
    Patrick Altmann, Christian Doppler Laboratory for Cardiac and Thoracic Diagnosis and Regeneration, Vienna, 1090, Austria
    15 Oct 2014
    Author Response
    Thank you for your helpful report. Your suggestions have allowed us to make our manuscript better and present our data more accurately.
     
    1. The authors should include the references for their protocol
    ... Continue reading
COMMENTS ON THIS REPORT
  • Author Response 15 Oct 2014
    Patrick Altmann, Christian Doppler Laboratory for Cardiac and Thoracic Diagnosis and Regeneration, Vienna, 1090, Austria
    15 Oct 2014
    Author Response
    Thank you for your helpful report. Your suggestions have allowed us to make our manuscript better and present our data more accurately.
     
    1. The authors should include the references for their protocol
    ... Continue reading
Views
46
Cite
Reviewer Report 21 Jul 2014
Johannes Boltze, Department of Cell Therapies, Fraunhofer-Institut für Zelltherapie und Immunologie IZI, Leipzig, Germany 
Approved with Reservations
VIEWS 46
The article by Altmann and colleagues assesses the therapeutic impact of conditioned medium from both human and rodent apoptotic mononuclear cells (MNC). The paper reports highly interesting findings that not only contribute significantly to the understanding of adult cell-based therapies ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Boltze J. Reviewer Report For: Secretomes of apoptotic mononuclear cells ameliorate neurological damage in rats with focal ischemia [version 2; peer review: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]. F1000Research 2014, 3:131 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.4517.r5480)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
  • Author Response 15 Oct 2014
    Patrick Altmann, Christian Doppler Laboratory for Cardiac and Thoracic Diagnosis and Regeneration, Vienna, 1090, Austria
    15 Oct 2014
    Author Response
    Thank you for your valuable and kind comments. Having included them in our manuscript, we feel that we were able to further increase the value of our manuscript.
    1. Please report all
    ... Continue reading
COMMENTS ON THIS REPORT
  • Author Response 15 Oct 2014
    Patrick Altmann, Christian Doppler Laboratory for Cardiac and Thoracic Diagnosis and Regeneration, Vienna, 1090, Austria
    15 Oct 2014
    Author Response
    Thank you for your valuable and kind comments. Having included them in our manuscript, we feel that we were able to further increase the value of our manuscript.
    1. Please report all
    ... Continue reading

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 2
VERSION 2 PUBLISHED 19 Jun 2014
Comment
Alongside their report, reviewers assign a status to the article:
Approved - the paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations - A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approved - fundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions
Sign In
If you've forgotten your password, please enter your email address below and we'll send you instructions on how to reset your password.

The email address should be the one you originally registered with F1000.

Email address not valid, please try again

You registered with F1000 via Google, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Google account password, please click here.

You registered with F1000 via Facebook, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Facebook account password, please click here.

Code not correct, please try again
Email us for further assistance.
Server error, please try again.